Everton vs Swansea City

, 15 February, 122comments  |  Jump to most recent
FA Cup 5th Round Preview

With the unexpected benefit of a full week's rest, thanks to the postponement on Wednesday of the Premier League clash with Crystal Palace due to dangerously high winds, Everton take on Swansea City this Sunday in the Fifth Round of the FA Cup.

When it comes to each round's draw, the least you can hope for is a home draw and the Blues were duly handed their second tie at Goodison Park of this year's competition and, though they have been paired with top-flight opposition, it was at least a team over which they have had the Indian sign for a very long time now.

Not that that should matter much in the heat of a do-or-die cup tie, but Everton, knowing that they are just two wins from a day at Wembley, will take all the omens and weight of history they can get. Swansea have never beaten the Blues and the only time the two clubs have met in the FA Cup was 60 years when Everton won 3-0.

This match-up against Roberto Martinez's former club would have been a meeting between the managers who steered their respective teams to the domestic cup triumphs last season had Michael Laudrup not recently been forced out of the Swansea hotseat. Instead, Martinez goes up against Gary Monk, someone he knows very well from his days in South Wales.

Monk is unbeaten in charge of the Swans so far, having overseen a handsome derby victory over Cardiff City in his first match, followed by the midweek draw at Stoke City, but this will be his biggest test so far. He could be boosted by the return to fitness of Michu though, after a long lay-off. The Spanish forward has been out of action since December so is lacking match fitness but he is in the frame to play.

For Martinez, he will no doubt have welcomed the extra few days' training for the likes of Lacina Traore and Gerard Deulofeu, two players whom he sees as being crucial to both the FA Cup run and the run-in to the League season. Traore was tipped to make his debut in some form against Palace in midweek, had that game gone ahead, and, with Romelu Lukaku still a week or so away from fitness, the Ivorian could get the nod to start if his manager deems him fit enough.

Deulofeu is in a similar position and in need of playing time but his hamstring injury was more severe than Traore's and he might need to be eased back into action more gradually. Furthermore, the experience of Ross Barkley, who Martinez admits he may have rushed back too quickly from a foot fracture, offers a cautionary tale for the manager to ponder as he draws up his starting XI.

With victory guaranteeing a quarter-final berth, there is a lot riding on this game and Martinez has acknowledged as much, making it more likely that he will field a strong side. Should Traore not make the starting line-up, it's conceivable that Martinez will go with a similar team to the one he would have played against Palace, although perhaps, given the stakes, with Kevin Mirallas in the side at the expense of Aiden McGeady.

Kick off: Sunday at 1:30pm

Full Coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (122)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Anthony Burke
1 Posted 15/02/2014 at 08:36:46
Lawrence has predicted an Everton win, which is a bad thing as he is usually wrong. Hopefully he is right on this occasion.
Darryl Ritchie
2 Posted 15/02/2014 at 08:36:29
Damn, it would be nice to win the cup. A bit of silverware just might shut the RS up. "What have you won lately?" Fuck, that's getting old.
Sharabi Singh
3 Posted 15/02/2014 at 08:39:22
A week's rest couldn't have worked out better. Injuries are improving and the players must be raring to go. There isn't the option for most of these players to move to a top 4 side so, if they want silverware or regular trips to Wembley and Champions League footy, then they've got to pull it out the bag. Now is the time...
Jermaine Jennings
4 Posted 15/02/2014 at 09:02:48
I'm confident of a win and the week's rest was ideal... but this has got 'potential banana skin' written all over it. A resurgent Swansea with Gary Monk and his history with RM and they are already more competitive and resilient than under ML... Oh boy.

We need to be quick out of the blocks and very aggressive in our tackles and play as Swansea won't be expecting that!!!

COYB

Dick Brady
5 Posted 15/02/2014 at 09:37:51
Its looking like a Top 4 finish is slipping away and most annoyingly even finishing above Liverpool again looks very unlikely. Those two things are very disappointing and I think a good FA Cup run is required to keep this season positive.

I'd love to see us make the final. Winning it would be a dream. COYB. You can do it.

Paul Campbell
6 Posted 15/02/2014 at 09:52:55
Martinez has got to go for this, no dropping players thinking about the league. I think 4th has gone; let's win the FA Cup and, as Darryl says, shut them fuckers up... well, as much as you can shut them up.
Sam Hoare
7 Posted 15/02/2014 at 10:21:44
Hope to see Traore get a good run around and ideally bang in a goal or two. I doubt Michu will start but Swansea are a good team capable of beating most others on their day. Hopefully we can dispatch them at Goodison as they would be a handful at the Liberty.
Kunal Desai
8 Posted 15/02/2014 at 10:19:27
We need to put the strongest side out, I think this match has the makings of a potential banana skin like Wigan last year. It's imperative we start of on the front foot. Mirallas, Deulofeu, Barkley all have to start. Put the game in a safe position around the 70 minute mark and then bring on Naismith, Osman, McGeady or Traore. What I don't want to see is the reverse and us chasing this game.
Dan Heaton
9 Posted 15/02/2014 at 11:34:20
As Lukaku can't play against Chelsea next week, I think Traore will deffo get some game time tomorrow. It will be good to see if he can blend into our system.
Max Wilson
10 Posted 15/02/2014 at 11:52:23
Even M Lawrenson (Shit Shirts) has us down for a narrow victory. Damned by faint praise hey? Swansea's record against us is poor but anything can happen in the FA Cup. We'll soon see how we are going to do when the team sheet is revealed.

At the mo my Toffee mates and me just look to see how many of our A-list will be on the field and who is still on the bench. We then feel either optimistic or shake our heads with frustration. They will be better than Stevenage, yeah?

Jon Cox
11 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:07:55
Max, I thought we played really well against Stevenage.

A very professional job by all, in what could have been a tricky tie.

Colin Glassar
12 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:11:11
Anyone else think that all these sports channels should just call themselves Liverpool FC TV? Just checked out football focus, SSN and BT and all three of them are/were talking about the RS. We win tomorrow and it will count for nothing if that shower beat Arsenal.
Mike Hughes
13 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:11:08
I generally agree with Kunal's approach – with the exception of Barkley as I'd prefer to sacrifice the short term for the longer-term benefit with respect to him. I don't think he's over that injury. Ossie could be a good impact sub in a game like this.

We should beat The Swans but let's not take anything for granted. This is a potential banana skin with potential newspaper headlines alluding to how Monk has got one over his old boss.

Don't let the season peter out – some silverware please.

Just to complete the newspaper headline theme, I really want to see The Arse Dump The Shite out of the Cup.

Max Murphy
14 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:18:37
Naturally I hope we win tomorrow, but it would be great if the top 4 all drew. They would then have a fixture pile-up, and hopefully get a few injuries on the way.

Sorry for being cynical, but we've had more than our fair share.

Adam Luszniak
15 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:21:04
I know what you mean, Mike, I would love to see them knocked out; however, what would you say to meeting them in the semis and knocking them out ourselves?
Mike Hughes
16 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:28:01
Adam,

Personally I'd rather they went out asap. After the Wembley debacle a couple of years ago, I don't think my nerves could take any more. It's not that I fear them per se, it's that we seem to choke or have some gypsy's curse against us when we play them. I loathe them so much (well their fans particularly) that defeat against them really puts me on a downer.

Max,

NO! The top 4 all drawing would be a disaster. I fear the RS would take advantage and could win the Prem if Man City or Chelsea screw up. Also, the RS have just destroyed the Arse and would likely do it again at Anfield. I want the RS knocked out this weekend and a win for either Man City or Chelsea.

Adam Luszniak
17 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:35:20
Yeah I hate it when we lose to them more than anything. Wouldn't mind a shot at revenge but, after the hammering they gave us, I wouldn't be full of confidence!
James Marshall
18 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:44:36
If the RS lose, they'll only have 12 premier league games left. All the other top teams have potentially over 20 games to play. I believe this could give them a real advantage in the league so weirdly I'd quote like them to win and have a fixture pileup of sorts.

That said, I'd also like them to get stuffed but the above does temper it. Basically I just don't want them to win the fucking league. Ever again.

Colin Glassar
19 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:56:08
James, they will never win the prem, despite the media hype.
Mike Hughes
20 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:52:21
OK, best case scenario is that Arsenal win tomorrow and the RS get several injuries and a couple of sendings-off.

Injuries: Sturridge (hamstring and calf), Gerrard (both legs and arms) and Suarez (neck, skull and teeth).

Sendings-off: their keeper and Henderson.

Max Murphy
21 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:53:22
I still harbour thoughts of us getting into the top 4 (don't laugh), so any fixture pile-ups for the top 4 can only benefit us. If Liverpool lose, then they can concentrate fully on the league, as James pointed out.

The ideal situation is Liverpool draw, and Arsenal win the replay at Anfield, with long-term injuries to Rat-Boy and Sturridge. Finally, Liverpool finishing outside the top 6.

Dan Heaton
22 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:58:05
Watching the Sky Sports pundits creaming their keks over Gerrard and Suarez again. The media bias is unrelenting.
Tim Greeley
23 Posted 15/02/2014 at 12:59:48
Match is on live in the States, Fox Sports One I believe the station is called. Channel 70 at the Jersey shore. Can't wait. I must start planning "Operation Ignore family for Three Hours on a Sunday morning" immediately.

We've been pretty comfortable against the Swans but this is a really important game for the rest of our season. I'd love to see Gerard Deulofeu from the off but doubt it will happen. The front four that Bobby was set to roll out midweek is not going to scare anyone... Except us Toffee fans!

Daniel Lawrence
24 Posted 15/02/2014 at 13:09:30
Whatever the team, let's hope it's not the one named on Wednesday night!
John Malone
25 Posted 15/02/2014 at 14:02:31
Bollox to them winning tomorrow, get them out and let them get hammered against Man City, Chelsea at home and drop points away in league. Us to demolish Swansea by 4, wind in our sails, and go on a winning streak that takes us to Wembley and striding into top four.

That's the dream anyway!

Jay Harris
26 Posted 15/02/2014 at 14:20:46
I just hope RM resists the urge to throw Robles in.

He doesn't inspire me with any confidence at all.

I see us going for goals in this one and hope for a 3 goal romp with a clean sheet for us.

Colin Williams
27 Posted 15/02/2014 at 14:53:43
What has Howard done recently to deserve his place? I prefer Robles all day long!! Howard is a liability every game, he will always give the opposition chances to exploit his poor decision-making.
Dan Heaton
28 Posted 15/02/2014 at 15:03:36
I think Robles will start. Bobby always picks him for cup games.

I don't think there will be many more surprises though. Although I would keep Barkley on bench. One week's extra rest will do him no harm. We have more than enough firepower to beat these without him.

I do want to see this Traore lad though. Surely he will play a part.

James Martin
29 Posted 15/02/2014 at 15:22:25
Robles over Howard. What was the last save Howard made?

Robles makes one clanger and doesn’t get in the team again. Howard gets beaten by a large amount of shots that he faces. Just take the Liverpool, Villa and Tottenham games for example. At fault for two of Liverpool goals, got beaten by Villa’s one shot, got beaten at the near post by Tottenham’s one shot.

Robles deserves a run.

Phil Smith
30 Posted 15/02/2014 at 15:13:26
Roberto's confidence is infectious, I see by reading some of these posts.

Unfortunately that defeat at Spurs has really brought about some serious questions, for me. I now think top 4 is out of reach. Playing for 5th is the reality, which would still be an amazing achievement if we can finish there. Defo think we can win the cup this year though.

Tom Bowers
31 Posted 15/02/2014 at 15:50:49
Provided they come out on fire, they should take care of The Swans but nothing can be taken for granted after the Wigan debacle last season. I agree that Osman should be best used off the bench these days but RM much like his predecessor still rates him too highly.

