Moyes Settles for a Point

, 1 May, 83comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes was content with a point at Stoke as his Everton side maintained their strong finish to the season. Everton have gone seven games unbeaten since losing to Arsenal in March and looked set to claim all three points at the Britannia Stadium before Cameron Jerome earned a 1-1 draw for the hosts.

And while Moyes bemoaned his side's inability to add to Peter Crouch's first-half own goal, he accepts it is not a bad result for his team.

"Getting the first goal helped us," he said. "That's always important.

"We gave away a lot of free-kicks at the start of the second half and that gave them a bit of momentum.

"We couldn't quite get that second goal.

"But Stoke were much better in the second half and it's not a bad point away at Stoke."

Everton's fortunes may have taken a turn for the worse in the second half of this particular game but it's a different story in terms of the season as a whole.

After losing six of their first 10 Premier League games of the season, Everton are currently on a run of just two defeats from their last 16 matches.

The improved form has lifted the Toffees above neighbours Liverpool, who lost at home to Fulham on Tuesday night, into seventh spot.

Moyes said: "We've tried to finish the best we could in the second half of the season.

"I'd like to do it in the first half as well."

Asked if he was sick of being asked if he knew the reason for Everton's regular habit of starting seasons slowly and ending them strongly, Moyes smiled, saying: "Yes, I am sick of answering that question."

Quotes or other material sourced from Sporting Life



Reader Comments (83)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Roman Sidey
1 Posted 02/05/2012 at 05:30:09
He hasn't ever answered the question.
Shaun Sparke
2 Posted 02/05/2012 at 05:48:21
It doesn't take a genius to work out that the brief Moyes is given at the start of each season is to keep Everton in the premiership at all costs. As a consequence of this, his mindset (whether he realises this or not) is to gather these points in any way that he can and if that means playing dour defensive semi-efficient football then so be it.

It didnt help his case this season by not having the same quality in the squad in August that he had after the January transfer window, but nevertheless his mindset still needs to change. Its no use him scratching his head saying he has tried everything to get us off to a good start. I think he needs to have a good look at himself first if he is seeking the answer.

I have always thought that underneath his dour exterior there is the potential for him to become the kind of manager that can win things with this club. I don't subscribe to the theory that he is a loser or a ditherer as some have cruelly labelled him. But he has had ten years to prove himself albeit with limited resources. I would love to see what he could do with a big fat cheque book and a brief to go out and win something.

He will undoubtedly get a pat on the back from Mr Kenwright at the end of the season saying "well done son job done". I would rather Kenwright said to him "Why only 7th Dave and how on earth did you let that pile of shite from across the park beat you 3 times this season? You can and must do better next season"

Phil Martin
3 Posted 02/05/2012 at 06:52:05
It doesn't take a genius to realise, no summer rebuilding equals stagnation and a slow start. Why are some people still suprised that when we actually have a few quid to bring in players our form improves?

Even Fergie has said in the past, even the best side in the league needs new faces - to keep things fresh and other players focused.

How many more transfer windows will it take for some of us to grasp this?
Shaun Sparke
4 Posted 02/05/2012 at 07:31:08
The problem with that Martin is that only 2 seasons ago it was heavily acknowledged on this website and others that we had assembled the best squad in years and some were even predicting a top 4 place. Sadly, it went tits up due to another dire start to the season.
Phil Martin
5 Posted 02/05/2012 at 07:34:43
2009 we were at our pomp. Playing good football, 5th place finish and a cup final (which we could've won, had Yak, Arteta, and Jags played).

That Summer we lost Lescott and still had Yak, Arteta and Jags missing. In effect we lost 4 key players. Since then our transfer policy (which will continue) has been to sell and then get a last minute loan deal in- weeks after the season started.

How can such a policy fit with the ambition to start a season well?
Phil Martin
6 Posted 02/05/2012 at 07:34:43
2009 we were at our pomp. Playing good football, 5th place finish and a cup final (which we could've won, had Yak, Arteta, and Jags played).

That Summer we lost Lescott and still had Yak, Arteta and Jags missing. In effect we lost 4 key players. Since then our transfer policy (which will continue) has been to sell and then get a last minute loan deal in- weeks after the season started.

How can such a policy fit with the ambition to start a season well?
Shaun Sparke
7 Posted 02/05/2012 at 07:45:23
I take your point Martin, but I think the truth lies somewhere between lack of investment and a cautious approach to games during the early part of the season. I honestly think that Moyes can and should change his philosophy somewhat. He constantly starts each season by announcing that it is going to be a difficult season and that a top half finish is something to aim for. Whilst I can applaud a dose of realism in certain circumstances, surely this attitude must filter down to the players. Let him set high but realistic targets next year. We might not have a pot to piss in but we all know that anyway. I see little to be gained by using this as a ready made excuse for potential under achievement.
Shaun Sparke
8 Posted 02/05/2012 at 08:01:20
Sorry, i should have said Phil and not Martin. Sounds like I was coming across as teacher like. Heaven forbid!
Kevin Tully
9 Posted 02/05/2012 at 08:33:46
When you earn £3m a year, you cannot absolve yourself of blame for these poor starts every season Mr. Moyes.

You still have 70k a week players starting for you - regardless of transfer pots.

Even though your record proves you can turn it around, there may be one season you will not, so what is the problem ?

My guess is no pressure on his position from the board, and familiarity with the players. A lot of players know they won't be shipped no matter how they perform.

A recipe for poor starts and mediocrity.
Kevin Tully
10 Posted 02/05/2012 at 08:56:29
?We will just try to keep winning, and I?ll be pleased with top 10,? he said. ?I think the point just gets us top 10. Certainly our form from January might be better than the top 10, but I would have taken that all day long at the start of season.

No wonder the R.S. have twatted us three times this season. Talk about an inferiority complex !

Kevin Sparke
11 Posted 02/05/2012 at 08:55:58
I'll not be surprised if Fellaini isn't the sacrificial lamb that Bill sells to pay the mortgage this season - Manchester United, Chelsea and Liverpool are short of decent midfield players and it's only a matter of time before they start knocking on Bill's door with their chequebooks out.
Edward Robinson
12 Posted 02/05/2012 at 09:07:17
Kevin, You hit the nail on the head.

That is PRECISELY why we don't win anything!

We are forced into selling our best players by lack of funds!

Moyes builds a great team and whilst others are building our team gets decimated.
Thomas Windsor
13 Posted 02/05/2012 at 09:23:58
If Moyes stays, which looks likely, as it doesn't look like any top jobs will be up for offer, give him money to spent now, in May, June and July and get the players he wants to get in. If he has to get rid of a few, ie, Cahill, Neville, Rodwell & Anichibe, then so be it; this must be his last season at Everton.
Thomas Lennon
14 Posted 02/05/2012 at 09:19:17
Are we forgetting that the last squad was decimated through severe, long term INJURY. The entire spine of the team was ripped out in a matter of months & they were not the same players for a very long time if ever. Add to that long term problems with Cahill's fitness.

This luck was the worst possible for us - can't sell, can't play. We are only just starting to recover.

Then take a look at the wages Liverpool can pay for a much larger squad - perhaps that is why we feel inferior? And yet it looks like we will finish ABOVE them in the hardest competition of them all as for all those wages and squad size they seem to have switched off.

Only a couple of years ago imagine saying to them they would finish 8th (at best) below Everton but would win the cup they christened 'Mickey Mouse' and they would have laughed until they cried.

Yes we need to push on with more funds but the only competition we are capable of earning decent cash in is the PL - the majority of new money will have to come from off the field but we have a major problem with that - and many people seem to want to stay there and worry about how they would get to a new, affordable stadium!

Until a board member can be convinced that it is worth their while investing a couple of hundred million this IS the best we can do.
Barry Rathbone
15 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:04:43
Edward (078)

Doesn't explain the semi final though does it?
James Martin
16 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:07:30
I don't blame Moyes for saying this. He knows, like we do, that this team can't play under any sort of pressure whatsoever. Why ramp it up on them in the last few games of the season with meaningless words like 'we'll make sure we finish above Liverpool'. Yes maybe the fans want to hear it but what if the players then choke and don't finish above Liverpool. Rather Moyes could say that top ten was our target, anything above that is a bonus so lets just keep winning and see where we end up. The result of this - great form in the league, free flowing football, a high chance we'll finish above Liverpool who have instead cracked under the pressure of trying to get back above us.
Peter Barry
17 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:12:05
@ Barry Rathbone # 086 - Nor the pathetic surrenders to the RS scum home and away either .
John Ford
18 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:06:41
Agreed Thomas, and the relatively recent rise of Man City and Spurs into the big money spending league has made a top five finish even more difficult.

Anyone could see how limited we were in terms of players at the start of the season. Moyes then did very well with three key signings and turned what could have been a possible relegation struggle into a decent league position. His approach is proven, he gets the best out of limited player resources season after season, though it isnt always pretty. He let us all down badly in the SF but we need to move on.

I dread this summer. If I could wake up 'Wizard of Oz' style in August and we still have Fellaini Jellovich Johnny, Baines and Piennar I'd be well happy.

Investment is by far the single biggest factor in determining success. Individual games can be dissected, but over a season the winners are always the same - the teams with the most resources. Ther'es just no getting away from this, regardless of what Moyes does or doesnt do in games.
Peter Barry
19 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:27:59
So John Ford # 091 your contention has to be that the three four goal games we just had prior to this relapse to 'situation normal' ,including taking Sunderland out of the Cup and the Draw at OT, were all just down to LUCK then. Nothing to do with motivated players being allowed to play to their strengths then.
Stephen Kenny
20 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:23:09
The chequebook rarely comes with time in this league.

If he get's the money he won't be getting the time to bed in new players and he usually favours a slowly,slowly appraoch with new players if it's possible.

I think if he were ever in a position to spend a fair bit he would again need to change his approach.

I don't know whether his mindset is brone out of a difficult set of circumstances or inherent caution. My guess is one feeds the other and it may take something big to break him out of that state of mind. I was hoping it could be scoring 4 at OT. It doesn't look like it was after last night but not many go to Stoke and play well or win.
Kevin Jones
21 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:01:57
Well Thomas, to tell you the God's honest truth, after being starved of Trophy's since 95, I'd take the Mickey Mouse Cup and a place in the FA Cup final, if it meant finishing 8th.

Nothing better than watching your team parade a nice shiney cup around Wembley
James Cadwaladr
22 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:47:09
I've always tried to defend Stoke when discussing them with pals but last night, seeing them in the flesh made me realise that they can not and do not play football.

Each to their own etc, but in 90 minutes they didnt string more than 3 passes together and completely by passed the midfield. They really do play for throw ins.

At times we passed the ball around very nicely, crisp, concise and some good movement but when you are playing against a side with no midfield with lots of bodies in defence passing around in midfield gets you no where. Without the ball Stokes formation was 1-7-3.

We could have won the game but our midfield never got a stranglehold on the game because of the way Stoke played and credit to them for that. For me it would have been a perfect game to set up 442 with Straq starting up top. Mix it up a bit, play some football but play Stoke at their own game, pin them in their area. We couldnt do that with the formation and players we had.

So whilst we could have won, Im not disappointed with a draw considering the shites result. Fulham wont catch us, so at the end of the day a draw and the shite losing is better than us both winning last night.

Take it. We are nearly there, and 7th could be enought for Europe.
Kevin Gillen
23 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:58:15
Well said John Ford and to some of you above stop moaning! I don't buy this "We play s***e football". We at least try and pass it and keep possession, 90% of the teams below us can't keep the ball or pass it (Swansea excepted). Yes we didn't turn up in the Semi Final but if Distin hadn't given the horror backpass of all time and we had sneaked a 1-0 you'd all be in clover. Moyes is doing an excellent job in the circumstances.
Jim Knightley
24 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:06:26
Re. our poor starts....whilst exaggerated, everyone has poor periods. Arsenal had it at the start of this season, and the last of the one before. Spurs and Liverpool have had it in the second half of the season etc etc. I don't see why there is a mindset, that if we could just get the start of the season right, then we would get into the champions league. Form is form, and effects everyone in this league, apart from the awe inspiring Arsenal team. I am of the opinion that changes in the summer could help morale, as they did in January, and give us a better start. I also believe it is now, after a few seasons, ingrained in our mindset, which clearly has a massive part to play in football. But if we did start the season guns blazing, we would tail off at some point; it's the nature of form.
Sam Morrison
25 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:13:01
I'm by and large pro-Moyes, even if I feel a bit jaded by him at times (or worse - I have suggested his time is up before). For me it's about seeing both the positive and negative - for all his flaws he still does an impressive job - results-wise- considering the context he works in.

But I really do wish he would talk the talk like he did 7 or 8 years ago. If Fellaini wants champions league football he's not likely to stay whilst the manager harps on about top ten finishes. Maybe he addresses the squad differently, but the forlorn expression and Eeyore style take on results to the media is not a big sell on Everton in my eyes. As I said after the semi-final, he needs to handle expectation as well as he handles the fire-fighting. If he can start doing that we might just have a great manager rather than a good one.
James Cadwaladr
26 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:15:34
Jim I dont believe it is ingrained in the players and managements mindset. It can not however be disputed that for the past 4 seasons the squad has not been ready for the start of the season. Just look at the team sheets!!

This is down to the boards incompetence and through leveraging of all our assets not being able to put a competitive squad together. This for me is a fundamental failing of the boards failings to both the shareholders and fans.

It is a known fact even when we had transfer funds, however we got them, he would not sanction transfers early due to additional wages. Back then it was for cashflow purposes now, Elstoone - Wynesses deputy remember, physically can not sanction or even put his hands on the money required.

Having a good start does not mean we would tail off.
James Cadwaladr
27 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:20:53
*he * = Wyness
John Ford
28 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:35:19
What relapse is this Peter? We did ok for large parts of the game yesterday., and we started with two forwards.

There was no real change on what went before - just the result wasnt what we wanted, mainly because the service in the last third was off.

You appear to have a view if a manager dictates how we play, it will then just happen on the pitch. No. Just because you set out to be positive doent mean it will be so. If we get beaten or play badly, its not automatically the manager being negative, it may be because the oppo were better on the day.

Consistency is an issue for all but the elite teams. They have the resources to replace out of form players with like for like quality. We dont.
Jim Knightley
29 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:32:33
James, I'm not disputing the effect of transfers; I am one of the most regular critics of our transfer policy/and advocates of our relative success as a consequence, on this discussion board. By ingrained in mindset, I meant implicitly. Why do Fulham never get a result at our place? why do Spurs buckle in the big game? why do we lose against Liverpool so often? why do teams fail to perform at Old Trafford? I do not believe that Moyes think his team will lose at the start of the season..but as soon as that goal went in for QPR on the first day, do you not think it was at the back of the players minds? a here we go again situation? I do not consider it the whole of the problem of course, but I think it may be a minor contributing factor. The best way to reactify it, would be to bring in new blood, avoid any summer morale problems (i.e Lescott like, which clearly affected us) and therefore create a good feeling of optimism, instead of pessimism, before the start of the season.
Jim Knightley
30 Posted 02/05/2012 at 11:42:27
And I'm with John here Peter, talk of relapse is bullocks. Teams can't go to Stoke and play. It is near impossible; none of the top six have taken more than a point there. They play the long ball, bring teams down to their level, and score goals based on height. Given that they have money to spend now (10mil on an old Crouch and his wages..one of the worse transfers of recent times outside the top teams) would be nice to see them improve. I doubt they ever will until the eventually get relegated.
Phil Martin
31 Posted 02/05/2012 at 12:42:26
Jim & James,

Exactly right. I'd absolutely put my mortgage on the fact that IF we were able to keep all our current team together AND buy 2-3 quality additions. We would have a decent start to the season.

Likewise I'd put my mortgage on the fact that this won't happen. We'll sell one of our star trio (Fellaini, Baines, Jelly) and struggle to buy Pienaar - or anyone significant for that matter.
The result will be a slow start from a sluggish, tired, looking team.
Peter Barry
32 Posted 02/05/2012 at 10:31:53
"Moyes Settles for a Point" -How sad and we know how often he does just that - that is the problem with the man
Denis Richardson
33 Posted 02/05/2012 at 12:47:21
James, 102, can you explain the crap start last season? W had Yak, Beckford and Arteta for the first 3 or 4 games of the season. I believe our opening game was at home to QPR (lost) and second game was away to Blackburn (they batterred us, hit woodwork and missed 2 penalties before we got a jammy pen in injury time to steal 3 points - the look on Jags' face at the final whistle was one of 'how the f'ck did we win that?').

My point being, at the start of the year, the squad we had was a lot better than the football played. You cannot really ask for more than a season opener at home against a side that just got promoted. The summer build up and pre-season should have the players champing at the bit to get going - however it rarely seems to happen.

Not blaming the manager 100% but its very worrying when he has no clue why we start that way - after a few years now! If we start poorly again in 4 months time, will the lack of transfer excuse come out again when we lose at home to Southhampton?
Phil Bellis
34 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:03:54
Have I missed this somewhere but...why did we wear the change strip?
Peter Norris
35 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:00:48
Peter - all the top teams go to Stoke with "I'll take a point" mentality as they know what kind of game they're in for and a point is always seen as a "result". We go and play with 2 up front (as TW readers crave) and we take a well deserved point but we slag off DM. So are Wenger, Fergie et al all in the same boat.? Give me strength.
Sam Hoare
36 Posted 02/05/2012 at 12:56:50
Peter Barry- you are ridiculous.
Phil Bellis
37 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:18:09
Ha! makes sense
thanks to Paul Martin who explains it on the Battle of the Brittania thread
James Cadwaladr
38 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:18:36
Denis. See above.
Richard Dodd
39 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:43:12
David has said again today that he will be happy if we finish in top ten and is totally unbothered whether that is above or below our local rivals.(Goal.com)
There is little doubt that his and BB`s major priority is to keep Everton safely in the Prem and,given our finances,this is probably a realistic aspiration.
But given the quality of our present squad, is our manager setting the barrier too low?Is he giving the players an easy ride when he should be encouraging them to greater achievement?
Personally,I`m backing his judgement although I wish MY boss would take the same line with me!
John Ford
40 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:53:29
RD he may say these things but we know his actual performance in terms of league position is impressive. Ive never really taken what managers say with anything other than a whopping pinch of salt. They can only be judged by what happens on the pitch.

Though I believe he continues to do well, like every manager (except Clough and perhaps Mourinho) Moyes is hardly a great orator. It usually just the same old same old.

Bollocks to the media merry go round. Im only interested in BK ensuring Moyes has the resources to get us to the next level.
Paul David
41 Posted 02/05/2012 at 13:54:52
Richard

There no doubt we dont have the finances to compete for CL places but how can you suggest we should be thankfull to just be in the league.Every year there is about half a dozen teams who dont spend money,the main difference is we have a number of players on £50k a week or over,I doubt theres many teams in the bottom half who can compete with our wages.

Taking into account transfer money AND wages we are,give or take one or two places were we should be.
Paul Foster
42 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:01:42
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17925203

Man Utd hierarchy seem to think it's inevitable he'll be Old Trafford before long ...
Danny Broderick
43 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:01:03
I don't know if anyone else has already said this, but for me our poor starts have a lot to do with who we play in pre-season. While the teams above us play in tournaments against the likes of Ajax etc, we generally go to a holiday camp in either Australia or America, then finish off by playing against Moyesie's old mates at Preston and probably Bury, with a trip to Scotland thrown in at the end.
We need to play some proper opposition so that we are up to speed come the start of the season - not still going through the motions when the season starts.
By the way, I am happy with a point last night, especially with Liverpool drawing. Stoke away is always a tough game, and we have increased our lead over LFC by a point. With a better goal difference too, we are almost guaranteed to finish 7th now as long as we win one of our last 2 games...
Jeremy Benson
44 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:06:25
I very much doubt that Ferguson will be given free-reign to pick his successor. It's a business.

Peter Barry
45 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:09:11
Why is that Sam Hoare # 121 for just repeating what Davey Boy has said far too often. Still I suppose if you think I am being ridiculous then you must also think Davey is ridiculous too for saying such a thing. Or are you so much in the tank for him that you can't see straight.
Paul David
46 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:11:03
Jeremy

I'm sure the board will make the final say but Ferguson's word will carry a huge amount of influence.It might be a business but appointing a manager is a footballing decision.

Not that I think for a second a CL club will ever give Moyes the job.
Jamie Tulacz
47 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:18:55
Playing down expectations doesn't seem to have done Mancini and City much harm recently? It's called psychology..

For those constantly on here slating Moyes, could they explain why he's being linked with top jobs, eg United and Spurs? There must be a lot of very poor independent judges out there since Toffeewebbers clearly know best!
Phil Bellis
48 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:20:31
Danny

Have a read of this...

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2012/writers/jen_chang/04/29/performance.analytics/index.html

Perhaps early on in the season Moysey hasn't got enough "stats" to work with

Mind boggling or what?
Jeremy Benson
49 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:18:50
Paul, I agree to a point - but boards are generally very conservative and considered in their approach. With that in mind, even if ferguson said moyes was a stick-on, I'd imagine they would find it difficult to ignore 3 facts;

1. He is unproven when it comes to spending large amounts of cash

2. He is unproven when it comes to dealing with the highly strung personalities that the top prima donna's come with (and could he command the respect?).

3. He hasn't won anything, and has virtually no champions league experience

That being the case, I would still think they'd go for someone who has got the t-shirt and is less of a gamble. Someone like mourinho or guadiola.
Paul David
50 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:23:33
Jamie

Moyes might get linked with other jobs but he's never been offered one.The Chelsea job comes around every 8 months yet Moyes is still with us.
Paul David
51 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:26:21
Jeremy

I totally agree with you.I wasnt making a case for Moyes being good enough to manage at a higher level,I just think the board would listen to what Ferguson has to say.
Nick Entwistle
52 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:26:32
How do you know Paul that he hasn't? And if he hasn't what do you infer from that?

Everyone knows Moyes is solid at Everton, it would be like slating SAF for not being approached.
Kevin Tully
53 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:24:24
Jamie#138,

If Moyes ever gets the gig with City, United, Chelsea, Spurs or Arsenal - I will donate a sizeable sum to a charity of your choice. ( Except our board ! )
Jeremy Benson
54 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:31:48
Paul, for sure I think they'd listen, and quite seriously too. But its such a big job every man and his dog will have an opinion on it, and I think they'll have a mind on their debt and having to be successful to service it, which will weigh heavily on a decision.
Paul David
55 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:36:52
Nick

How do I know Moyes hasnt been offered top jobs?

By the fact we're still stuck with him.
John Ford
56 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:37:43
Selective quotes I believe:

"You would expect them to finish strongly with the crowd behind them. It was a good point but we looked like scoring the second goal and played some good stuff so we are unlucky not to go away with the points."

Moyes said this straight after the game. You might think someone is trying to put a spin on his words....surely not Toffeeweb!?

Simon Watts
57 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:53:14
What I am pleased with is, if the commentary was true is that David Moyes, after 5 years of bad starts, and actually after every new year becoming one of the most in form teams, is actually looking into the reasons this happens. I have been banging on for years about his pre season preparation. Making players collapse on their knees and become physically sick is one of the most damaging exercise routines you can ever do. Not only for injury, but allowing fatigue, to plague the beginning of the season. It is well known it reduces to 80 percent of physical ability and energy performance. I cant believe how much energy they seem to have after new year. First to every ball. Sharp. Beginning of year is slow to every ball, and frustration.
Jim Knightley
58 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:51:55
Re.

1. He is unproven when it comes to spending large amounts of cash

2. He is unproven when it comes to dealing with the highly strung personalities that the top prima donna's come with (and could he command the respect?).

3. He hasn't won anything, and has virtually no champions league experience

So was Mourinho when he took over at Porto...or Guardiola at Barca...(I could name more obviously...there are lots of around)

I don't think for a minute Moyes will ever get the City job, the Chelski job or the Arsenal job. I do think though, Spurs is a possibility; do people think Harry is so much better than Moyes? or Jol or Ramos before him? what is so innane about the concept? Harry did well at Pompey, because he spent so much money, and destroyed the future of the club. Likewise, he has spent a load of money on Spurs (we've wasted money, but never 15plus million Bentley) and I think the Ferguson thing could work in Moyes favour for the Man U job, although I think Mourinho will take over the helm if Ferguson retires in the next couple of seasons.
Paul David
59 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:01:17
Simon you could well be right but Moyes isnt known for his flexibility or admitting his mistakes.

So expect him to train them even harder believing its the players fault for not training hard enough.
Jim Harrison
60 Posted 02/05/2012 at 14:57:17
Read somewhere near the top of this thread something about Moyes being paid £3million a year, so went off to see what I could find out about prem managers salaries. Turns out very little,most sites have conflicting info, and many are outdated. But the general gist made moyes wages about equal 7th in the league, of the teams above us in the actual table only Pardew at Newcastle makes less (Although there is very little info as to what di mattaeo makes, AVB was on considerably more).

In the same wage bracket as moyes, Martin o'niell & mark Hughes. Dalgliesh gets a full million more a season.

In summary, while it is a handsome sum, and I would dearly like to earn one hundredth of it a year!) it would seem he is paid commensurate to his achievements.

Interestingly, Ferguson isnt the top paid manager.
Paul David
61 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:05:44
Jim

Moyes has a history of negative attitude,dont take chances,dis-like of flair players,protect what you have at all costs ect.

Thats why he will never get a top job,the managers you mentioned might not of had experience of money,dealing with players ect but I bet they never showed any of Moyes's tendencies as coaches before they were offered the job (granted Mourinho is negative compared to Guardiola).
Jim Harrison
62 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:24:02
Paul, I am not suggesting that Moyes should be offered any job, or that he is either attacking or defensive, just that in terms of what he earns, he is achieving in line with league position.

The dis like of flair players just seems to me to be a bit of a stretch. He brought in Pienaar, Arteta, Felenini, fernandes, jelavic, Van de meyde (even if his was a piss head and lazy bastard he had decent pedagree), donavon and lest it be forgotten Drenthe. Not all worked out. Good flair players are expensive.Guys with skill but no consistency can be found at all prem clubs, but the ones who do it week in week out are few and expensive (Nani isnt consistent and imagine what he would cost?).

I would like to see exciting, fluid attacking football every game, but without finance, the flair players wont be coming in. It will be solid,hard working players who offer good value for money.
Paul David
63 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:40:19
Jim Harrison

That post was for Jim Knightley.
Jim Harrison
64 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:54:20
Sorry, I will get down off my soap box! But I stand by the fair players comment!
Sam Hoare
65 Posted 02/05/2012 at 15:44:13
Peter Barry ? it's because you make getting a point at Stoke sound like a disaster. Bet you're great fun around Christmas.
Paul David
66 Posted 02/05/2012 at 16:05:15
Jim H

I wouldn't consider Fellaini a flair player or even possibly Jelavic,the number of flair players he has bought in 10 years is very low and he does his best to turn them into different players,curbing there attacking threat by demanding they defend.
Jim Harrison
67 Posted 02/05/2012 at 16:20:14
As piennar has been so defensive since his return? And jelavics touch and style are dour boring charataristics? Fellenni may not be flair, but is capable of being creative, the past few games show that.

I think you should read the bleacher report link in the media section as to what players (Donavon included) Think of Moyes, but perhaps they just being fooled by the media?

If the players I mentioned are not to be considered flair, which other players has Moyes crushed the style out of? Dont say drenthe, the lad has only himself to blame. even the best players have to track back and he could be a lazy shite. And for every blistering run there was a blind rush into nothing.
Paul David
68 Posted 02/05/2012 at 16:29:48
Jim H

Pienaar is one of the few attackers whos natural game is to defend without it affecting his desire to get forward,it would be great if every player was like him but there not.

I'm sure theres plenty of players that sing Moyes's praises but i'm willing to bet there the same players he picks week in week out.

Now you mentioned Drenthe (forget about his off the field antics) he created and scored plenty of chances but would always get dragged off or fail to start because he didnt get back and would lose possession.

I'm not saying that attackers should be completely absolved of defensive reponsibility but Moyes wont entertain this type of player even if they would gain the team more points than the drone Moyes would replace them with.
Jeremy Benson
69 Posted 02/05/2012 at 17:42:52
Jim Knightley,

of course there are some managers who are appointed to big clubs without having won anything/been proven at buying players/etc, and sometimes they do well. I'm sure there are other examples as you say - but not as many examples as I could give you of managers who are unproven who have failed for big clubs. A ratio of about 10:1 in my favour, I reckon, if I looked them up.

And of those clubs you mention all have something in common - they change managers as often as we change our y-fronts. They can afford to take a risk for a season as they have no qualms/the culture to sack them pronto too and take someone else on. And someone else again...

Man United don't have that history. They will want to make the right appointment.

Which may or may not be Moyes, I just think they will be cautious and want to tick as many boxes as they can.
Richard Dodd
70 Posted 02/05/2012 at 18:08:24
Failing to score four against Stoke has given the doom mongers who haunt this site an excuse to hammer Moyes as they always do.
A few of us on here-and sometimes I think it`s only me-actually love supporting Everton and don`t get our kicks from dwelling on the negative issues-particularly on a failure to win at the Britannia!.
Most level-headed observers feel that Davey does a good job all things cosidered and hope that he will continue to grace our Club for many years to come.
Others obviously think that Lambert,McDermott or Martinez would win the Champions League in a trice.
NB. More likely to be the FL Championship,methinks!
James Martin
71 Posted 02/05/2012 at 18:16:21
Paul that same logic can be used to condone the behaviour of defensive players. Hibbert gets slated all the time on here for being rubbish at going forward, likewise Jagielka for not haveing good attacking distribution. If Drenthe is allowed to swan about doing whatever he wants in an attacking sense why should Hibbert bother to get over the half way line? It's not his job, he needs to be indulged as a defensive player or so the logic goes. Players need to be able to do both, every football manager knows this. It's only the fans who want to see attacking football who overlook all the goals Drenthe inadvertently conceded for the few belters he scored. Expressing some sort of desire for defensive solidity seems to have a stigma attached to it on this site, as though an Everton tream with the league's fourth best defense is somehow a point against Moyes. Osman has been playing in Drenthe's position on the right of late, another Moyes drone? How many goals have we been scoring with him in the side recently? How many assists has Hibbert got from overlapping him? How many goals have been scored down that side against us? These are the things Moyes will be looking at. As last night shows, no matter how much people protest about wanting to see good football, all they care about is the result. We played some rubbish stuff interspersed with good stuff in what was (if their ever could be) a tedious 4-0 against an abject Fulham side. Last night we played some really good stuff yet because it ended as a draw everyone has forgotten and just retrospectively repainted it as dour negative revert to the norm Moyes football.
Paul David
72 Posted 02/05/2012 at 19:02:41
James

If you read what I said I did say attackers should have some defensive responsibilty but not the the extreme Moyes expects.

I could only use Drenthe because he is the only one of his type we have on our books.What I do know is he made more goals than he cost,after lasts nights mistake Cahill has only scored more than hes cost.

Osman has been playing all season yet as far as I can remember we've been free scoring for a few weeks only in a 10 month season.

As for everyone forgetting the really good stuff we played recently just because we didnt win,well I think your forgetting the shite we've had to watch for the majority of this season (and 3 derby defeats) just because we've played well in a few games.
Roman Sidey
73 Posted 03/05/2012 at 03:01:47
Paul David, 142, best point made so far. Nick, your response was ordinary at best.
Jim Harrison
74 Posted 03/05/2012 at 03:47:00
Paul, you are right, there are no excuses for the early season form. Even before one of our better players left, Arteta, the team was not creating or scoring goals and put in some bloody awful performances.

If you read the article, the main feature was the thoughts of one Landon Donavon, who state that Moyes had him playing at a higher level, more consistently than he had thought previously. If Everton stand any chance of signing Donavon it will be down to his opinion of Moyes.

As for Drenthe, the fact that you highlight the fact that he lost possession for me helps prove the point. He gave away possession all over the place and failed to get back to help out regaining the ball. Its as bad as Jags pumping the ball forwards everytime.

I still stand by my point, good flair players (like Pienaar) cost more. Guys who can turn it on for a bit and then play abject again are widely available . As a club we cannot afford to gamble on guys like that, so we sign solid performers. If you look at the better teams they have the perfect mixture, and have the money to keep temperamental but potentially match changing guys on the bench.

But thats still no excuse for having McFadden in the squad.
Paul David
75 Posted 03/05/2012 at 11:28:13
Jim 331

I have to disagree.

You say we can not gamble on potential match winners because they might also loose possession when taking risks but I think we can.Swap that type of player for Cahill and I think we would have more points on the board.

I dont see why players who work hard but offer absolutely nothing else are not seen as a liability while players who can create something out of nothing but give the ball away sometimes are.

Both types of players have their faults and I know you cant have more than a few flair players in the squad but given the choice between a forward who excites fans,is responsible for 10 goals and to blame for 4 and a hard working average skilled forward who wont cost any goals but will only contribute to a handfull,I know which I would go for.
Jim Harrison
76 Posted 03/05/2012 at 14:05:31
Paul, given that choice, normally I would agree. In Drenthe's case, I don't, as he was too much of a liability and loose cannon.
Paul David
77 Posted 03/05/2012 at 15:25:58
Jim

My argument isnt about Drenthe, it's about flair players. I had no choice than to use Drenthe as an example as he is the only flair player at the club that can be a loose cannon as well.
Tony J Williams
78 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:01:24
For all his hatred of flair players, he seems to try and get a lot of them in his team
Paul David
79 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:05:53
Tony

Really?
Tony J Williams
80 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:09:38
Really, what?
Paul David
81 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:13:18
Try and get a lot of them into his teams.
Jim Harrison
82 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:19:04
Paul, my point is, we dont have many flair players,because decent ones cost more than we can afford. Its not that he dislikes them! I understand that your point is not soley based around Drenthe, but who are these other players that have been forced into defensive roles?
Paul David
83 Posted 03/05/2012 at 17:27:03
Jim

I think its generally accepted that Moyes expects everyone to defend even when it doesn't make sense.

Why have Osman, Drenthe, Pienaar etc back defending corners when they're never going to win headers? If these players stood further up the pitch, it would mean the other team has no choice but to leave more players back to mark them, plus it means we have a chance of scoring on the counter attack ,something that could never happen with every player back in our box.

If Moyes was offered the choice between a hard-working player who will follow orders but has limited skill and a player who can create something out of nothing but sometimes gives the ball away, I think I know which one he would go for.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads