Who is next for the Goodison Hotseat?

However, on the topic of the new Manager to replace Carlo, who I feel was a tad mendacious in his final remarks about successfully completing his averred targets, ie, getting into Europe. I bear him no grudge or ill feeling; after all, he is Italian and like the Spanish can say one thing and mean another.

Anyway... this is my own opinion of the set-up we now need:

Brands as principal controller of scouting amongst his other roles.

Ralf Rangnick as the guiding hand in providing an ethos and structure to how we play football and as a mentor to Duncan Ferguson who should be instated as the Coach; so Rangnick becomes ostensibly the Manager, in name... But the actual coaching becomes the remit of Duncan guided by Rangnick's own ideas, which have been successfully adopted by many football glitterati including a very successful Herr Klopp.

So there you have it, for what it's worth: a three-pronged management structure with Brands, Rangnick and Ferguson each sharing responsibility for performance but separately having distinct roles in achieving that level of performance. It is not written in stone that a manager has to perform with total control and in this way they could individually contribute and work to their strengths.

The short period that Duncan was mentored by Joe proved that he in tandem with an older experienced campaigner successfully motivate a team that was underperforming and I see Rangnick as the perfect foil that will monitor and mentor Big Dunc. Just saying.

The longer this goes on 2 scenarios may play out.

Martinez is coming, he has the European champs to deal with first and won't want to possibly destabilise the team.

Everton are going to appoint last minute to save money and therefore be limited as to who is avaliable, that would be Everton all over.

This club has been down the road before of appointing former managers with Kendall's endless returns and they could hardly of been viewed as roaring successes could they.

Controversial one but I'd have no qualms with seeing Rafa in situ at this club. Managed in many countires, available, has won trophies, has loads of European experience and still lives in the Liverpool area.

Ok, he slagged us off once (big deal, we slag them off) and used to manage them but of the potential candidates we could get he looks a sound bet. Not happening though, don't think our club would go for someone possibly divisive with our support.

Why is Pirlo even being mentioned here? What would he bring to the club?

Mancini anyone?

If you bring in Moyes, Potter etc, the big name players won't like that, their egos need feeding - we all have a view on who would be right for the job, but I suspect the club will certainly take into account the players thoughts & feelings as well. Supporters tend not to think of the human element as much.

Don't be surprised if Moshiri goes all out for someone like Pirlo or Mancini for the same reasons.

All of this should be meat and drink for your full-time regular staff. But it's not because on each and every criterion I have listed, EFC are serial failures. Put thes basics right and you have a chance. Without them - you will continue to waste millions and waste our time. Get started now.

Also I am unconvinced of Duncan Ferguson’s ability to step up, I am in the camp that would have liked him to step out of his comfort zone and prove himself worthy at a Championship club. The fact that he has never done that, to me, is an indication of his lack of confidence to succeed doing it. Or even a lack of absolute desire to be the no1. It follows from that he shouldn’t be given the top job at Everton based on almost no supporting evidence.

Francis 1, your stuff is as good as anyone else's. Make this a more regular thing. As for the structure, yeah that's what we all want but didn't we just witness the friction between visions of Brands and those above?

There is obviously no unified position at the moment or the club would at least mimic some PR move to help our image. We've got a struggle in play and I think most of us are thinking Brands is our guy on the inside. I still lean toward Nuno because it would be a safe choice which could keep some player values from plummeting and might produce a run at Europe sooner than deserved. Additionally, it would do as suggested by most, give Brands a true chance to build a team since the word is that Nuno is okay with that arrangement. Nuno is solid enough to get something from some decent acquisitions by Brands should he grow into that role with honor.

If it gets weird and we can't get a decent contract with protections the club needs from our preferred candidates I would then roll the dice with Dunc without fear.

It needs a football man not an accountant or impresario to see the spark, or lack of, in another football mans eyes. If Rob Halligan's insider is right then Brands get it, he understands the unique circumstances AT THIS CLUB.

Only a tiny minority from the applicants will be strong enough to inspire the requisite revolution and it will need Brands to sit opposite the applicant at the interview to spot it.

Fuck the cv it's the man that matters.

It needs a football man not an accountant or impresario to see the spark, or lack of, in another football mans eyes. If Rob Halligan's insider is right then Brands get it, he understands the unique circumstances AT THIS CLUB.

Only a tiny minority from the applicants will be strong enough to inspire the requisite revolution and it will need Brands to sit opposite the applicant at the interview to spot it.

Fuck the cv it's the man that matters.

I wouldn't describe Martinez as a safe pair of hands personally!

Benitez has the best CV, by a long way, of anyone linked so far. It's a shame a large number of us seem more bothered about a flippant remark made over a decade ago than having a chance of success.

Rangnick probably the next least worst option.

I agree entirely. The last thing we need right now is him or Gerrard coming in with half the fan base skeptical of them from the get go.

Conte was top of the poll when I last looked. He would bring his own lengthy wish list of signings and then moan like hell about broken promises when they don’t arrive. The chances of him working in tandem with Brands for the long term are next to none.

Bill (14) Given that all of Carlo’s caravan of coaches, fitness gurus and analysts have departed with him, who are all the dinosaurs still at Finch Farm? As for EiTC, your comment is ill informed. It is run as a separate entity and is ‘off site’.

David. What is it you want them to say?

Does this not do it?: https://www.evertonfc.com/news/2164100/club-statement-ancelotti-leaves-everton

Or do you need a daily "We're still looking"?

A quick offering from the master of comedy wisdom:
Good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment.

My hunch is that Ten Hag could be the man they are looking at. There’s obviously the Dutch link, and he works within the framework of a Director of Football. We could entice him here with better wages. He might also fancy a crack at the Prem. Ajax also play a decent style of football, one which fits in with all the age ranges at the club. Isn’t this what Brands is trying to do at our club?

My big reservation is that Cocu failed at Derby, and De Boer bombed at Palace. So could he bring what he does at Ajax and get it to work in the Prem?

It’s going to be a horrible summer. Big changes at the club do not often bring instant success. I really feel next season could be a struggle...

This is the guy who was a central figure in the Tevez and Mascherano saga, although he denied being the owner of the players rights. According to his Wiki Bio he was once a 'used car salesman'.

Okay his business was described as a car dealership, but seriously is this the sort of person we want Everton FC to be connected with?

Kia's Role in appointing New Everton Boss

Kia Joorabchian

Our recent finishes have been 10th, 12th, 8th, 8th, 7th, 11th, 11th. An average position of 9th/10th over the last 7 seasons.

Any expectation, or demand, that we can suddenly become a top 6 team is absurd. Our team is limited, as our our funds and our academy. A safe pair of hands manager is keeping us mid-table, with maybe a flirtation with Europe and hopefully a cup run.

When we had an average finish of 6th/7th under Moyes, we had a general strategy. But since he left, we have had zero strategy. Moving from Martines-Koeman-Silva-Ancelotti - all managers with distinct methods and the result is the mis-shapen squad that we currently have.

No matter who the manager we appoint, more than the name of the manager, the first thing we must do is develop a distinct strategy - AND KEEP TO IT. Be that under the guidance of Brands, or another. We currently have no idea if Brands is the man to lead this strategy, because he has been sidelined since his arrival.

If Moshiri can't keep his nose out, we must seriously start questioning his ownership. Too often, Kenwright is a scapegoat. And while I am no fan of his and believe he too should be forced away, for Moshiri he has been a helpful distraction - all of Moshiri's many failings are often ignored - Kenwright or the manager get the grief. Moshiri is seen as the rich owner - but what decisions has been made that have actually worked? can't think of any - From the Walsh/Koeman disaster, the mid-table 'galactico' signings, and more recently Ancelotti.

Time for him to step back and leave football to football people...otherwise time for him to find a new toy.

So, over the past few days of non- stop thinking about it, I am coming down on an amalgam of the above article, and the posts from Francis #1 and Bill #14. This is based upon if I was spending my own money.

I don’t want anyone associated with Liverpool FC. I don’t like them.

I don’t want anyone who has managed us before. I don’t like them.

I don’t want anyone who is coming here for a big wedge. The sort of contracts we have dished out to the last few appointments have been farcical, they have incentivised failure - Martinez and Silva were basically faced with a situation where they could think “If I make a bollocks of this now, I can get paid off and sit in the sun for 12 months/get another job and still get paid”. There is an entire industry going on where such managers are on the money-spinning merry-go-round. We can all see through it, why can’t billionaire businessmen?

So, I want someone who will work for their buck. They need to have charisma, and they need to want to win things because they like winning. Possibly a Ferguson, definitely a Cahill. They need someone alongside them who understands football inside out, an Alan Irvine/Colin Harvey type of character, someone who doesn’t want the spotlight. Invite these characters in to make a pitch.

They should be paid a decent salary, say, £1m per annum, with very generous incentives based upon league position and cup success. If I was paying the salary I would also award my own purely arbitrary points each week for entertainment. No doubt agents would be aghast at how this could be measured, but as the owner I would simply say “I’ll decide that, take it or leave it”.

It’s unbelievable to me how a very wealthy person can’t arrange such a contract. It seems everyone is in thrall to agents and the media. Turn the whole thing on its head, invite applications based on the above, if you don’t like it, off you pop. They would still be queuing up.

I've worked in numerous businesses, and the least successful of them all are the ones where the 'owner' can't step aside and trust knowledgable people to run the show. Moshiri is an accountant, not a football man, and that has been clear in many of his woeful decisions since coming on board.

Therefore, I am leaning towards Dunc with Cahill and an ex Everton player who can instil some passion into players about what Everton and its fans are about. Someone like Peter Reid as an advisor.

Where you from Mal Van Schaick? Name like that must be a Toxteth native.," I agree with other comments regarding foreign managers"

Where you from Mal Van Schaick? Name like that must be a Toxteth native.,,,1,21:36:34,,171.159.64.10,ok,2769,06/04/2021 21:36:34,Evertongator,reader,,,no 1162076,40893,toffeeweb,04/06/2021,Sam Hoare,sam_hoare@hotmail.com,"Don’t want one of those pesky foreign managers like Guardiola, Klopp, Tuchel etc. What have they ever done?!

It doesn’t matter where a manager comes from, it only matters that they are a good fit. What exactly that fit is will/should depend on Brands and should be uniform throughout the club at all age groups.

Personally I’d like a young, modern coach to play a direct, aggressive, energetic game (though admittedly we don’t have the right players for this currently).

Ferguson could be great. He’s an experienced coach and obviously knows the players and clubs but my worry is his lack of managerial experience, he should have a season or two in the lower leagues to prove himself first.

I think Potter looks a capable manager who plays good football and Fonseca and Ten Hag are interesting too.

Not young but also interesting could be Rangnick or Galtier.

Nuno would be a safe if unspectacular option.

One thing is clear, whoever it is will divide supporters on these pages!

Make the terms clear. Advertise them. Ensure there is full disclosure. Let the contract be simple. And keep the tenure of the contract short. If the manager is successful and is lured elsewhere, so be it. Get another one.

It's hard to find the right balance between short and to the point and a novel that leads to a nap. Sorry bout that.

Always felt he was 'the one that got away' in the aftermath of Moyes leaving.

And all he has done at the Red Bull franchise since has suggested that he really could have been the man to take us further.

Him, working alongside Brands - Rangnick football strategist, Brands transfer man and a young manager (be it Ferguson, be it Potter, or anyone else) could be something that has real long term value.

We need strategy.

No wonder Mosh&co think we're doing ok but will they orchestrate a Moyes to Utd ovation for Carlo to Madrid when the fans get back?

What a great sport - what a great club.

Followed Everton from 1960s, seen the good times and bad times. Like us all I just want Everton to be winning trophies and playing good football with some local players in the team like the good old days.

Conte 'and what will you do for me if I do this thing?'

Moshiri staring 'Anything'.

I cannot believe my eyes.

Years of misery inducing spoiling tactics has done nothing to stop some from declaring a wish to see people like Benitez and Moyes manage our team.

If we employ another fucking wagon Circler, I'm fucking off to collect stamps, or bake cakes or something...or go somewhere else where I'm not surrounded by fucking masochists

But for the chance to see you participate in Bake Off...it might just be worth it

His time at Juve was deemed a failure, but in fairness the team is in transition with older players needing to be replaced, and he did win the 2 domestic cups. Young Italian managers like Vialli, Di Matteo and Mancini had successes in their managerial stints in the Prem. Maybe Pirlo could be a feasible appointment who could probably work under Brands?!

First off, can we please learn the lesson of Carlo Ancelotti. I said before he came that I wasn’t too keen, but when he looked set to join I looked for how it might work. Key to that was the appointment of a top class first team coach.

You see, too many of you think in simple terms. Carlo has won 3 Champions Leagues, he’s a great manager, he’ll get us back we’re we belong. Sure, he is a great manager, but he’s great when he’s at big clubs. What does he actually do? Well very little according to the article in the athletic.

Well I already told you that. And it’s fine. Sir Alex Ferguson was not a coach, certainly not in the last decade of his career. He was also not a tactician. But Ferguson hired top coaches, and he kept things fresh by changing them. Read how Mike Phelan says he should have all the credit for the last couple of titles or the work of carlos Quieroz. And I’m not saying Ferguson was crap, just he didn’t do the coaching himself.

Anyway, Carlo used Paul Clement (last seen as manager of Swansea) as first team coach at Chelsea and Hermann Gerland at Bayern. I wanted Clement or someone of that ilk at Everton. Things might have been different. Instead he relied on his novice son and Duncan Ferguson. The latter is somewhat culpable for all the recent failings and should not be given the job. He needs to leave and cut his teeth at a lower level and prove himself.

Think carefully how your new favourite will transform everton. As always, I want a young hungry coach, playing fast, front foot football. And yes, that’s what I promised marco Silva would bring. Just because he ultimately failed, does not mean the plan was wrong, he just failed to execute it. We still need a hands on coach, with a plan who can transform the players we have and make them better, meantime working with brands bringing through new young players and players from the youth side.

We need to follow a tried snd tested template to break into the top 4. That is what Rogers is doing now with Leicester and what Pochettino did with Spurs. FFP prevents the Man City approach.

If we look through the contenders on the ToffeeWeb poll, most are against my preference. Rafa Benitez is yesrdays man in my book. His Newcastle side was dull, his tactics dated. Then there’s the small matter of his coaching. Rafa won trophies when he delegated the coaching to pako ayestarán at Valencia and Liverpool. After they fell out, Rafa has failed to win a league or the CL. His results have not be of the same level. It goes back to my point of delivery. Rafa would be defensive, like always, but his methods are dated and lack the execution of his former top coach.

Antonio Conte. He’s like Carlo. His CV is impeccable. He can’t fail. But how would he do it. Well he nearly always does it by spending. He’s spoke to Spurs and they said no to spending. Well he can’t here either. FFP won’t allow it. He wants the spending shortcut and doesn’t want to spend 5 years coaching Nkounkou and co to the top level. So, no, he might be the right man for a top side, but he is not the right man for Everton.

Nuno Espírito Santo. Here’s a man who’s only honour is the second tier trophy with wolves. He did poorly at Porto and nothing special at Valencia, which is why he went to the second tier with wolves. All that wolves did achieve needs to be taken into context with the money spent by owners richer than moshiri (yes really) and a tie in with super agent Jorge mendes. Wolves sacked him. He shouldn’t be on our radar. Speak to any wolves fan and they’ll tell you how dire his tactics were. And I’ll never appreciate him, as I don’t rate anyone who plays five at the back every game. Dire tactics if you ask me.

Lucien Favre. The Swiss is now 63. His only trophy in the top 5 European nations is the German charity shield. Yes really. Not a fan myself. Wrong age for me.

Ralf Rangnick. He’s 62. Only thing he’s ever won of note is the German cup once. He’s also the same guy who had serious health issues last time he was in the frame to replace Moyes. Too old. Too damaged and never was good enough.

Duncan Ferguson. As above. Needs to drop down and start a career further down and work his way back up. Kendall did it, why can’t Duncan?

Paulo Fonseca. A manager I know a lot about. One who’d guarantee to put a smile back on Bernard’s face. His old Shaktar manager. He did great stuff in Portugal with pacos, then sacked by Porto and back to pacos before getting braga to crack the top 3 in Portugal (always Benfica, Porto and sporting). Then off to Shaktar where he won the league and cup double 3 times in 3 seasons, as well as really making a name for himself in Europe. He got the big job at Roma. He did well, but not great there. 52% win ratio is acceptable. He just didn’t manage to push them up the table enough and they’ve gone the Mourinho route to get trophies. Is he right for Everton? No, I preferred Silva, and whilst Fonseca is more pragmatic, he’s less innovative. We can do better.

Eddie Howe. No thanks. We all know the pros and cons here. We can do much better.

Frank Lampard. If someone else takes your underperforming side to heights you couldn’t reach, then it says a lot about your abilities. Not good enough.

Roberto Martinez. Produced the best season of my adult life. Really enjoyed his football. Never wanted him sacked. Think too many of you don’t give him enough credit for his achievements. I mean google it, which Everton managers can beat 72 points (even if you change the olden days to 3 for a win and don’t adjust the 46 games a season down to 38). Go on, have a look who can, you’ll be surprised. Can’t be that shit now can he? I don’t want him back though. The ship has sailed.

David Moyes. Far better than some will have you believe, a lot worse than others think. He’s mr solid and dependable. We want more. And as with Martinez, never go back.

Graham Potter. Such an intriguing one. I can’t work out if he’s really going to be as special as some think, or if he’s just another Eddie Howe. I think he’s too much of a gamble. Let him continue to prove himself.

Simeone. May as well consider Guardiola for the job then! Never an option!

Erik ten Hag. Not seen enough of Ajax recently. Like what I have seen. Like more what I’ve read about him. He looks a real superstar manager on the rise. Brands show know him inside out. Sure Ajax are the biggest club in Holland, but he’s still done a fantastic job there, particularly in Europe. He’s in my top 3.

Christophe Galtier. I don’t know much about his Lille side. I love Bielsa. I watched his Lille side. They were always top 6. Marcelo had them bottom. They gave him time but he couldn’t get them out the bottom 3 well into the season and was sacked. The next guy saved them and then had them midtable. In came Galtier and they were flying. But note there’s a lot of credit to their DoF for his signings. Positive though is it shows he could work well with brands. Anyway, on to this season and Galtier was the best manager in the world in his domestic competition. No exaggeration. He pipped Pochettino to the French league title with Lille. Yeah, the same Lille Bielsa was trying his best to relegate. Galtier immediately resigned and is awaiting a top job. Don’t know if he’s a top coach or not, but he must have done something right. I’d be welcoming of him if brands does his homework and is happy with him.

Marcelo Gallardo. My number one choice. This is the guy I wanted ahead of Carlo Ancelotti. Since I last advocated for him, he’s remained in Argentina with River Plate. He’s won it all there. He needs to leave. He’s heavily touted but no one wants to take the plunge. Surely we can make an offer. He plays on the front foot. His teams are fast and direct. He’s a hands on coach. He’s got a temper and goes berserk on the sidelines, sometimes getting sent off. We need a nutter if you ask me. Get him in. This guy is being monitored by Barcelona for good reason.

I’ll throw in a guy opposite of what I want and not on the ToffeeWeb poll list: Maurizio Sarri. He’s 62 now. But he’s got energy. He’s a former banker and came to football late and so not had his energy levels depleted. As a former banker, he’s exceptionally intellectual. He’s a real student of football and invented his own style, Sarri ball. He’s fought his way up from non-league which is why he’s only been around a few years despite his age. He doesn’t do transfers. Give him a load of money and he’ll just buy his favourite ex players. This is a coach who’s happy to work with what he has. Sarri ball is great to watch, to some, but I accept some find it dull. But he didn’t really play it at chelsea. I think it would go down better at Everton. I also think with his clear style, brands could work well with him. He’s 62, but with something to prove. I’d be happy if we appointed him.

But going back, I want someone young and hungry, like Gallardo or ten Hag. Or someone on the rise like Galtier. Or someone with something to prove like Sarri. I don’t want yesterday’s man or the same boring old type of coach.

Whatever manager we hire has to work with what Brands gives him. Period. The business of bringing in new players for each manager is what go us this misshapen squad in the first place. The player operations need to revolve around Brands, not whatever manager we sign.

Every manager interviewed needs to know that first thing. If at any point, the interviewee says something like, "For the system I use, you'll need to get me players X, Y, and Z. . . . ", he needs to be shown the door.

Otherwise, there's no point to having Brands or anyone else in his position.

I have only two comments on your post.

1. Many thanks for not mentioning Rooney, who is still appallingly listed at 9/1 odds, or Gerrard. (Or Steve Cooper, heh-heh.)

2. You can't play "fast, front foot football" with the slowest side in the Prem. We need to sign five speedy players (RB, 2MF, wing, striker) to make that work. Try to play it with our current midfield and we'll front-foot ourselves right into relegation danger -- and sack our new manager by February. The window is every bit as important as the hire. And Brands should be in full charge of both.

Hope you're well.

I agree with most of what you say, although think you are a little dismissive of what Rangnick has achieved. In his role at the Red Bull franchise, not only has he been influencial in making them successful and being so through identifiing young talent and then selling them at a profit. He's also been highly influential in the identification of young and up and coming managers Hasenhuttel, Nagalsamann, Marsch, Rose.

In a similar role he'd be a good name.

Gallardo is an interesting one, but very high risk. As a whiff of Frank De Boar about him, and a real worry that his methods wouldn't work. I'd be excited if he was given a chance but it's high risk.

One name that seems absent from discussion but one I'd like to see is that of Jorge Sampioli. Highly experienced, and although his time as Argentina manager was a huge failure (multiple factors), when with Chile they were fantastic. He's from the Bielsa school of management. While not young (61), he could be someone to transform our playing style and methods that could have a lasting impact.

Concerned we are talking to Pirlo who has had one season at Juve, taken the champions to finish 4th. Not for me, we don't want someone cutting their managerial teeth.

I’m always wary of up and coming coaches who come out of nowhere in smaller leagues eg Perrin, Paul le Gunn, AVB etc... they tend to flatter only to fall on their faces. So Galtier is a no from me.

I also like ten Haag but will the Eindhoven - Ajax rivalry be an impediment for Marcel? A Dutch friend of mine (an Utrecht fan) doesn’t rate him at all.

Gallardo is an intriguing choice. Could our clueless MF play his high tempo, passing game? Could they stand his constant movement on the touch line? I think some of them might actually suffer from a nervous breakdown. I’d take him any day.

As for Sarri, I think he’d be a health hazard. We don’t want our wayward geniuses coughing and spluttering do we, and stinking of nicotine?

Sadly, I think we will play safe and opt for Nuno. He won’t rock the boat. The media like him. He will keep us as a top 10 team etc..

As long as it’s not Moyes then I’m ok. I do think we shouldn’t make a rash decision though and let Marcel make the final decision.

In my opinion, Everton are not in a position to go full flamboyant and chance it with another high-risk appointment. We got to lick our wounds and fly under the radar for a few years until the new stadium gets built. It does not mean we need to get a boring manager, just a low risk guy. I believe that if we don't get this appointment right (and the right player acquisitions), we very realistically run the risk of getting sucked into the Championship, and no, this is not a knee jerk sentiment. Even with the experienced Carlo, we scraped out a lot of nervy 1-0 away wins, and we all know about our horrible home record. If we don't get someone who has experience of the English game, especially the Premier League, we are asking for trouble.

If by some miracle, Pochettino can be enticed by the Everton project, then we should blindly sign him up. But I see close to 0% chance of this happening.

Nuno is the one for me - he has worked 4 years in England, knows the league very well by now, is a very respectable character, taking Wolves to Europe was quite an achievement, and at no time were Wolves in danger of relegation in spite of losing some of their best players. I also liked the Wolves playing style - they kind of remind me of how Everton played in Martinez' 1st season with us. The only thing I don't like about Nuno is his super agent connection, but that could be because the Wolves ownership constrained him to work with that particular agent. If Brands can put his foot down and say that he (Brands) would be in charge of player recruitments, and Nuno is okay with that, then this would be the best option in my opinion. I do think that Nuno as Everton manager will surprise a lot of people in a positive way.

My close 2nd option is Graham Potter - slightly riskier than Nuno, but his side plays exciting football, and with better funding, he might very well be the man who turns it around for Everton. The risk with guys like Potter is that if the initial results don't go our way, then the pressure starts building almost immediately, and we don't want another manager drama.

Whoever comes in should be given time to build up a team, evolve a playing style, and make it a sustainable business proposition for the owner to continue to invest in the project. In Brands We Trust!

- objectives: return us to the edge of "success" (being about 5th to 8th) while the stadium is being built

- budget: modest relative to at least 6 other clubs, especially given that so few of our current lot will generate money money for reinvestment from sale

- experience: knows the ropes in the premier league

- approach: happy to develop players bought for him (as well as developing existing playing staff)

- tenure: 3 years? That would give us a period of stability while BMD is built. With a shiny new stadium and a c6th place squad of younger, dynamic Brands signings we should be better placed to hire a more glamorous manager and arm him with a better squad and competitive budget.

This might sound tremendously unambitious but after chronic club mismanagement we find ourselves behind Leicester, WHU, Leeds and barely ahead of Villa. These clubs, along with Spurs and Arsenal, are our competition. We're not in the same league as the £bn squads of the top 4 - but we could be in about 3 years if we get this right now.

Ps. Good to see you back Steve.

The points made about the critical importance of the coaching regime that comes with a manager are what resonates with me. Midweek, on the training ground, being professionally trained, drilled and motivated day in day out is what makes for good teamwork. You used Alex Ferguson as a good example of of this, he always had his right hand man as a great effective coach. Closer to home when Silva lost Joao Pedro he didn’t recover. The season before the two of them were making some progress ( with the help of Zouma and Gana ). Still it was a big factor.

So I want the manager who can bring the energy and get us onto the front foot. But also a manger who can drill, organise us into a proper team via a great coaching team .

When we choose the manager we should be looking at the package that comes with him. How will the coaching be organised him ? What’s the qualities of the coaching team like he surrounds himself with ? Has the manager himself the energy and vigour to be on the training ground day after day to get the standards and methods established?

I think it’s not just a man we need to be looking for, but a coaching package he brings to the table that works well with him and allows him to operate to the best of his abilities.

Also , maybe most importantly, someone who actually wants and is happy to be here ! Not a transient big shot who thinks he’s doing us a favour and would always rather be managing elsewhere if the opportunity arose.

Moshiri is determined to sign a “name” instead of the sort of coach we really need - and that is my worry. Pirlo for example worries the hell out of me.

On another note I see Richi scored last night to remind CA he still has it- so off to RM he goes - if they’ve got the liquid of course!

Nice to see you back. I could definitely get on board with a top 3 of Gallardo, Ten Hag or Galtier; all of whom I suggested further up the thread.

I do think Rangnick would be an interesting option to throw in due to his vast experience and knowledge, perhaps in combination with a younger coach (Ferguson?).

As for Conte, he is what I think people hoped Ancelotti might be, a genuinely world class manager who has his best days in the present rather than behind him. He has the potential to be very destructive and it could all go very wrong quite quickly, but it would be an exciting and highly ambitious appointment if they could persuade him (which is unlikely I think).

I didn't agree with all of it but interesting piece. Your pick, Gallardo, should be avoided at all costs if you're right about

" 𝗧𝗵𝗶𝘀 𝗴𝘂𝘆 𝗶𝘀 𝗯𝗲𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗺𝗼𝗻𝗶𝘁𝗼𝗿𝗲𝗱 𝗯𝘆 𝗕𝗮𝗿𝗰𝗲𝗹𝗼𝗻𝗮 𝗳𝗼𝗿 𝗴𝗼𝗼𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗼𝗻"

He'll be on his bike to Spain quicker than Ancelotti if he does anything here.

I know a lot of match going Wolves fans and their take on Nuno bears no resemblance to the picture you paint.

I like Nuno but then I’ve liked them all except for Ronald and Sam. I don’t want any more likeable managers, I want a winner this time.

The three in question being Moyes, Martinez, Silva, add on to that Howe being an Everton ian must be ideal for Kenwright.
This man should have no input whatsoever in my eyes, how many pennies has he invested in Everton FC Ltd in order to rake off £millions from our clueless owner.

As soon as he got his shares Kenwright should have been told "off you pop Bill there is a taxi waiting and just for you we have managed to find the son of the taxi driver who John Moores used when sacking Johnny Carey".

As a "token" figurehead he should be told to shut up and sit at the back while we get on with finding a manager not a new ventriloquist doll for you.

If we could get Rangnick, which I don't think we can (but want), it would be a fantastic move. But yes, because of his senior position at RB Leipzig, there would need to be a management structure in place and I agree, that would likely need Brands to step up to replace Kenwright but still be involved in transfers. Rangnick as the manager but yes, a head coach underneath him to run the first team.

I like that idea, I just don't think it will happen.

Steve Ferns @69. Great analysis. I don't necessarily agree on with you on Rangnick (obviously). His strengths are building teams and his tactics. I like the Ten Haag shout. Don't know too much about Sarri to be honest. For some reason, not someone I've really paid attention too, so will take your shout on him.

I really don't know where this one is going now. My hope is that because it's ongoing, it means we are not considering the sentimental / internal ones as they should have been done by now if that's where we are or were going.

Conte talks broke down with Tottenham. Mmmmmm. I don't personally fancy that one (don't know why, just don't) and for those who worry about contracts, they were apparently talking a salary of £15m a year that he has just walked away from. Either he's taking a sabbatical or something bigger has just been waved in front of him. Maybe Crystal Palace has just offered him £20m and an unlimited budget, clearing the way for us to nab Nuno!!

I've noticed when we are looking for a manager (every few months) reading the posts I'd great to cheer you up, the humour is still there amongst us even though our team still continues to be pathetic on and off the field.

Thanks Colin, I now have an image of Darren in his pinny!

Whereas the likes of Klopp, Guardiola, Bielsa and Tuchel were ‘untried’ in the PL.

Not really sure what the basis of your argument is.

I want a young hungry manager who has ambition.

If that's the guy from Lille, Ajax, ex Roma or Brighton so be it.

I don't want the usual merry go round pension fund managers. Sarri, Moyes, Benitez.

I also don't want the like of Lampard, Rooney, Pirlo using us to cut their teeth in management.

Totally agree with Mike Gaynes that whoever gets the gig must address the lack of pace in the midfield as a priority.
I just hope Moshiri and Brands have learnt from previous mistakes. Ancelotti walking out and taking a 50% pay cut must have been a right dent to Moshiri's ego.

His strengths are on recruitment of non-obvious talent and developing youth.

It's an interesting one, but unrealistic. It would need a management structure in place to accommodate Brands. But it would be a great opportunity for a young coach to work under both of them.

Edit; it even applies before that if you consider top flight English football. Alex Ferguson and our very own Howard Kendall.

In the meantime any manager will need to adopt a high degree of pragmatism, an approach not welcomed by many fans. Whoever comes in will initially have to work with what he has got, operating within their limitations until they can be replaced. That’s why for the moment I believe the safer option is to go for someone who knows this league and has a track record of working with what he has got.

He likes the 'Hollywood' feel, and he's trying to make Everton into a big name club so he's likely to go with a big name in my view. Whether that's the right thing to do is a moot point, but we're not in charge are we.

Given the news that Conte and Spurs have fell out...though who dumped who(m?) first, probably Conte.

Then I did I read that he knocked back Real too before they came in for Ancelotti.

I wonder what would've happened? Nothing? or would he has just taken the next taxi off the rank? - Probably, is my view.

Bielsa arrived to a fairly mediocre Championship club. He finished above us last year.

For what’s it’s worth Graham Potter would be one of my top 5 picks but going for PL experience has not benefited us in the slightest recently so why are you ruling out so many talented coaches and limiting our choice?

He messed up with Silva (who I actually liked), Ronald, and has just been humiliated by Carlo. He will look for another reassuring football figure like Nuno or Sarri but will avoid, like the plague, nutters like Conte and Bielsa

I think we have to drop this notion we are a top club were not and havent been for over 30 years, we are a middle of the league team likely to finish between 7th and 12th in the league. So that limits our choice when it comes to managers and players, obviously Ancelotti thought might as well go there till something better shows up and £11 million a year is not to be sniffed at.

So whoever we get will probably be very average nothing to get excited about and will finish in our customary position. Then we will all be debating is the new manager to blame for not improving us or is it Brands or our coaches. After watching us for over 65 years and having a season ticket for 50 of those years, for the first time in my life I have less interest in Everton than I have ever had. Yes I will renew my season ticket, bit like a heroin addict I cant stop even though its killing me. Thank heavens its the close season so don't have to put myself through purgatory for a few months yet.

Have to say, and this isn't referring to your post Brian.

Why oh why do so many people, when they know nothing of what's going on, just assume the worst and condemn the club before they know anything!

The club won't give us daily updates, no club does,

the club won't reveal the practices they use to select a manager.

So many see a name that any half arsed journo, or college kid, can throw on a small time website and have it picked up by Newsnow and all of a sudden Evertonians are kicking up a stink because "we don't want him."

When did Evertonians become so gullible.?When did they become so bleeding negative?

Yes, we've had bad times, and yes we're not where we'd all like to be but ffs stop wallowing in your own self pity and misery.

If you already consider we're fucked then what's the point?

So glad I don't think like that because if I did I'd literally be dead!

Haha, no they have depressed me on many occasions but not quite to the level of self harm, someone said that Everton fans are the new Truman show, its an experience to see how much pain a set of fans can endure without exploding.

In

This season he beat a much more expensively assembled side to the title. Remarkable achievement but the key reason is arguably the quality of squad at his disposal. Lille have done a brilliant job of assembling a top class side on the cheap - along the lines of the Leipzig method. Galtier has has some very good tools to work with and, lo and behold, this unremarkable manager (not even particularly rated by Lille) wins the title.

It comes back to my usual point that we should spend more time thinking about how to build a £bn squad (without simply spending £500m) and less time fixating on who the next coach will be of our deteriorating £500m squad.

If we can manage that then we might suddenly find our managers are more successful all of a sudden.

Your insight into our managerial options is excellent, however, I fear that some of your preferred candidates do not even register with those who will be making the final choice.

We need a young ambitious hungry manager who wants us to play on the front foot and who will work with and improve the talent that Brands provides. We are slowly weeding out the deadwood, it will take time as non performing players are hard to off load but we can end up with a squad that is fit for purpose in twelve months time.

You seem to have two speeds; spend £500 million to compete, or unearth young players that swell our squad value to £1 billion. It’s almost like the acquisition of players like Stones, DCL, Holgate, Branthwaite (and Bowler, and Galloway, and Henen, and Garbutt, and George Green, and any number of other highly-rated youngsters who failed to make the grade at the club or beyond) don’t register with you. The club are trying to compete in these markets, but it’s hard to identify and acquire the best young talent when literally every other club is also trying to do the same, and we’re not top of the pecking order. You think you’ve identified some blind-spot that the club have ridiculously developed, but you haven’t. Getting the right players in - young or established - is a really tough ask, otherwise clubs like Manchester United, Real Madrid and Barcelona would have absolutely copper-bottomed squads. They don’t.

I don’t know what you do or how close to the professional game you are but if you are just reading scouting reports and watching footage of players then you might think you have a decent view of how to proceed, but I reckon it’s a bit like someone playing Call of Duty for a few years and thinking they’re equipped to go to the front line.

Can we compete with City, Bayern and Barcelona for the top players? No.

Can we adopt a model like Liverpool (dry vomit), Leicester and RB Leipzig? We should.

Our transfer non-strategy has left us we a squad that 5 managers have failed to meet our ambitions with.

I'm not in charge or making the decisions. Just a supporter who gives opinion. But we need better players. It always starts on the pitch. You build the rest around that.

In terms of your two penneth, I don’t really see much more in your arguments than a) spend £500 million on top players or b) miraculously find the best young players out there and turn small outlay into big returns. You also have suggested we copy other clubs (Leipzig, Dortmund) in trying to develop a very young squad of players - or even to buy clubs abroad and use them as feeder clubs. It’s just a bit like someone looking across the fence at a neighbour’s prize Azalea bushes and saying “why don’t we have those” - without really assessing the factors (sun, shade, soil, pests, etc) that might make your garden and their garden very different places.

Sorry not a fan of Nuno Espirito Santo. He did well enough result wise with Rio Ave, taking them into Europe. But they were not good to watch. An interesting point, maybe missed by others, is Nuno was the manager of Valencia who signed Andre Gomes from Benfica. Andre had a great season under him, and maybe he might be the one to bring Andre back to his best? Whilst I have not enjoyed watching Nuno's sides at all, particularly Wolves, that Valencia side were easier on the eye.

As for Andrea Pirlo, I think last season might have passed some of you by. In 2019 Juventus were managed by Massimilano "Max" Allegri. Max guided the Bianconeri to their 8th consecutive Italian League title. It was his 5th (in a row). Juve decided that they wanted to go in a different direction, as Max had a well earned reputation for dull (but highly effective) football, but the CL continued to be out of reach. Max himself fancied a well paid job in England, and so moved to London and set about learning English and expecting the phone to ring. It didn't, well not from the likes of Man Utd who he was expecting to call him.

Meanwhile Juve turned to Maurizio Sarri in their attempt to go more exciting. Sarri found a club that was very stuck in it's ways, and they did not let him do what he wanted, and so Juve had this hybrid of Allegri's style and Sarri's. Sarri was pragmatic enough to work with it and delivered their 9th consecutive title. The biggest problem was an early CL exit (to Lyon). They were also surprised that they conceded over 40 Serie A goals. The players were also in revolt and clearly resistant to Sarri-ball.

Juve thought they could lure Zidane, Pochettino or Inzaghi. Instead they went to Andrea Pirlo, their former great playmaker. They had a nightmare season. They didn't win their 10th consecutive title, and dropped to 4th. They were eliminated in the 1st knockout round of the CL by Porto (which is about the only good thing the vastly overrated Sérgio Conceição did last season).

So no, Pirlo is not untried and untested. He has been weighed and measured and found wanting. A disaster of a manager trading off his name as a player. He should be below Duncan Ferguson for me.

Back to Sarri though. If any of you have alarm bells after reading about the Juve player revolt, well if he came here and it happened here, then surely those on that list are exactly the players who have been holding us back.

Sarri comes from the school of managers with a plan. Someone who drills movements into players, rather like a "play" in American football. It looks spontaneous but it is not. This is also exactly what Bielsa does. And for the same reason, Bielsa can be a disaster, as the players need to be in awe of the manager and want to do everything he asks. Big name, big reputation players do not want to run these drills.

We need everyone at Everton to fall into line. Brands and the new manager calling the shots. Everyone in their place. This whispering and undermining of managers, and the revolving door to the manager's office needs to stop.

Mega fees for Dembele, Pogba, Hazard and a number of others that then failed to deliver.

However, Madrid also bought Rodrigo, Ostegaard, V Junior and others, so arguably they did try to sign young and potential only to find that isn't enough when a club that size.

On to the point on transfer strategy Robert has a point, however I feel it is also not as simple as that. If we only invested in young talent with potential, and those young players fail, then the club risks relegation. That worry will always be on the minds of owners, and Relegation is simply something that cannot be even imagined. It'd be the death of the club. That's why ambition will always be tempered by conservatism.

Robert and Sam both contribute much on here to potential signings, young talent about the continent. I'm sure they watch a heck lot more football than myself, and trust they do identify good players. But the club is just too conservative to adopt a full strategy.

Always the danger of assuming an great ex-player can step up and be a great manager.

Given how our midfield has been, I'd take Pirlo as a player!!

At St. Etienne he took a team that had become relegation strugglers under Perrin and then after coming 10th in his first full season gave them 5 consecutive seasons in the top 7, incluing qualifying for Europe a number of times an winning their first trophy in 32 years. Sounds pretty good to me!

Then at Lille, admittedly with a good squad handed to him, he delivered their first title in 10 years against the superstars at PSG.

The big question mark over him for me is that he has never done anything outside of France but his time in Ligue 1 has been almost entirely positive.

Obviously, he has to be responsible for the first team and that squad but does that include the coaching staff, transfers in and out and if not then whose bailiwick does what come under? For instance, the Manager should know what juniors we have at what level but, for me, the DoF should be overseeing the coaching and style of play at the Academy, and it should resemble the style, or desired style, of the first team.

When all this has been done then a list of candidates should be drawn up and somebody, probably the DoF, should make the initial approach and report back to the Board. This may also see a proper chain of command set up where each will know his position and responsibilities and nobody will be off on his personal dream appointment.

Oh, and do it in the next fortnight given that pre-season should start in about 4 weeks and the season, not to mention pre-season friendlies, starts in about 10 weeks.

And who would be my pick? Given my preference is probably out of reach I'll just settle for the right one but give my full support to whoever gets it until that appointment proves wrong, as would appear most likely with our management set up.

What do you propose the club should do next on the director of football role, football strategy, manager search and its approach to recruitment. Over to you.

Just a thought anyway!

Of all the posts you have called it right. The problem at Everton is deeper than the Manager and there are others in positions who are barriers to progress and will be even with a new Manager if it is a condition they stay.

Alot expect Brands to come to the fore, but he is part of the Everton Establishment and not his own man.

Steve Ferns #69

Has given the best summary of potential Managers and I am impressed with his final short list and the reasons for it.

By now within the Football world the reasons for Everton failings will be well known. The choice of the next Manager will be determined by the conditions that the Everton Board are prepared to accept from the New Manager. The Manager appointed will give a fair indication of that.

Ancelotti's main failing was that he accepted conditions that eventually prevented him to get the necessary shift in power to implement necessary progressive change. The fact that he had accepted such conditions and had a get out clause in his contract points to a exit strategy from the start, with a preference for European Competition football.

But as always, lets get behind him. Whoever it may be.

A last point on Ancelotti. It has been reported here that one of the reasons (a personal reason) that Ancelotti left Everton was related to freedom of movement. In an age of Covid and Brexit, with the Ancelotti family based in Liverpool, Carlo himself but especially his son and daughter (who is married to one of the Ancelotti's technical team) didn't have the freedom to travel frequently between the UK and Italy to visit Carlo's first wife who was dying of cancer. This problem doesn't exist in the EU where some guarantees exist for EU citizens, so they are better off in Spain for travelling back and forth to Italy.

Note too Wolves can't name their new Portuguese coach because they still haven't managed to get a UK work permit for him in the new post-Brexit era. Everton can only go for a well known foreign coach with all his badges or go for an existing UK resident foreign coach (like Benitez). This issue has pushed up the costs that EU coaches are asking to move to the UK i.e. Conte.

The Gazzetta here in Italy reckons that Sarri is ready to sign a deal with Lazio.

On Pirlo. Noting that Ancelotti has walked away with 6 members of Everton's technical staff, leaving only Duncan and Alan Kelly behind. All established coaches bring their team with them. I'm not sure that is the case with Pirlo. I believe he inherited a coaching staff at Juventus and he has left them at Juventus for Allegri. If Moshiri is interested in taking Pirlo then a complete technical team needs to be created.

Also regarding Pirlo, Italian TV takes the piss out of him because of his poor body language and the fact that few understand what he is saying (he mumbles). There is a belief in Italy that the Juventus team couldn't wait to get shut of him like they did with Sarri.

People have spoken about Tim Cahill as a potential coach, who is still very much in love with all things blue. He is currently in Qatar as an ambassador for the 2022 WC but is also using his time to complete his FIFA training badges working with an academy. His elder son Kyah was at Macclesfield Town but is now playing football for Rayo Vallecano in Madrid, while his second son Shae is on Everton's Academy books.

Does this mean we’re stuck with Gomes now and I can stop “watching this space”?

Interesting

There’s no consensus at all who would be best so whoever it is we end up with we have to give him support and a fair chance. You never know, they might actually turn the club around.

It’s not easy, with very few people actually certain who they want in the managers hot seat, and the thing that struck me most when reading Steve Fearns first post, (nice to hear from you Steve) was that he said Fonseca is more pragmatic than Silva.

John Rafferty, also picks up on how important it is that Everton appoint a pragmatic manager, given the state of the current squad, and I personally think Marco Silva, would still be here if he had possessed a bit more pragmatism?

So Fonseca is pragmatic, I’m not sure about Nuno, who I’ve heard the Wolves players really liked, but felt his mind hadn’t been properly on the job for the last six months, and a manager who I used to despise, but is probably one of the most pragmatic men in football, who I’ve heard Everton are going to speak to next week, Rafa Benitez.

I just can not think waht our manager's realistic title is?

At the end of the day Evertonians will get whichever manager the club chooses, so all of the posts, both reactionary and thoughtful are meaningless to the fortunes of Everton Football Club.

I just hope the naysayers give him a chance though I won't hold my breath given the vitriol previous "non-carlo" types suffered (will that lesson ever be learned? - not a chance).

Good luck Nuno you're gonna need it here

As for the fall-out on TW, that's inevitible regardless of who is chosen, Evertonians in general and specifically those posting on here are far from being a homogenous group.

There is quite a few younger managers doing their ''apprenticeships'' so to speak and some of them may get to the big time. Potter, Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, etc.

However, some who have had a few years plying their trade may be ready to step up and do better with better clubs such as Eddie Howe and Sean Dyche.

It must be very difficult for Moshiri & Co. to make a decision which will be right for the club after the failings of Martinez, Koeman and Ancellotti who are all still holding top positions.
Nothing is a certainty no matter who they get but let's all hope the next one is not a quitter like Ancellotti.

I have, the West Mids is my stomping ground with plenty of Wolves supporters around and yet to find one with a bad word for the guy. Which in itself is hugely unusual in modern footy

The problem with Silva was he was too honest. and compliant . After the AGM where Moshiri (his last show) made a threatening pronouncement about results, Silva was left isolated. The recently promoted Brands was silent. , having already agreed to Gueye 's departure. Silva should have threw a wobbly at that stage.

To Silvas credit Everton performances towards the end of that season where the best for years. But during the Zaha Summer Brands was far from in control to stop interference from Kenwright and Moshiri, Silva was left with a transfer window not fit for purpose. He suffered the consequences, left isolated again. By rights it should have been Brands that got the sack,

It's all a gamble the experience of Carlo shows the shortest of odds can blow up in your face.

I understand disparate views but the barely disguised glee of those looking to be proved right at the first dip in form because they didn't like the managers past isn't for me.

I agree with you, they don't say a bad word about him despite this season's disappointment.

But they're Wolves, not Everton. I fear if we go down that route, we'll be having a similar debate in about 18 months time.

Some say we're a mid table club. We're not. We have a mid table team but we are not a mid table club.

Behave like the big club you are Everton. Then you may get taken seriously and take your place.

In the crap and turn to Big Sam.He saves us and we don't give him a go.
The most successfull managers have played for us,Dunc, 73 goals 270 odd games?He steadies ship.

My god, Moshiri has loads of money,wants success but cant trust in people he has employed, must know football.

We have lost our identity on the pitch.Dubious signings, all over the place.

Got to be the laughing stock of Premier League,Europe.

Top four play pretty well same way home away.Beat us??
Maybe we have a chance to stabilise, create a style, Leeds???

Hope we get Nuno, ok sit back counter??
Seems like a decent bloke.

Lets not forget Howard Kendal was ruthless, Andy Gray, gone.
He made some horrendous signings left Ratters on the bench didnt fancy him.

We have history.

We are at a cross roads after Carlo,Pandemic 🤞🤞🤞🤞🙈🙈🙈

Lets hope its our time.They get it right.

No idea what the plan will be.Do they inside the sanctum.

You seem yo know a bit more mate, but I agree that Silva, never kicked up enough fuss after not getting backed properly by Brands, and maybe that’s why his name has been mentioned in some quarters with regards Everton recently.

I know everyone has been mentioned, but maybe Brands protected himself a lot more than he tried to protect Silva? but it goes back to what Barry is saying, and the vitriol, was already in place for Marco Silva, because perhaps not that many people wanted him in the first place?

Silva’s body language at Bournemouth, when a simple ball over the top killed us, made me think his time was up, but maybe if he’d been a bit more pragmatic, he might have went more defensive, and protected the centre of his defence, until he found more pace, and this is the main reason I feel Everton need a very pragmatic manager right now, because it’s not an easy job?

Steve (135) - I don’t know what the club should do. And I do not have the requisite expertise, experience or insight to write a route-map towards success. Nobody else on here does either. And seemingly nobody at the club too. It’s a tough ask, so that’s why the ABC philosophies of some posters on here are likely to attract my attention.

It's all deeply uninspiring though. 5(?) years on from the takeover you'd like to think we'd be pushing for the likes of Simeone or at least Rodgers. RS fans find it hilarious how we go about our business which probably says it all.

i agree that in the beginning of that Silva final season the player did give up on him. But during the run in at the end of this season, it did occur to me that it would have been worth Ancelotti contacting Silva for advice. At the end of Silvas first full season the players where not just motivated, they where relentless.

I'm not just a scratched record now. I'm a broken one.

I'm pretty sure we've all had spells in our own workplace where that attitude spreads like a cancer, he/she isn't giving 100% why should I syndrome.

That's why Everton needs a strong personality to become the manager, stop the cliques, ensure every player gives 100% as often as possible and get them to concentrate on their own individual performances. I imagine it's akin to herding cats when trying to get very rich young men to listen to sage advice, but that's why the manager gets the big bucks.

There are a lot of players at Everton whose capabilities are a great deal higher than they have shown, and if whoever becomes manager can truly harness that talent, and never allow them to drop their standards, the future may not be as bleak as many of us believe it to be.

Then Galtier came in and saved them. Next season they were back to pre-Bielsa levels and got into the CL. Before pushing on to their 4th ever title two years later.

As for St. Etienne, the side I always favoured in France, Galtier took over from Alain Perrin, who had battled to get them up from the second tier. Perrin left St Etienne in 17th, and safe. Galtier pushed them up the league immediately to 10th. Then he had them regularly 4th to 6th. He won them their first trophy for 30 years. Ok, it was only the league cup, but it was still a trophy. They had Aubamayang in that season.

Now, let's remember that St Etienne are traditional powerhouses of France. They have won a record 10 titles (level with Marseille), but no10 was back in 1981. Since then they've been passed by as the game has gone to the big cities and the team from the foot of the alps with just treading water.

Galtier did a solid, if unspectacular job there. The job at Lille was spectacular and on the back of the failure of one of the game's most lauded managers failing so badly.

Geez, Ajay, really?

The culture that's reduced us to lesser status is still infecting the boardroom, and everything else, and that's bizarre to me.

Just what it's going to take Moshiri, only the fifteenth wealthiest owner of a current Premier League club (and that's way less than midtable, obviously) to actually get real with football rather than planning applications and stadium designs is quite beyond me.

Gallardo is the one I want. But I would settle for Galtier or ten Hag. I'd like Sarri if he can be convinced to come here. I'd be happy with whoever Brands appoints, as long as it is Brands' choice and not foisted upon him. He needs his own man this time.

I've been to Dudley and would happily pass on the escape code and tunnel location if your wife's family need rescuing then again you might want to keep them right where they are.

On the club comparison I would suggest the Wolves transformation far exceeds our requirements given their start point. We have a solid mid table base and I'm firmly of the opinion if someone puts together a "team" rather than a compilation of "names" we would improve significantly.

I don't actually believe this BUT there might even be players in our squad who would improve with a different mindset.

I managed a team of lunatics once, and I’m not exaggerating when I tell you that one of my players said to me that he was leaving because he only wanted a game of footy, and this lad, was a world champion in a much tougher sport than football.

I banned cannabis in the changing room before the game, and although it was a struggle (some of them honestly needed a spliff to function) we finally got promotion, even if we stunk the gaff out as much as Ancellotti’s Everton. And yet in the prestigious National Sunday Cup, we were brilliant, knocking out the previous years finalists, a team from Kirkby, who had won their league a few years on the bounce, and a team from Silsden, who had half a team playing in the North West Counties league.

We would have won the next round only for Christmas, a bad winter, and also because old habits die hard, and looking back at all the games we played that season, you have just given me the answer why Barry!

“OUR PLAYERS FOCUS ON THEIR TEAMMATES PERFORMANCE MUCH MORE THAN THEIR OWN” is not only 100% accurate, (my own personal experience says it’s got to be because they don’t trust each other?) it’s also educated me, whilst also giving me a trip down memory lane! “even if I’m sorry for boring everyone though”!

He sounds pretty tactically astute and adaptable. I think he's the equal of Silva as a coach. Silva seemed to lose it when his assistant left. Santo is certainly a more personable man manager and I think he can put his ideas across well. Silva couldn't do that.

Less of the positive spin. Get with the script!

'Bah! Hambug! shows the lack of ambition and imagination that we are even trying to talk to Moyes. Typical bloody Everton that!'

They say Ancelotti prefers to manage, leaving the coaching to others, but his body language near the end, seemed to say, “what the hell am I supposed to do with these”?

We need someone stronger, someone to make the players concentrate on their own game, instead of having a half arsed attitude every few weeks, but this is just my personal opinion obviously.

There is not just a problem with some present players. There a problem with some ex players. Everton have been going round in circles for years. You can't expect things to change if the new Manager is jumping onto the same old roundabout. There really is not many capable or willingly hands at Everton to help him stay on.

The conditions that the new Everton Manager joins Everton under are critical. If he turns round and demands that Everton either ; need a new Director of Football, ; a New First Team Coach; New Head of Youth Development's or; a New Head of Medical Services what are his chances of getting the job.

If like Conte as reported in the case of Tottenham that he needs a sizable budget to replace players will he get even a hearing.

The Manager selected will either be one who agrees to work with what is currently at Everton or one that demands changes in personnel.

I expect the same old roundabout.

There is not just a problem with some present players. There a problem with some ex players. Everton have been going round in circles for years. You can't expect things to change if the new Manager is jumping onto the same old roundabout. There really is not many capable or willingly hands at Everton to help him stay on.

The conditions that the new Everton Manager joins Everton under are critical. If he turns round and demands that Everton either ; need a new Director of Football, ; a New First Team Coach; New Head of Youth Development's or; a New Head of Medical Services what are his chances of getting the job.

If like Conte as reported in the case of Tottenham that he needs a sizable budget to replace players will he get even a hearing.

The Manager selected will either be one who agrees to work with what is currently at Everton or one that demands changes in personnel.

I expect the same old roundabout.

And then clapped happily after he scored.

Fuck, I'm a happy clapper!!

In all fairness to Potter, the state of Everton means we might need Harry Potter!

Sadly I played with lads who had all the ability in the world who got sidelined by drugs, women and general lethargy. I remember one of the best centre forwards around turning up for a Sunday morning match eating a donner kebab straight from a night out (ingenious business model to bring a fast food van to the municipal playing fields on a Sunday morning). He still bagged a couple 😄

Not since Martinez was appointed anyway, which again makes me question how professional we really are?

Not since Martinez was appointed anyway, which again makes me question who professional we really are?

We all like different types of football. But Nuno's really grates with me. I don't enjoy watching a side with a back 5 and 2 holding midfielders. I don't care how far forward the wingbacks get, they are still defenders. He'd be playing Digne on the left not Richarlison. Moutinho and Neves sit so deep.

I'm sorry, but it's really boring to watch. I really do not like it. He's far too safe as a manager. That's why he failed at Porto. He's just the Portguese Moyes for me. He's certainly not a dynamic young coach, who will fix our side on the training pitch. sure, he will coach them, but he'll merely be drilling them using old fashioned tactics and methods. I want innovation. A manager who can unlock the talent that these players possessed to convince us to spend all that money on them.

I want exciting attacking football where we take the game to our opponents. Not scraping a 1-0 at Burnley because we are so well drilled.

No better consolation when you've been beat 4-1 than a postgame plate of fresh chimichangas and a Jarritos orange soda. For $3.

He actually played a 4-3-3 a lot when he was at Valencia so isn't afraid to change things around. I really like him in interviews. I think he has a bit of a maverick quality and will say what he means, but also comes across as quite a humble guy a bit like Carlo did.

Watch the Tifo video on Gallardo. He's surely a special manager in the making. I'd love us to sign him and then watch him catapult us up the league. So what if he left after a couple of seasons for Barcelona. He will only get that job if he can get us into the top 4 and unlock all that we desire.

My second point is one I mentioned to you previously. We don't have the speed to play "exciting attacking" football. Maybe we'll buy a whole bunch of pace this summer, but it's not there now.

And I gotta ask, who exactly in our squad do you think has talent that a good manager could "unlock"?? Dude, nobody is gonna make a superstar out of Bernard, Gomes, Iwobi or Doucoure no matter how much we spent on them. Allan and Siggy are not going to find a fountain of youth and raise their levels to new heights. Where do you see this hidden unlockable talent?

PS... thanks for the callout, but I barely glimpsed Valencia that season. I only really got familiar with Gomes when he arrived at Barca.

As Tony says Everton have had six Managers in this last eight seasons. Is a new Manager really going to change things , if other changes in personnel are not going to happen. It is noticeable that season after season Evertons performances gravates to the same very recognisable level. You could nearly put the kettle on for it is that predictable.

Mike, thought it was you I had discussed Andre Gomes with when he first came and you were explaining how he went deeper and deeper when he was at Valencia to the point he was a defensive midfielder when he signed for Barcelona, when the lad I enjoyed watching was box to box player who thrived in attacking positions.

As for the current squad, I think the main issue is the profile of the players. By profile I mean skillset. Nearly everyone of our players have things they are flawed at, even for their position. This is to be expected, as we can't sign world class players. Signing flawed players is fine if the other players cover the flaws, a moneyball type approach.

I really rate Brands, but there's concerns that the signings have not been joined up enough. So take Gomes, who I know I am in the minority in rating, but he needs players around him with certain attributes, mainly pace and defensive acumen. Putting him with Doucoure and Allan, as at the start of the season, and he looks good. Put him with sigurdsson and Davies and he looks terrible.

Sure, our squad does not look capable of playing front foot attacking football. However, this was a heavy pressing side under Silva. We did play front foot ball only 18 months ago when we beat Man utd 4-0, and beat chelsea and arsenal in the same run of games. So, for me, this squad can do that, they just need additions who can bring out the best in each other, and cover up flaws. Less of this signing Supposed Superstars just because they are available and having little regard for how it all fits together. I blame Moshiri for that, but Brands is meant to stop him.

Back to Nuno Espirito Santo, I just do not like any side that lines up with a back 5 and 2 holding midfielders. That's 8 defenders including the keeper if you ask me. So sure, I don't doubt what you say, but I will not pay to watch a team with so many defenders. No thanks, I would rather watch paint dry.

Good post.
Whoever the new manager is he will be getting the usual stick if he hasnt got us around top 4 before Christmas.
Almost an impossible job the Everton manager, regardless of who gets the job.

Regarding our signings, of course you're right that we're going to bring in flawed players because the perfect gems will go elsewhere. But the one flaw we can't live with -- if we're going to play on the front foot -- is lack of speed. In our current squad only DCL, Rich, Godfrey, Doucoure and Holgate have genuine pace, and the first two are not particularly quick off the mark, so they don't always press effectively. As for the last, the only acceleration I ever want to see from him again is burning rubber out of town.

As for the style of manager I want somebody committed to playing attacking high energy football. The team I have enjoyed watching most this season are Leeds they aren’t all great players but they are fit, they know what’s expected of them and they have a good attitude. Compare that to Everton’s collection of highly paid chancers for this season.

Since the season Joe Royle got us to sixth in 95-96 I can honestly say I’ve only really enjoyed watching us one season and that was Martinez’s first season. Moyes best season when we finished fourth saw us with two points more than we achieved this season and a negative goal difference. For much of his tenure home form against teams other than the top six was strong but away performances for the majority of 11 years were cowardly and unsuccessful on the whole with embarrassing capitulations against the top six. I don’t want Moyes, Benitez or the Wolves guy as they are fundamentally negative.

We (Everton fans) have no divine right to win trophies, we do or should however have an entitlement to expect Everton to play attacking football at home and away that doesn’t mean abandoning defending it just means trying to win all games. For the majority of 30 years under dour Walter, Miserable Moyes, Robot Ronnie, Fat Sam, Silva and then Carlo we have been subjected to some of the most abject sterile performances ever witnessed. Martinez doesn’t get a free pass either for being so arrogant that he decided to turn us into a ‘jarg’ Barca and lost the dressing room and fan base as a result.

Who to appoint is a tough call and I suspect Moshiri will plump for a glamour appointment personally I would rather have someone like Graham Potter or some other lesser known coach. Perhaps if we had a young team managed by a progressive coach playing high energy football it might engender a better atmosphere at Goodison (if and when we get back) and on TW (only joking there!)

Moshiri needs to go balls deep into his money sack and get us the best manager he can.

Next, he needs to give them pot-loads of money. Literally the most money any Everton manager has ever been given for transfers. Create a balanced squad of young talent, established quality players and end-of-career game changers like City and Chelsea were able to do back in the day.

UEFA can ban us from the next season’s European competitions (ha!), fine us, deduct points that mean we finish mid-table… whatever, who cares. We’ll have a great squad and manager plus a new stadium just over the horizon. Finishing mid-table due to a points deduction is a small short-term price to pay for supping at success’s ample teat in a few season’s time.

Go for it, big time. Fuck glass ceilings, fuck the cards being stacked against us, and most of all fuck incessant mediocrity.

COYFB!!!

However, I did a little search and saw the Portugal U21s are pretty decent, even beating England this year where talent is the best in years. So I'm all in for a Portuguese manager to bring in some of that young talent and nurture the next Ronaldo or Fernandes.

Another thing about tactics and drills... sometimes I think drills and tactics are useful for when defensive players to get the ball to better players when winning possession, or how the creative players can fit into a defensive position without the ball. Carlo got this down really well. The best teams have this and rely on the match winners to decide games. Unfortunately for us Richarlison couldn't decide on a dribble or a shot sometimes instead of a pass to DCL and moments like these affected us. If Nuno is boring defensive, that's fine with me, as long as he has the ability to bring in some exciting players in the final third. That's all we are lacking in reality... to add 15 or more goals to the team. Then we can improve other areas after this.

I think I’m caring less and less about whether it’s Nuno, Rafa, Moyes, Duncan or other…..just get it done, and get the players in we desperately need on the right please!!

This club is in the hands of a man who will take advice from a 'Del Boy' ex used car salesman and theatre ponce who cried his eyes out Gollum left for UTD.

Mmmm? I wonder what a spiv and theatre luvvie working together can come up with?

We'll end up with Sam Allardyce in drag if things go on like they are.

I've given many views, so I'm just going to ride this one out and see what happens.

Couple of follow ups before I call it a night.

Barry; yes. I know it's a cliche but I was always taught to win your personal battle first. If every player does that, the team wins collectively all over the pitch. But focus on your own game.

I agree, the manager is there to organise, coordinate, instruct and direct. But he needs the right players at his disposal. It is a combination of both but I just don't believe we have enough of the right players. We need to fix that.

Barry, please send the code! To be specific, the extended family live mainly in Pensnett. I find Kingswinford a good "escape" when I'm down that way! Nice place, decent pubs.

Jerome; if I think I'm on the same page as you, we have to get rid of this ex-player culture that is hanging around our neck. Especially now as they are ex-players that have barely won anything between them. Kendall and Harvey was one thing. Ebbrell and Jeffers is different.

Right, good night fellow blues. Although I've no doubt whatsoever I will be waking regularly and foolishly checking for updates throughout the night. The dogs will have me up at 5:30 anyway and I know the first thing I will do!!

I also think Santo is one of the least divisive choices. Not many would be genuinely thrilled by the appointment, but likewise - I don't think think many would be up in arms over it either. I think the majority of us on here would simply simmer down and take a "well, let's see what happens" approach, which may just be what the club needs right now.

(mind you, that's just part of me. The other part is still holding out for a genuinely exciting candidate)

The Everton squad that perhaps were in a false position after the first 4 games showed after that in most games a serious lack of intensity and ability to compete with even the lower teams.

I saw all too often James and Richie dropping their heads after half an hour if they were not getting involved either by their own devices or other players.

A forceful captain leading by example may have changed this but alas Seamus is passed his best and quite honestly doesn't appeal to me as a captain.

Obviously the midfield performers no matter who was out there just didn't get any control in most games and were just chasing shadows many times in many games.

We may look to injuries as an excuse but I don't buy that at all. When these guys got fit they played like the end of the season couldn't come quick enough.

The new gaffer whoever it is will have some time and many of us will grant some leeway unless he is someone that many don't like beforehand.

We are all frustrated as to how the season fell apart followed by the Ancellotti quitting so it remains to be seen how this situation will unfold in the next couple of months.

But he can't control everything and then blame a manager for not playing, picking, agreeing to certain styles, players etc.

Manager's need to have final say of first team affairs and agree on senior (over 25's) player recruitment.

My stated 25 year age is just an example. A good player is a good player, I'm not generally concerned with age within reason and there's always exceptions.

On Mancini, I known several players complained about his methods but they generally didn't play to often for a team who won the Premier league, so I wouldn't take to much notice of what’s said. Certainly playing and winning medals is more important, ask ex-players of Conte, Mourinho etc.

The controversy surrounding James Rodriguez's omission from Colombia's Copa America squad will continue to rumble on, yet the Everton midfielder has come in for criticism after being seen partying in Miami whilst his country faced Peru in a World Cup qualifier.

The video showing the Everton star in a Miami nightclub has been circulated on social networking websites, with the images supposedly being captured at the exact time the match against Peru was being played.

For many fans this would be unacceptable, whilst others would concede that Rodriguez wasn't selected by the coach, therefore he is on holiday and permitted to whatever he likes.

Unfortunately, the situation hasn't gone unnoticed, with some comparing Rodriguez's reaction to being dropped to that of Radamel Falcao, with the veteran striker merely going back to training in order to improve his physical condition.

That won't make James many friends back home.

The other one told me we should go for Ten Hag.

They both said no to Duncan.

Okay, that's what I told them. But they agreed. Well, I think they did. As always, they looked, nodded and just wondered when I'm taking them out or feeding them! No particular preference or order of priority!

It's going to be interesting to see what comes out Kieran. The theme emerging is there is no seeming upset or despair at his departure.

As always, it will be interesting to read and understand but as per what you said on the other thread, I'm trying to think forward. Guess that's all we can do now and hope (that word) we get this one right. But then many of us thought we had done last time.

Kenwright is playing the long game. He’s waiting for Moshiri to tire and after he’s squeezed every last penny out of him he’ll offer him a fiver for his shares and tell him to get lost. Billy’s dream is to recover HIS club and run it with one of his darling boys.

Usmanov needs to move quickly and get rid of these two useless fucks once and for all!!

The article also claims the new man will be tasked with trimming the squad. Is this the same squad that had 2 keepers and a primary school class on the bench at times last year and still have a full compliment of subs?

Just noticed the poll. I see us supporters (or those on here and who voted) are collectively undecided as well. No clear overwhelming front runner.

If true, the plus is that Moshiri isn't taking Bill's advice because we know where that points.

The worrying aspect is your last point. Trimming what?!! Stating the obvious time, but last season, aside from a lot of the players not being good enough, it was the depth of squad that cost us.

He'd be a great fit Ken. But then he will be for Tottenham as well given Levy doesn't want to provide a huge transfer budget hence the breakdown in talks with Conte despite the supposed talk of a £15m a year wage.

A player being snapped on a large bed in a private plane and doing his thing in a Miami nightclub when teammates are playing in high profile games doesn't need any translation between Colombia and Merseyside to understand the inevitable reaction and possible consequences.

James is obviously out of touch with his fanbase and professional standing, coming across as irresponsible.

Probably he will end up in Shanghai. At least you can be our Man in Havanna, so to speak, to keep us posted.

I continuously have that debate with my brother who grew up only really knowing Moyes. We watched Everton win the FA Cup together, but he was only 5. His season ticket and away days were all Moyes.

I understand them, I sympathise, but it worries me what level of expectation that generation has. Don't get me wrong, he's extremely knowledgeable about football. Probably less bias than me. But it's the expectation.It's been drained out of a generation.

I might be going mad and unrealistic as I approach 50 this year, but I can never have that level of expectation for Everton.

Maybe a safe manager to oversee a brave recruitment strategy is best of all.

I don't believe we're going to be in the mix for top 4 whoever we appoint, so stability and a return to the top 5, 6, 7th place with a developing squad would be a good option.

My only hope is Usmanov, like UFO’s will eventually reveal himself and save us.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rW9DxqYtvmU

Hope this link works? Bad machine 1 is ToffeeWeb posters! 🤪🤪🤪

Chairman Bill will have only one name in mind - the one familiar to us all - whilst the owner is all for considering a wider selection of candidates- particularly the ex-Wolves chap.

For me, I say just get the decision made and start the planning of a new season without delay. For what it's worth, my money is on Bill's will prevailing !

Just reading Andy Dunne, write a sensible article on Everton, although I’m not sure about Eddie Howe, who he was saying Everton should go for?

I do remember talking to Dan Gosling, he heard my scouse accent when I approached him and even my son thought I was going over to give him some stick.

I shook Goslings hand, thanked him for giving me something I’d waited 35 years of my life for, and then asked him about Eddie Howe. His reply was he’s brilliant, and he was certain he’d become the England manager one day, which had me smiling, and telling Gosling that wasn’t really much of a recommendation nowadays!

His appointments so far have set this club back years, and yes I know he has pumped in millions, but unlike Abramovich has little idea what is needed to turn this club around. Yes investing millions was one of the missing ingredients but even more important was the appointment of the right manager which he has palpably failed to do. He also brought in the DOF role which have been filled by Walsh and Brands, and even worse he has allowed both to sign players without having any recourse to what the manager wants Josh King being the perfect example. There are even some on here suggesting that Brands should be in charge of manager recruitment. So you bring in a manager and pay him £11 million per year but allow someone who has never managed in his life to buy the players, a complete recipe for a disaster which we have seen play out since Moshiri insisted on this DOF role to be introduced without ant concept as to what the role of the DOF should be.

Time will tell - but hunger, pace and energy injected into our squad would be a good start. Who can do that? I'll check me tea leaves.

Ps - Hello and welcome back Steve. Still on the bike?

This squad with a few exceptions capitulated. Dreadful display last few months. Good luck to turn that around.

When I look back at my own game, I always thought the better I became at one thing, then it usually took away from the things I was much more natural at on a football field, and this is how I now view Ancelotti, who got us some great results by making a shallow (imo) squad, hard to beat, but at the detriment of then improving us by playing positive football.

His narrow 4-4-2 was absolutely soul-destroying, and never suited the players at his disposal, not even one bit remotely, and this is why we capitulated, and possibly also why the manager lost interest?

Interesting point on your Gosling-Howe discussion. I could see him as England manager.

It's a totally different playing field. Look at Southgate. Who here would want him as our (or any) club manager? Martinez with Belgium. It's personally why I wouldn't consider Joachim Low even though is is available. I don't think we have, but I wouldn't.

It was near the end of June, and at a time when most footballers are feeling refreshed and looking to get back to work, and to get pre-season out of the way, and this is how the conversation went.

He said it was a pleasure working for Eddie Howe, because he was always coming up with something different, and this kept the daily training sessions very enjoyable, and he felt that he was constantly learning from his manager, and he was full of respect for him because of this.

What do you think about Southgate anyway Danny, because if you’re living in the patriotic part of the country, then everyone will have an opinion on the England manager, who has now got a lot of very good midfield players at his disposal, although they might just lack a little bit of experience at international level?

My opinion on Southgate? I think he's a decent coach, but a bit uninspiring. Better suited to the international setup, so it makes sense he came through that way as he never really cut it at club management and he's a good fit for the FA. He's more a coach than a manager, which I think is the key difference between the two types; club v international.

When I've watched England down here, it's difficult to know what they think as they don't tend to watch the match. They generally sing songs about World War 2, Germans and throw beer in the air if there's a goal!! Sorry for stereotyping all the London blues out there who follow England!!

Whilst on the subject of international, I see Dominic has just been quoted with some disturbing language from an Everton perspective according to my son. The curse of Everton players hooking up with the England squad could be striking again.

I see England having a chance this summer. I think France are the favourites. They look strong. Germany are in transition and I think Belgium's ship has sailed, but they're still strong. Watch Italy as well. They could manage their way to success in a very defensive and Italian way.

Good points about a lot of England fans, although I must admit to following England a few times throughout my life, and especially remember the World Cup in Germany, as being a wonderful occasion, sitting inside the stadiums with my mates and two young sons, who have unfortunately never seen Everton win anything But still they go, and one of them absolutely everywhere!

I was scarred by my very first England experience in Luxemburg as a young boy. Rival English fans fighting amongst each other and then rioting collectively through the city after the match.

Coupled with my "mongrel" background; Liverpool Irish, Northern Irish and Scottish plus spending some of my childhood in Germany, I just never really connected with international football.

Don't get me wrong, I love watching international football, I just don't have any affiliation with a particular team. I always want Holland to do well, but that's because of Cruyff and that 1988 team!!

'Moshiri needs to appoint an advisor to himself on all football matters because he is obviously clueless.'

He had one in Steve Walsh who advised him to appoint Allardyce having already ruled Sam out some weeks before. A panic move having been ill-prepared to find a replacement after sacking Koeman and allowing weeks to drift by without resolution.

He then appointed Marcel Brands at exactly the same time as Sam was dispensed with and Brands only role in Silva's appointment was to rubber stamp Moshiri's choice.

Similarly with Ancelotti. The timing of his sacking at Napoli shortly after Silva's dismissal at Everton gave Moshiri the opportunity to land a truly 'Hollywood manager' as he desired. Again, the hired hand Brands probably had little say in that appointment.

So for almost his entire tenure Moshiri has had a football man to advise him. The first was a bad appointment. The current incumbent should be allowed to do the job he was recruited for, to follow a plan and stick to it, rather than Everton whimsically playing it off the cuff every 18 months.

I'll repeat again, of course Moshiri is the man who will have the final say, but the name of the new manager will be a good pointer as to who has most influenced the appointment.

I've even heard Marco Silva is being considered again, Moshiri must have confidence issues if that's true, it would be the craziest, most laughable appointment in premiership history. I'd sooner see Ferguson installed before any of the dross mentioned in the press so far.

For heaven's sake Moshiri and Brands get it sorted out before we are left with a doomed squad of mostly relegation ​misfits and one the most feeble managers in the premiership.

💯% spot on Barry #17.

Sadly folks,it will be Moshiri's appointment ONLY...sigh

All the names touted above, it really hopefully comes down to a manager/trainer who can work for the first time in tandem with Brands. He hadSsilva basically dumpedo n him when he joined and the disaster Magnifico was Holwood Moshiri's choice no one else. So called world class manager (was a world class manager long ago), was never on the same page with Brands. So lets hope he has the control this time and actually gets someone he can work with, but I am not holding my breath.

My choice it would be only one person the person, the same person I wanted to see come in when Marco got the boot. Marcelo Gallardo is the one. Gets his teams playing on the front foot, tactically astute, takes no messing from anyone and players buy into his management. Oh yeah actually successful. Mid forties and now ripe for the move away from River to Europe. Plenty of big clubs monitoring him we should stike while the irons hot.

Marcel dialling code for BuenosAaires is +54-11

We need a ruthless,larger than life Gaffer at the helm,who will develop a fuck-you mind set throughout the club,a bloke who will reinstall "Fortress Goodison" and not whimp out going to the "Sly Sixes" backyard too,a bloke that puts smiles back on all our faces once again, believing we're back on track with this manager.

It would seem from fellow Blues that even the national footballing media now see us as a total irrelevance,having a new Gaffer that laughs at the thought and in a blink of a eye says..."fuck 'em all...were EVERTON,that's all that matters to me".

That'll do for me also,ta.

Potter has quite a good team with Brighton and should have done better than just avoiding relegation.

Howe kept Bournemouth in the Prem for many seasons not spending that much and playing attractive football. He's also a blue. He's served his Apprenticeship and is preferable to Nuno and Pottet without a shadow of a doubt.

My choice would be Rangnick. High press attacking football. No more defensive Italian shite.

In fact they were around the top 10 for net spending in the years after their promotion. They spent a lot of money on the likes of Afobe (10m), Ibe (15m), Solanke (20m), Yerma (25m), Mepham (12m) etc.

Howe did a good job getting them in the PL but was then given money to spend and took Bournemouth down. They may have a small stadium but are bankrolled by a Russian billionaire, Maxim Demin.

They played exciting football but were atrocious defensively and showed very little sign of improvement over their time in the PL. They achieved a best of 9th and had no cup runs of particular merit. Their best goal difference was about -12.

Don't see any attraction in Howe other than the fact he might be an Evertonian which doesn't count for much if you can't organise a defense.

I like Rangnick as an option but it's been a while since he coached, perhaps he might work in conjunction with someone else?

I suspect part of the very reason we got Ancelotti in the first place was related to this. Even when we played badly under the Italian his cv and reputation within football gave him a certain gravity. At least if we lost under Ancelotti, the owner could rationalize that there isn't another three time champions league winning manager sitting on his arse who could maybe do a better job.
There wasn't anyone more qualified and experienced than Ancelotti, who'd won as many things in as many places. And I do think that was actually the whole point.
A few other posters have alluded to a similar type of feeling - likening giving Lewis Hamilton an Austin Allegro and expecting a world championship. Moshiri bought the most expensive pile of flops perhaps ever assembled in football history, and is now hunting for the "right man" to get the results his expenditure predicts we ought to return.
This rather strikes me as like buying mutton for your guests, and then searching the planet for a chef who can turn that mutton into chicken maryland and a tasty vegetarian option. But I digress.

I don't think any "energetic young manager" could achieve anything of note at Everton right now. They would not enjoy the owners trust, faith or confidence and they would be a bad patch or mistake away from the out the door and I-told-you-so. We don't have the culture or the environment to support or develop a bright young football mind, nor are we even remotely viewed from a neutrals perspective as having such things either.
If you generally accept most or all of that then the folly of hoping for such an appointment starts to become more self evident. We actually need someone that Moshiri respects enough to essentially leave alone with Brands to get on with things. Whom that is, I've little idea, but somebody without a significant track record should be a non starter for the reasons I've discussed.

They all do need to be able to get respect in the boardroom and not be intimidated by Moshiri, Black Bill or Brands.
I'm thinking Rangnick, Marcelo, Galtier or Fonseca as the head honcho with a free choice of coaching support.

Howe or Moyes would just toe the party line and that has obviously led us to where we are = nowhere.

With a weaker coach, Brighton would not have a good side at all.

And if they can hang on to their players and bring in new talent (like Caceido who we were also interested in) then they might well start to do more than just avoid relegation.

If he's a smooth operator, he will find a way to work hand in glove with Brands and- if he has any sense -he will agree 'an accommodation' with him before accepting the job.

All this overlooks the hold that Chairman Bill will seek to maintain in his role of Moshiri's mentor. If there is a sniff of further interferance he will do well to walk away. And if this should ever be the reason for any dissatisfaction in the post, he will do the club a favour by telling the world about it !

I think both Moyes and Nuno have the ability and experience to do the job well, we can only hope that those charged with making the appointment have the nouse to make the right appointment and establish workable conditions to allow whoever they appoint to prove it !

Any decent player we got, we generally sold on for a profit, then used the proceeds to bring other players in.

If anyone has some time to do any stats, I would be more than happy to read our incoming spend on players, and our outgoing transfer money we netted, over the course of those Moyes years.

EFC Transfers

If BK had more money he would of spent more. I'm pretty certain he wasn't happy with best of the rest. Just as Moyes wasn't.

We will now sit on our hands as quality players we should be in for move to other clubs. Ooh that must be Kenwrights fault... sorry, l forgot.

With the BMD project about to kick-off and take priority in the money queue, any manager appointed will do well to maintain top half even with Moshiri's money. But if halfway can be maintained and the quality of football improves - and whoever is appointed lays off the bullshit - I, for one, will be satisfied.
For a while, at least !

Surely it can't be this hard to find a decent manager, afterall they get to bring home a £20-£50 million contract.

Brands will find, fingers crossed, 3 or 4 top signings and our new manager has a better chance than the last magician. Pity Paul Daniels isn't around anymore. Although we could get Duncan to manage us with Debbie Mcgee as assistant.

Also remarkable that Moyes gets lambasted and ridiculed on here for what he did achieve during that period with an £18M net spend.

Also Hilarious that Don Carlo couldn't even achieve what Moyes regularly did on a zero budget, and called it a successful season.

Makes you wonder how many lawnmowers there are at FF.

Teams like City and RS have this and is why they are very difficult to beat. With these qualities they are generally in control of most games and create lots of chances.
Only on odd occasions do they not take those chances and don't pick up the points.

We hope that the new gaffer recognizes the deficiencies in the Everton squad and sets about improving it----soon!!!!

Those are the players we should have kept hold of, instead of selling, each time we got into a promising position, we sold a key player, we could have said no, but instead of standing firm and saying no you are contracted to Everton, we rolled over at every opportunity, and took the money.

Rooney was the start of us letting our key players leave, you can add lukaku, Arteta, Lescott, Stones, Fellaini to the mix.

Not just a case of players leaving under Moyes, we continued to let decent players leave.

Will not be long before we allow Calvert-Lewin and Richarlison to leave, instead of standing firm.

Cannot disagree we bought badly these past few years.

What I am saying is back then, we bought well, and should have pushed forward, instead we allowed the big teams to pick off our top players, so everytime we built well, we buckled and allowed players to leave

There would be no chance whatsoever of a manager coming in from the lower divisions, steering us to seventeenth and Moshiri keeping the faith and not firing them. That was the the point I was hastening to make.

What a bizarre situation, it could only happen at Everton and explains the chronic delay in a new appointment, something we need to sort out and begin the process of recruitment before all the decent players have been snapped up.

Moshiri either needs to appoint Ferguson as manager or allow any new boss to clear the decks and bring in his own team, a shambles is the current result as usual.

We've expensively bought too many players who aren't that good, then we can't sell them, or have to do so at a loss. The good ones? We sell them, then we flounder.

Howe would make me nervous. Martinez done an admirable job of keeping Wigan in the Premier League playing a decent style of football. And he actually won a trophy as part of the course.

Howe smells too much of an English Martinez appointment.

Very good point Paul Tran. We've been having that discussion on a few of the threads (losing track of which ones). Unfortunately, we only need look across the park to see that there is no problem moving players on at profit as long as you replace them. And to do so without using all the money you've just made.

Our alleged business model has been a complete 180 to that.

My suspicion is that our manager search has three protagonists:

Moshiri: wants big name like Conte, Poch, to show his mates we're a big club.

Brands: wants to go for one of those 'up and coming non-Brit coaches I know nothing about who could be anything.

Kenwright: Moyes, Dunc, Howe, Dyche. Good old honest Everton, eh?

Who's gonna win this one, folks?

Whoever we choose, I'd like the board to come out with a statement/strategy on why he was chosen and how we want to grow & develop the football side of the club.

I'd also like someone to come in and look at the levels of competence in EITC, which I believe is the thing other chairmen talk to Keneright about, and see how it can be applied to the football side of the club.

For me, I will be happy if the appointment is made and Brands says that this is his appointment of a head coach that he can work with to steer the good ship Everton into the future. As many have alluded to, backroom staff will be vital if this is to work. Perhaps it is finally time for the likes of Ferguson and Unsworth to take the plunge into senior managemnet elsewhere?

If that's Nuno; fine. Eddie Howe; fine. Gallardo; fine. Roberto Martinez; fine. Whoever, as long as they really wnat to be here and are happy for Brands to call the overall shots on recruitment.

I continue to gravitate towards Graham Potter. Brighton seemed able to mix attractive, high energy football with a solid enough defense which would do for me. I think they were a bit unlucky last year and their goal difference (which I often think over the course of a league season is a decent indicator of how good a team is) would have had them 12th. If they had a striker who could put the ball in the net they'd have been even higher.

Brands bringing in talented players in their early 20's from around the world and Potter coaching them in a team that plays high energy, entertaining football without having a Howe-esque leaky defense. Aim for top 7/8 next season with some good cup runs and exciting football; and then push on from there. If all goes well then in 2-3 years time we are where Leicester are now, knocking loudly on the door for Champions league and with a cohesive team filled with young talent. Sound good to anyone else?!!

I think to achieve this Moshiri and Kenwright need to step back, stop treating this club like a train set or some faded glamour model to show off to the boys and let the football men take control. It may be that Brands is not all he is cracked up to be but we'll never know till you let him do his job properly.

The others just seem like filler without any real basis. Either just fan fantasy, or bookies trying to entice bets.

So Nuno or Potter? Nuno has generally performed better, although is a but more conservative. Potter plays a style we'd like to see adopted, but whether he can be successful in the top half of the league is a doubt.

Out of the two I'd go for Potter.

Moshiri will say, 'My money, my pick', whilst Bill will point to the clause in the share sale agreement which apparently ensures he is 'Chairman for Life' and thus a major decision-maker!

Big Sam saw it as a mess and it appears Carlo felt the same. Nothing will change and we can only look forward to seeing Brands' post continue to be merely titular – particularly if Moyes 'gets the gig'!

Someone needs to own this. It needs to be Brands acting on behalf of Moshiri's strategy (which I hope he is advising him on).

Keep Kenwright and sentimental Everton away from this one. You, I and most of the people who post on this website could do that.

The brightest future for this club may involve those two swallowing their pride to some extent when it comes to footballing decisions; a scenario that, like you, I'm not too confident will come about.

Since Robert Tressell put the Edin Terzic idea in my head, that's where I'm leaning.

But Rangnick; yes. Absolutely.

Ten Hag also.

That's my current wish list even though it's irrelevant what I think. It comes down to what Moshiri and Brands want, and more importantly, can get, which will obviously be a factor.

There were many on here unhappy where we finished... just remind me: where did Wolves finish? And please let's not use the excuse about Jiminez being injured.

Howe, well there was a reason Bournemouth let him go: his team lost too many games. Duncan, another name in the mix; apart from 4 games, he's never managed a team in his life.

Whatever happened to make Carlo change his mind, we will never know, but the one thing we do know is he didn't leave for more money.

I have no idea whether he would come here but Moshiri should be moving heaven and earth to get Conte, and I think £11 million a year would be a big enticement. Many said Carlo could only manage top teams, well Conte has taken teams who have been 10th, 8th and 4th when he took over to winning the league. What's not to like? So he has a reputation for upsetting people... so what? The man is a winner, unlike the rest of the candidates to manage Everton.

Should Santo be appointed, I can't help but think we'll be looking for his successor in about 2 years time.
Potter would be my preference but, like everybody else, my opinion counts for nothing.

We really need to learn the lessons of our mistakes

I looked at the names on the ToffeeWeb poll with the most votes (+10%) and I think Simone and Conte are pie in the sky to be honest. And if it's Benitez, well, hell could freeze over.

So that leaves Dunc (fine by me) or Nuno The Holy Ghost. I grew up in Wolverhampton in the era of Steve Bull & Andy Mutch and I have found it depressing to see Wolves' team sheets since their return to the Prem packed full of imports due to Nuno's special relationship with one of those much-loved super agents. Only Brit is normally Coady. I like our 50/50 blend of Brits and overseas players in recent years. How long would that last under the ex-goalkeeper with the fabulous beard?

Conte? Again, didn't go to Spurs because they couldn't meet his ambitions Everton Ha!

Simeone get a grip.

Galtier it appears he's set to stay in France. Not gonna happen
.

Benitez nope.

The only serious names I can see are Nuno and Potter, and I think it'll be Nuno as he's actually available.

It’s now 3/1 and 9/2.

Nuno is now around 1/5 for the Palace job.

Be interesting to see what happens but whatever it is needs to be done quickly.

He may not get to move straight into one of the bigger jobs and working at Everton with a dutch DOF might appeal as a very well paid stepping stone.

I agree it's unlikely but I don't see a huge difference between spurs and Everton ambition wise currently; if anything we will probably have more money to spend on players because of Moshiri.

Also, Nuno wanted certain players signed, which goes against Brands’ role.

Maybe Brands is finally getting more of what he wants and is looking for long term continuity rather than changing the entire setup with each new manager???

German reliability and tenacity, Ralph would bring stability, focus and wouldn’t be a turn coat for a better offer, like our las5 manager did.

Moshiri got well and truly soused by the last manager, the 5 year team plan is effectively at restart again in terms of the team, and also let’s hope BMD, does start later this year.

This could yet be a good week for Evertonians.

However, like Silva and Martinez, he hasn't had the pressure of managing a big club with expectations. So he will need to be able to bounce back from inevitable periods of poor form. That's easier to do for managers with a track record.

I guess the key thing - arguably the undoing of both Silva and Martinez - is to make sure we start the season with much better squad depth and quality. That at least gives the inexperienced manager some options. At the moment we have decent numbers albeit patchy quality in defence and midfield - but in attack and wide we don't even have the numbers. So could do with about 5 new faces rather than the originally intended 3. That means Moshiri digs a bit deeper or we spread the budget on more modestly priced players (like Brighton were doing).

Should be fun !!!

I really find it astonishing that some T/Ws don't want Conte and the suggestions why not are bizarre from him being a Carlo mk2 to being the wrong man with us being near our FFP limit. Conte took over Bari in deep relegation trouble and he managed to keep them up and the following season he got them promoted to Serie A, One of the criticism's of Carlo was he could only manage teams with top players so Conte has demonstrated he can work with some very average players like we have here. As for him not being suited because he will want to spend big money which may compromise our FFP position. Well if Usmanov/ Moshiri are interested about being one of the big clubs again then get Conte smash through the FFP rules and say to the Premier league what are you going to do about it. Because unless you deduct points from the group of 6 who wanted to destroy the Premier League, then be prepared for a high court battle if we break FFP rules and you threaten us with a points deduction.

But hey this is Everton we wont appoint the best candidate around and we would never dare like City did to take on the premier league, we are just quite happy to finish 7th to 12th and lets just muddle along to we can build our new stadium.

Back in the day, I raise you a Mike Walker!!

Derek, you're playing with my nervous state of mind!!

I really hope we're looking externally. Initially Nuno sounded a reasonable option, but I'm not so sure anymore. Wouldn't be the end of the day, but now seems a bit underwhelming. I wish I hadn't fallen into the trap of analysing options.

In honesty Derek, that model could work. Just delete Brands, insert Rangnick. Delete Ferguson, insert younger coach that Rangnick wants. Delete Baines and insert whoever the new coaching set up want to bring in.

I have nothing against Duncan or Leighton by the way. I just don't want them being the Everton management team. And certainly not just because they are Duncan and Leighton and I like them.

Harry Catterick
Howard Kendall
Joe Royal

I don’t think that is a coincidence. So I have decided I want an English manager this time round - any one of these three will do me:

Potter
Howe
Wilder

Just give it to the big fella and have done with it. Has DD signed a new contract yet (I hope so).

There is no guarantee Potter will want to leave Brighton in the first place, that will leave us with Howe or maybe another foreign coach looking for a pay day.

Personally I'd go balls out for the Dutch guy or a German but we all know this is Everton.

However, if we're not going to do that (which seems much more likely) then we can only arm him with something like the 6th or 7th or even 8th best squad at best. I'm not sure how enticing that really is for a serial title winner. Even if he improves us by somehow winning a cup or sneaking 4th, it would be pretty small beer compared with what he's used to. Sure we'd pay him - but he won't be short of well paid offers once managers start getting sacked throughout autumn.

Simply not true at all i'm afraid.

Brighton conceeded 46 goals last season. Less than us. Less than West Ham, less than Leicester. And a whopping 19 goals less than Howe's Bournemouth conceeded in their last season in the PL.

If anything Brighton's problem was scoring goals last season. They actually created among the top 6 amount of chances in the league but lacked a good finisher.

Fancy Evertonians wishing to have their 'threepenuth' on who should be our next manager. Did Chairman Bill set you up to stifle the debate when we all should know to put our faith in him and his wealthy mate !

Only an English manager? Chelsea have two English managers since 2000, Wilkins and Lampard. Their (Chelsea) success has not been due to English managers so it’s pointless to go back nearly 60 years to the Catterick days to claim we need an English manager. Anyone mentioning Howe or Dyche needs to give their head a wobble.

It is all well and good dreaming but don't mistake being realistic with saying they don't want him.

Plus, it leaves us open again to losing Conte the moment a title winning club turns up like Carlo and we start all over again.

If we bring in a Potter or a Howe and half the team are going to say “Who?” And the other half will say “Fuck!” … calls to agents will be a flood. We will be right back to the Moyes era. And no-one of any ability will touch us with a barge pole.

We need a manager they either fear or respect, those two don't cut it. Betcha it will be Rafa.

Nothing against our present staff but bloody mindedness is exactly what we've been crying out for.

A sneaky little secret about being a truly top boss is keep not only those working for you on their toes but those above you as well. I recommend throwing an office desk at your boss and telling him straight what the deal is when there's no witnesses.

Howe, if I'm honest, always saw as a "right place at the right time" sort of manager.

Lampard, who I don't rate at all as a manager, would have finished much higher than Potter's Brighton had he kept the Chelsea job. But he was massively under performing with an exceptional squad, whereas Potter is, if anything, over achieving with his.

I expect the 'transition' could be painful as his systems seem to revolve around players full of energy, movement and confidence. Qualities sadly lacking in our current squad. But i'd be intrigued to see what he could do.

He's not a glamorous option and perhaps certain players would not be thrilled but maybe that's not bad thing. We want/need players who are going to work hard and are keen to play for Everton Football Club; not just a bunch of charlatans attracted by a big name who will then want to leave when he does. There are plenty of good players who aren't big 'names'; that is Brands remit to find those players.

Nuno is now out of the running

Kendall and Harvey did 'ok' for us in management. Are there any obvious partnerships out there any more? Was it just a magical one-off or would a partnership work in the modern game?

Reading that every candidate put forward is great at one thing and shite at another, the partnership solution is obvious. Just a question of which one.

DEFENCE COACH / OFFENCE COACH

Moyes / Martinez for Bill Kenwright (What a managers!)
Potter / Lampard for the Anglophiles (What have forriners ever won?)
Conte / Gallardo for the Big Spenders (Mersey Millionaires v Volga Villains)
Baines / Ferguson for the Xenophobics ("At least we know what we're getting" - relegated)
Nuno Espirito Santo / Domingo - for the status quo (Translation - No new spirit at Everton)

Apparently my claimed association with the Chinese national side was classed as dubious despite the use of my usually successful pseudonym - "Sum Tin Wong".

They blew me out as a footballer now as a manager I don't know where we go from here

The scrap heap?

Out of the ‘available’ options I think Fonseca and Galtier look interesting.

Aren't we arrogant?

Thomas - You must have ESP the construction at chez Rathbone has already been christened the "scrap heap". Better half doesn't like cement mixers, scaffolding etc

I was too scarred by my failure in my brief stint at Bellefield to even apply.

I just don't think the timing is right for Potter. Could be wrong, but I'd like to see how he goes next season.

Continent for me, but not Conte. I've said enough times now the 3 I'd be happy with.

Continent... not such a prerequisite these days. TENA do an amazing range of "secure" underwear... some of it quite fashionable too.

"Call agents" – oh fantastic, that would be one way of getting rid of them all. Useless bunch!

From SkySports:

"Former Lille Sporting Director Luis Campos says Christophe Galtier would be the ideal candidate for the vacant Everton managers job.

Galtier has been linked to Everton after leaving his role in the Ligue 1 club and is someone the Goodison hierarchy have been informed about as they search for a replacement for Carlo Ancelotti.

Campos worked alongside Galtier at the French champions and says his style would be a perfect fit for the Premier League and Everton.

Campos told Sky Sports News: “Christophe has all the qualities to coach in England, technically he is very astute and is extremely detailed in his planning when preparing a team.

"He likes a 4-4-2 system, which would fit with the Premier League and he is a fantastic motivator in the dressing room."

Specifically on the Everton role, Campos believes the Frenchman would be a good choice.

“He likes to build a side, with quality and youth, he is someone that can develop a team ethic, he is also a fantastic human being," he added."

If she wants the house completing she will have to crack on. Tell her to wash the mixer after she has done the brickies their last mix.

With FFP hammering us, we can't invest too heavily either. So, if anyone has the balls to take on this job and try and get a tune out of this squad of shirkers, then good luck to them.

We're a poisoned chalice now.

Like the Galtier link... Benitez not so much. On the length of Potter's contract, I think he's only got 2 years left to run on his current deal.

Perhaps it is time to give Duncan a real chance. The only problem may be that we will need to have an interpreter for both the none English speaking and the English-speaking players. Fortunately, Duncan will not need words to show his displeasure. He just needs to "Glare"!

Personally I would do anything he told me to do... well, within the bounds of what is considered as legal.

Galtier looks a good fit but we would have to ensure he chooses his backup staff.

That was a problem for Nuno, I was told. I wasn't fussed on him anyway and would like us to consider Galtier, Fonseca or Rangnick with a younger coach.

Appoint whoever they want but as long as luvvie duvvie is pulling the strings with his old boys, nothing will ever change. Bill wanted David with Faddy as his assistant. He'd probably brought back Big Al, Wee Stevie Naysmith and of course, Big Dunc.

I don't care who the next manager is as long as he gets rid of Iwobi and co. And makes Calvert-Lewin get a haircut.

Santo, Potter... Jesus Christ Almighty himself won't be able to solve the Everton conundrum while he's still in charge.

Back on track, as I've just said elsewherr, my son is bigging up the Galtier rumours. I don't know enough about French football to comment. Thoughts from those that do?

Why Everton’s perfect replacement for Carlo Ancelotti could be in France

I'm pleased that this candidate can sort out the shortcomings in the staff canteen but can he sort out the shortcomings in the Everton squad? :)

I’ve just read Potter, signed an extended contract at Brighton after only six months in the job Brendan, and it runs until 2025.

If Duncan Ferguson doesn’t get the managers job, but is allowed to stay on as a first team coach, then this would be the fifth manager he has worked under whilst retaining this position Jay H, and this is something I find difficult to comprehend.

I'd like to hear Coronation Streets answer to Dumbledore in the meetings I bet his input is as cringeworthy as his uncle taking him to GP on the crossbar, bet it was a ladies bike.

I'd like to hear Coronation Streets answer to Dumbledore in the meetings I bet his input is as cringeworthy as his uncle taking him to GP on the crossbar, bet it was a ladies bike.

Never listen to fans

Needs to purchase a suit of armour and a good set of earplugs on the way here though.

The slagging has started already.
BEFORE anyone has been appointed

I'm hoping the Lille director coming out speaking to sky about gautier means he knows talks are ongoing because we would need to offer compo. Something bizarre going on though given he has left after winning the title with one year left.

Real then come knocking for Christophe Galtier after he works wonders for us and what does he say to us?

Au revoir !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Does the phrase "back at square one" mean anything?

I want the next manager to stay!

All I said was I can feel the irony of it, I also said I want the next manager to stay!

If it is him then I hope he improves us and stays, I never said I want a crap manager who no one wants.

Lyndon - in the light of Chris’s post at 371 do you think you should remove Potter and Howes names from the Toffeeweb poll😉

It seems that he did perform miracles in developing and growing the squad at Lille, and I need to do more research but what he’s achieved is considerable against massive odds! He done the feeding of the 5000, and more with heart, belief, and guts and good training.

I’ve taken some good vibes from this insight and right now some how I think though he will need a free license but if he and Marcel could work well then who knows?

I’m staying with Ralph and now Christophe, and my third would be Brighton’s boss, but I don’t see him, taking a chance on Everton, while he is doing a great job at improving his stock value.

So I’m going for a Dutch Alliance ( Marcel leading the fit) with either a French or German manager.

Well it could improve the match day food...Lol.

It’s the most important descision in terms of management in my view, since HKmk1, as the club, has been left in a very tough position, but onwards an UTFT! In essence the past is the past and reality checks for all Evertonians.

But the club must learn lessons from Euro Trash, and not go for the eye catching memory books of achievement and the Chicillinas of the world etc.in football terms, as they won’t be able to take the daily strain at EFC.

Many have said this last week and many stated in the first days of the last managers tenure, that it was a bad fit.

Salute! You were spot on.

Lessons learned and in some ways this is reality and liberation, no more fur coats and no draws for Everton...

Hopefully, but the Moshiri, must be fuming inside.

I still need to know and my apologies if it’s been disclosed on TW, did the last manager, have a get out clause to leave for any select list of clubs?

The club is like a basket case unwinding itself into a terrible, terrible mess, lying half submerged in the canal. No one appears to make decisions that all can follow. The board is dysfunctional the chairman lives in a fantasy land were Ball, Kendall and Harvey et al are still deep in his heart, and an EFC team will come forth from a blue heaven of his making - hell more like.

The DOF wants to sign young players so we employ a manager who wants experienced players and who told us he didn't have the time to bring young players through.

The squad is dysfunctional - the only thing they appear to do well together is fight. The training and coaching looks as though it is totally inept - passing is impossible for most of the squad - in fact Pickford is the best at the long ball pass !

The junior teams are not producing players for the first team. Young players go out on loan and from what I have seen this season only Ellis Simms has made a fist of his loan and he praised in glowing terms, the coaching he was getting, from Neil Critchley, their manager and former RS U23 coach.

We are a charity, a rest home for former players with a supposed EPL club attached and a laughing stock to boot.

To think, we were up there on the top table sorting out the formation of the EPL. A league in which we are out of our depth both on and off the pitch, particularly off the pitch and every couple of seasons sinking further and further into the mire.

You cannot fault Moshirir for the money he has put in but you can fault him for the way it has been spent. Thrown around like Confetti on players most other teams weren't interested in from what I can see. He who controls the purse strings calls the tune and so expect the Bay City Rollers when you really, and I mean really, want to hear The Clash.

Nothing will change believe me I wish I was wrong but I just cannot see it.

We are all shareholders in EFC. Through our hearts, our passion and our loyalty. This is pissed on by the club. They will argue they do care about us. We are the Peoples Club. We argued against the ESL didn't we.

Well if they do care about us its about time they f n showed it. Start running the club professionally. No more bloody handouts of jobs for the boys. Just because they are a former blue does it mean they are a great coach, a great motivator, a great role model. It just means they wore the shirt. Employ coaches for all levels, on merit. Those who are qualified, have experience and can show results. Use the head not the heart.

When the club is finally run properly then maybe, just maybe we can get a manager who will succeed but it won't be before then I can assure you.

So prove me wrong.

Hope eternal so now, the pendulum of fate decides as to whom the EFC board decide to hire as manager.

Let’s hope it’s a good descision.

He has not topped 15th position in the league and someone with that track record should not be considered for the Everton job. If he wants to develop, then he consider a job at Newcastle or Soton as a natural progression.

But of course if he gets the job, then he gets my 100% backing. If he succeeds, the Everton succeed.

English Candidate: Potter; best of a poor bunch.

Continental Candidate: Galtier.

South American Candidate: Gallardo.

last but not least...

The Manchurian Candidate: Ray Shaw; likes to play A Diamond Formation, has the killer touch...just don't play cards with him.

Colombia really needs a point from this game. They're outside the South American qualifying slots at the moment. If they don't pull their shit together, James and Yerry will be watching the WC on TV.

Sheffield Wednesday, Blackburn Rovers, Oldham Athletic do you see a pattern there? To focus on the teams people have previously managed as a indicator of future success at Everton or indeed at any club is inane - you should be appointing people who have the attitude, intelligence, character and skills no appointment is without risk regardless of how ‘big’ the name or CV is as we have just found out to our cost.

I'd personally like to see what Moyes can do with some better financial resources available, especially considering how well he did with West Ham this season. His United stint was a failure - but anyone taking over immediately after Ferguson was destined to fail.

I'd take him long before any of the so-called big name coaches who - as we have just seen - will walk away as soon as anything better comes along.

Moyes was disingenuous in the last 6 months of his time at EFC claiming he was close to signing his new contract, unfortunately Sir Alex said he and Moyes shock hands on Moyes succeeding him in February.

The final straw was firstly offering £23M for both Fellaini and Baines. Moyes then claimed EFC were holding the players' careers back not letting them move to a "bigger" Club in Man Utd???

Bear in mind Moyes eventually paid £27M solely for Fellaini...

Moyes shafted and disrespected EFC, the same EFC that made him a millionaire for winning nothing in 11 years at the club.

Since Spurs couldn't agree terms with Conte, it's gone very quiet for them... maybe they are still trying to agree a deal with PSG to release Pochettino? Palace seem according to this morning's Telegraph close to tying up a deal with Nuno, so that leaves Everton still looking.

There are certainly some top managers not tied up; whether any would want to come to Everton is another matter. But the real problem is our fan base is divided on both who should be the next manager, which is not unusual, but it's been a long time since I can remember so many Evertonians not caring who we appoint.

I think many of us for years wanted someone with money to come in and take the club back to where we all believed we should be; when Moshiri joined and with his close association with Usmanov, we thought at last we can now compete financially with the top boys. And to be fair, Moshiri has backed every manager with money, he even gave Allardyce £50 million.

But, because of our failure to appoint the right manager, our fanbase has become apathetic and it's beginning to dawn on all Blues that the injection of cash without the ability to link that to a manager has been our downfall.

The fanbase has become disillusioned and rightly believe that this board have got most of their managerial appointments wrong; so why would we have any faith in them getting it right this time?

Imo, a man with no principle.

As someone who stood up for Moyes early on when he came in even when some turned on him early on, I understood what he was doing, what he had to do and the constraints he was working under. I got that and supported it.

But, even the eternal optimists like me turned as we realised he wasn't going to take us further. I've said previous, there were two turning points that done it for me with Moyes, the semi final and the Wigan Cup match. There for the taking and we bottled it on both occasions.

The problem with Moyes is his negativity. And I don't necessarily mean in all of his football teams or tactics when he has the right players.

He continuously plays down expectation. He enjoys being the underdog so convinces everyone that second best is good enough and that we shouldn't expect too much. He took over the biggest club in the world so has had that opportunity in terms of resources. He inherited the Champions and serial winners. He bought Fellani and told them they aspire to be like Manchester City. Now if that isn't pouring petrol onto a fire, I don't know what is.

He even done it with West Ham this year when they were in a Champions League position. Rather than being positive, begging up their position and pushing on, he played it down. He's great at sneaking in when no-one is looking, but as soon as the expectation is there, he seems to get concerned. To me that smacks of not liking or being able to handle the pressure of being in a position to challenge to win things.

Moyes is not a winner. He's a good survivor who can get teams into good positions with the right players. I like to think and hope the club are aiming to win things. Yes, that won't happen overnight and initial European qualification would be a stepping stone. But surely we don't want to go back to being satisfied with continuously finishing 6th - 8th?

Can't believe I've just spent so long talking about Moyes. He is the past. We've been there and done that.

I asked the lad connected to Everton who was getting the job and he said his mate had said it’s already been sorted, so because he threw his mates name in, I’m personally not taking this as 100% legit

Social media is full of "celebs" doing one off film shoots at foodbanks etc mate, don't know if Moyes does the same stuff all the time, if he does all credit to him.

I much prefer the people who do the good work behind the scenes.
I have a good friend from the city who has raised over £1 million for good causes ( if I said his name you would know it straight away ).
He runs a mile from any publicity.

Try it lads, it fits well. Practice it for August. 😉

To claim. that you should hire someone without reference to the seniority of his/her previous posts or the status/size of employer is ludicrous. Equally, skills can only be assessed based on the previous experiences in your CV that enabled you to develop them.

You have evidently never hired anyone in your life.

I merely pointed out that the previous three Everton managers who have won something the 4 leagues titles, three FA cups and a ECWC between 1963 and 1987 (not going back to 1878 really is it?) had been recruited from relatively unfashionable clubs and didn’t have masses of managerial experience and or were laden with honours when appointed. Moyes and Martinez had enjoyed relative success at Preston and Wigan and their appointments were logical at the time. When Koeman was appointed Southampton had finished 6th the previous season which again was a relative success and therefore seemed a sensible decision at that moment. Your original post cited these clubs so what pattern are you alluding to exactly?

If this is your logic ? Arsenal would have never appointed Wenger and the RS would never have appointed Shankley. Your attempts to deride me personally just make me smile. Before retiring I was actively engaged in the recruitment of staff for over twenty years and I never appointed a single member of staff based upon who they had previously worked for and certainly never relied upon or trusted the utter shite I read on CVs.

As an aside according to one less than creditable outlet, Bill Kenwright has had informal talks with Moyes, and Stuart Pearce has stated that he is loyal to Moyes and he'll agree to extend his contract with the Hammers if David Moyes does.

“If I had to choose my destination, I would go to Liverpool,” Galtier told Canal Football Club. “It’s my dream.”

Obviously, he meant the CITY of Liverpool rather than the club, didn't he?

Fortunately, outside the modern media, as soon as people hear me speak, they ask me if I'm blue or red, not just assume I'm a Kopite. They are fascinated when I declare Everton.

I just assume that if the quotes are right, he is referring to the city of Liverpool.

Keep dressing the Liver Building up in blue lights and build that stadium on the banks of the Mersey. It's our city as much as it is theirs.

Well, that has now been dispelled entirely by Galtier himself, who, relayed by Homme du Match, told Canal+ the truth. Speaking on the 24h de Boulleau TV show, the Lille manager was asked about this so-called desire of his, to which he replied: “I know how to speak English, but I need to get better. My dream isn’t Liverpool.”

Once the scope of the role is defined, market mapping will be conducted to produce a long list of 40-50 pax. Candidates are long listed based on five factors a) the size and complexity of the roles held b) reason for career transitions c) size and complexity of the companies they have worked for d) their delivery record e) their reputation in the industry. Each candidate will be pre-qualified and interviewed by a headhunter to reach a short list of 6-8 pax. The preferred 2-3 candidates from the short list after first round interviews by the company will then undergo ability, personality and culture fit assessment by an occupational psychologist. The preferred candidate after assessment will then have a final interview with a CEO.

Due diligence will already have been done on the candidate's career history, therefore the CEO will focus on three things a) organisational fit b) alignment on strategy c) personal rapport. The last step is finalising compensation, but the hiring company will already have established the candidate's compensation expectations at the short listing stage so there shouldn't be any shocks there.

Attitude, intelligence and character are important (they will be assessed through the entire process), but unless your career history demonstrates that you have done roles of similar size and complexity to the vacancy you won't even make the long list. Hence my point - unless the board assess the manager's job at Everton as the same size and complexity as the Brighton/Bournemouth or Swansea managers' jobs, Howe, Potter and Cooper should not even be interviewed by Everton. They are good enough for the long list only at a stretch.

Now I am not assuming that Everton are running a professional hiring process. They haven't in the past. But I am hopeful that the silence means that a proper recruitment process is taking place led by Brands, with Moshiri and Kenwright only involved when the final candidate has been selected.

I’m interested in your opinion of who you think
would be good enough to manage Everton given the criteria you have alluded to.

Some may not like it but the old boys network won't cut it. Especially as the old boys network we are now talking about have won little, if anything.

Find the right person for the job. Regardless of whether they're connected to Everton, regardless of whether they have Premier League experience and regardless of where they come from. Liverpool dumped the boot room years ago. We need to dump the same sentiment that has crept in.

Get the right person for the job based on what the strategy is and what we want to achieve.

And his wife would also have to attend the interview unless BMD is Bourne, Mouthe and Districts.