A perfect opportunity to start Traore to see what he is made of in light of Lukaku's unavailability next week and hopefully Delboy will get some time when we have the lead and not as a desperate measure late on.

I hear that the Gunners may rest a few key players ahead of the Champions League but they may just be conveniently dropped after recent poor results.

Mark Frere
32 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:02:16
Our whole season is riding on the FA Cup unless RS have a massive collapse in the league, so this game is as big as it gets.

Play to our potential and this should be a routine win. Hopefully, Traore will get the nod for this one.

Leon 'twinkle toes' Osman looks in fine form at the moment and should start in this one, then come off at half time.

My team to face Swansea:

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
McCarthy Barry
Mirallas Osman Pienaar
Traore

Mark Taylor
33 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:19:36
I think we have probably lost CL, so we now need to focus on the Cup and that means playing our best XI.

That means Barkley, Mirallas, Delboy and presumably Traore, if he is as good as advertised. Otherwise, he will have been a fairly pointless back up for Lukaku, given the latter is likely to be back next week.

I see they are saying Alcaraz isn't match fit but I've yet to have any decent explanation as to his injury.

Max Wilson
34 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:35:30
Dear Jon, yes we played well v Stevenage. Your on a hiding to nothing when you have to play a lowly club in the Cup. My point is tomorrow is "The Cup", arguably our most exciting competition against a much better team. I don't know what you think but I like Brother Mark's team choice except we have Deulofeu back raring to go.Ossie can still do amazing things sometimes. He's been a wonderful team man over the years.
Yair Kaye
35 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:35:50
I disagree with the notion that we are on the right track of returning to glory, and it will happen if RM is given enough time. I am 59, and still remember the glorious 60s. Back then, in 1970, four clubs ruled the Football League in turns and all held the same amount of league titles – Everton, Liverpool, Manchester United and Arsenal. Chelsea & Manchester City belonged to a lower level. Even in the mid-80s, we were still among the top four... What happened since?

We are the only club out of the quartet that dropped permanently from the elite. This did not happen by coincidence. Since the introduction of the Champions League, the Bosman ruling, and the big money, only money decides the placing of Premier League clubs. Tradition, management & training can improve the standing to an extent, but not to create miracles.

I watched on telly a fortnight ago the Man City – Chelsea clash, for instance. Not in a million years will our team be able to play to this level of tenacity, accuracy and talent. The gap between us and the current top four (including, I hate to admit, the hated RS), is quite big, and it's only a matter of time until Man Utd, with their resources, will be in front of us again (if not this season, then in the next).

OFM did a decent job with the limited resources he had at his disposal. As much as I am impressed with RM, he won't be able to create miracles either. Sorry – with the current ownership of our great club, there's a glass ceiling of 5th to 6th place at best, and eventually, since other clubs are seeking ways to bring bigger investments, it will be difficult to maintain even that.

Which brings me to my main point: The only way to take us back to our natural place among the elite clubs is a change in club ownership . As long as Bill Kenwright keeps his grip of club ownership and doesn't sell, or at least bring big investors to share ownership with him, we will keep dreaming about those days when we were a force to be reckoned with.

It speaks volumes of our ambitions that, after long barren years, we are only too happy to settle for a cup.

Ray Roche
36 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:45:27
Mark Taylor, Lukaku can't play against Chelsea so it'll be the West Ham game before he plays again in two weeks time.
Colin Glassar
37 Posted 15/02/2014 at 16:52:01
The spurs game was a massive blow. If we'd been crap and lost, I could understand the result... but we played them off the pitch and should've won.

I'm not giving up on 4th just yet, but it looks like 5-6th which ain't the end of the world. So I guess a good cup run and top 6th would be a great start to Roberto's reign seeing as many predicted a struggle to stay in the top 10.

Jay Harris
38 Posted 15/02/2014 at 17:11:01
Traore must get some game time so he gets "match" fit for Chelsea.

I think Pienaar is still feeling his hip injury so would give him a rest this week as I would Barkley.

I would go for 4-4-1-1 with Mirallas supporting Traore.

My 11:

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
Deulofeu McCarthy Barry McGeady
Mirallas
Traore

Colin Glassar
39 Posted 15/02/2014 at 18:12:24
My starting XI would be:

Robles
Coleman
Jagielka
Distin
Baines
McGeady
McCarthy
Barry
Pienaar
Mirallas
Traore

Subs: Howard, Hibbert, Stones, Barkley, Naismith, Deulofeu, McAleny or Vellios.

Jon Cox
40 Posted 15/02/2014 at 17:19:43
Dear Max, I take your point. Perhaps I was being a little literal.

Mark’s team is good but I prefer Mirallas in the centre, just behind the striker. That way, he can go from left to right, pulling defenders all over the place.

If we can’t put a team out without Ozzy then we really do have a problem. I really liked him in the past but I think the sell-by date has now been reached.

Jay’s line-up at #184 is more my sort of team, as it screams excitement.

Brian Waring
41 Posted 15/02/2014 at 18:44:18
Daniel (#164) "Whatever the team, let's hope it's not the one named on Wednesday night! "

Daniel, I've got this funny feeling we'll see tomorrows starting 11, the same starting 11 from Wednesday.

Si Cooper
42 Posted 15/02/2014 at 18:12:51
Hopefully Swansea will be more than a little distracted by their Europa League tie with Napoli next Thursday, otherwise this could be a real tussle. Southampton came unstuck against Sunderland even though they were stronger on paper and probably better for most of the game

We could do with the impetus a good win would give us so I expect as strong a team as we can muster (though I would prefer it if players aren't risked from the start if they are not fully fit), and just hope the weather is decent and the players are fully switched on. Agree that Traore needs game time if he is to have a significant role to play against Chelsea.

Gavin Ramejkis
43 Posted 15/02/2014 at 18:47:49
Watching the games already played today, Southampton and Cardiff didn't give the game the respect it deserves and paid the price. It's our only realistic chance of winning anything this season and gaining Europe so hope Bobby goes for it from the off, no faint hearts and goes all guns blazing; it's far harder to attack when you are too busy defending. We have to put our chances away though so hope we don't get blinkered players or half-arsed attempts. This should be a full blooded shot at winning, get the old lady loud and bouncing.
Andy Meighan
44 Posted 15/02/2014 at 20:35:07
Adam (#153),

Oh don't you ever learn, pal? What would you say to knocking them out ourselves in the semis? Come on, mate, it's just not going to happen... Our players are fucking petrified of them away from Goodison Park. We had a great chance the last time at Wembley. Their 3rd choice keeper was in that day and didn't have one save to make.

No, I'm afraid Wembley is a bit of a graveyard for us, the Man Utd semi-final apart — another one where we were shite but got lucky on pens.

We do not want to meet them again, believe me; their forwards frighten the life out of me and they always score against us. So we do not want them, end of... Arsenal will make big changes tomorrow with Munich in mind so I expect them to win. And I really believe we'll get them in the next round. God, I really am one morose bastard...

James Stewart
45 Posted 15/02/2014 at 21:26:43
Top 4 has long gone we need to just concentrate on playing some good football again.
Mark Tanton
46 Posted 15/02/2014 at 21:49:46
Oh God, I'd almost forgotten that Wembley 'performance' — the heavy legged way we walked back onto the pitch for the second half just seemed to scream "We'll never hold on, we'll never hold on, please just let us hold on".

Never was a comeback more inevitable. Pathetic. Shudders....

Colin Glassar
47 Posted 15/02/2014 at 22:09:13
We have a different manager from that day. We no longer go onto the pitch employing damage control as our Plans A, B and C.

I'd love to get the RS in the next round, if we get through, but I've got a sneaky feeling it's going to be Wigan.

Ste Traverse
48 Posted 15/02/2014 at 22:54:35
Chelsea are out so we now don't have to worry about Lukaku not being available should we have come up against them.

But the downside to that is we'll miss Gareth Barry should we clash with City somewhere along the line.

Ste Donoghue
49 Posted 15/02/2014 at 23:33:16
We will put a good performance in tomorrow and we will win. I don't think it will be easy but have a little bit of faith. After a few bad results, it doesn't mean that's it, does it?

Everton have been a good if not great side all season, so when it starts going a bit wrong, it's where we need to show our commitment as a team and as fans. This FA Cup is opening up nicely for us...

Andy Crooks
50 Posted 16/02/2014 at 01:14:05
I really hope Traore takes no part against Swansea. I have no idea how he is going to fit into the Martinez style, therefore, I doubt that Chelsea do. I'd like to beat Swansea without him and launch the secret weapon at Stamford Bridge.
Ian Tunstead
51 Posted 16/02/2014 at 01:26:01
Surely he can't do any worse than Naismith.
Si Cooper
52 Posted 16/02/2014 at 01:55:07
I can kind of see what you are getting at Andy, but what about the idea that a competitve run out might settle him or even boost his confidence before the test that will await us next weekend?

I don't think that RM really believes in secret weapons anyway (at least not in the singular). From what we have been told so far, Traore is not particularly suited for an aerial bombardment approach (though he must have some advantage over most opponents) and so he will not change the way we play anyway. What he may do once he has the ball at his feet is (hopefully) not going to be revealed in the course of one game.

If he can help us to thump Swansea tomorrow then I really hope he plays and the Chelsea game can take care of itself.

Kieran Kinsella
53 Posted 16/02/2014 at 02:01:37
Yair Kaye

Always nice to see some optimism. I get your point but I remember Denmark winning Euro 92, Greece winning Euro 2004, Wimbledon winning the FA cup, Cameroon with two men sent off beating reigning World Champions Argentina. Based on "quality", none of those teams had a hope in hell but they all won.

The great thing about football is that, every now and then, you'll be surprised like when bottom division Bradford got to the League Cup Final last year or when Norwich under Mike Walker of all people finished in the top three with a team of has-beens, kids and journeymen nobodies.

If any of us truly believe the "glass ceiling" argument then we may as well pack in this lark altogether and find some other way to keep ourselves amused.

Harold Matthews
54 Posted 16/02/2014 at 03:03:56
Pre-match Press Conference. Would you believe, he did it again. Tugged his ear when Traore’s name came up. 4 interviews, 4 tugs. Says he’ll take some part. Hmm, that could mean anything.
Doug Nestor
55 Posted 16/02/2014 at 03:32:35
Who gives a shit if Swansea are distracted? Just do it – not to much to ask for ... get on with it and get it done.

We are EVERTON... How can some people think so low??? if we do, they do.....

Matt Traynor
56 Posted 16/02/2014 at 05:00:07
Paul #135 "Martinez has got to go for this, no dropping players thinking about the league."

Before the game was called off the other night, the team sheet that was published suggested RM had one eye on the cup, so I doubt very much he’ll start rotating – with the possible exception of the GK.

Peter Barry
57 Posted 16/02/2014 at 05:33:06
It looks like a top 4 finish is now a lost opportunity so winning a cup would seem to be our only chance of glory this season. For that reason alone, we should give it all we’ve got.
Yair Kaye
58 Posted 16/02/2014 at 05:39:32
Kieran (#217)

In our glorious history, we were never Denmark, Greece, Wimbledon or Cameroon. In terms of World Football, we were Italy or Holland of English football.

Let’s assume we manage, after 20 barren years, to win the odd cup. So we will resemble Wigan or Wimbledon. Is it our ambition, the crown of our achievements? I am sick of looking every week at the results of our neighbours across the park hoping they lose or draw - it’s time they look in fear at out results.

The only way to return to past glory is to get a top 4 spot on a permanent basis and thus participate in the Champions League. This is the only way to attract top talent. And the road starts by parting ways with BK and getting massive investment.

Paul Rimmer
59 Posted 16/02/2014 at 06:15:11
We have an excellent opportunity in the Cup and, as one of the few teams who always take this competition seriously, it’s about time we won it. 16,000 at Sunderland as they knock out a dangerous Southampton and Cardiff going out to Wigan is good news.

Man City are fighting on 4 fronts which is going to affect their team selection for the Cup – reminds me a bit of 1985 when we were in the same boat. I think we’ll get another 4 against Swansea then hope for a home draw in the 6th round – hopefully Wigan as we owe them!

Michael Kenrick
60 Posted 16/02/2014 at 06:27:24
Yair Kaye, you seem to be suggesting that winning the FA Cup would be of little or no consequence. You talk of changing the ownership as a greater priority, a prerequisite before the good times can return.

Let me ask you to consider which is the greater short-term possibility — this season?

1) That Roberto Martinez could take Everton to Wembley and win?

Or

2) That Bill Kenwright will relinquish his ownership and control of the club?

While the first may not be a forgone conclusion, it represents perhaps the only tangible reward still within our grasp this season. Whereas the second seems less and less likely of ever happening. And it in no way guarantees Champions League football; it may increase the likelihood; it may not.

In any case, the two are thankfully not interdependent. Let’s see what Roberto can do in pursuit of the first: that’s all matters today, surely?

Paul Rimmer
61 Posted 16/02/2014 at 06:54:15
Yair Kaye, 4th place in the league means little to me. I’m taking my three kids to the match today and they need to see Everton win something. The Board, manager and players may agree that 4th is preferable but not me.
Matt Traynor
62 Posted 16/02/2014 at 07:14:37
Yair Kaye #222, I get what you’re trying to say, but when you have a statement like
"Is it our ambition, the crown of our achievements?" about winning a cup, followed by
"The only way to return to past glory is to get a top 4 spot" you’re basically suggesting that finishing 4th is success - it’s a total buy-in to the Murdoch Media Myth.

I know it’s unrealistic to expect us to challenge to win the league, but that should be our aim. 4th might get us into the CL, but as City found out for the first couple of years, it means nothing until you have the squad and game experience to cope with it. Regular CL qualification might gjve us more money, but it’s just as likely to bust the club as the owner has to do a Ridsdale to chase the dream. Perversely a 4th place finish might hasten the change in our owners as he’d know he can’t sustain it, but equally the CL qualification might smoke out a buyer so he gets his profit. Equally perversely it’s possible he doesn’t want a CL finish for that reason - to retain control. A Cup win gives him Whelan-esque access to the media.

A cup and 4th place aren’t mutually exclusive. At the end of the day our Honours List shows the last entry as winners of the FA Cup in 1995 (I don’t know if they still list Runners Up, but in which case it’s 2009). Qualifying for the CL qualifiers in 2005 doesn’t warrant a mention - although in these days of dumbed down expectations it probably should to propogate the Myth.

Yair Kaye
63 Posted 16/02/2014 at 07:46:43
Michael , Paul & Matt;

Don’t get me wrong — I will be delighted at the sight of cup glory. But it won’t change our prospects and will only serve as a one-time blink in the darkness.

In order to return to the zenith of English football, we must have a change in club ownership that will enable us to get a top 4 position on a permanent basis.

In my opinion, we don’t need the amount of money being splashed at Man City & Chelsea – we have better tradition and support base than these two. Half the expenditure will do for us. You cannot run a club on pauper’s budget and expect to be at or near the top.

Mike Green
64 Posted 16/02/2014 at 08:04:53
Paul #226 - if it comes down to 4th or winning the F.A. Cup I’m with you - F.A. Cup all day long, no contest.
Peter Warren
65 Posted 16/02/2014 at 08:03:25
I would love to win the fa cup and would enjoy it much much more than being 4th. Did people on here love being 4th under Moyes or winning cup under Big Joe? No contest for me.

Martinez is doing fantastic and I’m still only just getting to grips with the consistency of high performance levels. Even against the RS (although tactically wrong IMO) performance level the same. West Brom away was awful but that’s about it since, ironically, West Brom at home at the beginning of the season.

Looking forward to run in at end of season with players getting fit and match fit again. Made up that Martinez I stubborn as a mule and planning for long term future and that he has a plan.

Peter Warren
66 Posted 16/02/2014 at 08:03:25
I would love to win the fa cup and would enjoy it much much more than being 4th. Did people on here love being 4th under Moyes or winning cup under Big Joe? No contest for me.

Martinez is doing fantastic and I’m still only just getting to grips with the consistency of high performance levels. Even against the RS (although tactically wrong IMO) performance level the same. West Brom away was awful but that’s about it since, ironically, West Brom at home at the beginning of the season.

Looking forward to run in at end of season with players getting fit and match fit again. Made up that Martinez I stubborn as a mule and planning for long term future and that he has a plan.

Peter Warren
67 Posted 16/02/2014 at 08:03:25
I would love to win the fa cup and would enjoy it much much more than being 4th. Did people on here love being 4th under Moyes or winning cup under Big Joe? No contest for me.

Martinez is doing fantastic and I’m still only just getting to grips with the consistency of high performance levels. Even against the RS (although tactically wrong IMO) performance level the same. West Brom away was awful but that’s about it since, ironically, West Brom at home at the beginning of the season.

Looking forward to run in at end of season with players getting fit and match fit again. Made up that Martinez I stubborn as a mule and planning for long term future and that he has a plan.

Brin Williams
68 Posted 16/02/2014 at 08:39:55
Can you say that again Peter, I missed it the first few times.
Colin Glassar
70 Posted 16/02/2014 at 09:37:07
The FA cup is watched all over the world and the winner is on the lips of billions of people. 4th place just doesn’t get the same coverage does it? But, given the choice, I think I’d go with 4th place and the promise of future riches, and glory.
Kevin Tully
71 Posted 16/02/2014 at 09:34:11
An incredibly important game today for Martinez I feel. A loss would take the wind out of the sails of many blues as far as the rest of the season is concerned. A Wembley final in his first season could be the catalyst in his quest to change the whole ethos of the club into winners, rather than plucky overachievers.

I’ve no doubt he will set up his team to go for the win from the first minute, but Cup games are sometimes all about that extra effort, which has sadly been lacking in this type of game. Will he send out his team sufficiently motivated?

With the players in the right frame of mind, we should win this comfortably. No excuses.

Bobby Thomas
72 Posted 16/02/2014 at 09:26:54
Yair (222)

I know what your saying, I don’t agree but I do. Managers lately have talked down the cup, Lambert for example, and the finances of the Prem now mean even the place money can equate to all the cash you get from winning the cup.

If your Prem future is under threat, if you are, say, 6 points from the drop zone, then I can see where that manager is coming from. Taking a side down is a stigma and in most cases you will be sacked. Furthermore the Prem and Champions League is where its at and anything else is a sideshow.

Birmingham City have not recovered from going down for example. That day out was great for them, but how many would swap it now? Who knows.

We however, are a different example entirely.

You make the point we should have ambitions to win the Prem, as in that should be our base ambiton. Other fans and indeed Southall have stated the same. But, due to the club not being progressed, we don’t even have the finances to build a squad to have a tilt at 4th. Expecting, wanting, as indeed I do, or even hoping, that we can have a dart at the title is fantasy.

Even if we qualified for the Champions League, we would have to get through a qualifier. And if we made the group stages, as it stands, with the size of the squads we run it would be a one off as we certainly wouldnt qualify again. We wouldnt be able to handle the games and our league position would suffer. Putting it bluntly trying to balance the league, Champions League and the domestic cups is nails. Spurs got in, they run much larger squads than us and havent been back since, although theyve been close. Also, with no experience or pedigree in the tournament I could honestly see us getting spanked initially anyway.

We need to build the club up gradually and I personally think looking to qualify for European football of any sort should be the baseline for the club currently. I include the Europa through a league position as it would get the club accustomed to european football, get the club used to playing the amount of games and get the club exposure. We need to set the club up in that way. But that also means developing the club. Without big finances it can take a generation to turn around a generation of decline. We have progresses far. We need to keep progressing.

This kind of progress is achievable through the domestic cups. We need to develop a culture of success again at the club. A consistency. If we arent doing it in the league then we will most certainly need to have a damn good go through the domestic cups. We finish in the top 5-8 consistently and there is no reason why we shouldnt be having a real go for both the domestic cups every year. The League cup record for example, for a club of our stature, is a joke. Its a free pass to the quarters and its the best chance of european football every year. It needs addressing.

Winning either of these would create positivity, give the club greater exposure, attract sponsorship, bring money in, lift the fanbase, attract more fans, get european football and, crucially, build momentum for exactly what you want to happen.

Noel Early
73 Posted 16/02/2014 at 10:07:49
Si Cooper #188

I didn’t even know Swansea had Napoli Thurs night, it shows what prize is on offer for winning the cup or finishing top 6. The Europa league is utterly depressing hopefully the rumours of a guaranteed place in Champions League for Europa league winners comes to fruition.

Ged Simpson
74 Posted 16/02/2014 at 10:28:43
I love the cup. It’s a competition were you’re aim isn’t to get 4th place. God that is so insane - the desire in football to come 4th. It’s a competition with bugger all money involved but a final that is an event and a time for Blues to fill half of Wmbley and sing any openents out of the park.

Compare that to a last league game when you beat someone and dance for coming 4th. Imagine the open top bus running through the city with RM holding a photocopy of a league table above his head. I really couldn’t care less if we fiunish in top 4. Winner or even runner up may be something to be proud of but 4th ? Oh there’s all that money but in the end we’d only use it to try and come 4th again having played so drab passionless games in some bloody group stage.

Basically what I am saying it the Cup is a taste of what football once was ....before the bloody "Champions" and Premier leagues made it into souless and dull events for rich people to protect their prized assets by making the game make Strictly look like a vicious contact sport.

Ged Simpson
75 Posted 16/02/2014 at 10:38:36
Above written in "rant" mode
Brian Harrison
76 Posted 16/02/2014 at 10:47:36
I can remember a time when the winning the FA Cup was nearly as good as winning the league. But sadly things have moved on and not necessarily in a good way, but the FA Cup is no more than a day out for the fans and carries very little kudos. Oh apart from getting automatic qualification to a competition nobody wants to be in the Europa league.

You only have to look at the attendances at most of the FA Cup games played over the last couple of years, a lot of the games are played to half empty stadiums. The FA themselves have harmed the competition by playing the semi finals at Wembley, that was part of the attraction of getting to the cup final you played at Wembley a unique occasion.

Derek Thomas
77 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:02:04
Don’t apologise Ged, if more saw a middle-ish single digit finish as failure and not the Holy Grail ( mixing cinematagraphic Pythonesque metaphors... whats 6th ever done for us ) We would be a lot better off... * also disengages rant mode.

Short version: as Danny Blanchflower said;

It’s about the Glory!

David Chait
78 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:15:40
Never understand the 4th vs Cup debate… we want to achieve 4th so we can earn money to have a squad capable to win a cup… well why wait till then…
for me FA cup over 4th any day.
Dave Williams
79 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:01:23
Fans negativity transmits to players- maybe they are apprehensive of Liverpool because we are? We can beat them and should have done at Goodison this season and we lost so badly at Anfield because our game plan played to their strengths which Roberto would surely not do again.

But back to the age old football saying- one game at a time! We should beat Swansea as they have no individual players to fear and our squad looks strong.

What we lack is a scorer and hopefully Traore will spark in this regard. We need a return to the swashbuckling style of pre Christmas and with so many players having had a rest through injury we should be capable of that.

This has all the hallmarks of Wigan in the quarters and Liverpool in the semi and I say bring them on and let’s have another go at them!!

Iain Thomson
80 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:20:38
Im usually very negative but I think we are going to give them a spanking for some reason. Hopefully that big tall unit will get decent minutes and give us reason to be hopefull that we arent reliant on lukaku
Andrew Ellams
81 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:23:01
4th place shouldn’t be considered a success but the benefits that come from that COULD be a catalyst towards future success IF they are channelled properly
Andrew Clare
82 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:23:38
Years ago the FA cup was a great competition. Semifinals in the mud and rain at Villa Park, Hillsborough etc under the floodlights, huge crowds, looking forward to the draw for the next round on the radio - fantastic!
Now it’s just not the same. The European Cup was a great completion between the Champions of Europe, now it is a money making exercise.
Having said all that I hope we win the cup because Evertonians will make it a great day.
Andy Crooks
83 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:25:28
Bobby # 240, I disagree, Celtic have had some wonderful Champion’s league nights with fewer resources than us. They were spanked by Barcelona but by and large have performed well.

I’d rather win the cup than finish fourth and in my view the cup winners should get the fourth Champions league spot. That would certainly rejuvenate the competition.

Howard Meakin
84 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:31:29
I’m predicting a 3 -1 Everton win today followed by the R/S beating Arsenal. We will draw Sheff Wed in the quarter finals and the R/S will draw Man city at Anfield.
COYB.
Robbie Muldoon
85 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:35:23
Bobby Thomas, you make a very confused and conflicting argument. We shouldn’t bother with Champions League qualification because it would be a one off with us certain to not qualify the year after because of the extra workload (fair point), but then suggest Europa League makes sense to build up experience? What are you taking about!? The EUROPA have a detrimental effect on the following season without any of the rewards. What experience is to be gained from playing Red Star Racistest on a Thursday night?

As somebosy mentioned, even Celtic are capable of beating Barcelona, and they’re leagues below us. We want to compete in the top tier of football and nothing else. They should be our expectations as they are Roberto Martinez’s.

John Crook
86 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:39:27
Anyone think Robles will play today? Roberto played him in the cup for Wigan last year. I think he will. I think he will get played for as long as we go in the cup which I hope is another 3 matches after today. Fingers crossed for a Traore goal today to get his confidence up and off the mark early on!
Linda Morrison
87 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:41:07
Howard I hope you are right!

Do you predict the lotto numbers as well

Ray Roche
88 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:51:35
Andy Crooks, fair enough, as you say, Celtic have had "some wonderful Champion’s league nights " but then again, if you get the chance to play every year you are bound to have the odd occasion when things go your way.( just like they did for Wigan last year) When they meet real quality they are frequently found wanting.
I’m not sure about the fewer resources than us. Their LOWEST average attendance in the last ten years is 46777 and in addition to this they have the money accrued from their CL adventures. The only reason their average attendance has dropped for the past two seasons is because Rangers don’t turn up due to their dropping down the leagues.
I’m sure if we played in their Micky Mouse league we’d be enjoying some wonderful Champions League nights too.
Thomas Lennon
89 Posted 16/02/2014 at 11:54:44
I remember the EUROPA cup having a beneficial effects on our league results a few years back as it gave certain players a lot of confidence, so that’s not a given.

However it is increasingly becoming (has become) an era when money has to come first before CL qualification rather than there being any examples of a team in PL playing their way in and up.

Everton are the only team in the PL to perform consistently in the ’best of the lesser funded’ competition, if we plan on working our way up via the European cup competitions we will also have to set a precedent. It can be done, has been done abroad but there qualification via the league seems less competitive at least in financial terms so domestic success is easier to come by?

Kunal Desai
90 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:01:03
I want Everton to win any kind of silverware at the end of the day it’s a trophy and it adds to our collection of trophys from the past and above all we gain greater recognition throughout the rest of the world, so be it the FA cup or Capital one cup I WANT Everton to win it. That said you cannot dismiss being in the top for as lucrative for a club like us. If we got to the group stages of the CL imagine the huge sum of money this brings to the club, the level and calibre of players we are able to attract to further push on in the league and further increasing the commercial side of the business, it changes the whole stature and dynamics of the club, providing the money is not swallowed up in the pockets of the current custodians which you certainly wouldn’t rule out!
Howard Meakin
91 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:11:16
Linda
No lottery predictions I'm afraid, I find that life's one big lottery but football's a passion can you just see Everton running out in the quarters against Sheff Wed and giving them a right good stuffing. No endless replays like back in the 80's. Ah the 80's now that was a great era the music was fantastic. Sorry i'll stop rambling.
Bobby Thomas
92 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:12:27
Robbie (255)

Im talking about this:

The Europa is a lower level of tournament.

One we are much more likely to qualify for in the short term, based on wage bill, squad size and where we currently consistently finish in our domestic league.

One we are much more likely to do something in

You want to go straight into the Champions League with no experience? Look how City struggled to get accustomed to it with all their resources, class players and Mancini in charge who knows the drill about European football.

The idea is to build the club up by getting European football REGULARLY.

Not having one season in the champions league and then bombing out.

Im saying we should try to make European football the norm, Europa or Champions League.

We would be much better drilled to handle Champions League football if we had a pedigree in the Europa. Think Seville when they won it twice on the bounce.

That is indisputable.

We would attract better players, raise the profile of the club and we would progress.

Or are you saying you don't want to win a European Trophy? We have been pretty thin on the ground with these silver pots lately.

Thats what im talking about soft lad.

Tahir Abdullah
93 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:28:29
Howard 255, I like your prediction except the win for the Shite. I hate those fuckers; hope they lose so that come back down to earth. COYB.
Bobby Thomas
94 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:24:59
Andy (253)

Celtic play in a no mark league and qualify every year.

They get a free pass into Champions League football and have been playing it for so long they are actually accustomed to it.

And they regularly get whipped. And they do it playing in a league where they don't even have to turn up most weeks. We play in the most physically demanding league in Europe.

The Celtic example is a complete red herring. It has nothing to do with this league.

On the FA Cup I know what your saying but its the old UEFA and Cup Winners Cup combined, its never gonna happen giving it a Champions League place.

A much more likely thing they will do is the FA will can replays and have a shoot out at the end to give it a kick up the arse.

Jamie Barlow
95 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:36:21
Robles and Traore start.
Kunal Desai
96 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:36:33
Starting line up:-Howard, Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Barry, McCarthy, Pienaar, Barkley, Mirallas, Traore
Matthew Salem
97 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:32:10
Everton starting XI: Robles, Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Barry, McCarthy, Barkley, Pienaar, Mirallas, Traore

Subs: Howard, Hibbert, McGeady, Deulofeu, Naismith, Stones, Osman

Robbie Muldoon
98 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:28:04
Bobby, our squad consists of experienced international players from countries all over the world. Schooled in different philosophies of football and currently coached by a Spaniard soaked in the British customs of the game but widely regarded as the most progressive and innovative manager in the game. It's bullshit to suggest playing in the Europa will enhance this squad in ways nothing else can. The Europa will drain a squad and make it impossible to achieve the Champions League qualification goal.

Kunal Desai
99 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:37:08
Sorry I meant Robles
Kunal Desai
100 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:39:12
Tremmel, Richards, Bartley, Amat, Taylor (c), Canas, de Guzman, Hernandez, Routledge, Lamah, Vazquez.
Matthew Salem
101 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:38:03
I love this line-up....I hope that Traore is a revelation
Robbie Muldoon
102 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:37:43
One simple solution to make the Europa worthwhile though... the winners qualify for next season's Champions League. That would be an incentive!
Kunal Desai
103 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:39:27
Swansea making wholesale changes, got to win this now.
Jackie Barry
104 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:40:10
I believe that is actually going to happen from 2015-16.
Mark Frere
105 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:40:27
fantastic looking line-up. Really looking forward to seeing Traore.
Kevin Rowlands
106 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:36:03
Just seen the team sheets, looks like we've probably put out arguably our strongest eleven and they are fielding a weaker side, hopefully a good hammering on the cards, I'm looking forward to seeing Traore.Hopefully the draw later on will see Arse vs City and is at home vs Wigan!
Nick Entwistle
107 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:38:23
"widely regarded as the most progressive and innovative manager in the game."

Last season, wasn't it Laudrup?

Quite a bold statement though. Whom are the widely regarded?

Simon Smith
108 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:47:12
Not happy with Robles in goal hope he proves me wrong
Jackie Barry
109 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:47:55
Still think Laudrup is a good manager and Swansea were crazy to fire him. We are after all talking about Swansea and not not Man U.
Gerry Quinn
110 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:57:39
Another 4-0 will suit me - if it is would that be some kind of record? No Live Match Forum, gents?
Tahir Abdullah
111 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:59:56
http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/feb/14/everton-swansea-fa-cup-fifth-round-Martinez
Jamie Barlow
112 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:06:22
Click on TWLive under History Gerry. There’s a few already on.
Simon Smith
113 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:05:54
Right lads no cock ups today show no mercy and hit them hard and fast
COYB!!!
Robbie Muldoon
114 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:05:29
Nick 279: Well here's one example: (March 2012)

Roberto Martinez can be 'as good as Wenger'

SPANISH football analyst Guillem Balague has told Celtic they would be on to a winner if they appointed Roberto Martinez as their new manager.

SPANISH football analyst Guillem Balague has told Celtic they would be on to a winner if they appointed Roberto Martinez as their new manager.

But I suppose you would still rather have Moyes hahaha

Simon Smith
115 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:10:15
Where’s the match day forum???
Bobby Thomas
116 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:53:22
Robbie (270)

To be honest I don't think your getting what im saying

I want us to play regular European football and want it to be the baseline for the club

The way the club is set up we arent likely to achieve this Champions League football dream. We are likely to get better players in and raise the profile of the club, grow the club, if as a bye product of aiming high we start to regularly qualify for the Europa. This can also be achieved by the cups.

If you are saying that regularly playing in the Europa, attracting better players with possibly more European football experience, would not prepare us better for the Champions League if we ever qualified, then, honestly, you are talking out of your arse.

Man City.

Unlimited cash. International players all over the place. Roberto Mancini in charge, massively experienced in European football. They went into the Champions League cold and got fucked. As would we, if we got through the qualifier. Last time we played a qualifier I thought we were embarrassing.

You need experience and pedigree in that tournament. Some experience and pedigree in european football in general, gained in the Europa, would quite obviously help.

To say otherwise is nonsense.

Tim Greeley
117 Posted 16/02/2014 at 12:52:50
Haha haha they just showed Ric fecking Wee on the pregame here. Milk it bro, milk it. Lets win this shit for Ric Wee!!
Tahir Abdullah
118 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:15:53
Simon, I'm on via Google. If you enter toffeeweb on Google, you should click on the live forum link which is under the main heading.

http://toffeeweb.com/comment/live/

Nick Entwistle
119 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:14:24
Robbie, 2 year old line, from one journalist, and a 'can be' a Wegner. That's good case work right there.

so ha-hahs to you.

Robbie Muldoon
121 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:16:47
Bobby, the Europa League does not attract any players, you're talking out of your arse on that one.

Liverpool haven't been in the Champions League for 4 or 5 years but do you think they want a couple of years in the Europa before stepping up? Of coures they won't. Why are we different?

Let's just agree to disagree, but you really should have higher ambitions, you only live once mate.

Keith Young
122 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:11:40
Michael #224 BK does NOT own Everton he has a minority shareholding in keeping with his personal financial constraints he has told all and sundry about. He does have the support of sufficient other shareholders on the Board to enable him to control Everton, on terms acceptable to them. If they become unacceptable, as with Paul Gregg, they will sell.
Robbie Muldoon
123 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:29:26
Nick, 2 year old statement backed up in the mean time with silverware and what he's doing at Everton now.

And I'll take that you would prefer Moyes you strange cat.

Nick Entwistle
124 Posted 16/02/2014 at 13:47:25
Only its not though is it Robbie. Progressive and innovative, ok perhaps, but 'the most progressive and innovative'?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb