Press Button marked 'Self-Destruct'

, 5 November, 129comments  |  Jump to most recent
Newcastle United 2 - 1 Everton

Match Summary

With Marouane Fellaini suspended and Royston Drenthe returning from a ban of his own, there were no adventurous surprises in the selected team... with the possible exception of Heitinga selected over the injured Sylvain Distin, who joined the injured Tim Cahill on the bench. These players were deemed not fit enough to start but fit enough to come on at a pinch, to change the game — in preference to the likes of Vellios* and Gueye, who have now clearly been relegated to the Reserves while the talented young Barkley spends another game warming the bench.

Everton contained the Geordies well for the first five minutes but most of the possession was in the visitors' half until Newcastle won the first corner and Guthrie got in the first shot. Coleman was set up with a glorious chance off a Saha header that he messed up horribly.

Everton looked to be in easy control but then came moment of bizarre idiocy from Heitinga, scoring a horrific own-goal, flicking the ball needlessly away from the advancing Howard and into the Everton net... Utterly shocking incompetence!

Everton tried to regroup and took advantage of a very ragard stop-start game but some of the passing was Sunday League. A dreadful return ball from Drenthe almost let the Geordies in.

Suddenly, with a quarter of the game gone, Everton fashioned a nice chance with Drenthe putting in a great forward ball for a glancing header from Rodwell that forced a good save. Then Osman got a chance to shoot but at the keeper. At the other end, Ba was denied his first chance.

A tremendous ball over the back from Jagielka saw Saha beat the offside trap and, with the goal at his mercy, leathered it high, wide and hideous. A dreadful piece of shooting!. Another chance fell to the Frenchman and he screwed it well wide. Lots of chances but zero end product.

But off a poor Rodwell clearance, an unbelieable strike by Ryan Taylor flew in over Howard, an unstoppable shot, and Everton down two goals after actually playing better than a poor Newcastle team.

Coleman did well to create a layback for Rodwell but he set-up Neville for a hopeless shot into the mix, and a snapshot from Saha hit the post, Coleman driving the rebound across the face of goal where Drenthe coming in powered a poor shot into the side netting. It was setting up to be one of those games would do anything but score, while a Newcastle cross drifted over Howard and glanced off the bar!

To rub salt in the wounds, Dan Gosling then came on for a very rare Newcastle first-team appearance as Neville collapsed, holding his leg, after his left hamstring went as he over-stretched for a ball, and was replaced by Sylvain Distin.

Gutirez illegally won a dangerous free-kick but the Everton wall did its job and Everton looked to break but Coleman lost the ball into touch. Drenthe had a long conversation with Andre Mariner as Howard had to punch away a Taylor free-kick.

Everton's first corner in stoppage time was swung in brilliantly by Drenthe, and Rodwelll powered home an excellent header to make things a little more respectable at the break. The 600th goal of David Moyes's reign.

A very strange first half, where Everton should have dominated but pressed the self-destruct button, with Drenthe at once both brilliant and dreadful in equal measure.

The lack of composure continued from both sides into a scrappy start to the second half, Heitinga's hesitancy and then a stupid foul earning him a stupid yellow card.

Everton should have had a penalty when Gosling quite deliberately handled a Saha shot, pushing it wide of the Newcastle goal but Mariner was possibly unsighted. 56 minutes and Cahill replaced the shocking Heitinga, as the shocking passing continued to destroy any attempted fluency.

Saha was having a nightmare, passes going nowhere, shots off target, and easily dispossessed by Gosling. A chance fell to Cahill off a long ball and he drilled a good shot that forced a decent save from Krul.

A free-kick on the corner of the Newcastle penalty area was swung in by Baines but defended away. Saha looked to have a chance but waited too long for the ball to drop. Baines incredibly was booked when he was kicked by Simpson, who collapsed under non-existent sniper fire.

The ball fell nicely for Drenthe to break but he took the wrong option, not releasing the ball for Coleman and a good chance was gone, as Everton struggled to withstand a growing aerial bombardment. For relief, Baines and Coleman advanced down the Everton left, Baines eventually crossing for Osman, all alone, to totally mess up his shot.

Cahill did well to win a ball that came to Coleman but he slipped horribly as he went to shoot. But a ridiculously lofted free-kick form out wide right by Drenthe summed up the at times abysmal quality of the football on show... followed an equally poor delivery from an excellent position by Leighton Baines.

With 10 mins of an increasingly dreadful game left, James McFadden made his second Everton debut, replacing Tony Hibbert as Moyes risked everything to secure the result. McFadden's first touch won a free-kick for handball. Then Drenthe finally went in the book for a poor foul borne of frustration.

Gosling went for glory down the middle but Osman did very well to put him off. Everton shaped to attack a little better with McFadden on, and won a corner that Cahill almost got onto, but McFadden's follow-up cross-cum-shot came to nothing as Saha wasted another half-chance.

Four minutes of added time but it was now all Newcastle, with Everton spent of ideas and unable to do the basics in terms of keeping possession until Mariner's whistle finally ended the misery. Newcastle, who are supposedly in a false position because they have still to play anybody of note this season, go second in the Premier League. Just shocking.

Sixth defeat in seven games for Everton. But the untouchable David Moyes will no doubt be pleased with what he saw... basic defensive errors notwithstanding.


* Correction: It appears that Vellios had been selected but was forced to pull out of the pre-match warm-up due to injury.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (129)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tom Bowers
1 Posted 05/11/2011 at 13:31:16
2-0 down very predictable. You don't need to be a rocket scientist just a stubborn Scotsman by the name of Moyes. When is BK going to get shut of him. This is unbelievable. He has nothing left to offer this once great club.
Is he waiting till we make the bottom of the Prem?
Roman Sidey
2 Posted 05/11/2011 at 13:43:44
Howard should have communicated better with Heitinga. Not shifting blame off the Dutchman, but the 'keeper is the one that orchestrates the backline.
Ryan Holroyd
3 Posted 05/11/2011 at 13:46:47
If John 'I'm one of the top 10 defenders in the world' Heitinga had done his job properly then wouldn't have been a problem for their 1st goal.
Oliver Molloy
4 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:45:47
Tom,
Just who would you get to manage the club then and slove all our problems?
Joe McMahon
5 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:46:13
Guys, it's time for us to be worried. Newcastle are light years ahead of us, great stadium too, good luck to them.
Joe McMahon
6 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:49:40
Oliver (4), please stop with that one, next it's Becareful what you wish for, and if not Moyes who.
Nathan Ward
7 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:51:31
I've never once asked for Moyes head. Think he has been awesome for us and generally speaking we would be sunk without him.

However today is a different story. We started with the wrong XI. He then made stupid substitutions and gave all the space in the world to the Barcodes.

We are in a right royal mess and unless something changes - either the manager or his thinking - its going to be a really long slog
Howard Don
8 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:46:50
What nonesense- "flicking the ball away from the advancing Howard" - Heitinga hasn't got eyes in the back of his head or a clue who's behind him. He has no option but to go for that ball, unless he gets a shout, ALL the commentators and summarisers agreed on that.

Yes it should have gone in row Z but for goodness sake it was a killer ball in "utterly shocking incompetence" is way OTT. If there's any incompetence around it's at the other end in our inability to play balls in like that.
Bobby Mallon
9 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:46:58
Gutted.

I can't describe how bad I feel... Moyes needs to be sacked; fucking McFadden getting a game. I am sick of this manager and board. 6 out of 7 lost... relegation is going to happen if we don't get rid and shake things up very very soon. And I don't want to hear we have not spent much because neither have Newcastle.

We are so bad at present, I feel so sorry for all the fans who went. There needs to be big protests at the next home game, no messing about. Moyes out, Board out... Fuck off, Kenwright.

What has Gueye, the Secret Weapon done wrong to have been kept out of the team? The boy is miles better than McFadden and Vellios. What has happened there???

Sack the Ginger Moron.
Oliver Molloy
11 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:56:55
Joe,
What are you on about,tell me who the would make us better.
It's easy to say this and that,much harder to put it into practice.
Please tell me.
Iain Love
12 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:50:16
Every week Moyes gets stick, sometimes rightly so, but now we're in the position where we dont just not buy players but we're selling them as well, Arteta , Pienaar , Beckford , The Yak etc etc , and all we've got in are players who aren't up to it.
We are bad enough to go down but i'd blame others before Moyes.
Ray Robinson
13 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:49:44
Heitinga isn't capable of playing against big physical forwards so why didn't Distin start?

Some random observations:

* We gave the ball away too easily,
* We underhit passes, overhit crosses. * Coleman had his worst ever game in my opinion and would probably benefit from a rest if he wasn't one of the few getting forward quickly with the ball
* Hibbert stops the play dead every time he receives the ball
* Drenthe is wasteful but at least tries to make things happen
* Howard's communication needs to improve but that still doesn't exonerate Heitinga

Finally, how did the ref fail to see Gosling knock the ball away with his arm?

Despite having most of the play in the second half, did we really play enough joined-up football or attacking prowess to deserve anything?
Mike Keating
14 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:56:16
Sorry Joe @ 5
Barcodes "light years ahead"?
They were crap and we gifted them 2 goals and had the lion's share of the 2nd half.
They will not get into the Europa League let alone the top 4.
However, the big issue for me was the number of times we gave them the ball. If you can bear it - watch all 90 minutes of this dreadful game again and count the number of times we actually passed the ball to a barcoded shirt.
Newcastle did not win this game - we gave it to them.
Just pathetic.
Joe McMahon
15 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:01:28
Oliver, not all this again, but apart from Big Sam, anyone. 65k a week will make mangers interested. Lambert, Poyet - again anyone. 10 years into the job, and very, very near relgation places. As for spending Money, 10 mill waste Bily on the bench. Osman still plays, do I need to go on. Don't respond, I can't be arsed (like Moyes)
David Mathieson
16 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:05:42
If you are not part of the solution you are part of the problem; my feelings towards all things blue.
Brian Waring
17 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:00:28
Oliver, the " Who could do a better job " is getting a tad boring now, especially when its spouted after another defeat.

The only plus point, we won't have lads coming on here after this defeat, telling us how Newcastle have spent millions, so therefore we can't be expected to compete with them.






Joe McMahon
18 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:07:36
Mike, take your point, but maybe the 3 games weve won this season we've been lucky, certainly Blackburn & Fulham.
Jackie Barry
19 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:07:33
What rubbish write up for the game! LOL! We were pathetic and yes Newcastle did look light years ahead of us. It's all very well blaming Heitinga for the first goal but what on earth was Howard doing??? Also how is taking Hibbert off risking everything when we are 2-1 down????? Sounds like Moyes methodology of management to me. There is no papering over the cracks for this one we were trash and look pathetic at the moment.
Ian Adams
20 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:08:40
lets face it, we have no imagination, no ideas, no f***in money and never even went for a win today!our players are average at best, our finishing is piss poor, god its depressing, especially when a team like newcastle is 2nd!!!
Kevin Elliott
21 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:45:11
Roman .2. Bang on.Where was the comunication between Howard and Heitinga,fuckin schoolboy stuff.And if we're gonna' play Heitinga,then why not at the expense of Jagielka and not Distin.How many chances does Saha need and when is Howard going to pass a long ball to one of his own players?.When is Drenthe going to pass a square ball to one of his own players?When are any of them going to pass any type of ball to their own players?.When is Moyes going to realise that he is a shit manager?.Why do we bother?
Brian Waring
22 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:11:05
John Ford got it right when he said we don't have the brains.

Newcastle looked fucked, and for all our possesion, we just didn't have a clue what to do with it.
Jamie Barlow
23 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:12:23
Newcastle were light years ahead of us? I must watch a totally different game.
Nathan Ward
24 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:03:33
Iain #10 - you are right. Having lost all those players is a massive hinderance and a decent excuse/reason why we won't finish 7th this season.

However today we lost because as Ray #11 has pointed out we had the wrong players from our available squad playing. Distin if fit to play from when he did should have started.

We shouldn't have had a defender in midfield again. Rodwell is a defensive midfielder.

Hibbert & Osman aren't up to the job.
David Mathieson
25 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:11:51
The only thing Everton can take any pride out of the game for is the poppies on the shirts. I would sell them off and donate the money to the poppy appeal.

http://www.mirrorfootball.co.uk/news/Armistice-Day-row-War-veterans-fury-as-FIFA-ban-England-from-wearing-poppies-on-shirts-article827019.html
If they done this to Everon I would expect us to refuse to play.
Robin Cannon
26 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:06:32
While a new manager might provide a short term boost, let's face it, under the current regime nobody is going to achieve any more long term success than Moyes has.

That being said, it's very clear that Moyes is failing to adjust to current circumstances. I never believed that 4-5-1 was inherently a negative formation, but when you take the creativity out of it (i.e. Pienaar and Arteta) then it becomes far less effective or flexible.

Yet Moyes can't (or won't) adjust. His substitutions, even if they are for more attacking players, never change our basic formation. There's no tactical flexibility. That's not always been the case, but either as a result of being here for so long, or the financial and squad restrictions, or both, Moyes simply won't adjust.

When what you're doing clearly isn't working, then you have to change. It almost doesn't matter what that change might be, just do *something* differently.

I don't call for Moyes out, because his and the team's failings are a symptom of a far greater malaise, not the cause. Indeed any kind of anti-Moyes campaign pretty much plays into BK's hands because it distracts from and pressure on him, and that pressure is *far* more important for our long term success.

Today was just infuriating. We actually approached the match in a relatively positive manner, but there was so much sloppiness and missed opportunities. At least I was more engaged than I've been in recent games, and not completely resigned to the result. But there was just so much basic incompetence (especially Saha), or general stupidity (Drenthe may have talent, but he clearly has zero footballing brain), it drives you crazy.
David Mathieson
27 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:17:31
"...nobody is going to achieve any more long term success than Moyes has..."

Stop reading after that because it is simply not true.
Brian Waring
28 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:15:35
Nathan, the thing is, Newcastle lost four of their best players as well, Barton, Nolan, Carrol and Enriquez.
Robin Cannon
29 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:19:26
@David (25)

Given the current situation of zero investment, and players being sold off, I can't think of any managerial change that's going to consistently exceed any of the league positions that Moyes has achieved in the time he's been here.

Any change is purely a short term solution or a cosmetic fix until *any* manager (Moyes or otherwise) is going to be in a position to manage the team without being hamstrung by board incompetence.
Nick Armitage
31 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:18:30
Howard Don 8 - well said, he should have had a shout. Fault lies with Howard there, all day and caused by another example of Baines not closing down the space on his man.

Baines defending right now leaves a lot to be desired, but then again, so do the rest of the overpaid uncommitted fuckers.
David Mathieson
32 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:23:06
Robbie
I believe it is called thinking outside the box.
Ray Robinson
33 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:22:18
Robin #27 while I agree with you up to a point, the financial situation didn't pick Heitinga ahead of Distin or cause any of the other strange team selections / substitutions that we have witnessed this season.
David Mathieson
34 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:27:06
robin even haha
Nathan Ward
35 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:22:23
#24 - Good points but unless SOMETHING changes we are in big trouble

#26 - That adds to my points. We could have won today. We should have won today if the manager had picked the right players from the squad and made the right subs.
Robin Cannon
36 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:25:16
@David (29)

Out of the box thinking is exactly how Moyes achieved relative stability over a long period of time while facing massive underinvestment. I think you're dreaming if you think any other manager, however capable, is going to achieve long term success without serious structural change in the financial situation of the club and how it's run.

That's not to say that a managerial change wouldn't see us improve for a season or two, particularly because Moyes has become far more conservative over time. But all that would do is paper over the cracks of the far deeper entrenched problems at the club.

I'd rather see pressure for change at the board level, which might provide the opportunity for the structural change we need for long term success, than distracting from that with pressure for a managerial change that would be a short term solution at best.
Steve Barr
37 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:23:22
The miscommunication amongst the defence, the unimaginative midfield play, piss poor attacking. We had plenty of chances but no one with the guile and basic skills to finish.

Added together this is a team in desperate trouble.

It's no good saying "who can replace Moyes"? Of course no one is irreplacable.

What is clear is that we need some spark to save this season. Where does anyone think we're getting 30+ points from based on the season so far.

Historically, that spark usually comes from new management. Remember the difference Royle made when he took over.

This is just terrible.
Andy Corrie
38 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:28:19
Total and absolute rubbish, I am utterly lost for words, ashamed and embarrassed to be an Everton fan, what a disgrace.
David Mathieson
39 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:31:17
Robin

If the board stays the same and we fluctuate betweet say 8th and 16th for the next say 15 years, at any time would you want Moyes to leave?

Everton are not Crewe, all it would take for someone to be more successful than Moyes is do a Joe Royle.

Moyes will never win a major trophy in my opinion and he has not changed our youth set up infact under him it has probably got worse.

David Mathieson
40 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:36:46
"Out of the box thinking is exactly how Moyes achieved relative stability over a long period of time while facing massive underinvestment"

Everton are the tenth highest spenders in the premier league hardly "massive underinvestment" This is for all teams which have been in the Premier League.
Rob Prince
41 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:33:15
Whoever says "Who would we get instead of Moyes" for fucks sake it´s getting old. A someone stated on here fairly recently there are thousands od well run respectable football clubs around the world and they are not managed by fucking David Moyes. Face it we are piss poor and MOyes days have to be numbered FFS
Robin Cannon
42 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:37:50
David

If the board stays the same then frankly I can't see anyone doing any better. Though I agree that there would be more likelihood of a slow decline without a managerial change (but then we'd just face the same issue, postponed for a couple of seasons).

In some senses I think your Royle example is proof of that. He provided a short term boost and confidence that had the team playing well, he pushed us forward when he had investment in player, and then when the board failed to provide us with the means to take the next step, and started selling off our best players, we went into decline. That's pretty much exactly the same route we've taken with Moyes, the main difference being that Royle won his cup final and Moyes lost his.
Oliver Molloy
43 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:31:19
Joe @ 13,& Brian @ 15...
The very reason you are unhappy is because of Moyes.
I am really disappointed with todays result also but this is the reality for Everton.
We have no money,we do have a very good manager who has to work with what he has,and until someone tells me who, under these current circumstances at our club would do a better job then him then yes " i am in the be careful what you wish for" corner.
Peter Barnes
44 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:35:35
Lets face it there is a reason why Drenthe is with us on loan and not at Real.His passing is poor.However the guy does have strengths in his pace and shooting.And we need to play to these strengths which clearly we dont.

Regardless of the utter shite talked on the TV.All of this "expressing themselves"bollocks that the clowns spout.
The basic concept of playing a guy out ontheflank where there is space and passing the bloody ball to him is hardly new, revolutionary or scientific in any way. It is simply basics that have been involved in football since year one.
Today we were poor on most of the basics.
Kevin Elliott
45 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:45:11
Roman .2. Bang on.Where was the comunication between Howard and Heitinga,fuckin schoolboy stuff.And if we're gonna' play Heitinga,then why not at the expense of Jagielka and not Distin.How many chances does Saha need and when is Howard going to pass a long ball to one of his own players?.When is Drenthe going to pass a square ball to one of his own players?When are any of them going to pass any type of ball to their own players?.When is Moyes going to realise that he is a shit manager?.Why do we bother?
Oliver Molloy
47 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:47:59
Andy @ 35...
You are the one who should be ashamed and embarrassed coming out with comments like that...
Get lost and support some other team then.
Robin Cannon
48 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:52:44
David

If you take the figure from 2003-2011 (roughly Moyes' tenure) then our spending is 15th most (and our average position during that time is considerably higher than that). Over the last two seasons our total spend has been £1.5 million total and our net spend has been minus £12.1 million.

So, yes, Moyes has faced massive underinvestment, and that situation has worsened significantly over the last two seasons, which is when we've also started to see a more consistent decline in league performances.

I think that's a completely unsustainable situation for any team, and any manager.
Jon Cox
49 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:37:40
Robin, you are correct in what you say about the board. Bit it's not them that select the players or style the tactics come Saturday afternoon.

It's Moye's baby and the buck stops with him and no-one else.

Which ever manager we were to aquire would give the team a new impetus, a new direction. It doesn't matter if it was only short term at least we would have the breathing space to work out our next step.

Everything now regarding Moyes is stale. New blood is needed and with that new blood has to be an attacking mentality from the off. Even whomever the number two is.
Kevin Elliott
51 Posted 05/11/2011 at 14:45:11
Roman #2. Bang on. Where was the comunication between Howard and Heitinga? ... fuckin schoolboy stuff. And, if we're gonna' play Heitinga, then why not at the expense of Jagielka and not Distin?

How many chances does Saha need and when is Howard going to pass a long ball to one of his own players?

When is Drenthe going to pass a square ball to one of his own players?When are any of them going to pass any type of ball to their own players?

When is Moyes going to realise that he is a shit manager?

Why do we bother?
Robin Cannon
52 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:00:36
Jon

I agree that Moyes has become stale, and overly conservative. I can to some extent understand why he's moved more towards a "have what you hold" mentality given the circumstances he's forced to manage under, but it's clearly not working.

Why is he stale, though? Presumably because of the situation in which he finds himself in terms of lack of investment and a (relative) lack of options. I think the negativity has become particularly apparent since the start of last season, and I think his disappointment at the total lack of investment to try and push on from the strong end to the 2008-09 season has had a huge impact there.

I suppose the question is:? Which situation is more likely to lead to the systemic change and new ownership that is what is really needed? I think a new manager who gives us a short term boost protects Kenwright, lets him claim "Look, we're doing OK". He has to be put under pressure to sell this club, because clearly he's not going to choose to do so himself.
David Mathieson
53 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:01:59
Robin
You are only looking at the net spend column if you look at Spend which is there for a reason you will see we are tenth!

If you look at net spend we have outspent Arsenal and Newcastle in the period you mention


Source:

http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2003-2011.html
David Mathieson
54 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:05:31
"I think that's a completely unsustainable situation for any team, and any manager."

From your own argument and my source Wenger seems to have done ok but he is a real manager Everton will never come across while Moyes is in charge forever.
Rob Hollis
55 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:05:49
Peter Barnes

Absolutely spot on. People are always spouting rubbish about how complex the game is, as if you needed an Oxbridge First to understand it.

Hate to say it, but great managers like Shankly and Paisley always talked about the simplicity and they were right.
Robin Cannon
56 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:05:14
David

What mindset is that? That I want Everton to have real change so that we can be a well run club with a foundation for long term success on and off the field? That I want the fans to be agitating for that kind of change, and not distracting themselves with short term solutions that won't address the deeper lying problems.

I am not happy with the fact that we can't support any manager, and I want systemic change so that we can challenge any club in the Premier League. I want Everton as an institution to pull itself out of its long term decline, change itself root and branch and move forward. You apparently just want to change the manager.
Brian Waring
57 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:11:06
The thing is though Robin, Moyes is paid a wad of cash to manage us, and it is his job to find solutions when things are not working on the pitch, but it just seems to be the same old, same old with him.

Mick Davies
58 Posted 05/11/2011 at 15:54:20
"Who would we get instead of Moyes" ? Well how about the SkyTV commentator?

We started off taking the game to the skunks then Moyes, utilised all his tactical prowess by swithching Coleman and Drenthe. From that moment on, Seamus was awful and the commentator at least twice questioned the reasoning behind this.

If I could I would tell him that David "Hibbert for England" Moyes does these things regularly, and then maybe the media would stop singing his praises and realise he is not good enough to manage in the PL.

Last 10 mins with Coleman at right back looked the most dangerous period of play for us as an attacking unit. Trouble is, the game was already lost
David Mathieson
59 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:11:45
"Gradi is notable for his 24-year first spell as manager of Crewe"

This is what Moyes and Everton are turning into and all the blame is on the board for our problems which is rubbish.

If you don't go looking for Wengers you will never find them and we are the top flight version of Crewe.

It is the fans fault in my eyes small time.
Jon Cox
60 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:05:13
If I could point to where it started to go downhill then I would guess it was with the non aquisition of Donovan. With Pienaar on the left and Donovan on the right we were aforce to be reckoned with.

Even Bainsey has never been the same since. With the loan of Drenthe, Moyes should have been trying to move mountains to replicate the Baines Pienaar act.

I just dont see anything that says Moyes has tried to acheive this. Even basics like passing and shooting is so woeful. I mean WTF do they do at training in the week.

When the team plays football like we've seen in the last 4/5 weeks Moyes should have the fuckers in every day from 9-5 working on these basic skills. For the money they get they should at least have to work comparable hours to the rest of us!
Robin Cannon
61 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:13:52
Brian - You can also very legitimately argue that he has "found solutions" over an extended period of time; that's why our league positions have been relatively solid during his tenure.

That being the case, I don't disagree that he has become stale and increasingly conservative, particularly last season and this. It's incredibly frustrating.

My point is not that Moyes is amazing. My point is that a managerial change should not
David Mathieson
62 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:16:57
"Moyes should have been trying to move mountains to replicate the Baines Pienaar act"

Moyes spent ten millon on Billy spliting up the best left side, posssibly in the premier league, of Baines and Pienaar.

That is because he is one of the best managers in the world.
Robin Cannon
63 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:17:45
...to finish that last sentence...

My point is not that Moyes is amazing. My point is that a managerial change should not be the focus because achieving a systemic change in the way the club is run is far more important, and without that I don't think over the long term it will matter who the manager is, the decline won't stop.
Jon Cox
64 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:21:04
David, quite.
Robin Cannon
65 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:23:39
David (55)

In terms of your overall assessment of the club's standing, I'm actually in agreement with you. I just have a very different interpretation of the causes.

Crewe under Dario Graadi effectively punched (somewhat) above their weight. Under Moyes we've done much the same.

Yet without systemic change, Crewe never had the potential to push forward from that situation (whether with Graadi as manager or not). Crewe didn't really have the potential for that structural change, Everton do have that potential. And as fans we should be bringing the pressure to make that change, because that's what's going to make a difference to our changes of long term success.
Trevor Mackie
66 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:34:30
Robin are you Ian?
Ciarán McGlone
67 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:23:06
Robin,

You appear to be sporting a rather obvious cognitive dissonance.

You cannot on the one hand suggest definitively that no-one could do better than Moyes, and on the other concede that he is stale, frustrating and conservative.

The only way you. can link these two positions logically, is if you think that every other potential manager has the same flaws. That's a nonsense.

Let's stop playing silly Bugger and dragging up redundant excuses for bad management.

Try talking about what he does with what he's got for once, instead of resorting to the same old tired nonsense.
Jamie Barlow
68 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:50:23
David@55. It's fans like you who big up the board and cheer Bill Kenwright when you see his face on the big screen who have fucked this club up.
Robin Cannon
69 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:45:39
Ciarán

I've already said that I think Moyes has become overly conservative. I think that's a combination of a decade at one club and a frustration at the increasing lack of investment.

I've also said that a managerial change might see a short term improvement, i.e. that for a season or two another manager could do better than Moyes. Over an extended period of time, however, that improvement would be unsustainable because of the structural issues at the club. In essence, without any support (and, indeed, with incompetence than actively undermines the manager), and manager is going to fail; whether they become disheartened, decide to move on, or simply can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear any more.

We've finished in the top eight for six out of the last seven seasons. Given the situation at the club, that's a solid long term performance that I don't think any other manager would have noticeably improved upon. I think there's a degree of unrealistic expectation on what a new manager could achieve while working under the same restrictions.

Most importantly, my argument is that it is far more vital to maintain significant pressure on the board in order to try and achieve long term structural change. A campaign against a manager who has achieved relative success over a concerted period distracts from the far more important changes that need to be made.

A potential short term improvement from a managerial change would simply remove some of that pressure because the board can claim "look, we're taking action, we've improved" and it's unfortunately the nature of football fans in the absence of a crisis situation, a campaign for real change is likely to lose impetus. Only with a competently run club under new ownership can the Moyes of today be realistically assessed, and real change and improvement occur over the long term.
Tony Twist
70 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:43:57
It is, I think, bad management and it's not the first time Moyes has been extremely slow to react. When was our last clean sheet, seems a lifetime away. Considering he plays a defensive team set up we are extremely poor defensively, not being able to keep the ball and when passing unable to find a team mate doesn't help on that front.

However, it will be a very brave (or foolish) man to sack the manager as, with no money, there won't be anyone of quality interested in taking the job. Only a quality replacement will ensure the "stars" stay committed.
Tony Marsh
71 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:56:19
What has happened to the so-called Indian buyers? Do any of you really believe selling the club to them was discussed? I mean what's to discuss if the Tatas want to buy and Kenwright wants to sell? Where's the hold-up coming from?

It's all Bollocks and another BK Red Herring. Kenwright is to blame for today, last week, and the week before that. It's Kenwright who keeps himself and Moyes here and only if we are relegated will there be any change at the top.
Simon Harris
72 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:44:11
Robin #52 - Bang on. The real issue here is at boardroom level. If we sack Moyes we've still got the same fundamental problems of no investment, and a club in decline.



Moyes is not without critism, but replacing him could been seen as a sticking plaster, when we require surgery.

Ciarán McGlone
73 Posted 05/11/2011 at 16:59:33
Robin,

Your points regarding the board have merit, but you cannot use that as an eternal defence of Moyes.

You are simply wrong when you suggest that Moyes can only be assessed in the context of a properly run club. He can quite clearly be assessed by what he does with the hand he's been dealt.

And he has consistently made the same managerial mistakes over the course of his tenure. To suggest that this will change with boardroom competency is nothing but a fairy tale.
Robin Cannon
74 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:11:56
Ciarán

I'm not using it as an eternal defence of Moyes. I've said repeatedly in this thread that a change of management could potentially bring a short term improvement.

In regards to assessing Moyes by the hand he's been dealt, again, he can legitimately be assessed to have made a pretty good job of that over a long term period. Now this season is a different matter, and so far its frustrating and depressing, but I think there is a case that current frustrations and anger are also coloring the viewpoint of Moyes' past achievements. I think in general he has been a positive influence on the club.

But, to reiterate, my main point is that the we as fans should be focused on "Kenwright out" and not distracting ourselves with a campaign against the manager. The only way this club is going to improve in the long term is with board level change, and agitating for a change of manager distracts from that.
Richard Dodd
75 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:10:44
Forget changing the manager ? it will never happen as long as BB is in charge and, with no bids on the horizon, that could be for some time yet!

We are no worse off than at this time last year and have many of the most difficult games behind us. A point a game up to Christmas and the usual resurgence thereafter will see us safely into the top half.

Keep the faith!
David Aden
76 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:12:49
The fact of the matter is out of the last 10 seasons the only seasons we made profit were champions league season, the sale of Rooney season and the sale of Lescott season. To blame Moyes is a disloyal thing to do. We have simply bought out of loaning money from other places, which is unacceptable, and stupid.

Moyes' tactical naivety is true though, we can all see it. Not selecting Vellios and Gueye is beyond me who have ACTUALLY shown promise opposed to playing youngsters who will be out of their depth. But @David #37 to say the youth system has gotten worse you are clearly misguided. Having worked at Finch Farm the youth system is outstanding, Moyes has if not improved everything that has happened at youth level.

The sheer fact is that we dont want a business owner who only uses us as a toy, and once they are bored its off to the next venture. But we don't want the spiral downwards to continue. We don't want a new manager, but we can't be left with the same old boring tactics as it has been over the recent year. In truth as a fan I am just as confused and baffled as much as Moyes seems to be when it comes to choosing a formation.

I have lost any sort of knowledge on how to explain our situation.

Wayne Smyth
77 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:13:03
Lets look at some of the points made:

1) Moyes is doing a decent job with the resources given.
2) The lack of investment is the "real" cause of our inability to string 2 passes together.
3) Replacing the manager will not correct the systemic issues.

Then add some of my own observations:

1) Kenwright will never bring in investment.
2) Moyes will never call for Kenwright to go.
3) Kenwright will never sack Moyes.

Doesn't sound like a recipe for success or stability. Sounds like a recipe for relegation to me.

Scary thing is, I can't even see that Kenwright would sack Moyes even if we were relegated. Their relationship is far too cosy to be effective.

The solution is to replace the old stale manager with no fire in his belly with a new manager with something to prove. How many of us thought Moyes would do well when he arrived? He did fantastic for the first half of his tenure. We need another young manager to come in and do the same.

I want a manager who is going to put pressure on the board to manage the club competently. I want a board who will put pressure on the manager to get the best out of the players. Only then will we start to improve and have a chance of winning something.
Gavin Ramejkis
78 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:22:33
David #70, the trouble is we already have a chairman out of his depth for over a decade who see Everton as his private toy, his failings are killing the club yet he clings on for dear life at the direct consequence of the club edging clower and closer to administration and losing its abaility to compete in the EPL.

A change is needed both in the boardroom and of manager, seriously McFadden to save a game still not match fit with Velios, Gueye and Barkley all overlooked?
Robin Cannon
79 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:22:06
David (70)

Depressing, but accurate. I feel much the same; I'm disheartened about every aspect of the club at the moment.

For large parts of Moyes' tenure Everton have given me some hope, certainly a happier time than most of the 1990s. It's in some senses more depressing because there was that flicker of something in the past, some potential, and it never got followed up.

I just don't want a false dawn. I'm suck to fucking death of Everton being also-rans at best. And that's never going to change without change at the boardroom level. It's just so frustrating because frankly most of us could run the club more competently as a business than it seems to be run now, even regardless of additional investment.

I don't want us to get some new manager who's positive and exciting (as Moyes was), see his opportunities slip by because of lack of investment and business incompetence. I'm fed up of Everton being an embarrassment off the field. I don't want a billionaire, I just want someone with a fucking clue how to run this club properly, and move forward from there.
David Aden
80 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:28:55
@Gavin 71. All your observations are true mate, I just worry that we will be a Blackburn model of takeover. Managerially Moyes is poor when it comes to selection and tactically it just confuses me, and as a coach I dont see why he does some things.

I just cant see a right step, Everton as a club are a very poor investment, we need a wedge planted into the club, and your right we have been in invested in poorly too.

It's just, we're do you start and opposed to "just sack the board manager and everyone" a proper business plan is needed, not people just claiming they think Moyes is garbage as well as Kenwright, Bill is a massive blue and his heart is ruling his head, but the same goes for most fans.
Gavin Ramejkis
82 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:28:41
apologies for typos, trying to type and entertain two children at same time
Trevor Mackie
83 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:49:28
Most people, maybe 99.98% (joking!! before the strops start), will tell you why you can't do stuff but look no further than the fella celebrating 25 yrs at manu as why you can, it was imposible to knock liverpool off their perch when SAF took over but he said fuck 'em - and did.

I don't care whether it's short term or not, nobody knows what's going on in the next 5 mins let alone a year or two, pinky and perky need splitting up for the good of the club.

The illusory best of the rest complacency of "everyone wants to be like us " kenwright and "knife to a gunfight" Moyes is reaping what they've sown the less than dynamic duo have run out of luck, ideas and mortgageable assets.

It's easy to just target Kenwright - but to get at Kenwright you've gotta go through Moyes! oops.
David Mathieson
84 Posted 05/11/2011 at 17:45:22
"@David #37 to say the youth system has gotten worse you are clearly misguided. Having worked at Finch Farm the youth system is outstanding, Moyes has if not improved everything that has happened at youth level?

Improved facilities does not equal improved youth you could put that as a + for the board apart from we now have liabilities and not assets.

How has are youth preformed under Moyes compared to before him? Also how have are reserves done? We should have a winning mentality at the club from top to bottom.

In the youth system before Moyes:
Jeffers Rooney Ball McCann Dunne Branch Oster Cadematri Osman few more fruits of labour before Moyes

Ten years of Moyes what has come out: Rodwell, Anichebe, Vaughan, Baxter, Barkley.
David Mathieson
85 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:03:36
Some on the Moyes list were at the club before he got here so not his youth policy in deployment.
David Mathieson
86 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:06:58
"David@55. It's fans like you who big up the board and cheer Bill Kenwright when you see his face on the big screen who have fucked this club up. "

Whiff of shit from your post.
Jon Cox
87 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:00:48
Gavin, singing and dancing works wonders.

Oh the mental picture.....
Alexander O'Brien
88 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:10:38
"A moment of bizarre idiocy from Heitinga set the tone" Who write's this stuff?? If you look HOWARD didn't shout at any point to claim the ball, which is my view makes him the man at fault, also his reaction said it all! it was an error by Heitinga but if your keeper doesn't claim the box and your waiting for him to do so, it's a reaction to stick a leg out! Don't forget it was a nasty ball to deal with.
Tony Cheek
89 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:01:48
First Goal fact 1 : If Howard did not make a call, he is as much to blame as Heitinga.
First goal fact 2 : If it was Distin there, the ball would have been booted into Row K.
First Goal fact 3: Our best defender started the game on the bench.

But the reason we lost today is none of the above, it is because of absolutely dreadful finishing. We should have been leading 2-0 before that goal. We are just so absolutely toothless in front of goal. If you see the highlights again, just watch Saha after he hits the post, Just stands there and does FA, instead of keeping switched on. He is nothing but a drama queen! Could you see Suarez, Chicarito, Van Persie doing the same, not on your life.
Christ, we moaned about Beckford missing chances, but at least he was always in the right place to miss them.
David Aden
90 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:22:03
@Gavin 77. I'm going to just say mate that facilities regardless are not what is a perfect academy. You are right, but I never stated that. Not once. And I have NEVER believed that, it is philosophy and culture what do! I agree with you doesn't matter how good facilities are if the players/coaches arent good enough facilities wont do shit.

Your list of before and after leave a lot to be desired, I dont quite understand your aregument, are you saying that McCann, Cadamatri, Oster, Branch, and even Jeffers to some extent are proof of how good are system was because it is proof of how bad we were back then. Rodwell, Barkley, Vaughan, are toegther better individuals than the ones listed before Moyes. But feel free to name to me some of the players that have come out of Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and even Man United ACADEMIES from being very very young (eg. 10 and below) and start in their 11. You will find maybe 5 or 6 names, between all teams that have a chance of starting very regularly for them. Which proves our academy is doing something right.

But very true, we DON'T have a winning mentality that is being SHOWN at the club, it is right. I am not defending the mistakes that are continuously being made let alone pointing out to you that we maybe aren't as good as we all think we are. Maybe we aren't as an attractive team to others as we hope to be. I would play for Everton for free I am sure you would, but with no money maybe we might have to start pulling on the blue for ourselves.
Lol McNally
91 Posted 05/11/2011 at 18:31:55
1 /82 Let's be honest, who was good today?

Osman was shit as were the rest, we are in bad trouble.

Moyes brings McFadden on instead of Bily but, either way, too late. Moyes has lost the plot; Newcastle weren't good.

Saha is one lazy twat, come back Beckford!

As long as we don't get beat 5 0, Moyes is happy... does my head in.
Christopher Kelly
92 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:00:03
Guess what??? Im watching a taped version of QPR v Man City... so QPR has just come up, have a couple of quality players but not nearly the history we have... But guess what, they're having a go and the crowd is really into. They just tied Man City 2-2. I know they lose but it seems to be a lot more fun for their fans when their team gives it a go!
Tommy Heskrth
93 Posted 05/11/2011 at 19:41:17
David Mathieson,

I stopped reading when you listed Anichebe as a positive, unbeliveable.
Ryan Holroyd
94 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:48:51
'How has are youth preformed under Moyes compared to before him?'

Well we won the FA Academy league last season.
Jon Cox
95 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:42:58
Chris, the QPR fans gave their team a standing ovation at the end of the game. Why?

Because they "HAD A GO"

Moyes take note and get some strikers on the pitch FFS. And another thing look at Andy Johnson now he's not under Moyes's management. He probably scored tyhe goal of the season the other night.

Of course he now plays for a manager who lets him play with freedom of expression and look at the result.

Oi Davey you had this guy at our club and you fucked up just like you fucked up with so many of our strikers. Either work out how to set up a team that knows how to attack, knows how to pass a ball, knows how run into space, knows how to shoot with venom,

Or fuck off!!!
John Daley
96 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:33:25
"my main point is that the we as fans should be focused on "Kenwright out" and not distracting ourselves with a campaign against the manager"

The simple fact of the matter is that one will not go without the other. They are intimately intertwined now and a partnership in the truest sense of the word. Kenwright would never dream of sacking Moyes. Moyes will never speak ill of Bill or countenance any criticism of his " fantastic chairman". If Kenwright was ever forcibly ousted due to intolerable fan pressure then Moyes would probably walk in support of the buffoon.
John Daley
97 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:59:45
"We are no worse off than at this time last year"

So the fact we were equally shite for the first half of last season (and the season before, and the season before, and the season before) is now a defence for being shite yet again for (hopefully) the start of this season? When did being shite for five or six months every year become acceptable?
Robin Cannon
98 Posted 05/11/2011 at 21:11:11
@Jon (90)

You do realize that Johnson has a worse goals per game ratio at Fulham compared to that at Everton, right? It's not like he didn't score some crackers for us too.

While it's fair criticism of Moyes to suggest that he needs to take a more positive approach to games, let's not just start rewriting history regarding former players in order to back up that point.

@John (91)

Yes, Moyes has been complicit to some degree in terms of backing up Kenwright, but that also appears to be waning as the financial issues become more serious.

Doesn't mean that Moyes would walk if Kenwright left. I imagine he would want to assess his working relationship with any new owners, just as they would want to assess a working relationship with him.

I don't see any reason why Moyes would have to go in order for Kenwright to go. If anything, Moyes is ultimately somebody that Kenwright can sack in order to appease the fans and distract them from the deeper issues. Hell, remember how buddy buddy Kenwright and Walter Smith were? At that point the fan pressure became intolerable against Smith, and Kenwright gave him up. Kenwright then got lucky with Moyes, and that removed a lot of criticism and questioning of his own regime at boardroom level. Do we just want to let the same thing happen again?
Jon Cox
99 Posted 05/11/2011 at 21:15:36
John Daley, "i'll of Bill" does that star Uma Thurman, and if it does can I get my Dad, Michael Winner to direct :-)
Jon Cox
100 Posted 05/11/2011 at 21:19:49
Robin (93) which ever way you want to put it.

A. Johnson was a better goalscorer before he joined Everton. And,

B, he's going to be a better goal scorer since he's left our illustrious club.

It doesn't matter what you say but Andy Johanssen enjoyed his football most, before, and after leaving Everton.

And that my friend is down to one man.

And I'll bet he's looking forward to new years eve piss up, ie Hogmanay.
Ryan Holroyd
101 Posted 05/11/2011 at 21:32:40
Robin

You do realize that Johnson has a worse goals per game ratio at Fulham compared to that at Everton, right?

Don't give people facts like this. It distorts their argument.

Silly you
Keith Pratt
102 Posted 05/11/2011 at 20:40:49
Well, where do I start? How about Everton ruin your weekend??

I couldn't afford my season ticket this season as my son Joe has turned 16, so we have only been to 3 games so far, but work has picked up so I react to watching that shite today by booking Wolves tickets and a cheap hotel to stay up for the Bolton away game.

Why? Because I feel guilty for not going... not to our clueless manager or very ordinary team, but to the best supporters in the world, which make this club so special and if we loose, i want to be with other blues ? not in a pub in a market town in Northants, surrounded by plastic Kopites, Mancs and cockneys, not to mention the diehard Brummies that can't be arsed to drive 50 miles up the M40 to see their heroes.

My rant for the present shambles is Jags has become a pub centre-half that hoofs it aimlessly when in possession and makes a large number of mistakes that lead to goals conceded. Distin is the best we have, Heitinga is a legend in his own deluded arrogance and should fuck off to Barcelona (wake up Johnny, Go Ahead Eagles need a World Cup Final appearing centre-half.

Leon should play as a cente midfielder or not at all. Rodwell is a great prospect as a surging attacking midfielder, but Moyes has turned him into a defensive crab. Young Ross struggles to make the bench for having too much youthful talent and risk-taking ability for Dave's liking ("Ohcch, he mae beat 3 players and create something outta nothing but he's still only 17 and needs to understand his defensive duties.") Tim, I love you Cahill (both me and Dave saying that) but regrettably, I think we have seen his best days 2 seasons ago.

I'm boring myself now, so won't go on anymore, but WAKE UP MOYES LOVERS, he has lost the plot and is taking us down, final straw today was when he threw Mcfadden into the affray... I didn't recongnise him, he looked 50 and ill.
John Daley
103 Posted 05/11/2011 at 21:48:07
"John Daley, "i'll of Bill" does that star Uma Thurman, and if it does can I get my Dad, Michael Winner to direct :-)"

I was so disappointed when I first watched Kill Bill and realised the 'Bill' in question was actually David fucking Carradine.
John Daley
106 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:00:58
Proclaimer: I am not a big fan of murder, manslaughter and any and all unnatural causes of death, and in no way do I advocate any one even contemplating taking out a contract on any football chairmen....except Ken Bates.... no, actually not even Ken Bates. Although, feel free to slap him around the face with a fish. Not too forcefully though. Just a little stunning blow, so he takes a step back and thinks "what the fuck?" and then gets a massive whiff of fish. A haddock would be my weapon of choice.
Robin Cannon
107 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:14:09
@Jon (95)

On what basis? Sounds like you're effectively saying that "Andy Johnson is a better goalscorer since he left Everton. The facts don't support that, but it's true."
Anthony Flack
108 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:19:18
Johnson scores in low rating Europa league games, I barely noticed him against us, reminds me of Anichebe.....

Pointless going on about Johnson, mouse had nothing to do with him leavIng, he dId it for his family I.e london
Ian McDowell
109 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:31:33
Too many players in this squad are still living off there form from the 2009 season and the good finish we had to 2010. Saha, Osman, Neville, Jags, Heitinga and Cahill. Add that to the fact we haven't made a successful signing since Distin and have sold our 2 most skilful players in Arteta and Pienaar and thats why we are struggling.
Jon Cox
110 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:37:17
John Daley, i'm so dissapointed. You mean you actually watched that shite.

Anyway, Uma was only well bonkable in Pulp fiction, as far as i'm concerned.

Now dont argue cos i'll have to blow up the building and shoot all the state employed cleaners, and why not since they're all related to snoop dog g
Jon Cox
111 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:42:46
Robin (101)

Have you watched the games staring AJ? He looks like a man who's "Seen the light" Purlees, the guy looks liking he's enjoying his football. Unlike his time at goodison. There's no argument on this fact.

Just except the fact that he's enjoying scoring great goals and he doesn't have a Stalinesque manager to tell him how to do it.

Because, at the end of the day football and the skill to enact ones skills is a gift and no amount of "Badges" will change that fact.

Therefore Mancini can only be thought of as a great motivator with "Slight stratergy" thrown into the mix.

Thats why we were great five years ago. Moyes was a great motivator. But now it's gone and we need a new "Great motivator"
Jon Cox
112 Posted 05/11/2011 at 22:57:42
Robin (101) Stop with the quotation rubbish.

Tip. Get a five year old to proof read for you.
Brendan McLaughlin
113 Posted 05/11/2011 at 23:09:16
Yeah.. Andy just left us last season!
Paul Holden
114 Posted 05/11/2011 at 23:20:03
If we don't win against Wolves I think that will be the breaking point - for the fans, players who aint good enough, Kenwright and Moyesy. The perfect storm is coming to a head
Terry McLavey
115 Posted 05/11/2011 at 23:29:41
Just watched MOD post match interview with our "Great " manager "We didn't expect to get anything from today" or near enough ,BRILLIANT !! You don't expect anything from any match do you and it's your apathy that permeates our team !! are you hanging on for your fat cat pay off !! You have out stayed your welcome now f off and give Martin O'Neill a ring ,someone with fire in his belly , you've been boxing above your weight for too long !! Do the decent thing and fall on your sword!
Jon Cox
117 Posted 05/11/2011 at 23:43:09
Terry, Have you not sussed it yet. He's waiting for Celtic, or the Scotland Job.

If you had that amount of money in your bank account, wouldn't you?
Robin Cannon
118 Posted 06/11/2011 at 00:27:36
"There's no argument on this fact."

If you're going to suggest that I get a proof reader, you might want to learn the difference between "fact" and "opinion".

Still, I suppose you're right. Andy Johnson left Everton and instantly...three seasons later, had a good run of form. He's a great example of the point you're trying to make.
Mark Wilson
119 Posted 06/11/2011 at 02:42:12
You know your mad, really crazy, when you read through 110 contributions to the TW match report on yet another defeat. Depressing doesnt begin to cover it. But what makes it really really bad is when you recognise that it's the negative, sometimes Blue Union'ish contributions, that keep ringing that bell in your head and despite your "position" you cannot fault the logic .....unless something or someone changes something very quickly then this is the season where we don't escape thanks to a storming second 19 games.

I've said it before over the last few weeks, the lack of money is of course a severe handicap, but....the current squad is capable of better if given an opportunity to HAVE A GO.

We owe Moyes so much. But the pressure and disappointment has finally got to the guy. He seems to start games now expecting a hard luck story. He depresses the hell out of me right now, he really does. His selection approach is negative in the extreme. Mind you he can't win can he, there are it seems people blaming him for not having Velios on the bench when the guy pulled out during the warm up!

Whats really scary is some of the team are clearly struggling to find any form at all and look bemused by positional changes....Coleman cannot be a left winger and shoving him there just to accommodate Drenthe "cutting in from the right" is bloody daft. Rodwell got a good goal today and missed another but he's more crab-like thn Ray Wilkins ever was. Does the lad ever hear those magical words "your the attacking midfielder today" ?

We didn't deserve to lose to Newcastle but the fact that we did will not surprise most Evertonians. We look beat before we kick off and seem unwilling, not necessarily unable, to go up a gear, that second half showing was dire, lacking in vision and honest to goodness drive and determination. Moyes is the boss and yes he's held back by shameful lack of money to fund even basic team building. But he's not getting the best from what we have and clearly won't risk us getting blathered, even if in two from three games an attacking approach could see more points picked up.

Criticising a hero is never easy. Moyes is that hero in my view, what he's done for us is amazing. But he seems a beaten man and his team selection and tactics are surely dragging us down right now?

Where the hell this all ends I don't know. We could pull off another great surge up the table, could surprise a dubious public. But unless we get more from a suddenly under achieving squad I am very scared that the spiral downwards will continue. Cue a six nil win next week !

Ernie Baywood
120 Posted 06/11/2011 at 03:39:48
Read the first few contributions and if the next 100 or so saw the Heitinga incident the same way then there are a lot of people who should step away from discussing football.

Communication is only one issue. The problem is that Heitinga is an absolute disgrace. One lazy fkin cunt and that's inexcusable.

That's the second time in two weeks he's been challenged by a forward to follow him and twice he's gone for the lazy option and tried to cut the ball instead of doing his job and going with the man. And it's cost us two goals and a minimum of 2 points.

Don't get me started on Osman. Honestly, what could be worse than them two?
Mick Davies
121 Posted 06/11/2011 at 04:45:50
"Don't get me started on Osman. Honestly, what could be worse than them two"? erm . . Hibbert?
Ernie Baywood
122 Posted 06/11/2011 at 05:51:04
For spells yesterday he was our brightest attacker. Put a few great balls in.

Kind of the anti-Heitinga is Hibbert. Limited ability but gives his all.
Simon Harris
123 Posted 06/11/2011 at 07:07:53
Ahhh - Not Martin O'Neill again. FFS he left villa because they wouldn't match his ambition with the necessary funds.

Maybe after being out in the wilderness for so long, his ambitions at a crack at the big boys (ala Redknapp with Spurs) have diminished and he'll now settle for an over achieving top ten club. But how long do you think he'd have lasted with a nil spend for two years and no imminent hope of any investment.

The simple truth is, Kenwright has to go to facilitate real change at Everton, all the rest of it is just papering of the cracks.
Terry McLavey
124 Posted 06/11/2011 at 08:25:58
jon #109 Yeah your probably right ! can't blame him for not wanting to be a Championship manager and maybe having to appear in one of BK west end shows to make his money up !! (hasn't he already managed Celtic ?)
Gavin Ramejkis
125 Posted 06/11/2011 at 09:53:47
David Aden, I hope you aren't waiting for me to respond about academy players as it wasn't me that posted about them.

Change needs to happen at Everton from the top down, if a new chairman was to review the current manager's performance I'd be inclined to say he or she would also consider getting shut of him too.. No one person at this club is indispensible or should be.
Thomas Windsor
126 Posted 06/11/2011 at 11:00:25
I thought Everton should have gotten something from this game, but we just can't score enough goals .
Tom Dodds
127 Posted 06/11/2011 at 12:03:10
An ardent Moyes supporter posted a thread last season (regarding his tactics/subs) that ended thus:

"At the end of the day, although I have been very mutch a supporter of David, I feel now, that there needs to be a seed planted in his mind, that something has to give."

We are well there now and nothing basically has changed. I mean, Is it so bloody much to ask when we haven't got a pot to piss in that he can't use a player costing £9M in his designated position???

As for Osman... nah I've said enough, this is all becoming soooo tiring. I got 5/6 games last season I could say I was entertained. For nearly 600 Quid ... Start working out this season's cost per game .

DO SOMETHING, MOYES!!! Oh, and fuck that other ditherin side kick ROUND off for a start.
Tony Kelly
128 Posted 06/11/2011 at 12:34:45
What with Alex ferguson celebrating 25 years in managment a United....i wonder if he would have been there for so long if he had not won anything in his first"10"years..........
Chris Hughes
129 Posted 06/11/2011 at 17:10:15
Terry, post 108.
Regarding Moyes saying on MotD that he didn't expect to get anything up there..

He was TALKING ABOUT THE OFFICIALS!!!

But hey, don't get the truth get in the way of an anti-Moyes rant.
Jimmy Sørheim
130 Posted 06/11/2011 at 19:48:44
I am bitter, very bitter,against Moyes for selling Arteta and Yakubu. You know, we might have someone proper to fill in for Neville/Heitinga today, plus score a goal. I am so bitter and angry at Moyes you woud not belive it. Would you shoot yourself in the foot? I would not have liked to do that. And I always put Everton Football club first, that is more than Moyes is doing, much more. He has sold and given away the pices that were Everton. We are left with shit, the average. It breaks my heart, it really does!!! It is getting more and more painful trying to support the team with their garbaga.
Brendan McLaughlin
131 Posted 06/11/2011 at 20:10:10
Jimmy #120
"shit..the average"..way to go to back the lads!
Chris Matheson
132 Posted 06/11/2011 at 20:25:29
Jimmy you are a regular contributor here and I am surprised at your comments. Surely you can see it was Kenwright who was responsible to the sale of Arteta?

I am a Moyes supporter and even I am losing patience with him. But the bottom line must be the financial constraints he is working and all of that is down to vain, incompetent Kenwright and his 24/7 search for investment.

Kenwright' financial strategy has been to mortgage our assets to keep the wolves from the door and the only assets left are players.

We all know Moyes's weaknesses so I won't spell them out but they're 100 times worse cos of the state of the club under this board.
Ian Bennett
133 Posted 06/11/2011 at 20:24:49
Really disappointed that we didn't get anything against Newcastle. Yes, they are in the top 3, but the midfield were all injured and were dead on their feet after playing Stoke.

We can't pass the ball (never mind quick), and have no cutting edge whatsoever. We need a creative (Arteta type) player to move the ball around the pitch, a decent forward to hold up the play, a right winger with pace, and I am sorry a new right back.

Playing Neville or Heitinga in midfield must stop now. A team with Hibbert and Coleman cannot take another defender playing in midfield.

We simply have to sign 3-4 players in the January transfer window. It cannot carry on where we are picking 11 players from the same 14 every week. Moyes clearly doesn't fancy Denis, Bily etc and just needs to get rid, bringing players in that will make a difference.



If it means selling Barkley and Fellaini to bring in £30M plus, so be it. We need at least 4 decent players who make a difference.

Come the summer, I would expect a massive clear out, as a number of players are clearly finished.
David Aden
134 Posted 06/11/2011 at 20:23:23
@Gavin 117. Sorry then mate, must of misread the name. I guess my inability to read the "developing game (arguement)" is my downfall like a certain redhead we all know. I will let you of the hook for having no involvement in my argument.

As far as I am aware we need a change big time! But Moyes is still a hero for us and always will be. Sadly it is hard to slate you heroes like @Mark Wilson 111 stated. I don't want us to forget what he done so maybe it is time he left before he breaks the cracks he already fixed for us. And truly it makes me unhappy to think of an Everton team not managed by Moyes, as before that all I can remember is sheer depression.

Jimmy Sørheim
135 Posted 06/11/2011 at 21:29:41
Chris, the problem is that I am finding it hard to stand by and watch Everton lose its best players. They are both to blame, maybe Kenwright more so. After the willing sale of Arteta, plus Moyes and his pre-City comments made me disgusted. I have never hear of a manager giving up like that. He talks like we are a Leauge one club, well we are not.

I hate to lose, but I hate more to give up and call it a day before the match is even started. I am not alone, people want to be optomistic about this club, and when Moyes deliver some crap like that it just rubs me the wrong way. You can understand that.
Tom Las
136 Posted 06/11/2011 at 23:48:23
I have read every one of the 125 posts before me.

I agree with the consensus that Kenwright has to go. There is no question in my mind that this is where the cancer in our club lies. A change at this level will trigger successive change further down the order.

This might seem like a silly question for those of you that know the answer, but for my benefit, HOW THE HELL DO WE GET RID OF HIM?
Roman Sidey
140 Posted 08/11/2011 at 00:09:00
Tom, I think that question is why so many of us want rid of Moyes so vehemently. Without trying to speak for other people, I think we all know that BK is causing the problems that are making Moyes seem incompetent, but we also know that getting rid of BK is near impossible. A change of manager would do one of two things: offer a new approach to the same game with the same players, or show the rest of the competitors and press (the same people that apparently praise Moyes week in, week out) how poorly this club is being run.

Still, I think Moyes has to go, more so because the longer he stays in these circumstances, the less respect he's going to have from an entire sporting community.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads