Webb gift hands Everton a point

, 26 December, 168comments  |  Jump to most recent
Sunderland 1 - 1 Everton
A typical teamsheet selection for the trip to Sunderland featuring the misfiring Cahill and Saha, who missed great early opportunities, only to see Everton all too predictably give up the first goal. Substitute Colback's shot was heading for Howard's hands but Distin, the only change to the side, sliding in deflected it over Howard and into the net.

Drenthe had a good shot that was touched wide. But five first-half corners came to nothing, other than a hopeless stooping header from Saha, all alone with plenty of time at the far post.

No changes at half-time, of course, and Howard had to be sharp to deprive Sessegnon of a shot. But a bizarre decision from Howard Webb gifted Everton a penalty when Osman stubbed his toe and Baines absolutely lashed it home to put Everton back in it.

Saha, in defence came so close to heading a Sunderland corner into his own net. He was given 83 unproductive minutes before Vellios replaced him. Distin came close on a last-minute corner but another 'cameo' appearance for McFadden at the end summed up another dire Everton display of unincisive football that incredibly yielded a draw that will nevertheless have Moyes touting an away point gained.

Barkley was 'rested' on the bench for yet another game, despite having now signed his long-term contract... a game when both Fellini and Rodwell are out. It can't do his confidence any good knowing that when Everton are down to the bare bones, Moyes would rather play a couple of defenders in midfield ahead of him.

» Read more



Reader Comments (168)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Luke Dunn
1 Posted 26/12/2011 at 15:30:03
So predictable, all the possession but 1-0 nil down. Looking grim....
Anthony Fielding
2 Posted 26/12/2011 at 15:26:26
Howard
Hibbert, Jagielka, Heitinga, Distin, Neville, Baines
Osman, Drenthe, Cahill
Saha

Ah the new attacking formation... 6-3-!
Luke Dunn
3 Posted 26/12/2011 at 15:36:34
Well here it starts... get Cahill off once again ? he is dire. We are playing with 10 men. The guy does not add anything to the team; get rid asap.
Wayne McNee
4 Posted 26/12/2011 at 15:50:13
Is there a seperate league where you get points for fielding shite & keeping talent on the bench that I don't know about?
Saha should be on a pay as you play contract where by he pays EFC a fee for each game. Watch he'll score 2nd half now? #asif
Christopher Kelly
5 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:10:29
#changethechannelandenjoytheholidays

#can'tbebothered
Luke Dunn
6 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:26:55
Farcical penalty, for such a top ref that Webb gets tons of decisions wrong, but a bit of luck for a change......
Wayne McNee
7 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:28:08
Use a sub for fucks sake!
Clueless, ginger twat!
Colin Malone
8 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:55:15
PATHETIC. FUCKING CLUELESS. ANOTHER OPPOSITION GOALIE WHO HAD NOTHING TO DO. Absolute shite Moyes.
Wayne McNee
9 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:53:46
As long as this crazy world exists where McFadden even sits on our bench, subs are made in 85mins plus & the likes of Cahill & Neville start... I will no more set foot in GP, buy my kid a kit or waste my broadband allowance on EFC in the current state, management, ownership. Give me a nudge when they've all gone.
Ricardo Gimpardsle
10 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:59:07
You could post the same comments after every game and they would be as accurate as the last lot!! This is not football it is crap
Danny O'Neill
11 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:00:08
Have we not just got an away point against a team that is under the customary honeymoon period following the appointment of a new (& highly respected) manager? Oh, forgot, we didn't win 5-0 playing like Barcelona. I suppose now I will subject to the usual apologist / acceptance accusations. As an 80s season ticket holder I know what I am used to but I am also a realist in the current climate. Good things come to those who wait, as it did to the faithful who were there circa 1983 when the "hoards" & their leaflet campaign called for change just before we went on one of the most successful run in the club's history. The season ends in May & I will judge it then.
Barry Rathbone
12 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:08:20
I will be doing Karaoke later.
Amit Vithlani
13 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:06:39
Whatever your views about the club and its current predicament branding Cahill and Saha as "useless" is out of order and uncalled for.

Cahill is certainly past it but he has been a fantastic servant for the club and there is absolutely no doubt that he still cares passionately everytime he gets on to the pitch.

Saha has proven time and again he is a talented player and age too may have finally caught up with him but he has given us some great memories - I will never forget his four goal salvo against Blackpool.
Terry McLavey
14 Posted 26/12/2011 at 16:57:52
I've think I've just witnessed a team who are just as bad or worse than us!!(no not a misprint!) Are Saha and Cahill holding Moyes's children hostage?!! Because that is the only logical explanation for playing them! The only player worth his salt was Drenthe, he never stops trying,although he is probably "shop window" playing to secure his future elsewhere and he was substituted ! I was considering how much money was being earned(?!) on that pitch during the 90 mins? If they had a conscience they should refund it or give it to charity!Also with all the litter blowing around the pitch in the second half I thought an apt metaphor for the absolute rubbish being inflicted on the crowd! One nil down in the 1st half Davey! it's becoming quite a pattern! I am actually waiting for it now ! although you will no doubt view todays debacle as a great success! Championship here we come!!
Vic Flange
15 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:14:43
UTTER, UTTER, UTTER, UTTER SHITE.
Brian Waring
16 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:12:23
Danny, its not about playing like Barcelona.
Its about actually going and trying to win the game, instead of dour, defensive, I'll take a point before the game has even started tactics.

We were as shite today, as we have been for most of the season.

Also " Good things come to those who wait " What does that mean?
Terry McLavey
17 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:14:18
Amit#9 Saha's and Cahill's successes are ALL IN THE PAST !!! We are playing NOW!! and memories won't score goals and keep us in the Premiership!
Mick Quirke
18 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:17:47
I'll still settle for that. Maybe Moyes could've started with Bily or Barkley but to be honest with Feli, Coleman and Rods all injured, don't know what other options he had today. Landon can't come soon enough. That was a good point, Norwich home was 2 dropped.

Brian Waring
19 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:17:31
Amit, I reckon the ' Useless ' bit, is more down to the current form of both Cahill and Saha,

At the end of the day, just because of what Cahill has done, shouldn't gaurantee him a start.
Carl Peters
20 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:16:40
We're going down, simples...
Michael Winstanley
21 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:15:36
Sunderland were there for taking today even with the team we out out. Agree with everyone about Cahill and Saha starting, it makes no sense. As for Neville well...shocking at best.

No desire to win the game in the second half, we played for a draw. Appalling decision by Moyes. His subs were too late to change a game, it appears he wanted a draw.

And agreed about Barklay, how he cannot get a game is beyond me.
Col Noon
22 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:09:56
That was painful. Moyes's team selection suggests that of a man who is afraid. He is playing it safe and sticking with his old guard in hope more than anything.

Neville ? Abysmal again. Offered absolutley nothing and his distrbution is getting worse if thats possible.

Saha ? Anonymous again and missed a good chance. Clearly out of sorts and no longer offers a goal threat. Poor work rate, sloppy and dis-interested again.

Cahill ? Forgot he was playing.

Osman was OK and Baines had a go, apart from that the performance was nothing short of woeful. Bringing McFadden on was the nail in the coffin and it is now clear that whatever made Moyes successful has now vanished and is unlikely to re-appear. The man is done and no longer has the answer. Time to go Davey, for the sake of yourself and the club. More and more fans are turning against him and I would hate to see that as he has been fantastic for the club. Last season in charge I think.
Danny O'Neill
23 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:20:22
It means stop reacting to individual results and initial frustration immediately after the event. I suspect most assumed we would automatically beat Sunderland away - perhaps they had other ideas. I think it's a good (dare I say "fantastic") point. My opinion, which I am entitled to just like the glass half empty brigade on here whose negative vibes are becoming tiresome.
Michael Winstanley
24 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:27:30
How can you not be tired after watching that Danny?
Andy Crooks
25 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:26:08
Amit.I chucked out my old slippers before Christmas.Loyal servants as they were,age had rendered them useless.Yeah,not a perfect analogy but...my old slippers weren't on £50k a week. That amount of money makes sentiment misplaced.Time for them and Moyes to go.
Danny O'Neill
26 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:28:55
Because I've seen a lot worse in the late 70s and early 80s not mention the dross that was served up during the 90s!!!! Brian (post 14): good point, current form should be the driver for selection, not reputation.
Brian Waring
27 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:27:59
So Moyes's ' Negative vibes ' aren't becoming tiresome for you then Danny?

Also " Stop reacting to individual results ' its not about an individual result Danny, its about an accumulation of all the shite game we have conjured up.
Andy Crooks
28 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:32:51
Danny, I certainly didn't expect us to automatically beat Sunderland. What I did expect was the coach to send out a team that might beat them. Week after week of mindless drudgery; how can any one defend this negative worn-out coach???
Michael Kenrick
29 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:30:23
Sorry Amit, but what were they, other than useless today? (Yes, we're talking about TODAY!)

It's not 100% their fault, as a competent manager would not be picking them to play. But there ya go...
Kunal Desai
30 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:43:20
I don't think anyone can we've had our fair share of luck this season, whether it be with given pens, missed pens and missed open goals. I make it we'd be on 14 points and joint 3rd bottom if those crucial decisions had gone against us in the Blackburn, Fulham and Sunderland games.

As for Saha, he needs to be shown the door, nevermind Everton contemplating giving him another contract. His playing days are over. Cahill needs to be used as an impact sub from now on, 15 or 10 minutes max.
Jay Wilson
31 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:41:19
Who would and should he pick Michael? The bench was full of kids and Bily none of whom I have seen set the world on fire. They may do in the future, but he is in the business of getting results today. I would do things differently if I were manager but I am not and am not armed with the inside knowledge he is.
Jamie Barlow
32 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:34:08
Good result considering we played with only 8 men. Neville, Saha and Cahill contributed absolutely fuck all. Drenthe was shite and the defense looked a bit more shaky than usual.

Apart from another point away from home, there's nothing to get excited or shout about. Pretty dire shite if you ask me.

Motm would be from the usual whipping boys. Hibbert or Ossie. Maybe Johnny.
Brian Waring
33 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:49:45
Jay, could Vellios and Stracq do any worse than Cahill and Saha at the moment?

Could Barkley have been any worse than Neville was?

He could've dropped Neville, and started with Osman in the middle where he played some of his best football for us, and started with Gueye out wide.
Michael Winstanley
34 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:49:57
He could have played;
Gueye on the left.
Drenthe on the right.
Osman instead of Neville.
Barkley instead of Cahill.

A midfield of Neville and Heitinga should never be a first choice pairing.

Once we scored we settled for a draw, that's not acceptable. Sunderland were dire.
Colin Malone
35 Posted 26/12/2011 at 17:54:20
Let me tell you something, Saha would score a bag full if he played for Spurs.

Why is Barkley on the bench? He's only 18, people say. Barkley in his pram is better than Neville.
Danny Broderick
36 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:28:29
I would love to know our results whenever we have fielded Neville and Heitinga together in centre mid. It clearly doesn't work.
Robbie Muldoon
37 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:29:25
Boxing Day and I didn't even bother watching it. When I heard Neville and Heitenga were centre-mid, I wanted us to get thumped. Quicker Moyes is gone the quicker I can get my interest and excitement restored.
James Stewart
38 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:35:08
It works if you're Moyes. He clearly had no intention of changing it.
Aiden Jones
39 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:31:43
Strange how so many people think Barkley is the answer yet as Moyes never plays him you can't have seen him play much.

Maybe a manager who sees the players train every day is in a slightly better position to make an informed decision. Maybe a youngster with so little experience would struggle away from home.

Injuries and a limited squad gave Moyes few options. I thought Neville broke up play and protected the back 4 well.
Richard Dodd
40 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:37:56
A point away from home is always a good point, however fortunately it is obtained. Injuries meant the cupboard was bare and Moyes is loathe to throw Barkley and the other `babes` into a struggling side. That`s his caring way!

21 points from 17 matches gives us c47 at season`s end, even without the expected `second half` surge in form, and that`s probably good enough for comfortable safety. For gawd`s sake cut the man some slack, wll youse?
Robbie Muldoon
41 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:43:38
Aiden, if you wayched the QPR game and you belive Neville to be a better option in midfield than Barkley, then I am afriad you are wrong.
James Stewart
42 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:42:06
Aiden it's not that Barkley is "the answer" as you put it. It is just the fact he is a creative player who god forbid is actually entertaining to watch.

Watching Neville is just painful. How a professional footballer can be so bad with the ball at his feet I will never know. He was in good company today though the quality on show from both sides was quite frankly embarrassing. I have seen better play and imagination at the local park.
Ray Roche
43 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:48:38
Colin Malone.

Saha would have to get into the penalty area, or near it, to score. He'll not score scratching his arse out on the wing.

Robbie Muldoon
i don't give a shit about you getting your interest restored. Some Evertonian you are, wanting us to get thumped. Try joining the lovable rascals across the park if that's the way you hink. You've got something in common with them.
Brian Waring
44 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:52:41
Aiden (#33) Saha and Cahill must be shit hot in training, because how they get picked by Moyes on current form on the pitch. beggars belief.
Andrew Clare
45 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:44:01
I will always support Everton but I have to say this is one of the worst teams to wear the blue and white that I have seen in 50 years.

We look like a very mediocre team hoofing the ball all over the pitch. There are three or four players who are completey 'past it' on the pitch, I won't name them but we all know who they are. The Everton I grew up with would never re-sign a player like McFadden!
Why bring subs on for 10 mins?

I cannot believe that anybody has any faith in David Moyes anymore.

If this carries on we are just going to fade away.
Marc Sansum
46 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:54:56
What an absolutely wank bit of "journalism" reporting.
Amit Vithlani
47 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:52:54
Michael, its about respect. Cahill and Saha deserve better than to be branded "useless". This is not the Everton way. We treat players who have served us well with respect. Maybe they do deserve to be on the bench, or out of the club, but whilst they pull on a blue shirt, they deserve better than your contempt (which fortunately counts for very little outside this realm).

Ste Traverse
48 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:06:24
Amit.

We don't always treat well players who have served us well. I seem to remember the likes of Reid, Ratcliffe and Sheedy coming in for severe terrace criticism in their latter days at the club.

Overall today we were awful. Again. I'd be mad had that penalty been given against us.
Sam Fitzsimmons
49 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:09:42
Einstein?s definition of insanity ?doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results?
Ian Tunstead
50 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:18:35
You sound like a Blackburn fan Robbie, very poor.
John Ford
51 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:10:10
The match report is just silly.

Its getting grim to be a blue. Moyes has always priorotised defense, and to be fair it has served us well down the seasons. Today again we effectively stopped Sunderland as an attacking force, but it was painful to watch.

The difference is that until this season we always had an effective attacking option. We have litte creativity which irrespective of results makes for poor viewing. Our squad is now so limited and Its a real shame. Tinkering with the line up will make little difference.



Michael Kenrick
52 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:13:57
Amit, I don't think you should talk about 'respect'. They get gazillions of money from the faithful Evertonians who pay to watch them fail to perform. They neither need nor deserve respect for continuing to put in useless displays like today's.

But in large part it is actually the manager's responsibility. He continues to pick them. And he orchestrates the team to play the god-awful football that is mainly responsible for their failure to perform.

Perhaps when Moyes shows some respect for the Everton name, the Everton traditions of playing football, and the lifelong Everton fans who expect more from him and his beloved Chairman, I might show a bit more respect for his training, team preparation and above all team selection, all of which pretty much suck at this time.
Colin Malone
53 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:19:29
Ray *37. precisely.
John Daley
54 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:08:23
"Michael, its about respect. Cahill and Saha deserve better than to be branded "useless".

They don't 'deserve' anything. They're paid handsomely to do a job and, to be brutally honest, they haven't been doing it. They've scored two goals between them all season and don't look likely to be adding to that total any time soon.

Don't make out either of them have gone above and beyond the call of duty. Fair enough, Cahill has played through injuries for the team in the past and so deserves credit for that. However, he has also continued to travel halfway around the world to play in meaningless matches for his national team whilst his club form and fitness deteriorates rapidly as a result.

Saha has never put his body on the line for the club. First sign of a knock and his fragile psyche holds up the white flag and thinks "fuck that Louis lad" and he's out for weeks.

Both players have this season kicked off and got a titty lip at being dropped. Saha took to Twitter to piss and moan, and Cahill chucked his shirt on the floor before storming down the tunnel like a six year who's been told he can't watch fucking Thundercats on tv. Is that 'the Everton way' then?
Ian Smitham
55 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:26:40
Robbie #31, Whatever the rights and wrongs, and most are hotly debated on here, your comments are a disgrace and destroy your credibility for future contributions. Hang your head in shame.
Tom Dodds
56 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:14:43
Blue Benitez.
Chad Schofield
58 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:06:38
"21points from 17 matches gives us c47 at season`s end... that`s probably good enough for comfortable safety."
Nil Satis Dodd, Nil Satis
Tom Dodds
59 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:14:43
Blue Benitez.
Phil Walling
60 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:32:10
All players get paid to deliver on their particular and special skill.In Cahill's and Saha`s case, their manager classes that as `striker`.

Can any sane person ? however `loyal` they wish to appear ? possibly argue against the assertion that for this season, at the very least, they are both `useless` at it?
Colin Malone
61 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:46:53
Phil # 59. I,m pretty sure if Arteta and Pienaar were in the side, you would see a different Cahill and Saha.
John Ford
62 Posted 26/12/2011 at 19:48:44
Phil, probably not but in Cahills case at least he has been a real asset for our club and his demise is part of the reason we're a blunt attacking force.

Whatever your view on Cahills current form its simply not on to have a lead match report with an opening paragraph such as that.
John de Frece
64 Posted 26/12/2011 at 20:06:07
Comes of a bit of a shock to me - but we happen to be 10th in the league! Amazing !

So we"re going to have to be even shiiter than we are now in order to get relegated

Epitome of our ambition today with le Moyes and Bill - just survival.
Ernie Baywood
65 Posted 26/12/2011 at 20:15:47
That's the first time I've ever turned Everton off. 7 of the 11 defenders (incl. GK).

Out of form Saha and Cahill. Plus Osman out of position. Leaves Royston.

Mick Davies
66 Posted 26/12/2011 at 21:21:35
The oldest team ever to represent Everton in the PL. What happened to lowering the age of the squad? Walter lives on
Roman Sidey
67 Posted 26/12/2011 at 21:15:22
Richard Dodd, at 67k a week, slack will not be cut... ever.

Couldn't see the match today for personal reasons, but if anyone is happy with a point against Sunderland, well, I guess that's an indication as to where Everton really are these days.

Ian, was waiting for someone to bring up Blackburn fans. Now that Moyes has condemned them, I guess Everton fans have to as well. I'll tell you this: there is only one reason why Moyes was so "disgusted" by them the other week, and it wasn't compassion for his compatriot peer.

Disgusted? No. Alerted? Hopefully.
Simon Howett
68 Posted 26/12/2011 at 21:21:34
I understand Moyes's predicament with Fellaini out but why does he always react with such negative tactics. Playing both Nev and Heitinga in CM is flawed as neither cover the ground quick enough or make a telling pass, plus Heitinga was doing OK with Jags and we kept a clean sheet v a toothless Swansea.
Gueye made a decent debut last week and deserved a start again today. Royston failed today but only in trying to do too much in a poor attacking line up with Cahill and Saha offering nothing.(again and again why persist ?)
As for the Mcaffaden substitution, well what does that say to Barkley. It says " I will have to be down to the dregs before I give you game time" I excepect the lad is chomping at the bit to play unllike some others.
"The wind ruined the game second half" said Moyes. Well tell the players to pass the ball on the floor.Simples.
Sunderland were shit and so were we. Gifted a pen by Webb. .We have had some good decisions this season and our position flatters us and the dire, dull football we are playing.
Moyes is not going to change and the brand of football he chooses to play is outdated and laboured. The other managers have him sussed and his predictable formations, subs and tactics carry on week in week out.
Would he change with investment and money to spend on players. I doubt it, he had a couple of good seasons once when we got 4th on 60 pts.( ashit prem that year)
I digress,. Moyes plays not to lose, I dont' like his football philosophy and I don't like how he sets the team up to play. Somewhere I hope this changes . Maybe we get 40 points and hen he plays the young guns in preparation for next season. But I doubt it.
Foottball is supposed to be about entertainment but I can't remember the last time Everton entertained me. ah yeah Blackpool and the ghost of Saha. It certainly wasn't this season.
It's piss poor this season and we all know it and so does Moyes
Ted Smeethes
69 Posted 26/12/2011 at 21:46:40
It was another fantastic, unbelieveable draw.
Alan Clarke
70 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:19:35
Interesting Amit, I had an exchange on twitter with Saha where he moaned about me not showing respect. I did a deal with him - he starts scoring and I'll show him some fucking respect. Guess what, he's not scored since!

I wish Saha would just fuck off. I wish Moyes would fuck off for persisting with him. He's as much use as a chocolate teapot so why not play Vellios or Gueye?
Andrew Clare
72 Posted 26/12/2011 at 18:44:01
I will always support Everton but I have to say this is one of the worst teams to wear the blue and white that I have seen in 50 years.

We look like a very mediocre team hoofing the ball all over the pitch.There are three or four players who are completey 'past it' on the pitch, I won't name them but we all know who they are.The Everton I grew up with would never resign a player like Mcfadden!
Why bring subs on for 10 mins?

I cannot believe that anybody has any faith in David Moyes anymore.

If this carries on we are just going to fade away.

Jamie Barlow
73 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:17:16
Roman, I don't think anyone is happy with how we are playing but a point away at Sunderland is not something to be really disappointed at. Maybe the way we played but we've no reason to expect three points whoever Moyes picks to play.
Peter Mills
74 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:18:27
David Moyes would be a much better manager if he had Rooney, Lescott, Pienaar and Arteta in his team. He has had to sell them for Everton survive in the economic lunacy of the EPL. And he is playing safety-first football for the same reason.

Phil Rodgers
75 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:33:29
In the short term I'm just glad we didn't lose. In the long term we hac
Bobby Mallon
76 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:29:44
Danny O'Neil, the point is this: in today's climate, the team of 83 would have not gone on that incredible journey because the gap between the top 4/5 and the rest is too big.

The other thing is this WE ARE PLAYING SHITE FOOTBALL ? the same useless players getting full games when there are hungry and better players on the bench not getting a sniff. Saha playing for a contract, Moyes says... he should be kicked out in January, end of ? he just does not have it anymore.

Moyes needs to bloody well wake up and drop those two.
Jim Knightley
77 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:28:15
Why such a subjective match report? Give the details, leave the opinions to those of the forum. Absolute joke piece of reporting. I know this is a relatively minor football forum, but you should really try harder than this.

To the game. Did no one think we played well first half? Little seems to be said about that.



Re. Roman's comment (I'm sure indicative of many opinions)

'Couldn't see the match today for personal reasons, but if anyone is happy with a point against Sunderland, well, I guess that's an indication as to where Everton really are these days'

Please someone tell me why we should not be happy with a point away to Sunderland? We sell players and do not buy... We have one of the smallest squads the division has seen in the past 10 years. The problem is not with realism, but unrealistic expectation. We should be happy with a point at Sunderland, because Sunderland are at our level. It is a point away against one of our rivals. Arsenal, Manchester United, Chelsea, Manchester City, Liverpool and Spurs are no longer our rivals. If we finish in the top half, as sad as it may be, we have done well. If you doubt that, look at the players at our disposal, look at who we have brought in and sold, and do a simple comparison. We play poor...because we are poor. Not to say Moyes does not deserve cricism on occasions, but this much? and after a draw away to a difficult team under the influence of a new manager? in a game where we were unlucky to go behind, besides what may have happened later.

Get real.

Phil Rodgers
78 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:41:22
In the long term we simply have to buy a striker. Saha is just not good enough. He was woeful again today and he should be dropped immediately. Cahill and Neville may be out of form but at least they put a shift in.
Sam Hoare
80 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:52:54
All i hear about is how crap and inept our players are and yet Moyes has us in 10th. Does that mean he's doing an alright job...or are we meant to win the league with the rubbish players we have?
Joseph Elworthy
81 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:49:05
Does anyone find Jagielka's 'defending' absolutely comical - maybe he should submit a urine sample before taking the field.
Roman Sidey
82 Posted 26/12/2011 at 22:59:48
Jamie and Jim. I guess that's the difference. There are 3 points on offer at the beginning of a match. Sunderland are below us on the table. For these two simple reasons, I think we should be claiming those 3 points for ourselves. Don't think I'm not mildly RELIEVED that we got a point out of it, but to be happy or not disappointed with a draw is ludicrous.

Moyes plays defensive football with a team who CAN'T DEFEND. That is also ludicrous.

In January we play 5 League fixtures. I think our goal should be 13 points. Goal only. But I think our expectation, given the opposition we play should be 12 points.
Jim Knightley
84 Posted 26/12/2011 at 23:12:24
I think Roman, your comments on next month sum up a central problem: unrealistic expectation.

We have Bolton and Blackburn at home.

West Brom, Spurs and Aston Villa away.

We should beat Bolton and Blackburn (who both incidentally, spent alot more than we did, but are under achieving).

Now you expect another 6 or 7 points away from West Brom, Aston Villa and Spurs?

Realistically, from those games, 8 points would be a very good total for us. 12 points would be the goal of Arsenal/Chelski, 13 for Manu and City.

Please realise Everton now have a mid table squad. A mid-table squad should not be disappointed to draw at Sunderland. A mid-table squad should not expect to take 12 points from our games next month. We all want us to win against Sunderland, and to win 4 of 5 games next month, but look at our squad. Do you really think that squad should? It is ludicrous to suggest it should be the expectation, we are not a champions league chasing team.
Jim Knightley
85 Posted 26/12/2011 at 23:21:50
Also, I do not think it is fair to say we cannot defend. Only Liverpool and the top three have let in less goals than we have. The problem is that only three teams have scored less than us. Do you not think saying that we can't attack is more accurate? and given our complete lack of numbers/quality in attack, and in creativity, is that really a suprise?

For all those that constantly advocate attack over defense. Should a team, whose main strengths are in defence and are weak in attack, play defensive or offensive football?
Robbie Shields
86 Posted 26/12/2011 at 23:37:13
Jim, ask yourself why we are strong in defense and weak in attack. Then ask yourself do you like watching that 'style' of play. Finally ask yourself if it could be changed by selecting different players and having a different philosophy on how football should be played.
James Flynn
87 Posted 26/12/2011 at 23:00:44
We'll move up in the 2nd half of the season. Yeah it sucks "Best of the Rest" is all we can shoot for under current ownership. But that's the reality. With that . . . .

Would like to see LD in the "Arteta" role in front of Fella w/Drenthe one side and one of our young speedsters on the other. Wonder if any of them are leaving the training pitch when Moyes calls "Time" or staying on their own to build up their conditioning. Would be interested to know.

Saha has proven over an entire career the same player. Gifted but fragile. He is on his way to a lesser team, perhaps in a Continental league. His time with EFC is coming to a close.

I believe Cahill should be parked until back to full health. He can still help the team.

As much as I like Barkely, he's 18 years old. 18. Just like Rodwell (who himself is still 2-3 years away from being a complete EPL player), Barkley IS NOT Rooney!

I wasn't in here when Rooney detonated onto the scene, but everyone who follows him into EFC seems to be compared at the same age. Unfair.

We have a number of youngsters with talent and physical ability. Let's see which of them is busting his ass on his own to build up the strength and endurance for an EPL 90 minutes.
Really want to see them flanking LD for a couple months.

Oh, and countdown to Bily gone. 2 weeks? 3?
John Ford
88 Posted 26/12/2011 at 23:57:05
Good points Jim There are also numerous examples where teams have attacked at the cost of defending and have dropped like a stone, this happens season after season in the premier league. Moyes knows this. He is defensively very sound, even with a mediocre squad.

Sadly we dont have the creativity to entertain. This is the first time in a Moyes team that I can recall this. We usually have an 'out' and decent attacking options, but not at the moment. Drenthe offers something, but seems also to forget he's part of a team.
Wayne McNee
89 Posted 27/12/2011 at 00:20:44
We're 10th.. Whoop dee doo! Is that an actual argument? The league works on points don't ya know & an armchair glance up & down the table shows all the "stats" you need to know. We're in the shit & besides luck, DM's tactics, selection & attitude are not the answer.
Jim Knightley
90 Posted 27/12/2011 at 00:06:14
Robbie, we are weak/strong based on personnel. Do we have a forward (relatively speaking) the quality of Baines? or Jags/Distin/Heitinga? The higher up the pitch we get, the worse. This is because we have lost our best two creative midfielders in Pienaar and Arteta and are unable to properly replace Saha or Cahill (Although giving Billy an opportunity for a few games in the attacking mid role of Cahill's would not go a miss)

If we had money we could add to the top third of the pitch, and score/create more whilst maintaining a defensive record good enough for the top 6 of the division. We could attack more, but it would not play to our strengths, because a front two of Saha/Velios (or Denis...) would probaly (beside perhaps swansea and one or two others potentially) be the worse in division.

I would rather watch Barcelona Robbie. But great football is a game for those teams with money. When Moyes has more money, when we had better footballers, we were more entertaining to watch.

Ask yourself again Robbie, does a team with very poor attacking players and good defensive players, attack or defend? You've said nothing to injure my original argument. I believe Moyes could freshen up things more often. But I also believe Barkley is nowhere near ready yet. I believe our bench players are substandard, and I believe the dour football we watch is the result of depleted squad caused by financial problems. I also believe very few managers could come into Everton, and achieve higher finishes than Moyes will achieve. Alot of managers could play more attacking football, but to score more goals would be to let in more, and we would run the risk of replicating the tactical errors on show at Blackburn and other poorer teams who have attacked more than they should.

Dermot Ryan
91 Posted 27/12/2011 at 00:11:09
I pretty much agree with Jim Knightley's analysis. We've flogged our creative midfielders (Arteta and Peanuts) and replaced them with one on loan (Drenthe, who Moyes is regularly giving a game).To my mind, Moyes is a little too defensive and risk averse, but I think under current tightened straits, maybe this makes some sense. Are the Moyes-haters still enjoying Coyle's attack-minded passing game? Or Martinez's continental style?

Expecting this squad to compete with Man U, Man City, Chelsea, Spurs, Arsenal, and Liverpool when you compare their spending over the last 5 years with ours is unrealistic. I think it is more significant that we are still competing with Stoke and Sunderland, teams that have also outspent us recently. Wish our situation was more exalted but its not.

We will not be able to get into or compete in the Champions League until the club is sold. Simple as. Everton was a once great club and may well be great again, but at the moment it is a skint club run by an selfish and incompetent Chairman. People need to adjust their expectations accordingly.
Phil Martin
92 Posted 27/12/2011 at 01:23:27
Lets not forget Moyes had Demba Ba lined up before Newcastle got him. But the small issue if him requiring a salary killed the deal (even tho he was free).

NSNO RIP
Robbie Shields
93 Posted 27/12/2011 at 01:58:54
Dermot, the day I adjust my expectations to the same as a lot of you seem to is the day Everton has died in my heart.

Jim, no matter how big your Squad is you can still only put 11 players on the pitch. Moyes insists on putting 7 defenders out all the time, playing out of form players and yet again killing strikers. Saha is a quality player, but he's fed up along with EVERY other striker that has EVER played under Moyes.

Barkley IS good enough, Magaye Gaye IS good enough, Rodwell IS good enough, Moyes isn't.

Moyes and his anti football may be good enough for you, but it isn't for me and a lot of other blues. And all this shite about us only playing defensive crap football since Arteta and Pienaar left is bollox.

A number of us have been complaining about this hoofball ftyle of play since AJ and Beattie were at Goodison, the only difference is the results, it's the same old shite, year on year, week on week. 6,000 + fellow blues this year seem to agree with mine, Michael's, Marsh's and Roman's point of view. If Moyes stays more will follow.
Andy Peers
94 Posted 27/12/2011 at 02:23:51
Robbie Shields, you are 100% correct.

I would like to add that I remember being pissed off at Arteta 85% of the time and 100% of the time when he took our free kicks from Baines. Pienaar was only as good as Baines made him look, he will never be that good without Baines, just look at his pathetic World Cup. The McFadden signing really sums Moyes up. Amazing to think our top scorer this year could be a Left Back.
Steve O'Malley
95 Posted 27/12/2011 at 05:50:12
Robbie 87 and Andy 88. Thank you and a few others for a bit of common sense instead of all the emotion on this site.
All the crap about Saha in particular. I am not saying he is a player in form and I am sure he would be the first to admit it I am just as sure that even Van Persie would struggle to score for us. Goalscorers rely on good quality service and service in the right areas.
More than half the goals that Van Persie scores are tap ins that are laid on a plate for him. Where in the name of god is good service going to come from at Everton. Who in the current team is going to make a defense splitting pass. Look at the team that took the field yesterday and if you were the 1 man leading the line you would put money on yourself not even getting a half decent pass.
Moyes 2 leaders of the line, Cahill and Saha are both nearing the end of their careers yet under the Moyes Master Plan they along with the other 10 are expected to be back for every corner and to get down the other end when we make a quick break. I personally feel sorry for every striker who has featured under the Moyes regime.
Moyes and attractive football are 3 words that are never going to be used in the same sentence. The man has a place in football but he along with a few others are trying to strangle the self expression and style of play of people who entertain. For those old enough to remember he is a reincarnation of Gordon Lee.
Unfortunately I would imagine, for age reasons, that I am one of the minority on this site who have witnessed the School of Science era. I am not quite sure watching the garbage that is served up now, whether that is a good or a bad thing, although they do say that it's better to have loved and lost than never to have lost at all
Dave Wilson
96 Posted 27/12/2011 at 06:29:21
Do you know I honestly thought there would be a different argument when I logged on today.I haven't had the chance to see replays on the telly yet, but here's what I saw :

Cahill missed s a great chance - again. Saha missed a complete sitter, Distin entered the miss of the season competition and Drenthe was rugby tackled INSIDE their penalty area . .so how did all that happen if we didnt attack ? why are some of our fans so intent in deliberately choosing not to see these things ?
Its absurd, We accept shite decisions like the Rodwell sending off, or the Gosling hand ball, but we consider ourselves jammy fuckers when one like the Osman "penalty" goes our way. We must have the only fans in the world who bemoan our GOOD luck.

Dermot #85 absolutely nails it:
The people with the " I dont care if me arl fella`s been made redundant, me and me brothers STILL want a top new bike for chrimbo " attitude, will continue to be disappointed that much can be guaranteed.

Some people seem to think Moyes should be playing the youngsters, for some reason - desperation perhaps ? - they have convinced themselves that these kids are the answer. They`re not, they are only in the squad in the first place because there simply is no one else. Only Barkley has a chance and he will be given his opportunity in the second half of the season.

We have of course seen all this before. When Seamus Coleman came onto the scene, the clamour for him to play was absolutely deafening . . I've watched Seamus closely and although I too was desperate for him to be the new Danny Mcgrain, the harsh reality is, he has struggled for two seasons to rise above the ordinary. His enthusiasm may get him into certain areas, but lets be honest, our new "superstar" simply isn't good enough.

Cahill, Neville, Heitinga, Jagielka etc, play pug ugly football alright, but their collective international experience will guide us to 50+points again this season and I dont believe theres a manager in the world who would trade that in order to risk his and the clubs future on a handful of youngster Simply because the MIGHT generate a little excitement on rout to the championship.

Its heartbreaking to KNOW that unlike others, you cant have a new top of the range bike for Chrimbo. Some will scream the house down - blame the manager - even turn their backs on the team . . .but the mass exodus they confidently predicted hasn't happened. Despite the recession and lack of investment, our average gate is over 34,00 - a few hundred down on last season - and with Spurs, City, Arsenal and Chelsea still to come, that figure is likely to rise.before the seasons out

There are many thousands of Evertonians around the world who are prepared to stick it out until their Arl fella finds himself a new job.

KENWRIGHT OUT !
Lyndon Lloyd
97 Posted 27/12/2011 at 08:04:30
Whatever your views about the club and its current predicament branding Cahill and Saha as "useless" is out of order and uncalled for.

As a lead news item, it was completely out of order and I've re-written it to reflect a site that is supposed to at least attempt to deliver news and opinion separately.

We have an Editor's Blog, Column sections and Comments for a reason.
Phil Walling
98 Posted 27/12/2011 at 08:15:01
Whilst Richard Dodd and his generation of` thirty-somethings`have had little opportunity to witness Everton play entertaining football and have thus come to see the present rubbish as `normal`,those of us who have seen better times continue to lust after better fare.
However,our dream may be further away than even we realise.I suspect the `joined at the hip`deal between Moyes and HIS patron requires `our man` only to provide continuance of Premier status.Success-in the traditional sense meaning Euro qualification and the odd Cup-are nowhere in the equasion as our motto has now been subtley tranformed to `Pragmatism rules OK`by every action of the Board and manager.
At the Swansea game,most of my `neighbours`seemed happy to accept the points and focus on the return of Donovan and `the inevitable New Year resurgence`.There was even talk of the possible arrival of an Owen or some kid from Cliftonville transforming our `goals for` column! Of course,we all know we can`t score for pussy but only a fool attributes that to ageing forwards or inexperienced Greeks.
The reality is that the midfield is totally inadequate-whoever plays-as the tactical approach is focussed entirely on not conceding.Three months` work will be required with any new arrival before the manager can become satisfied that `the defensive side`of the new striker`s game is up to par whilst,in the meantime,another frontman`s reputation will go in the bin.
Frankly,despair is my only emotion as I await the opening of the window although,if things go as usual,I shall still be awaiting news of our salvation a month from today!
We`re doomed,I say,we`re doomed!
Robbie Shields
99 Posted 27/12/2011 at 08:57:28
Dave #90, the clamor for Coleman to play was because he played without fear, was positive, energetic and tried to beat defenders, not necessarily that he was the best thing since sliced bread. Moyes wouldn't play him because, wait for it..... He wasn't an accomplished defender!!!! Big sigh! So, then, when Osman was woeful out on the wing there was a clamor then to say, well why don't you push Coleman up a bit and try him on the right side of midfield, and EVENTUALLY, Moyes played him there, and he created a damn site more chances and scored more goals than Osman or Neville had. I just want to see positive attacking football first, not this defensive shite all the bloody time. Why not try Coleman at right back with Gaye in front, that'd get me up in the morning!
Wayne Smyth
100 Posted 27/12/2011 at 09:02:21
I didn't see the game yesterday - I'm quite thankful having read most of the comments - but based on the other games this season, this sounds little different.

I'm one of the people who would give Barkley, Bily, Gueye and Vellios some game time ahead of McFadden, Cahill & Neville, certainly at home to the Norwich's and Swansea's of this league, and any that deserve it can also start against Sunderland away. We certainly have an experienced core of players to help them.

We may not beat City, Utd, RS, or even Sunderland, but we'll try to and longer term our young players will get the experience they need....and who knows, with a more positive setup and creative players, we might actually create some chances, score some goals and win some matches. Can't win if you don't score.

Regardless of the money we've (not) spent, Moyes still has a decent squad to work with and he can put out a good first 11 if he chooses. Essentially I'm of the belief that he could still get the results he does(or better), but also be planning for the future in the process. I don't think he's doing a good job with what he has.
Robbie Shields
101 Posted 27/12/2011 at 09:22:15
Phil #92, great post.
Conor Feeney
102 Posted 27/12/2011 at 09:37:39
Jim Knightley, thank you for the common sense. When I need an antidote to all the schmalzy sentimentality at Christmas I pay a visit to Toffeeweb where the angry and the disillusioned hang out.

That point yesterday was a decent point away to a team on a new manager bounce etc.

To those that say we need a new striker - OF COURSE WE DO - in fact we need two. That won't be happening though. Could also do with a creative centre mid, a top drawer right back and another speedy skillful winger. None of this will be happening anythime soon, so therefore with the players Everton currently have, small squad, injuries etc, the point yesterday was a decent result. Had we taken the lead as we might have we could well have won it.

Fortunate penalty alright - but I'll take it. About time I say.

Anyone think this place should be re-named Scroogeweb or Grinchweb ?
Jimmy Sørheim
103 Posted 27/12/2011 at 09:46:57
Moyes changed a winning side,that is why we lost.
Gueye,Barkley and Vellios should have played for Neville ,Cahill, and Saha.
The poorest Everton team ever was last night, we lacked everything.

I hope it was the christmas pudding taking its toll, and not for things to come because it was truly dreadful.
Ray Roche
104 Posted 27/12/2011 at 10:09:26
Lost?
Richard Dodd
105 Posted 27/12/2011 at 10:22:11
In answer to Phil #92, I do agree that we are now into an era of `Don`t feel the quality, look at the width`, as far as Everton is considered. You are right; I don`t find the present `fare` as you call it, any different to most of that I have watched since 1992 and I totally concur with the management`s philosophy that Premier League survival is ALL IMPORTANT.

For good or evil, I continue to hold that BB and Moysey have done a good job at Everton. Without any outside funding, they have managed to keep us afloat and ? compared with so many north west clubs ? relatively stable financially.

OK, Davey has had to flog the odd player and Bill pawn everything of value but we are still in with the elite. And that IS an achievement! For what it's worth, I don`t see much hope of a sale in 2012 ? the financial climate is just not right. So, like our very worthy manager, I look forward only to reaching that 40-point safety line.

To me, and many of `the thirty-somethings` Phil refers to, that WILL BE success. Anything else a pure bonus.
COYB!
Roman Sidey
106 Posted 27/12/2011 at 10:33:35
Apparently 2 clean sheets in the first half of the season is adequate defending... for a team with between five and seven defenders on the field. Add this revelation to last week's "the crosses would be good if someone was there to get on them", and I think I've been reading and writing about the wrong sport.
Thomas Windsor
107 Posted 27/12/2011 at 10:44:13
Please, Kenwright and Moyes bring some new faces in and try and offload one or two, the place has gone stale. Each home game the fans are protesting by not coming ? can you blame them? This style of football is not the Everton Way.
Colin Malone
108 Posted 27/12/2011 at 11:39:30
Jim # 78.
Please realise Everton now have a mid table squad. A mid-table squad should not be disappointed to draw at Sunderland.

Well Jim, the way its going, it want be long before we are getting mid table crowds. I believe, if the club had confidence in the manager, they would find £40 or 50 mill for players. you will soon getv that back with qualifying for europe, shirt sales, bums on seats, you reap in what you sow.
Peter Cummings
109 Posted 27/12/2011 at 11:48:12
Totally agree with most of the posts, why DM insists on playing Saha is beyond everyone, we know we are now in a 'bare bones' situation now that the injury curse has hit Fellaini but playing those who are clearly past their sell-by dates instead of those youngsters who have proved themselves at every international level is quite baffling. Those lads MUST be given their chance and now.

I couldn't stomach any more after the first half so took the dog for a walk instead. The biggest shock was Webb actually giving us a 'non' pen and keeping his cards in his pocket when he should have red-carded everyone on the pitch for this travesty.
Jamie Barlow
110 Posted 27/12/2011 at 12:04:34
Shocking post Jimmy@97. You say we 'LOST' because Moyes changed a winning team and then say we should have played Gueye, Barkley and Velios.

Talk about Christmas pudding.
Paul Gladwell
111 Posted 27/12/2011 at 12:21:57
How can Moyes bleat on about our lack of goals and tell us they are working hard in training on it, then names a team of seven defenders and one striker, the man is a clown and then when he brings a forward on it is in the 85 minute.He is also soon going to ruin Phil Nevilles Everton career as he will turn into a fans whipping boy as these two last games in centre mid have been shocking, just how can we create for our one forward with a pairing of him and Heitinga?
David Hallwood
112 Posted 27/12/2011 at 11:53:13
Richard Dodd states ?I don`t find the present `fare` as you call it ,any different to most of that I have watched since 1992? I?ve watched Everton a lot longer and disagree with that totally. In the early days of the Premier Everton were the whipping boys of the division, I have seen Man U put out a 2nd XII against us and still beat us comfortably. The great Arsenal side?s regularly played with us like a cat with a mouse, believe me gents we were piss poor.

This season, I didn?t renew my season ticket and I haven?t set foot inside the ground-it?s weird how quickly you get out of the habit. But from what I?ve seen this season, no team has battered us, the City game, yes we parked the bus with no invention or intention of attacking, but as soon as they scored Mancini took an attacking player off and put a defender on. Likewise Man U, they scored and Fergie unlike him, did a Moyes (probably on the back of the drubbing they had v citteh the week before) and pulled everyone back to hang onto the lead. Arsenal we were done by a wonder strike, Stoke one shot then hang on for dear life QPR ditto;

I could go on but I?m beginning to sound like Owen Coyle. But it makes me howl with frustration when I see the groundwork that has been put in the last 5-6 seasons being steadily eroded and we will get back to the point of being the league?s whipping boys

What is obvious to me is that we are paying the price of not being able to replace and refresh the team, calling Saha & Cahill shite is bang out of order, but Saha looks like he?s run his race and Cahill has just played too many games and should have retired from international football 2 seasons ago to prolong his career-proud Aussie that he is, it is the club that pays his wages.

Which brings us back to the directors. People that want to become involved with running any business should understand the rules of the ?game? so to speak, and not dive in without a realistic medium-term plan. What we have at Goodison is crisis management, and as we lurch from crisis to crisis the business of providing a stable environment to take the team forward has gone out of the window. Surely the club?s directors are all involved in business, and they must realise that the current malaise will only drive the club-their business into receivership, if that happens they will get very little or nothing of their original investment.

Yes it is a tough environment out there with very few people wishing to buy a team with a clapped-out stadium and a mountain of debt, but just like in the real world that should be reflected in the price, and it is obvious that the asking price for the club is too high-yet another example of the new Capitalism-reward success and failure in equal measure.
Wayne Smyth
113 Posted 27/12/2011 at 12:41:18
Paul(103), I agree completely.

Its true that Moyes has not been given money to compete with the elite of english football, but that doesn't excuse the consistently shocking team selections and subs policy.

My gut feeling is that Moyes is happy to pick up the very odd win against the bottom 3 or 4 clubs and try to get a point everywhere else in order to amass 40 pts by seasons end.

The squad is capable of a lot more, but I think Moyes is more concerned about his own reputation and he likes to play a no-risk strategy. Trouble is if you risk nothing, you can never gain anything.

Since he's a world class coach and tactical mastermind, I wish ManU or Chelsea would hurry up and take him off our hands. Its not like those type of clubs to sit around and watch such undoubted genius fester away at a club like ours when he's so obviously capable of doing as good a job as the likes of SAF.
Bill Simpson
114 Posted 27/12/2011 at 12:54:50
Colin # 101.

I don't know what was in your Christmas pud but if you seriously think that it would be remotely possible for the club to find £40-50 million for players under the present regime it must have been some kind of mind altering substance. We're skint and, however much you and others blame our current failings on David Moyes, the reality is that he's doing what he has to just to keep us in the PL and, hopefully, as is usually the case, decently placed by the end of the season.

Yes, some players are now nearing the end of their careers and it shows, some aren't up to it and some aren't quite ready yet, but they are all that Moyes has because he can't afford anything else, so don't blame him for playing to the limited strengths that we do have. I know he's well paid for what he does but I feel some sympathy for a man who built a squad that was on the verge of achieving something then had to begin dismantling it to satisfy the bank - hence my opening comment about the self-delusion of thinking that an investment of £40-50m in current circumstances is remotely possible.
Ray Roche
115 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:28:35
Roman Sidey @100
I agree completely with your observation regarding our inability to keep a clean sheet despite flooding the team with defenders.Why not play a higher line when possible with...perish the thought....another forward at the expense of what we laughingly regard as a defender.(who,apparently,can't defend)

However, I also think you are wrong to regard the "the crosses would be good if someone was there to get on them" as being a poor observation. It's usually a winger/wideman's job to get to the by-line and provide a good cross for forwards or mid-fielders to attack, which is what was happening in the game for which that statement was made. Could you enlighten me as to what Baines, Gueye or Coleman's job is if it's not to provide ammunition for forwards when they are not occupied with their defensive duties? Carry the ball to the half way line and then pass it back to Jags to belt into his Mother In Laws kisser in row z?
Dave Wilson
116 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:11:50
It's one of the great mysteries of football:

Davey Moyes, the guy who "doesn't play to win" wins more games than the 14/15 managers outside the elite group of mega rich clubs... and he does it every year! ? beats me that one.

Here's another mystery: "Money doesn't matter" yet the six richest clubs ALWAYS FINISH in the top six... except, of course, when Davey Moyes gate crashes it.

And perhaps the greatest mystery of all is: Even though there are loads of people who could do a better job than Moyes ? apparently "anybody at all would be an improvement" ? all the other clubs choose to pay fortunes to even worse managers, who finish below him, year after year... You`d think at least 2 or 3 of them would snap up one of these better managers, wouldn't you?
Michael Winstanley
117 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:39:45
One of the most disappointed things yesterday and in fact for the last few games is we are clearly better than the teams we've played. That much is obvious after 15 mins. Once it becomes clear we're better, by that I mean in our passing and controlling of the game why not change it?

Yesterday, Moyes could have brought on either Bily or Barkley in replacement of Cahill. Either would offer us creativity around the oposition box which could then perhaps enable us to capitalise on our dominance.

Anyone who thinks a point against a very poor Sunderland team is a good result should head off to specsavers.
John Ford
118 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:33:25
Dave Wilson. Excellent post.

It seems common practice on TW to simply highlight certain players as if they were the answer to all our problems. You mentioned the clamour for Coleman, who has subsequently shown his limitations. Drenthe is the new messiah but he too clearly has limitations. The latest is Guaye and Barclay, who we all hope will come good but again he isnt a Rooney. The solution doesnt lie on the squad it lies in investment.

The truth is this is the weakest ever squad under Moyes. This is not Moyes fault. We are dour at the moment and thats because we cant aford decent attackong midfielders or proven goalscorers. Instead we pulled in some bargain basement and loan players of which only Drenthe looks to offer anything of note. Of course this may change and Strac Vellios may show well at some time. At the moment we are doing enough for mid table, this is mainly down to Moyes defensive style, dull though it is.

The dull football served up is a direct result of nil investment. A midfield yesterday of Osman Barclay Drenthe and Guaye, with Strac and Vellios as forwards would have seen us torn apart. Dont kid yourselves. Imagine the space all over the park for Sunderland.

Kenwright out.
Tom Winek
119 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:46:22
Just don't understand this criticism labelled at Moyes and his style of football always having been terrible and unwatchable. Admittedly, it hasn't been great lately but, no matter what anyone says, our squad is tiny and fringe players inexperienced and young. Until a year ago we played decent football; without quality personnel and having sold our most creative players, we now struggle.

Oh and another thing; people need to stop living in the past and harping on about the good old days. Right now our aim is to stay in this division along with every other team apart from a handful of rich ones.
Jimmy Sørheim
120 Posted 27/12/2011 at 13:52:11
As to my post nr.97 it was suppose to read: "Moyes changed a winning side and that is why we lost 2 points."

Is it offensive to say Cahill and Saha has been useless, I think not.
However as a neutral post match summation of the game you should at least try and explain what happened and leave the comments in the comment section.
I think some people take things written here in this site way too serious, one would think it was personal, but it is suppose to be a debate, not a place for badmouthing a poster for giving his opinion.
Am I right??

Tony Rutherford
121 Posted 27/12/2011 at 14:04:31
Dave Wilson # 108 great post....totally agree.....we've been punching above our weight for years with no cash and a small squad.

Moyesie has been the main reason for this and while I don't always agree with his team selections and certainly not his substitutions, I feel this season is his biggest challenge yet...as the squad is so small and I don't feel all the kids are ready yet.

Moyesie is one of the most coveted managers in football and loads of club woud be happy to take him off our hands....but I don't think anyone else currently available could do a better job for us with the current constraints.

Only a sheikh or a Russian billionaire is going to change that for us based on the fact we need a new stadium. There just aren't that many around in the current economic climate.
Jimmy Sørheim
122 Posted 27/12/2011 at 14:42:14
I agree that is the smallest squad yet, and that Moyes faces a battle, but I think Moyes is partly to blame for his latest transfer dealings:

Bily was bought for £9 million, when we needed a top striker.
Yakubu was bought for £11.25 million and sold for £1.25 million, a loss of £10 million.
It would make much more sense to keep him then giving him away like that. Overall, Heitinga and Distin have not been close to copying Lescott's performances.

My main problem is the selling of Arteta.

1. Why sell a first class player when you do not have a replacement ready?

2. Could Moyes not wait until January before selling him, and then be given a chance to get in a direct replacement for him.

3. As Saha recently said, the sale of Arteta disrupted the team morale and performance, did Moyes not think that this would happen?

4. In the sale of Arteta I find no good reason to sell him without having a replacement ready, and if anyone else does I would like to hear it.
Mike Bates
123 Posted 27/12/2011 at 14:51:00
John is right. Just imagine it, with two centre mids instead of a couple of defenders in the middle of the park, and playing TWO wingers offering width and pace, we deffo would have gotten torn apart by Sunderland. Sure.
Jim Knightley
124 Posted 27/12/2011 at 14:45:13
Good to see this thread has veered into intelligible territory and the original article has been altered.

Nice post Dave. The sooner we become more realistic, the better. Posts from Colin and Roman sum up the unrealistic expectations of a porton of Everton Supporters. In reality 10th in the table is where we should be and probaly lower; we have a poor squad because of continued financial problems. We would all LIKE us to be challenge the top 6 and even the top 4, but such expectations are completely out of sync with reality.

I believe the current top six, will be the final top six. I believe we will come in one of the next three positions, alongside Newcastle and Fulham. This will be not in spite of Moyes but becaue of Moyes.
John Ford
125 Posted 27/12/2011 at 15:05:16
Jimmy,

Arteta, folk hero and top banana that he was (WAS) he hadn't put a decent shift in for a season and a half, since before his injury. I recall the general consensus on here was that we should cash in while we could. Not that that proves a point of any kind but I think there was a feeling that he was struggling.

We got good money for him and, despite him doing quite well for Arsenal, I believe we had his best years. Having said all that, I do miss the bloke, and wish we had the Arteta of five years ago here.
Jim Knightley
126 Posted 27/12/2011 at 15:02:19
Jimmy how reductive is it to highlight poor transfer dealings and not the good ones? And even the very best managers, Sir Alex (Djemba djemba, Miller, Kleberson etc) and Wenger included (Jeffers, Wiltord etc) make mistakes.

To even out your transfers listed, the other side of the coin, sell-on clauses not included:

? McFadden ? bought for £1.25M; sold for £5M rising to £6M
? Lescott ? bought for £4M rising to £5M; sold for an estimated £22M.
? Arteta ?bought for £2M; sold for £10M
? Johnson ? bought for £8.5M, sold for £10.5M

We made good money on Beckford and several others (and have lost some too).

To look at our current squad, how much profit could we make? Jags and Baines would near-on triple original prices. And considering we only payed £1.5million for Cahill...

Moyes has been about as successful, bar Wenger, as any manager in the league with his profits on transfers and net dealings. Whilst Liverpool and Spurs wasted over £100M and much more on wages, we continued on a fraction of the amount. If you are going to suggest Moyes has made poor transfers, Jimmy, then why not mention the good?

And we needed to sell Arteta, and £10M for a 29-year-old is good economic business. Especially given his faltering performances.
Ray Roche
128 Posted 27/12/2011 at 15:50:44
Jim Knightley

Some very good observations there, it is also worth pointing out that I don't think we lost much, if any, on Pienaar, who Moyes used to great effect and, it could be argued, made Baines a much better player than he looks now. This is the same Pienaar who may well be shown the door at Spurs. Maybe if Moyes was manager there he'd put Pienaar to better to use than 'Arry can.
Wayne Smyth
129 Posted 27/12/2011 at 18:24:33
Tom(114), I'm with you that our squad has no depth and that is not really Moyes fault, but if we're going to struggle to compete against the likes of Norwich, QPR, Blackburn, wouldn't it be better to at least get something positive out of it? Like blooding our youngsters with some serious premier league experience?

I've got absolutely no problem if Moyes finishes 14th because he has so little to work with, but I do like to see a long-term plan based on the resources we do have. How are we going to know if Barkley, Vellios Bily and Gueye are good enough unless they get some proper time in the squad in their best positions?

All I can see so far is journeymen who ARE PROVED not good enough, like McFadden, keeping our youth players out of the team. Players who are unfit or not performing should also be dropped(like cahill/neville).

I'm not a fan of Moyes style, but I don't think my expectations are unreasonable. I dont expect us to beat Man City or Man Utd, but I do expect us to try to compete and not admit defeat before a ball is kicked.

Our wage bill is still somewhere around £60M, so that probably puts us around mid-table I'd guess, so its not like Moyes has a worse squad than teams that have beat us this season, in financial terms.
Steavey Buckley
130 Posted 27/12/2011 at 18:58:35
The idea of 3 points for a win and one for a draw was for a big incentive for defensive minded managers to adopt more attacking styles of play to go for wins,not for draws.
Tom Dodds
131 Posted 27/12/2011 at 22:57:43
Eh up!
Who the bloody `ells slaggin off our Neville (the crab) ? AND old father Tim(e)??
Our Ossie`s playin a bloody blinder at mo, and as for that blummin Russian lad with is high bleedin `opes of `Playin behind the striker`! Ha! who the `ell does he think he is ???

AND It's a bloody good job Moyes dosen't let those bleedin' young whippersnappers sittin' on the bench onto the pitch either, who the `ell would let the bloody apprentices on in a League One match, when they haven't served their time yet??? I mean who???

It makes me want to throw me pipe at Moyes for lettin' that young French lad on... I mean, Louis, alright at least he`s over 30.

You'd have to be a dead zombie to think like that.
Mick Davies
132 Posted 28/12/2011 at 04:30:15
Danny O'Neill @23 ? "I suspect most assumed we would automatically beat Sunderland away." ? Well the answer to that question is YES. We are Everton and we should expect to at least try to win every game, but, with the strange, failed system our wonderful management team persist with, maybe we should all give up and create our own Everton, like Man U fans did.

The great name of our club is becoming synonymous with negativity and the 'school of science' looks like Grange Hill. The whole thing needs a huge shake up and everybody involved in the running of the club, should be hanging their heads in shame. Thousands of loyal supporters are being shat on and even the most diehard Blues are losing faith in what was once a proud institution
Mick Davies
133 Posted 28/12/2011 at 04:40:59
And John Ford, i'm afraid you're wrong: it IS Moyes' fault. He is the one who sanctioned the sale of 3 key players on deadline day without any replacements, he fell out with most of his strikers and behaved churlishly by sending them out on loan or not playing them. He is the one who hasn't found a decent right back, or right winger in 10 years; who plays a stagnant system which isolates a lone front man, usually one not suited to the task., And he admitted years ago he needed to get players early in the summer to bed in well before the season starts but only did this once. He never plays the same side more than two weeks running and he stopped Lescott going when everyone knew he wanted away, resulting in another thrashing by Arsenal before he left anyway. He told us he was lowering the age of the team, yet has just picked the oldest side Everton has played in the PL. He is the one who praises the chairman and board, telling us they will always back him when he needs funds. He is the reason we are not scoring goals, therefore not winning games and it is he who brought in the failure that is Steve Round after he'd just helped get Newcastle relegated!! He is the one who makes baffling, last minute substitutions and sends out the side to 'fight a gun battle with a knife'. So please tell me, if it's not his fault, who's fault is it?
Jimmy Sørheim
134 Posted 28/12/2011 at 07:05:46
As you point out the defence of Kenwright by Moyes is one reason alone not to approve of Moyes.
Another is his poor transfer dealings this calender year, and by that I refer to the selling part.
Robbie Shields
135 Posted 28/12/2011 at 07:36:54
Mick #126, incredible as it may sound to the likes of you me and a fair few others, there are a number of supporters such as John that I have come to the conclusion of simply do not understand what we are talking about.

All your points are factually correct, the standard reply is to either ignore the inconvenient truth of your post and 'move on, there's nothing to see here', or plead mitigating circumstances, you know, BK and the banks forced the sale of players, ignoring all the other points made. The problem with that argument is that Moyes has always stated that no-one leaves the club without his say so and the banks and BK have not told him to sell players.

I can therefore only conclude that he is either completely incompetent and out of his depth at our great club or he is very good at telling whoppers, or both.

The good thing about having posts such as John's is that it gives us the opportunity to spell out to everyone exactly why Moyes isn't the Moyesiah in plain English. A number of fervent Moyes supporters have actually started to change their stance given the overwhelming evidence posted on here. Some others though are either as stubborn as Moyes is and won't ever admit to either being wrong, or indeed not being 100% right, but such is life.

The latest argument is that Moyes will turn it around in the second half of the season like he always does! That always makes me laugh, fatalist bullshit, bit like saying West Ham, Leeds and Forest were too good to go down.

A bit of bad luck, some injuries or even just a continuance of our shite defensive football and we won't see any surge up the table, unless of course all our defensive midfielders get injured and Moyes has no choice but attack instead of defend.

Keep up the good work Mick, I've got bored repeating myself, but it's great to read the postings of fellow blues who know it could be all so different just given a change in direction.
Martin Mason
136 Posted 28/12/2011 at 08:56:33
Robbie 129

It is equally possible though that you don't understand what the others are talking about. As I've said many times the concept that there is a minority that can understand what is happening at Everton and a silly majority that just blindly accepts what is happening is laughable. You certainly don't seem have a clue and that is why you can't seem to get your message across. Moyes knows more about soccer than you will ever know and he sees the players all week in training. That he does things in a way that we don't agree with doesn't make it wrong. My view at the moment is that we have a fairly ordinary squad which should be at best struggling mid-table and no better even if we had Alex Ferguson at the helm. We play a very negative 4-5-1 and my own view is that if we went for a more adventurous set up we would be relegated. Moyes drives me crazy with some of the things he does but that doesn't make him wrong. EPL survival is his only aim and playing nice football is way down his list.

EFC are a small debt ridden club now with a weak squad run on a shoe-string budget and Moyes out, board out will be like shuffling the deckchairs on the Titanic.
Gavin Ramejkis
137 Posted 28/12/2011 at 09:10:44
Be careful Robbie the "kopite behaviour" brigade will be on to you. So it's not Moyes fault he stays with a formation and players that aren't on form or making the grade and the old he sees them in training chestnut or the "those clamouring for x" lot are bumping their gums with the same tired excuses.

We'll all - the collective, both sides of the fence, all not going to know what would happen if the misfiring Cahill and Saha were dropped and replaced with the likes of Barkley and a pairing of Velios and Saha or Velios and Straq as Moyes has simply not done it or seems likely to do it.

Pack away your "we'd be relegated Fact" type shite or other supposition and tired excuses, repeating the same mistakes that don't work can't be the way forward. Donning tin hat and awaiting another ban.
Paul Maguire
138 Posted 28/12/2011 at 09:39:46
Saw the Arse Wolves game and was sad to see Arteta clutch his lower knee in agony after a tap on the ankle (and that's all it was) which got a Wolves player sent off. I'm no Wolves apologist. Fletcher and Hunt's histrionics were at least as bad.
Cant help thinking of Big Dunc once saying "If I go down get a f**kin' ambulance cos I'll be f**kin' deed".
Anyway my laboured point is after seeing Arteta's performance (he took the resulting free kick) I was glad he doesn't play for my club Everton.
Denis Richardson
139 Posted 28/12/2011 at 09:39:30
Robbie / Gavin - there's no winning with some people. The only 'excuses' for the football on show seem to be the fact that we have little money and sold Arteta and Pienaar. However, people seem to quickly forget that the football was still crap when these two were in the side last season (Pienaar was never that great anyway IMO and Arteta needed a change of scenery to start playing well again - i.e. better tactics and not being played in an almost sweeper role - he also didn't play that well last season).

Moyes did a great job putting the ship right when he came but he has now become part of the problem. The biggest problem is of course the board but we need a change of ownership and manager to really get this club back up - a fresh start. Having no money does not excuse the football we currently play and for those going on about being mid table, please review the results we have had and hand on heart tell me that we have not been really lucky to be where we are now. Had a couple of dodgy decisions / penalties not gone our way we would be sitting in the relegation zone, would you still be saying the same thing abuot the manager and his 'tactics'?

With the squad we have, relegation should not even be a discussion point (we have the 8th highest wage bill in the league ffs!), so we could at least try to play football - especially at home to promoted teams! (I remember we played the same crap negative tactics at home to Newcastle when they were promoted - and lost!. Nothing ever changes....)
James Hollister
140 Posted 28/12/2011 at 10:16:48
I get the impression, week-in and week-out now, the players simply don't want to play for Moyes and his negative bullshit tactics. I mean he selects the team, puts it out, and 2 weeks down the line it's been changed ? and this happens repeately.

If I was playing for Everton right now, I'd be fucking furious with Mr Moyes I really would be. The man is incompetent, doesn't really know what he is doing etc.

We might have no money, and we may have the smallest squad in the Premier League... but ffs, you have to make do with what you have at your disposal and put the strongest possible squad out to win matches. And yet we have the completely baffling decisions he makes, week-in and week-out.

This is entirely down to Moyes, he puts players in a hat and draws numbers and puts them anywhere... but 7 defenders??? Shocking!!

For me, its high time Moyes went... not because of the money but because he is has consistently proven himself inadequate as a manager, whose job is to pick the best possible combination of players to go out and win matches. Not having 7 defenders and 2 clapped out players on the pitch... thus reducing us to playing effectively with 9 men!!!
Robbie Shields
141 Posted 28/12/2011 at 10:22:02
Denis, great points, with the 8th highest wage bill then 8th 'should' be what an average manager should be able to accomplish, a better than average higher and a true miracle worker higher still, even forgetting the actual footballing and entertainment angle.

Martin, I've actually seen Everton in training for a total of 4 hours on 2 occasions and have been a youth coach myself, and actually managed to get young boys to play very entertaining and successful football, without millions to spend I might add! haha. To say I was underwhelmed by what I saw from Moyes and Round would be a gross understatement.

As others have pointed out, some of our players must be having blinders in training, but what would I know, you have to come from PNE and win fook all and have been a defender at Celtic to know anything about football............ Apparently.
Kevin Hudson
142 Posted 28/12/2011 at 10:13:20
Those who know better than Moyes do not have the credible facts to support their easily-defeated attempt at demagoguery.

The manager has provided the most consistent league returns in a generation, thus the 'argument,' has simplified to a merely cosmetic gripe over the 'attractiveness,' of our football, apparent certainty that he's 'run out of ideas,' or isn't the best placed individual to judge his own players worth.

When Everton win, it's either through luck or opposition ineptitude; when we lose, it is met by a gleeful sense of 'vindication.' Then follows the abuse, the hysteria, the cowardly fear-mongering and guess-work - incompatible with reality.
Phil Bellis
143 Posted 28/12/2011 at 10:42:10
Martin
Don't be so "respectful". You don't need a billionaire backer at a club to enable players to do the basics - honest
And please, stop calling my club "small" - we have our share of small-time, "we know our place" 30-something supporters, granted
Steve Pugh
144 Posted 28/12/2011 at 10:54:02
Can people please stop using dodgy refereeing decisions to justify their love/hate for Moyes. Whilst it is true that had a few decisions not been given our way we could be sitting in the relegation zone, had a few decisions not been given against us we could be sitting in or around the European spots. Therefore we are exactly were we deserve to be and people need to make their arguments based on this fact, and not their own constructed interpretation of incomplete information.
Gavin Ramejkis
145 Posted 28/12/2011 at 11:07:03
Kevin in really simple terms

Everton v Sunderland - a penalty to Osman for a miskick really easy one this was that down to luck or not?

Again a simple one without the speculative nonsense you seem to decry, without punctuation or attempt at verbosity overdrive - playing players out of form and to no effect and repeating that failed plan ad nauseum is that a genuine sign of genius or lack of an alternative plan you are willing to try?

Finally again speculative as per your own use of it in an argument but what is your definition of attractive football? Is it multiple passes, defence splitting moves, attacking players taking on an opposition player and leaving them in their wake, scoring goals with aplomb and putting an opposition side to the sword? As opposed to huff and puff and no final product in the final third of the pitch? Or maybe its not going down a goal most games and suddenly playing significantly better only to get a draw and single point from a game instead of starting well and trying for the three points?

Steve, you can't argue with dodgy decisions as they are hard cold facts and have decided games a prime example being the Osman penalty, we are where we are, the "deserved" tag is merely conjecture and speculation
Kevin Tully
146 Posted 28/12/2011 at 11:09:55
There is now a new breed of Evertonian - the "we would be relegated without Moyes" strain.

Just because we flirted with the drop over 10 years ago, and once with Mr Moyes, we are all scared of change.

I can just picture us all huddled in Goodison, afraid of falling off the edge of the world.

Every comparison or yardstick is made to relegated sides, no-one ever compares a new manager to Mourinho,Guardiola, Wenger or Ferguson.

Be happy with your lot Everton fans - we manage to stay up every year.

Our club & manager are a myth perpetuated by other managers and the media, don't believe the hype. They told us two years ago we were the best run club in the Premier League, we have not signed a player since.
Denis Richardson
147 Posted 28/12/2011 at 11:18:38
Steve, have a look at the results again, the league position we have is mainly down to luck rather than the tactics/manager ? that is what I am trying to say.

Some examples:

? Blackburn battered us, missed 2 penalties and hit the woodwork god knows how many times, we score with a pen in injury time to nick 3 points.

? The penalty against Sunderland where Ossie kicks the ground - right in front of the ref!

? It's 1-1 in the 89th minute and Zamora misses an open goal and we go on and win the game at Fulham

? The soft penalty awarded to us against Wolves.

? The undeserved (IMO) red card for the Bolton player after only 25 odd minutes etc.


On the other side, we were admittedly unlucky not to win against Villa and QPR had one shot. (I think we would have lost to the RS even if Rodwell had not been sent off.) Net the luck has really been with us this season so far and we could easily have 6-7 points less and not complain about the results ? trust me, I am not complaining about us being lucky.

So IMO our current league position is down to luck and not any great skill from Moyes. Had we not had the rub of the green so many times, we would be in the relegation zone.

So what am I trying to say? The tactics are simply not working. The points against Norwich and Wigan only came about once Moyes finally realised his starting XI was not the answer and changed things later on. What then happens? Same tactics next game from the off.....

He is either stubborn or seems incapable of learning and changing things when it seems obvious that some things are just not working now or never did (Neville in midfield, Cahill this season, one striker on his own with little support, Osman on the wing, Bily on the wing etc).

Another manager would see these things and do something about them ? it cannot get much worse given luck has replaced Neville and Cahill in the side so what is there to lose?

As said before, the other players may not be the answer but how will we know if they are not tried? Norwich, Swansea, QPR, Wolves ? these sides are full of Championship-level players but we still stick to the same old tactics and favourites in the side... that are not working without luck.

It doesn't take money to change tactics to suit the opposition or occasion. I just cannot see Moyes ever changing, with ot without money.
Dave Wilson
148 Posted 28/12/2011 at 11:04:56
Mick / Robbie/ Gavin

WTF are you talking about guys? No wonder the majority don't understand/agree/listen to you, if you are going to ignore the real facts.

It's clear from your previous posts that you are all aware of the financial situation at our club. And because you take an interest, you KNOW (nb: not think, you KNOW) that Moyes couldn't have hung onto ALL of his players.

We all KNOW ? because he has stated clearly ? that although the wages need to be lowered and some of the the debt has to be cleared, Moyes will be the one who decides who comes and who goes.

So Guys, let's pretend it was YOU and not Moyes who had to make this decision. You can:

A) Hold onto the ageing Arteta, Yakubu and Beckford ? two of whom wanted to leave anyway;

B) Move them on and use the fees gained and wages saved to fund the new extended contracts of Rodwell, Fellaini and Barkley.

Come on, guys, you are accusing others of glossing over the points. Let's have your answer... only remember you are making the same decision as DM; you CANT do both ? its either/or.

Be warned, though: If your answer is (A), you may find yourself in an even smaller minority than the one you are already in.

If your answer is (B) then you will understand why the majority don't see your points .

And if you want to introduce an answer (C) Like "I would have sold Saha / Anichebe / Hibbert / Osman / Heitinga etc." ? you may want to consider the fact that nobody wanted them.
Gavin Ramejkis
149 Posted 28/12/2011 at 12:00:31
Dave, its pretty obvious that the players had to go to keep the club afloat but by aligning to the Bullshitter Moyes has joined the problem, denial isn't a river in Egypt and by denying there was a problem has just delayed the inevitable and prolonged those myopic enough to still believe all is well at the club.

In terms of the WTF part I stand by there being no more harm to change than there has been with not making a change with it quite clearly failing and that can range from as little as changing the formation and players in the match day squad to changing the manager, anyone coming in would have exactly the same players at their disposal that Moyes no longer seems to get anything beyond a scraped draw out of.

As far as alternatives I'd look at the perennial benchwarmers or never has beens and never will bes - Bily, Anichebe to name two, McFadden and Hahneman signed for what exactly?
Robbie Shields
150 Posted 28/12/2011 at 12:12:56
Dave mate, your doing it again, claiming you speak for the majority, please stop it, it only weakens your argument, and you do have valuable points to take into account. Also, please don't associate myself with ever saying I KNOW anything, I observe, interpret and post an opinion, you will be pleased to KNOW, I don't KNOW anything, and have never consciously stated that, anyway I digress.

Let's plump for answer........

B) Move them on and use the fees gained and wages saved to fund the new extended contracts of Rodders, Felaini and Barkley.

So where did the money come from to give Anichebe the big new contract and McFadden, and Neville and Stracquilasi, who made those decisions and where they right? what was the combined cost of those signings to the club and how much of the $60 million in salaries do they draw? Also, if he did sell to pay for these guys then why the bloody hell hasn't he been playing Barkley?

I see where you are coming from, but you must take into account the fact that these 'replacements' cost loan fees and salaries too. One of Moyes' hands may have been tied behind his back, but he then went on and did the other one! IMHO of course ;)

All of which still doesn't explain away his dire defensive first tactics (7 defensive midfielders and defenders for example), shite dour defeatist comments, playing out of form favorites, slagging off our most potent threat in Drenthe for not defending enough, knife to a gun fight, blah blah bloody blah.

There, got it off my chest, now I need a whiskey!
Paul Gladwell
151 Posted 28/12/2011 at 12:50:17
Dave, you speak a lot of sense to be fair regarding Moyes over the years but when was the last time you left Goodison happy we had played great?

Lack of cash or whatever, playing seven defenders and one forward is shite. Neville and Heitinga in the middle is just plain shit too; we have better options than that and would have beaten Sunderland if he had taken those options.

As for Arteta, wasn't Moyes the one who said we never had to sell Arteta?
Phil Bellis
152 Posted 28/12/2011 at 13:03:41
Robbie

I do know something ? some of the best football I've ever seen came from the Everton teams of 66-70 and 84-87 It was a joy and a privilege to watch those sides; watching this team now is a duty, fast becoming a real chore.
Jamie Barlow
153 Posted 28/12/2011 at 13:08:08
Arteta put in a transfer request and Moyes gets blamed for letting him go and also gets the blame for trying to keep hold of Lescott after he put in a transfer request.

Why do people keep choosing to ignore that Moyes had to sell and it wasn't his choice?
Brendan McLaughlin
154 Posted 28/12/2011 at 13:34:14
Robbie #144
"I don't KNOW anything and have never conciously stated that"
Robbie #129
"Its great to read the postings of FELLOW BLUES WHO KNOW..."
Kevin Hudson
155 Posted 28/12/2011 at 13:58:59
Gavin,

I'll match your "really simple terms."

Rodwell's red card. Heitinga's freak OG. Balotelli's deflected goal. We could go on all day. (See swings and roundabouts).

Also, I couldn't help noticing that this is now the THIRD TIME you've pointed out the "verbosity," of my prose.

Now why is that..? Do you think that this is a smart move? And how exactly is it pertinent to an exchange of ideas about Everton?

Are you eager for me to dumb-down both argument & rhetoric in parallel/ sympathy to your own superficial, pickable analysis? Or, to your comic-book, (or cerebral penchant), for the term: "Gollum."?

Or your unsuccessful, repeated attempts to create a worthy, catch-on phrase pertaining to Moyes aka: "The Grinch Who Stole Football." (Genius).

(The Oxford University Debating Society is NOT missing it's keynote Speaker, folks..)

As I carefully explained last time, if you (clearly) disapprove of my writing style - then (in equally simple terms) you are not obliged to READ my comments or DIRECT posts to me - as you're simply eliciting another (so-called) VERBOSE REBUKE.
Dave Wilson
156 Posted 28/12/2011 at 16:02:54
Robbie

When Anichebe was scoring goals in Europe, he was earning a Grand a week . .a Grand a week, half the people posting here wont be too far away from that and although many people will claim its a Grand too much, there would still be hell to pay if he rediscovered his scoring form and we let him go Gosling style - He had to be re-signed.

Mcfadden and Straq will be amongst the lowest paid players in the Prem, I suspect the wages paid to the Yak or Arteta over six months would pay for all the loan signings this season. Lets be honest, we are getting exactly what we pay for here. we have repaid some of the debt by replacing class with dross and like everything in life, you get what you pay for.

I believe that given the same dilema both you and Gavin would have done exactly as Moyes did, You may have brought in different dross with the loose change, but you both KNOW the importance of tying up these youngsters.

Why doesnt he play Barkley ? I believe he knows the hopes and the expectations of many Evertonians ride on this lads shoulders, possibly unfairly so, but I have no doubt that Barkley will become a regular starter once the 40 point mark is past.

Paul #145

A simple and direct question, but I dont know the answer. I really cant remember the last time I came out of GP feeling we had played great - Man U two seasons ago ?
But the games against Spurs, City, Chelsea the shite and a couple of others since then have been satisfying. Does that count?

Let me ask you one Paul;

Given that we have now sold our "footballers" do you really think another manager would ditch experienced pro`s like Neville, Jagielka, Hibbert, Distin, Cahill, Saha, in our current situation ?

Actually I have another question ;Do you believe theres a guy out there that would get this lot playing the sort of football that would have you leaving GP feeling we had played great ?
Gavin Ramejkis
157 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:23:41
Kevin you still waste multiple paragraphs of guff to say what you could have said in one line - QED verbal diarrhea but if you chose an onslaught from the stance of large words makes it a winner then so be it and I'll continue to highlight it, as far as the G word goes email the webmasters of TW asking why that got me a ban yet fuckwits using the kopshite analogy continued posting on the same thread?

Kevin your style is your own but don't try the morality high horse as if a smattering of multiple syllables makes you such a charming cad of ages past, a flawed argument overflowing with tripe is still overflowing with tripe.
Gavin Ramejkis
158 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:31:49
....and Kevin if you fancy a flame match ask permission from the webmasters first as I really can't be arsed having to wait days to post to argue puerile points against the dimwitted
Phil Walling
159 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:34:20
Anichebe`s name keeps getting thrown into this debate although he hasn`t kicked a ball for months. As someone at last has pointed out, he was earning buttons when he was scoring goals in Europe-but that was before Moyes` coaching influence had been absorbed by the lad! I

f you remember, Moyes picked a fight with him about his desire to play for Nigeria and he was rapidly dispensed `to the boondocks`. Only when several other managers started showing an interest (I think Sven was one of them!) was the player brought in from the cold, taught to be a winger (God help us!) and a £20k a week contract proffered.

I wish begrudge the lad (and his agent) nothing but he really must be amongst the most overpaid players in the game-and this at a club without tuppence to their name!

I wonder on whose recommendation this happenned? Answers on a postcard, please.
Richard Dodd
161 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:24:30
As far as I am aware Victor played little part in our creditable draw at the Stadium of Light but still comes in for a slagging by one the `negotivos` who have recently migrated to our favourite site.
The truth is that the lad has much to offer and,in my view,would have established himself as a valuable member of the side this season had he not been struck down by injury.
He does,of course,labour under the same handicap as Hibbo and Ossie as a player developed by Everton.We do so love to hate our own, don`t we?
Ciarán McGlone
162 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:25:28
Good stuff lads, good stuff.

It's a pity that those with entrenced positions in support of Moyes, cannot find it within themselves to admit that his repeated tactics are failed.

It's like the playschool 'fingers in the ears' tactic..

To ignore the finer details of the managers decisions in each game - but instead simply point to his overall league placings as some sign of relative success - is churlish at best.

I just don't understand why the Moyes supporters post on this site - a site which is designed for deep analysis of each game.

If they're not interested in the finer detail of what Moyes does in each and every match - then why not post just once a season - and do your rather insipid appraisals then.
Kevin Hudson
163 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:16:21
There's the rub, Gavin.

You'll "continue to highlight," my writing style, as opposed to simply arguing the facts.

If you're not as "dim-witted," as I (apparently) am, then why hasn't the penny dropped? Ie: IF you think I'm wasting "multiple paragraphs," you are neither required to read, comment on, or invite more time-wasting verbosity from me.

How I choose to embroider my position is irrelevant to the actual arguments that I've repeatedly posited. Your puerile line of attack is symptomatic of someone who cannot succesfully argue their case, and typically descends to non-essential mockery in order to compensate for this deficiency.

By all means, console yourself with the mis-guided belief that your aversion to my "flawed argument," (Ie: Facts versus guess-work) wins the day. But please don't presume to deviously pin the moral high-ground / hubris presumption onto me.

Equally, don't try to drag me into whatever issue it is ToffeeWeb's Editorial team have with YOUR writing style.
Richard Dodd
164 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:48:01
Hey,Gavram! Time for some support from me?
You know (as my alto ego)you have only to ask!
Paul Gladwell
165 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:39:25
Dave how many teams outside the top six can pay player £70k a week?

No matter what you say about our squad being small etc it is still far better than most in a piss poor league and he still goes all negative against shite like Stoke and Norwich, teams who have so many players I don't even know, so yes I do think there are men out there who would maybe do better.

You have stated we were right to get shut of Arteta then have shouted about getting rid of our best players.

We got shut of Arteta and Pienaar and that has hurt us but we have added Coleman, Barkley etc and I saw enough from Barkley to say he should be in the middle instead of those two donkeys as the last two games Phil Neville has been shocking, its all well and good keeping Barkley under wraps but who will that benefit? Man Utd when they buy him.

Put it this way, Dave, you can bet every Prem football fan has seen a good 90 minutes from their team this season bar us; even Blackburn.... the man's stubborn tactics are the reason Saha and Co are getting slated as we play so deep leaving our attack isolated, his whole gameplan is caution.
Paul Gladwell
166 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:54:52
Remember the last time we had a glut of goals?last January when injuries forced him to play 4 4 2 with Saha and Beckford, oh what would we do to witness something similar against pisspoor teams at home, he has done a good job over the years but at present he is playing a stinker but to some he can do no wrong.
Bobby Mallon
167 Posted 28/12/2011 at 20:09:51
Jim Knightley/John Ford and any other fans who bang on about a good defence and a rubbish attack... well, who gave us a rubbish attack???

MOYES did!!!

He sold the Yak and he sold Beckford and now he winges that we don't have a cutting edge.
Dave Wilson
168 Posted 28/12/2011 at 20:05:43
Paul

I believe we were right to get rid of Arteta, I also believe he was our most talented player, but such is our current financial situation, we no longer have the luxury of dealing with transfer matters purely from a football perspective. If Moyes didn't take age and future valuation into consideration, he`d have been betraying the lot of us.

I`m watching the Old Firm game as I type this and both teams are throwing men forward like there's no tomorrow, we would all love to go back to seeing games like that but the EPL financial stakes are too high,

I can't agree that other teams attack more than we do, it's simply not true. The EPL is the richest league in the world and 14/15 clubs are terrified to drop out; it may look as if they are all out attack on MotD but every full game I watch is a war of attrition.

Fear rules them all, mate, and it's not just Moyes. You`ve seen all these teams managed by so-called "Golden boys" against Everton and you`ll know that you can count their combined attacks ? never mind shots on target ? on one hand.

If we are ever to shake the shit of mediocrity from our shoes, we need major investment. THEN perhaps we could look at the manager.

Anyway Paul, interesting debate, one I`m sure will continue well into 2012.
Robbie Shields
169 Posted 28/12/2011 at 23:33:03
Dave, I agree that an awful lot of teams play with fear in their eyes, but doesn't that then give someone with a bit of footballing nous an opportunity to elevate themselves above that fear and take a dire EPL by storm? I personally think it does, especially given the talent and salaries at our disposal, but I also personally think that it is beyond Moyes given what I've seen.

Brendan #148, come on, play nicely, talk about being missquoted! You missed off the next few very important words....

"it's great to read the postings of fellow blues who KNOW it COULD be all so different just given a change in direction."

You don't work for the Echo do you???????

A bit funny that, I can picture you now hitting Find in Internet explorer to find the word KNOW in the thread just to see if I had used it, eureka, got the hypocritical little tike. But I suppose it does go to prove one thing, some blues do not comprehend what others are trying to say and are instead entrenched in their particular view, misreading and misquoting others just for the sake of it. Open your mind just a little Brendan, you may be surprised at what you see.
James Flynn
170 Posted 29/12/2011 at 02:51:52
Dave (160) - "If we are ever to shake the shit of mediocrity from our shoes, we need major investment. THEN perhaps we could look at the manager."

Well and simply said.



Ray Roche
171 Posted 29/12/2011 at 09:16:10
Bobby Mallon@159


"He sold the Yak and he sold Beckford "
Yes, he did, the Yak wanted his regular signing on fee and Beckford can't get a game at Leicester.
His problem was not replacing the Yak with someone with a smaller arse to warm the bench. Regardless of what Moyes says about outgoing transfers I still believe he's covering Kenwrights back.
Phil Walling
172 Posted 29/12/2011 at 09:32:11
You are 100% right in that assertion,Ray.You look at Moyes and you see Kenwright-the closest duo in football.
Amazing how much loyalty £3.5 mii a year can buy,isn`t it?
Ray Roche
173 Posted 29/12/2011 at 09:50:36
Phil,
I'd be INCREDIBLY loyal for half that amount.
Andy Crooks
174 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:37:00
Dave,you really think that half the people posting here won't be too far off a grand a week? Things must be better on Merseyside than over here.
Dave Wilson
175 Posted 29/12/2011 at 17:48:22
Fair comment Andy, Some will be earning that much but it was silly to suggest half were. I`ll retract that

I take it the rumours about you quaffing Champaigne whilst posting on TW from the side of your swimming pool arent 100% correct then ?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads