Season 2012-13
Opinion
Talking Points
Shhhhh...
It's all gone silent from our wonderful Chairman, Mr Bill Kenwright. Not a peep about a possible takeover, no mention of a new stadium... nothing, nada, zero.
The question is: Do we really care? The team is playing great stuff; we are high flying in the league; we had a good summer of transfer activity... so why no uproar from the fans about a takeover? Why no mention of investment?
The fact is we spent nothing in the summer yet again; our club is still broke; Bill is still searching 24/7 (*cough*) and nothing has changed. I believe most fans couldnt give a shite as long as we are winning!
Don't get me wrong: I don't want negativity around Everton while we're on a great run but surely this has to be addressed... How many times can Moyes pull of signing like Mirallas, Pienaar, Gibson etc? Every year, we sell to buy... we can't keep going like this; at some point, the roof will come down.
To put a positive spin on this, just imagine we had got a takeover with the new board investing a few bob every year – where would we be? Could we get back to being one of the best clubs in Europe again?
Answers on a postcard.
Sean McKenna, Posted 19/10/2012 at 04:17:11
Reader Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
045 Posted 19/10/2012 at 08:02:50
047 Posted 19/10/2012 at 08:16:07
The recent scare stories from Blackburn owners are just beyond this world. A nightmare in truth, better safe then sorry, but this cycle of selling 1 top player each summer has to end, we are down to bones so Baines and Fellaini are the next to go.
How can we stop them from going? Get into CL.
052 Posted 19/10/2012 at 08:40:54
053 Posted 19/10/2012 at 08:52:29
Who would you blame for that ? BK is culpable and the current success (as the OP seems to define it as playing some decent football) continues to paper over the cracks which will only widen whilst the 24/7 search for investment (not buyer) goes on.
061 Posted 19/10/2012 at 09:19:31
Of course,I hope and pray for better but our squad is still alarmingly weak when you factor in the certainty of injuries and loss of form.Reseves of the quality of Naismith,Gueye and Mucha leave us miles away from top four probability.
Yes,Moyes has sold well to buy and Fellaini may well provide the funds for January re-inforcements but only at the cost of weakening the spine.
062 Posted 19/10/2012 at 09:29:35
070 Posted 19/10/2012 at 09:02:43
Goodison Park in its present state has had its day: the Bullens Road stand is 83 years old and the Goodison Road stand is 42 years old which is the same age as the previous stand before it was pulled down in 1970.
My first game at the ground was 60 years ago and the Upper Gwladys St has remained virtually unaltered since then. Throw in the minimal corporate hospitality and obstructed views and it can be seen that the "Grand Old Lady" is in need of more than just a face lift.
075 Posted 19/10/2012 at 10:24:31
To have a manager in the last 12 months of his contract and seemingly no talks planned, reminds me of the Redknapp scenario with Spurs. Although here the manager holds all the aces not the chairman. He is by far the most important person at our club, and as it stands he becomes a free agent at the end of the season. Which means any club can negotiate with him without Everton getting a penny in compensation.
Also talking about someone not saying anything thankfully we have heard nothing from Blue Union, but I guess a couple of bad results and they will be back protesting funny how their argument goes quiet when were winning.
076 Posted 19/10/2012 at 10:52:24
Perhaps the Blue Union have realised the extent of how fickle our fanbase is?
Perhaps they know they will only get support if we're getting beat?
Perhaps they know that fans will only be unhappy about the stadium if we're losing?
077 Posted 19/10/2012 at 10:55:13
"funny how their argument goes quiet when were winning"
You think?
Makes perfect sense to me they've gone quiet.
From what I have seen over the last few years, the majority of Evertonians (re Everton FC) have shown they basically exist 'in the now'.
That if things are hunky-dory RIGHT THIS MINUTE, they're happy.
Few wins a few good performances, all is well with the world and what the fuck are the BU whining about?
Right?
As for he future - Pfffff!
QPR and hopefully three point, THAT'S the future.
If the BU have decided to protest about the future of the club, only when results aren't going well, I certainly wouldn't blame them.
It might logically sound mad of course, when discussing the FUTURE of the club, but makes perfect sense if the majority can't see any further than the next fixture.
081 Posted 19/10/2012 at 11:33:56
099 Posted 19/10/2012 at 13:03:06
BT have paid £800m for a small percentage of live matches!! They will be looking for a break-even position and to possibly start paying the debt down, thus keeping the banks happy.
Obviously their valuation will be much larger now the new TV rights have been secured.
Looks like we will have to clap Bill for a few more years yet...
100 Posted 19/10/2012 at 13:06:40
101 Posted 19/10/2012 at 13:15:13
1. Moyes for taking the piss at Leeds.
2. Fans for putting champions league (no trophy) above pretty much all cup competitions.
3. Chairmen for wanting the same as 2.
4. Players for being bottling shites.
For the record I would prefer the league cup than champions league. I have supported everton since 84 (8 years old), and are sick of not winning anything, mind I was sick of not getting to semis and finals a couple of years ago....
105 Posted 19/10/2012 at 14:08:50
Preferring the League Cup to the Champions League is such small minded thinking that it's actually shocking. One competition gives you about 1 million and a little trophy that nobody really cares about, which can be proven by the dismal attendances around the country. The other is worth tens of millions, now the biggest competition in the world, with every stadium sold out and being shown in just about every country, and the competition that all the best players want to play in.
Put it this way, it doesn't really matter what YOU would prefer. The best players on this team (Fellaini, Jelavic, Mirallas) would stay with Everton if we were playing in the Champions League. The League cup and no European football? They'll be out the door to a Champions League club before the new season even kicks off. The League Cup doesn't propel a team to anything. The Champions League puts Everton on the biggest stage and gives us the money and reputation we need to not only hold onto our best, but bring in more quality players.
Or look at it like this. Winning the League Cup doesn't bring us any closer to the Champions League. But getting in the Champions League would give us the squad depth and quality that would improve our chances at winning a trophy, League Cup or FA Cup. I know I'd much rather watch Everton facing off against the likes of Juventus on a Wednesday night at Goodison rather than Sc**thorpe.
106 Posted 19/10/2012 at 13:50:36
Back in the early 80s, it was the united support of the fans deciding not to attend matches which forced the hand of Carter and the board to alter their policy and start to spend a little more... Even after the 84 FA Cup win, we were in danger of losing our top players until Kendall demanded that they were given better wages. The one constant during this period was that EFC were not a selling club and therefore HK was able to build a team.
Evertonians are split mostly by a generational gap: firstly, the older fans remember the club being at the forefront of all things football and, even in the dark days of the 70s, expected and demanded that the club was competing at the higher end of the league.
The younger group, the Premierites, have witnessed a dire time for the club, something not seen since the 1950s: constant financial struggles; a never ending revolving door of first team players; and expectation lowered to the point where 6th place is a seen as success.
At least the younger fans since January have seen some football which resembles the standard of play which us old-uns took for granted in the pre-Premier League era.
But the two generations must agree that the future of Everton Football Club should be viewed in a much longer timespan than our current form or indeed the current campaign.
Protesting for protesting sake is not a solution but, if enough people believe that they are being misinformed – or worse, ignored, then direct action is a legitimate way of getting your views aired.
Our manager is in his last season (unless he signs / is offered a new deal); our stadium needs refurbishing; our top player is/was unsettled and, if he goes, a few more may follow...
On the pitch, things are OK, but any shift may lead to a worse campaign than we might have expected; therefore, yes, I would like to hear from our chairman and the board as to what is their plan of action for the next few years... even if the details may not please us.
I offer no solutions, indeed there are few people who can, but I would welcome the board doing more than treating us like addicts who will accept whatever they deal us and come back for more shit time and time again.
112 Posted 19/10/2012 at 14:52:25
113 Posted 19/10/2012 at 14:56:11
(you see where I'm going with this?)
114 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:07:13
115 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:07:35
116 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:09:26
118 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:14:40
In any case, surely BK's statment of, 'I want to sell the club to a buyer who has the clubs best interests at heart.' is fair enough.
119 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:09:24
If a person lies to me, then lies to me again..and again, eventually it will occur to me "This person is....a liar!" and I'll eventually just stop believing them
(II mean call me old-fashioned etc).
And given the lies, I'll (sort of) throw your question back to you — Why DO you believe... etc?
So far, the only 'reason' you've given is 'he said' — and let me remind you: he SAID the KD money was ring-fenced.
121 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:19:54
We are and always will be.
It has always been so.
Now enjoy it.
122 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:22:46
123 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:04:27
How many buyers do you think would be interested at that price? Or do you think if I asked a realistic price it would attract some interst?
124 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:16:44
BK "has bought more shares in the club" therefore he doesn't want to sell...
That's a complete non sequitor, haven't you ever heard of a shareholder buying in the hope of selling at a profit?
I don't know why Bill might have bought more shares (or even whether he has); all I know is that it doesn't make it any more or less likely that he'll sell.
125 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:29:40
Crap too.
Loads of people at the head of companies or country lie for the good of the company or country.
Churchill.
Kennedy
Mandela
Saville
Sorry... missed the point with the last one but the others fibbed all day and to some success.
Real openness in high finance or government rarely works or the likes of us will stump good plans. Such is it.
Pray for the Euro Millions — only then will your view carry weight and you can do something.
Otherwise you remain as a previous poster said — "An addict who will accept whatever they deal us"
Sad but reflects capitalism and football. COYB
126 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:36:01
127 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:38:23
I hang my head.
130 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:23:49
KD was a long time ago, I think even BK would acknowledge mistakes were made. Why can you not move on from that, it was a very long time ago.
Now to my previous question, can you name any buyers?
134 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:52:50
135 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:42:43
As for a man buying more shares to make a profit that is what he wants...£150 million for a club that is in a worse state than when he purchased it for £20 million.
So Ken, in conclusion, you're right, I'm wrong: he does want to sell but at a price that no-one is prepared to meet for a number of very good reasons.
136 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:52:06
137 Posted 19/10/2012 at 15:53:47
BK has himself said that he has spoken to several interested parties – coincidentally, this has generally been when the BU has been putting pressure on him. What happened to these buyers? Why did they not firm up their interest? Where did they go? Could it be the club made them sign confidentiality clauses before the discussions (assuming they did exist and Bill wasn't lying to us), and that they were frightened off by the reported price of £150 million?
(By the way, it was Keith Wyness who revealed that a price of £150 million was not far from what is being asked for us. That would mean an extremely good profit for a board who have sold off all our assets, mortgaged us out to the max, sold off our training ground so that we now rent one, and to whom the banks will no longer lend as we own next to no assets. Oh, they have also tied up our revenue streams into long term deals.)
Oh, and Henry, the other clue is that pretty much every club in the land has been bought out – some more than once – since BK has been in charge. Why haven't we? It can only be that the price is too much – or we are not for sale.
Why has BK never revealed the asking price, if we are truly for sale?
142 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:09:30
147 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:25:38
Troll Alert. So we should take Bills seriously, but not the BU? I'll wear a hard hat for the next home game shall I?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7HQFLkxr2g
149 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:22:21
No point in me commenting further on your posts.
When we debate, we hope to convince people that what we are saying has some validity.
Well it occurs to me that for people reading this thread, the strongest arguments I can come up with, to back up my opinion, is nowhere near as persuasive on my behalf, as your arguments against.
So, you go for it (please!)
153 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:49:37
I have heard over the last few years from posters on here saying we should replace him with Coyle, Rodgers, Lambert, Martinez and countless others who are not in the same class as Moyes. So if we are going to protest about anything, it's why have the board not started negotiations about a new contract? Because, if he leaves when his contract runs out, not only will we get no compensation but to get anybody half-decent we will have to pay that manager's club compensation; seeing we have very little spare cash, will that determine the quality of the manager we bring in.
I am convinced that if Moyes leaves we will be playing Championship football inside 3 seasons. Let's not forget, had Smith stayed for the rest of his last season, we may already have been playing in the Championship or worse.
155 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:57:59
In my view BK wants an investor who will let him continue to do what he is doing.
156 Posted 19/10/2012 at 16:47:15
It's in the Annual Reports, Ken. In 2011, he owned some 200-odd shares more then he did in 2010. Now, in Kenwright's own words he is "desperate to sell" the club. But then he's gone and bought even more shares. Does that sound like the actions of a man who's interested in selling something, buying more of it? If I was desperate to sell something, I'd sell for whatever the market will bear and I certainly wouldn't be putting more money into it. Would you, Ken? Perhaps BK is so deluded he really thinks someone out there is going to pay his ridiculous valuation of the club and the larger the piece of it he owns, the more profit he stands to make?
161 Posted 19/10/2012 at 17:28:51
My real worry maybe short, medium, definitely long term is how long can we keep Goodison Park open. Seriously concerned that we'll lose our safety certificate in the not too distant future unless some fairly major expansion/refurbishment work is done. And I can't see that happening without investment from somewhere, the like of which our present board seem unwilling or unable to provide
169 Posted 19/10/2012 at 18:01:36
Success is about winning things. Its why Brazil 5 have stars on their shirts rather than a turnover note from the nike deal, etc, etc, etc.
In the vain hope we get top 4, do you think we would qualify again the following season with the squad our size? So when the squad disappears off for more CL, you'll think well that was a great experience looking at the sparse trophy cabinet.
173 Posted 19/10/2012 at 18:13:17
If we get tens of millions just for getting into the Champions League, the squad size would increase. But not with people just to make up the number, with quality. That would allow us to realistically believe we could win something. It's not to put another zero to the right backs pay cheque, it's to get a right back who has the quality to earn that amount.
If we finished in the top 4 this year, the likes of Fellaini and Mirallas wouldn't have/want to leave next year for Champions League football because they'd have it right her. So our squad would stay together and actually improve for next year, they wouldn't disappear.
One League Cup isn't going to send our trophy cabinet from being sparse to full, but the Champions League will send our account to sparse to full real quick, as well as greatly improving our team, which would give us the ability to start filling that trophy cabinet back up.
176 Posted 19/10/2012 at 18:19:33
Unlike some on here, I'm not convinced that simply qualifying for the CL one year is going to be the panacea to all our problems. If we did do it, it would be a fluke and as Ian suggests, with our squad size it would a huge task to stay in the competition and you'd have to spend big just to be uncertain of qualifying again the next season.
I'm sure the likes of Fellaini, Mirallas and Jelavic don't want to qualify for the CL just to be knocked out at the first hurdle. They'd be off just the same as if we didn't qualify.
183 Posted 19/10/2012 at 18:48:33
The CL dream needs to be repeated a number of years to make a real difference, rather than a temporary blip. I have thought the same as you for many years, but the cold reality is that we would be back to square one selling off those players we can't afford to keep on with no CL money.
Anyway, I want a trophy. I am a good evertonian and think its about time I enjoyed one with a beer in my hand. 95 was a long time ago, and 87 even longer.
188 Posted 19/10/2012 at 19:43:41
It's amazing, people are scared to have us qualify for the Champions League and say we'd lose before it even got started. I don't believe that at all. The Shite have been trying to get back for years and failed due to terrible management and terrible transfers. I have a bit more faith in Moyes's ability to find decent players than that.
Not all players of Champions League ability cost £10-15 million, it's just that you have a very hard time attracting those players if you're not capable of being in the Champions League.
You can't repeat getting into the Champions League if you don't qualify for the first one. I could absolutely see us getting out of a group, albeit you can get a terrible draw, and then you just never know.
I'd fancy Gibson, Fellaini, Mirallas, Pienaar, Baines, and Jelavic to get us out of the group stage, not counting any players we would add. I actually think that the way this crop of players is able to play football would allow us to thrive in Europe, unlike in the Premier League where lesser teams just kick the shit out of Fellaini, Pienaar, Jelavic, Baines and Mirallas.
189 Posted 19/10/2012 at 20:25:38
Going back to the theme of the thread, what is it thats holding us back?
It's not the manager. Not the players.........
190 Posted 19/10/2012 at 20:15:50
The same XI aint going to play every week. Look at the follow on results from the sky 4, with their squad strength, what makes you thin everton will defy that? Everton perform well with one game a week, its the way we play. Playing two a week would sap the players.
We are playing well, but let's not get too carried away. We have played no one decent away from home with a couple of injuries, and bang the picture might look different.
As I say I admire the aspiration to turn around the club, but I think it's flawed. I hope I'm wrong.
191 Posted 19/10/2012 at 20:47:41
And that's my point. Winning the League Cup will give us absolutely no new resources to strengthen our team, does nothing for us financially and would not influence a single player to choose us over someone else. Getting into the Champions League would give us the finances to strengthen our side, add depth so that the same players don't have to play every match. It would actually help us win the League Cup you want.
192 Posted 19/10/2012 at 20:58:57
The man can barely string a coherent sentence together.
194 Posted 19/10/2012 at 21:00:44
Who has had the more success over the last 8 years? Arsenal no trophies and qualified every season for CL. Liverpool a European cup, a carling cup and an fa cup. I'd take the latter, redshite or not.
197 Posted 19/10/2012 at 21:22:31
202 Posted 19/10/2012 at 22:26:52
Moutinho was the player the fans were yelling for and nothing was being done until the 11th hour. So long as survival is the main aim of our board, this will continue. Ambition has long gone and the club motto is a joke.
Our squad is tiny and now we have three key players injured as I feared would happen. Unfortunately the injuries are to players that we do not have top cover for. That is why Hitzlsperger has been given a contract... he is the stopgap or bandage until one or all of them return to fitness.
Statistically our squad is diminishing in size over the past few seasons. Effectively we started with 19 squad members which is now down to 16. Our bench must be the weakest around and has players that will not be used. The only players from the bench that will be used include Anichebe, Naismith and Magaye. Shuffling will enable them to come on if things are going pear-shaped.
I forsee DM playing for a point at QPR unless Gibons makes a surprise return.
212 Posted 19/10/2012 at 23:46:13
We peaked under Moyes around 2008 (when we played well in Europe) but we seem to be back to that benchmark again, indeed perhaps better, whilst the attacking style and desire to push forward is clear to see, even for the anti-Moyes brigade.
However, all this good news still masks the problems that lie beneath, ie, the lack of vision and future planning from the Chairman and Board. I am certain that he has Everton's best interests at heart but the fact that we are doing well and playing some great stuff shouldn't be used as a shield to protect himself from his main duties – making cash available to the manager by finding investment and funding a new stadium or refurbishment of Goodison Park.
I have a thirteen-month old son and I want to be able to take him to the match when he is older and not only be proud of the supreme history and traditions of our great club but also feel the wow factor when he goes into the ground for the first time. My first game was in 1980 and my dad held me up as we came through one of the entrances of the Top Balcony. I was only 7 but I thought 'wow' this place is 'big, high, blue and brilliant!'
We must move on upwards and forwards. My preference would be a magnificent redevelopment of Goodison – though a 55,000 seater 'New Goodison' (as part of the new Peel Waterfront development – wishful thinking, I know) shouldn't be sniffed at – but we need the new owners first... It won't happen with Bill; it must be a new owner with vision and business acumen. Perhaps we need a Liverpool city bid for a future Commonwealth games to get a stadium in place? Any thoughts?
216 Posted 20/10/2012 at 00:10:43
How about the theory that realistically whoever owns Everton at this moment in time would face the same challenges (unless they were a Shiekh / Russian hobbyist who takes the fun & challenge out of football anyway)?
Maybe the fact we are debating what is holding us back from Champions League qualification or winning a trophy in comparison to the annual relagation expectations when BK took over warrants a thought?
I have no affinity to anyone other than Everton Football Club, but just putting it out there......I standby for the anticipated lashing!!!
219 Posted 20/10/2012 at 00:22:10
I get the winning matters mentality at the business end of the premier league, but until we change the "win at all costs" mentality at youth level and concentrate on development of footballers vice the results focussed angry parent coach culture, we will always be in the situation we are in now (buy and sell for a quick fix). See the Dutch, German, Spanish and up-and-coming Belgium models (where we are obviously investing) for examples of how to do it. Develop footballers over time for sustained success, not the buy / sell / buy / sell / buy / sell stock market mentality that simply provides peaks and troughs that only satisfies Sky TV and its cronies.
Rant over - boys are playing the best stuff in years!!!
234 Posted 20/10/2012 at 02:18:53
So is the Club is for sale because BK said so and Elstone deliberately committed purjury?
235 Posted 20/10/2012 at 03:37:16
Let's not get carried away with the early form to the season; I know and, most of you know that we are playing to our maximum potential right now. So, once the euphoria abates, the inevitability of a few defeats, then the masses will be back out in force asking where is the chequebook.
So don't be kidded: let's not hide... this is not negativity, this is reality, mate. In a couple of months, the unrest will raise it's head again. Until Mr Kenwright is removed from his position and a new investor is brought in, we will carry on treading water. I have dreams like the rest of you and Mr Moyes I believe can fulfill all of our dreams given a decent purse.
246 Posted 20/10/2012 at 07:57:32
300 Posted 20/10/2012 at 16:15:25
I came across the above snippet on the newsnow website but when I clicked on the link it said the page was no longer available.
Considering the link was timed a day earlier I went to the Echo website - found the headline OK but again the page was no longer available.
Weird considering Echo archives articles going back years - does anyone have any idea what it refers to or have the RS costing Liverpool rate-payers £8m and hiding it?
303 Posted 20/10/2012 at 15:54:08
My Lord, we have a thread running right now discussing the corrupt ref 7 YEARS later!
I don't know who's more at fault, the board or the fans? My guess is the fans. The board members don't care. We do. They have the money to put into the club yet they don't. We have the power to boycott and force change yet we don't. The roof will fall one day and we'll be left holding the bag.
Our last hope is DM holding out for some financial support. Surely he's seeing what vacancies there will be around the Prem (Man Utd, ahem!) but, if he can get them to spend, well that would be just dandy.
#notholdingmybreath
304 Posted 20/10/2012 at 16:33:05
308 Posted 20/10/2012 at 16:34:47
The stadium will not fail to meet its safety requirements as they are based upon exits, fire fighting and the like — all of which are already catered for. Even a complete incompetent buffoon like Billy Bullshitter wouldn't kill his own cash cow by having it closed beneath his feet in that way.
314 Posted 20/10/2012 at 17:38:14
I noticed that too. Very suspicious.
374 Posted 21/10/2012 at 01:21:21
Also, just as an aside, if we can't look forward to CL football (or think it will be a millstone round our necks, what the hell else is there to get excited about? Why are we spending our time following this team?
If we had 3 more players to the current standard, we would be in much, much better shape than we are now. We're on the brink of greatness but also on the brink of collapse with such a thin squad. Step-by-step.
696 Posted 22/10/2012 at 14:38:22
785 Posted 22/10/2012 at 23:12:50
Yes CL would give us a temporary boost in income which adds a couple of players for one season, which we would have to jettison the following season if CL was not delivered again – which realistically we couldn't pull off 2 seasons running. We don't have the resources to play at that level when the opposition up the ante, although it could tempt a buyer admittedly (unlikely, but may).
CL could be be the making of our club and a great experience. However, I just think like Rooney we could not capitalise on it.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


041 Posted 19/10/2012 at 07:39:17
Some players will be happy to stay at everton, and some will want to use it as a stepping stone to the rich, trophy chasing clubs.
As long as Moyes can cash in for top dollar, not be a baby about it, and can bring in younger/hungry players on the up, then everton will stay near the top.
This is not what nil satis is about, however that's where we are. We are not going to get a buyer until bill cuts the price, as this is clearly the sticking point on a club with limited upside to an investor.