Everton 0 - 1 Manchester United

, 29 October, 52comments  |  Jump to most recent
No way through determined United defence
Along with Cahill, and Neville, Sylvain Distin was a surprise absentee, as injuries strated to bite for the first time this season.

Team: Howard, Hibbert, Baines, Jagielka, Heitinga, Bilyaletdinov, Coleman, Fellaini, Rodwell, Osman, Saha.
Subs: Mucha, Stracqualursi, McFadden, Gueye, Barkley, Vellios, Mustafi

Everton struggled to compete with the wounded Champions in the first half, but limited the damage to just one goal, scored a little too easily by Hernandez. They almost came back before the break when a Baines free-kick smashed off the United crossbar. Luois Saha did well to work a couple of shooting opportunities but could only fire straight at De Gea under pressure.

David Moyes removed the completly ineffective Diniyar Bilyaletdinov at half-time, bringing on Ross Barkley.

Rodwell got in a much better shot that forced a good save from De Gea as Everton had a good spell of possession and pressure but few final balls creating any chances, and leaving the defence exposed to the counter.

Coleman got booked for catching Evra, which was a pity as his enrgy had been helping drive Everton forward with the ball. Fellaini looked for a penalty when Rooney clambered all over him. Saha looked to tee up Coleman in a central position but his left-foot shot was horribly sliced for a throw-in.

United were defending too comfortably, the lack of guile in Everton's attacking play letting them down, while Ferguson was able to role in his expensive subs, the frustration showing in a ridiculous lofted effort at goal from midfield by Jagielka in lieu of a more sensible out-ball.

Moyes decided to go for it with just 15 mins left, Vellios on for Osman.
There was a mad scramble off a corner, Saha hemmed in by four United defenders but he managed to squeeze the ball to Rodwell who shot wide. Everton built well again but Coleman fired too softly straight at De Gea, as the secret weapon, Magaye Gueye, was sneaked on after a month's absence from the action.

with two minutes left, any tempo was lost when linesman Andy Halliday went down after hurting his back, requiring treatment before the Fourth Official, Phil Dowd picked up the flag for 6 added minutes, starting with a corner by Gueye that was poor.

A big shout for a penalty was never going to be viewed favourably by Halsey, it was more a case of Gueye running into Evra, and going down far too easily. Fellaini went in the book for a really stupid clip on Jones that allowed United to timewaste in the corner.

One final free-kick came to nothing but Vellios did get a desparate shot in before the final whistle bringing to an end another now depressingly familiar defeat to a big moneybags side, and in front of a somewhat smaller crowd than normal for this fixture — only 35,494.

» Read more



Reader Comments (52)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Armitage
1 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:17:39
On a brighter note, at least McFadden didn't get on the pitch.
James Martin
2 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:46:22
If it hadn't have been for that Zamora miss, it would have been 6 losses in a row. Jagielka needs to be dropped he's making a mistake a game.

We're just so negative, even with a whole 45 minutes of uninterrupted possession we didn't really test the goal keeper. Fellaini and Jagielka are just so slow in their ball distribution.
Andy Crooks
4 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:59:26
Just watched the match. At half time I'd have settled for 0-1. We really could and should have got something from this.The most worrying aspect of this is the attendance.Is it the recession or what? I didn't count this game as one I'd go to because I didn't think I'd get a ticket. Grim times indeed. Apathy; we need something to light up Goodison Park.
Tom Bowers
5 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:56:22
What else was there to expect with the typical Moyes selection? He just has to play Osman. What for, I don't know anymore.

Hibbert and Bileyletdinov are poor choices. Playing one striker who is getting quite slow and trying to use Osman as a second striker defeats logic.

Apart from Bainsey's free kick most of the efforts on goal were woeful. Putting on a second striker with 15 minutes to go was too little, too late as Saha was too tired to help at that stage.

We are a team with a powder pufff offence who only look dangerous at set plays and Fellaini now gets double marked when that happens. We have no real creativity in midfield since the heyday of Arteta and with Drenthe missing it was always going to be a struggle even against a jaded Manure team.

Well done, Moyes.
John Ford
6 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:00:12
Lack of guile is correct. We threw all our toys at them second half, but lacked composure and footballing knowhow up front.

What that really means is we need a Berbatov, Rooney or Hernandes. Depressing.

Credit to the boys for their approach today. Moyes too. What this does is highlight the club's defficiencies and limited options. This we all know.
Steavey Buckley
7 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:58:41
From where I was sitting. If Baines was judged solely on his positional sense around the 10 yard area near the goal, he would probably would not be selected. When an innocuous cross came in, Baines froze again and allowed the Mexican to score an easy goal.

Other than that, Saha needs to change his body deodorant or after shave. It appears only the team in red where happy to be around him. The Everton players, by and large, did not care for what he was using and stayed away from him.

Fellaini got booked 2 minutes from time so not to disappoint those who had speculated he would get booked and miss the next game.
Max Main
8 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:05:46
I think Barkley looks very talented, and I'm confident he'll go on to be an excellent player...

But he was dreadful today. Really dreadful. Offered absolutely nothing. Seemed unable to take anyone on, his passing was sloppy, and he kept giving the ball away when we'd committed players forward.

I say this because all the time on here people are whinging and whining about how he should be playing every week and how Moyes is an idiot for not playing him.

I think today showed that he's not ready yet and Moyes is justified in introducing him gradually.
Andy Crooks
9 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:12:43
I'd like to have seen Vellios with Saha today with Osman on the bench.

I like Osman and I believe, in a team playing well and with confidence, we would see his best. However, we are a team drained of confidence and we do not seem to have a player with the arrogance to think "Fuck it, I'm better than them and I'll show it".

Drenthe? His fucking ludicrous and entirely expected sending off cost us dear today. I'm with Dave Wilson on that one. A round of applause for that cretinous lack of professionalism was mind boggling. If he'd played today we would have beaten a poor United side..
Brian Waring
10 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:22:12
Credit to Moyes and the lads today for being positive, just nothing in the final third to make it count though.
Kunal Desai
11 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:20:14
Plenty of huffing and puffing in the final third, but I'm afraid until a striker or two starts finding the back of the very net soon, then we'll struggle this season, especially as we're struggling to keep cleans.

Need to start using Vellios more especially if we are to put balls into the box. Another striker in January is a must.
Steven Pendleton
12 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:31:21
Brian #9

We were positive today? How is playing with one striker positive? There was nothing in the final third because we weren't fuckin positive with our team selection. Osman playing in front of the striker? What a fuckin laugh.
Steven Pendleton
13 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:36:28
Let's also not forget our True Blue lad, Tony Hibbert, as wasn't it his side that allowed the Man Utd player an eternity to decide where to put the ball?

Lost count how many times it happens from his side. But hey, he's a professional local lad living the dream. He's living the dream at the expense of our fucking team. God help us!!!!!!!!
Brian Waring
14 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:48:41
Steven, I'm one of Moyes's biggest critics, but some credit is due today, because we never bent over and took it up the arse like we normally do against the Mancs.
Andy Crooks
15 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:56:16
Brian, I agree with you. I thought we did okay today and played better than most of this season. Overall, I still think we need a fresh start but today I think looking for a scapegoat is wrong.
Nick Armitage
16 Posted 29/10/2011 at 15:59:40
Steavey Buckley ? bang on re Baines. He tried to blame Heitinga, but it was Baines who should have got nearer. I don't understand why he isn't inside the far post when balls are being crossed.

He is neither use nor ornament marking space outside the post, the immediate threat is in behind the centre half and he should be there.

I don't know whether these are tactics because Hibbert does similar. Whatever the cause it is a big weakness and one which oppostion forwards are exploiting.
Dalziel Kane
17 Posted 29/10/2011 at 16:24:41
I haven't seen the game but on paper at least it was always going to be tough getting a result against this opposition even with home advantage. Obviously disappointed, and right on the back of a domestic cup exit too. I'm in two minds about watching any highlights later, but you would expect we won't feature last this time around.
Sam Higgins
18 Posted 29/10/2011 at 16:46:13
Its just so fucking joyous supporting everton i just love it.
Dalziel Kane
19 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:03:58
Sam, what were you doing at this time in 1994? We played Arsenal on this day back then and it was our 14th game in all competitions without a victory. If memory serves, it wasn't until November the club won a match ? the short-lived Ian Durrant, on loan from Glasgow Rangers, I think it was in a home win over West Ham.

Oddly enough, today is Durrant's Birthday.

Point being, we've been in worse situations than this, at least there's been some victories up to now, and moments of optimism.

I genuinely feel Moyes is becoming a bit stale now, I don't have an issue with the man as an individual, but soccer is a results business, and with the Scot in charge, are we really going to win anything any time soon?

10 years he's had now, done very well on occasion with limited resources, but I feel the time is near for a fresh face and a new challenge. Saying that, I feel he may well be around for some time to come...
Kevin Elliott
20 Posted 29/10/2011 at 16:52:31
Best I've seen us play all season. When was the last time we had the lion's share of possession over the Mancs? We can all lay the blame at somebody's door, but today we were unlucky.

Re the Baines bashers, he is the best player we've got. Just hope he doesn't read some of the shite written about him on here, and fucks off in January. Then we will be fucked!!!
Kevin Elliott
21 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:21:48
Dalziel (#16):? Watch the game and enjoy. I know we got beat but it might just give you a bit of hope. It has me.
Jon Cox
22 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:10:49
I thought they were there for the taking today. This was not a good Man Utd side by any stretch.

The lack of guile in the last third was almost tangeble.

The apathy in our team our lack of passion and desire is directly linked i think to the mindset of David Moyes. It's almost like he's lost the will to live and given up.

We need someone, anyone who could give us a fresh approach and inject a bit of verve into the side.

Why does he persist with Jags. This centre back has lost the plot completely. One has to wonder not how he got into the England squad, but how he made the grade to be a pro footballer in the first place. If anything I thought it would have been Distin along side Heights. At least Jonny can pass the ball with a modicum of accuracy.

Depressing times are they not? but we have to stick together and support our club come what may.

Andrew Gilbert
23 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:27:19
Just back from the match. At first it looked like it was going to be a bit of a hammering but after about 30-40 mins United just seemed to stop playing and we took control.

Baines and Bily just did not work again, it was more like Bill and Ben and was happy to see Bily subbed at half time although Ross B just carried on where he left off, a few decent sideways passes and that was it.

The pressure we put them under in the 2nd half should have produced at least a point but lets face it we are lightweight up front and it showed.

Again a more consistent ref might have helped with more than one penalty worth shouting for.

Maybe with Drenthe today we might have done it.

Tom Bowers
24 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:49:04
It's just more and more of the same selections and tactics and on the odd occasion we will win but not against the good teams (i.e. billionaire teams). A struggle for the rest of the season unless we change the management and/or get the investment.

Moyes cannot get it right playing one striker. What does it take for the penny to drop? We were a better team with Beckford and Saha together but Beckford was deemed expendable. Now Moyes has egg on his face over that clanger.

Can anyone say that Straqualursi and Vellios have shown more than Becks? Please don't say they are for the future. They should make plans for a fire sale in January before some of these underachievers become too old to get money for.
Marc Williams
25 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:04:13
How many times does Bily have to play on the left before Moyes realises, he's not a winger?
Either play him behind the striker or sell him, because he was a £9 million embarassment, out wide today.
Denis Richardson
26 Posted 29/10/2011 at 17:58:25
Expected the result but a bit disappointed as Manure were pretty poor by their normal standards and seemed to just go on autopilot after taking the lead.

We did not put any realy pressure on them and Vellios should have been on a lot earlier, I thought. It would have been great to see him and Saha together but, to be fair, I don'[t think we have a player who, on current form, can provide the link from midfield. Osman really needs to be benched.

Not sure what happened to Distin but we badly need Drenthe back in the side.

Also, Fellaini sometimes is such an idiot, totally unnecessary yellow at the end.

Onward to the bar codes....
Jamie Barlow
27 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:21:47
Tom, I can say Vellios has shown more than Becks. Vellios jumped up for a header in his first game and in that moment he shown more fight than that lazy twat.
Steven Kendrew
28 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:16:35
It was a decent performance today given injuries and the opposition and we were unlucky not to get a point at least. One down but we kept going and the possession improved after a poor first 20 mins. However, some schoolboy defending has let us down AGAIN and I would blame the whole back four for the goal. They need work!

I thought the the selection was ok, but we could have opted for Vellios instead of Osman, but Osman at least fashioned a couple of shots. Get off his back.

Barkley - No, not ready. Rubbish today, sorry.

Vellios/Beckford - I think Vellios is as good as Beckford so Moyes took the profit on Becks. Simple.

Baines - Poor goal conceded but great player generally. Nice free kick. Must always play.

Fellaini - Pretty good today. Must have been knackered by the end. Just didn't get enough ball.

Gueye - Let's play him more. Perhaps he should have started today.

Keep believing, and for those at Goodison. Make some bloody noise!! I know it's not great at present but a silent Goodison won't help.
Peter Cummings
29 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:33:46
Only saw the 'highlights' here (Ontario)... game was not on live. There were a few positives but, as usual, too many negatives, and now that our injury season is in full swing, very little light at the end of the tunnel.

It's half-time at The Hawthorns as I post... bloody lousy game so far, the diver got another pen and the Reds have shut up shop, nine men behind the ball every time WB attack.

As for the Manc goal, I thought Jags got a touch and diverted it to the scorer and yet again Howard was rooted to his line when he should have anticipated the cross. As against Chelsea, we dominated but lack of finishing did for us, again.
Mark Wilson
30 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:47:04
I really thought we played quite well today against a very odd Man Utd in performance terms, almost uninterested. But lack of half decent forward line up remains a nightmare for Moyes. Baines is struggling a bit right now and that's not good news when your best player keeps losing track of attackers.
John Ford
31 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:54:13
Steve@11

Playing positively doesnt necessarily mean a 442. Looking at today we had plenty of the ball second half because we outnumbered them in the middle, worked hard to win the ball and were able to get good numbers in the box to support louis.

With a fixed two up front we're less likely to win ball. The five midfield has served us well down the seasons - with Piennar, Arteta, Coleman, Donovan, Cahill and Osman getting forward in numbers. Im not sure the players now are quite as effective, but saying that, we're not exactly screaming with quality forwards either.

For me our real problem is passing and movement around the box, irrespective of formation. How many times today did we have 6/7 players in/around the area but ended up just punting it over - hopefull crosses. Not clever football.

Good football brains cost a premium.
Matt Compton
32 Posted 29/10/2011 at 19:12:04
I watched Bilyaletdinov closely today to try and work the lad out. I don't think Baines trusts him at all. Saha also when he snatched at a shot could have easily slided it across to Bilyaletdinov to result in probably a certain goal.

It has to be said that it seems patently obvious that he must be played in the middle. He doesn't have the pace to play out wide and he knows it. This is probably the route cause of his confidence issues.

Most of his screamers have been from running through in the middle. The lad has a terrific shot on him, vision and a decent first touch (most of the time). I'd fancy him to score a few from the centre with his shooting ability.

I would however not fancy Osman with his powder puff shooting to do the same.

Give Bilyaletdinov a go in the middle Moyes. It cannot make us any less threatening than we actually are.
John Nelson
33 Posted 29/10/2011 at 19:42:05
Got to ask what game were some of yous watching today? We were "negative"? Give me a fucking break.

Man utd - apart from the spell where we couldn't get the ball and they scored - came to defend, and did a very good job of it. For all the media bias and bullshit they couldn't speak highly enough of vidic and Evans today, they played out of their skins.

We had 18 shots to their 9, had more possession, hit the bar, could of had 2 pens and generally played some very nice football - surely I'm not the only fucking one who thinks this?!?

As for their goal... I've tried to pinpoint who was at fault, but in truth it was a superb cross from
Evra, who'll do well to better a cross like that all season.

I thought moyes and the lads were sound today (hats off to jagielka for looking like his old self, and also not hoofing the ball at every opportunity), the hard games are put the way now, play like this and we'll go on a run.

COYB and guess what? IMWT - time to get behind the blues now, getting sick of the constant slagging off.
Steve Barr
34 Posted 29/10/2011 at 20:07:35
Problem is we don't play that well against the so called lesser teams!
We needed more points from October... don't bank on us beating the so called rubbish!
David Flanagan
35 Posted 29/10/2011 at 20:38:22
Hibbert was once again one of our better players but as as usual it's all his fault. Baines has been shite all season but escapes criticism. Bily wasnt great but Barkley was awful.

Second half they sat back and gave us the ball but we were so poor it made it easy for them.
Mike Keating
38 Posted 29/10/2011 at 19:40:26
Matt @ 30
Completely agree
In the first half Bily came inside and demanded the ball - turned and ran on goal. OK he didn't score but you could see that this is his position (he plays there for Russia when he gets a game).
Should have played there against Chelski
Sorry to see that Barkley came on (also not a winger) and looked equally hopeless.
We could lose a lot of dosh on this guy because he was never played in the correct position. With Tim out Moyes should give the guy a chance in the hole and play Gueye or Drethe on the wing
Mike Keating
39 Posted 29/10/2011 at 21:52:41
Sorry I meant Matt @ 31
Lori Fekete
41 Posted 29/10/2011 at 22:05:02
Dose of reality lads, we deserved at least a point against the champions today.

Toothless up front again (but that's been the case since the 1980's!)

I actually thought Jags was back to his old self today,
Heitinga is always a whisker away from a pen or red card, so doesnt deserve Jag's place.

Do agree that Ossie needs dropping though

Missed Drenthe today. Get used to it, unfortunately he's going to be bloody frustrating at times. If he was always that great at going forward he wouldn't be at Everton!
Paul Holden
42 Posted 29/10/2011 at 22:39:09
Can't remember feeling so fed up, and the first match I went to was in 1977! I can see three or four players going in the January transfer window ? they must be looking at Arteta and Lescott and thinking, fuck this, I'm off!

No money, no spirit, no pride in this fantastic club, and no clue! Moyes will be gone (either own free will or pushed) before Xmas. Will somebody in the boardroom please tell us what the gameplan is?
Ian Tunstead
43 Posted 29/10/2011 at 22:39:57
I thought we played well today in spells and had them on the back foot for much of the 2nd half, we should have at least come away with a point. Coleman was excellent, Rodwell was contributing in attack for once. Fellaini dominated the midfield.

I can see why Moyes has not been playing Barkley though, he is clearly not on form and Moyes must have recognised this in training. The thing is Bily was even worse so he had to be replaced and Barkley and Gueye were the only options.
Paul Holden
44 Posted 29/10/2011 at 22:45:08
Having said all that, I'm going to the Wolves and Swansea games ? 16-hour round trip and £120 a go, not that the players give a shite.
Jamie Barlow
45 Posted 29/10/2011 at 22:55:00
Paul, no spirit and no pride? They might not be a talented bunch but I don't think you can acuse them of that.
David Bridge
46 Posted 29/10/2011 at 23:45:53
Steven #12 ? get a grip will you, how can you blame Hibbert? Hibbert was outstanding today, he didn't give up and was a constant threat.

The player to blame was Saha. he HAS to be dropped. Completely disinterested, lazy and just didn't get near the ball or provide any kind of outlet. His few shots on goal were very weak rolls across the floor, very easy for them.

On the whole, I thought we played well; it would have been a different story had Gueye and Vellios started today in place of Saha and Bily.
Trevor Mackie
47 Posted 29/10/2011 at 23:55:45
We never play a forward pass.

I don't mean long diagonal hoofing or the faltering side to side pointless stuff, I mean incisive passes to feet.

I can't remember the last time I saw an Everton player cut through playing a wall pass for example.

It's a blunt instrument labouring away rather than a razor edge slicing through.

Too easily dealt with.
Vincent Siow
48 Posted 30/10/2011 at 02:36:43
7 Max Main ? Totally agree. Barkley was DREADFUL!
John Barnes
49 Posted 30/10/2011 at 06:41:48
Possibly unlucky to lose but we were never going to win cos we didn't do much in front of goal. And so the inevitable mistake cost us dear... as it will, I fear, right through the season.

None of the midfielders offered a goal threat yesterday so another forward might well have reaped rewards. But be honest, had Baines's free-kick gone in and 1-1, we would all be happy. Fine margins indeed.

My only real criticism is the substitutions. We ended up with a balanced team when Gueye came on. Why waste time with Barkley on the wing? He's not a winger. Nor is Osman, but both spent time out there proving the point before Moyes put the proverbial round peg into a round hole. We used 4 players on the left wing yesterday which shows the manager's puddled thinking.
Roman Sidey
51 Posted 30/10/2011 at 04:33:36
Goes to show that playing to the best of our ability is just not good enough against a United side that barely turned up.

Today's defence, a la Baines going missing in the box and Hibbo not defending his wing for some reason, proves that we should be playing 3 centre halves. Heitinga showed more talent today than Jags has had warm baths.

If you watch Bily, he knows he's not a winger, and can see his frustration that when he does get a game, it's out there, and he's pissed. Why does Moyes use the wing as a right of passage for players? Barkley isn't one either, so it just confuses me why he'd sub a central attacking midfielder off the left wing and put another central attacking midfielder in the same position to suffer.

Osman - how has this bloke still got a contract??? I mean, really, a few good games every couple of years, but never a true contributer and a ball hog who can't actually hold possession.


Roman Sidey
52 Posted 30/10/2011 at 04:33:36
Goes to show that playing to the best of our ability is just not good enough against a United side that barely turned up.

Today's defence, à la Baines going missing in the box and Hibbo not defending his wing for some reason, proves that we should be playing 3 centre-halves. Heitinga showed more talent today than Jags has had warm baths.

If you watch Bily, he knows he's not a winger, and can see his frustration that when he does get a game, it's out there, and he's pissed.

Why does Moyes use the wing as a right of passage for players? Barkley isn't one either, so it just confuses me why he'd sub a central attacking midfielder off the left wing and put another central attacking midfielder in the same position to suffer.

Osman ? how has this bloke still got a contract??? I mean, really, a few good games every couple of years, but never a true contributor and a ball hog who can't actually hold possession.
Brian Waring
53 Posted 30/10/2011 at 12:11:45
The worrying thing, if you look at the ages of those players that would be considered as Moyes's first choice 11, it's scary as fuck.

How are we going to be able to replace them when we haven't got a pot to piss in?
Jamie Barlow
55 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:18:31
Gerard, what has Ian said in post 39 that merits him being called a complete arsehole? It seems about right to me.
James Tunstead
56 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:29:28
No need to have a pop at my bro Gerard, everyone Ive spoken to agrees with him regarding yesterdays performance. Whilst we are dishing out insults, learn to spell before you come on here slagging other people off.
Arsehole - vulgar slang for anus.
Andrew Laird
57 Posted 31/10/2011 at 08:31:07
Barkley WAS poor, about as poor as Jagielka, Cahill, Neville and Osman have been ALL season. It's like he was being played out of position after being rested for a month without first team football after being publicly hung out to dry at Blackburn before the penalty had even been taken. Oh, that's right, he has had a "dip" in form in training.
Mike Keating
58 Posted 31/10/2011 at 09:54:05
What happened to Gerard's post?
Was he pulled for offensive content or poor spelling?
Eye fink wee shud no

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads