Anichebe rescues sorry display

, 4 February, 211comments  |  Jump to most recent
Wigan Athletic 1 - 1 Everton
With just one defeat in their last six games on Wigan's home turf, recent history is on Everton's side as they look to build on the momentum gained from the wins over Aston Villa Fulham and Manchester City, not to mention the arrival of Jelavić and Pienaar. Sylvain Distin was back in with Jack Rodwell still unavailable as he recovers from hamstring strains, while Tim Cahill retains his place and was named as captain despite no more goals. Pienaar was clearly well happy to be back with Everton where he belongs and set about putting some pace back into the left flank, getting well involved and putting in a lovely throughball for Stracqualursi but he was offside.

Pienaar again did well to set up Cahill with a smart ball into the middle but Cahill's supposed shot was hopelessly high and wide. Bosejour got down the Everrton right and swung in a couple of good crosses. Stracqualursi at least got his first shot on target but it was only a weak prod after good work by Donovan.

Stracq's control and ball play was disappointing and Wigan got Beausejour in around Hibbert yet again, and he was having trouble staying on his feet as Everton started to look the better team but showed less likelihood of getting close to the Wigan goal, as a Di Santo mis-hit forced a desperate save from Howard. That gave Wigan more confidence and they won the first corner on 22 mins.

Fellaini was doing a good job breaking up the play but his distribution was very lacking at times, which was not like him. Heitinga gifted Wigan a dangerous free-kick that Gomez lofted over wall and bar. Pienaar won Everton's first corner that Heitinga got a head on but Pienaar skied his shot poorly to finish the move.

A Baines free-kick somehow came in behind Everton's three tall players and Heitinga should probably have done a lot better with the follow-up as the sleet came down in sheets. Gibson was having something of a nightmare, making a poor pass, and the Wigan move forced a great goal-saving block by Hibbert.

With Everton looking increasingly out of sorts, a better set-up by Baines for Gibson was completely wasted as Everton finished a less-than-inspiring first half rather lamely with nothing to show.

Neville rather than Jelavic replaced Cahill, who had taken a knock, with Fellaini playing further forward instead. As the required hour-mark approached with nothing of note to report from an increasingly poor game of football, Moyes finally readied his new acquisition for his Premier League debut. Gibson finally got one on target but it was very weak, as Jelavic finally replaced Stracqualursi but bizarrely dummied a golden chance to put Everton ahead.

At least his arrival briefly livened up the game, but the quality was still shockingly poor in so many areas, real bottom-of-the-table stuff as Everton lowered their standards to Wigan's level, as Martinez bought on Rodallega and Jones. Most of the time, it was like watching pinball, with any continuity in possession lost to a random ricochets.

And that was a perfect set-up for the most attrocious goal Howard has ever let in, the spin of the ball from a defelction off Neville bouncing in front of him and turning in nicely off his leg stump! Unbelievable!

The absolute rubbish continued with Everton players called offside again and again, while Moyes made his final play, Anichebe in place of Hibbert. Baines finally won only Everton's second corner, then taking their third, which was headed back to him, with Baines having time to deliver a perfect cross for Anichebe to head cleanly into the Wigan goal — the first piece of crisp Premier League football in the entire dreadful second half.

Figueroa held back Jelavic, giving Everton a great free-kick opportunity that Baines curled harmlessly over. Four minutes of added time saw Wigan win a corner that Howard punched poorly into a crowded goalmouth and Everton were lucky to escape further punishment. Pretty poor fare overall.

Everton: Howard, Hibbert (83' Anichebe), Heitinga, Distin, Baines, Pienaar, Fellaini, Gibson, Donovan, Cahill (46' Neville), Stracqualursi (60' Jelavic). Subs: Mucha, Drenthe, Gueye, Duffy.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (211)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Alex Cooke
1 Posted 04/02/2012 at 16:10:37
The game is there to be won at the moment but, as ever cautious George must defend every corner with eleven in the penalty area, and waits until the point of blow your brains out boredom before making a proper attacking change. Is it so taboo to bring on some early subs and have three or four exciting players on the pitch??? Why Neville?? Shocking decision. Drenthe easily.
Alex Cooke
2 Posted 04/02/2012 at 16:10:37
Surely two up front? Don't make him plough the lone furrow like Saha, ffs...
John Audsley
3 Posted 04/02/2012 at 16:55:57
Utter shite, dull as dish water and Moyes never had a clue what to do all game.

I don't think it was the same manager/players who did so well against City.

Another point closer to safety though......
Andy Crooks
4 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:00:43
Neville should not have scored an og as he should not have been on the pitch. Why did Duffy not start? I actually can't be bothered wasting any more words on Moyes.
Ernie Baywood
5 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:00:03
If Howard's concession was pathetic then nothing can describe the half time substitution.

The first half wasn't pretty but we DID play some football. Generally it was started by Fellaini who remains (despite lots of comments on TW) our best midfielder. So we throw him up front and play our worst midfielder in the centre instead.

Just beyond any sort of understanding for anyone who understands anything about football. And he had halftime to make that decision. Odd beyond odd.
Andy Codling
6 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:03:58
Moyes needs sacking based on his Neville for Cahill decision alone. Utter dross as usual from the Premier's third highest earner!!!!!!
Steve Guy
7 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:06:22
I said after the City game I believed we would have really turned a corner if we battered Wigan. No corner turned as far as I can see. Poor.
Anto Byrne
8 Posted 04/02/2012 at 16:58:45
Bring on Neville for the misfiring Cahill. More Moyes negativity for a match waiting to be won.

Wigan are fucking shite and we had 3 shots on goal all afternoon. Nice goal from Anchibe but he should have been on at half-time with Jelavic.

Poor defending from Neville for their goal even if Howard fucked it up.

I would have liked to see more crosses for the Stracq to get on the end of and playing Fellaini as a forward... well, I just don't know.

Certainly the game called for an attacking 4-4-2 and we didn't see that until Anchibe came on for the last 10.

Dismal affair... one point closer to safety.
Tom Bowers
9 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:00:41
Isn't it just so typical of Moyes and Everton to turn in a display like this against the bottom club?

Moyes as usual stubborn as ever buys a £6 million pound player who isn't good enough to start but a player who has scored one goal in 13 months and not 100% fit is a starter. Hence the usual 4-4-1-1 formation against, dare I say again the bottom club. Just pathetic, Moyes.

Despite this, they started brightly for the first 10 minutes but as usual showed very little real commitment or prowess in the final third. This prompted the bottom club to get some confidence and made the game all the more difficult for Everton.

It was no surprise when Everton concede first, albeit a freak goal but enough to force Moyes into his usual desperation substitution to save his face and a point.

Shameful, Moyes... just shameful. Please quit for God's sake.
Dermot O'Brien
10 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:04:42
After the almost euphoria at beating City I was looking forward to us winning by a few goals at wigan but deep down I kind of wasn't writing off that it would be a load of shite. It will be the same in the cup against "lower" opposition. Load of fucking shit. Moyes you tool.
Richard Dodd
11 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:06:23
With 14 games to go, we are only 10 points off safety and yet another year in the top league. Just can`t see why my fellow Evertonians can`t see this as a very positive situation, given that we are supposed to be `at death`s door`. Half the clubs in the Prem would swop with our apparent doomsday scenario!
Tom Owen
12 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:09:25
Negativity from the manager has cost us once again, for me. Neville on for Cahill says it all. Hugely frustrating after such an encouraging performance mid-week. Why can we not string together a few wins together. Wigan were dire and there's no excuses why we couldn't get three points today. People will say Jelavic failed to make an impact, but what service did he have? Nothing. When will Moyes ever learn?

Another wasted season were we could of achieved something.

On a positive note, Pienaar played well. Great to have him back. A bright spark today. Hopefully him and Baines will revive there partnership.
Steve Guy
13 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:12:21
Doddy. the only ones who'd swap with us are in the bottom three. Straw Clutching is what you are doing.
James Martin
14 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:11:44
Sad that a half-fit Pienaar who hasn't played in ages was our best player. Shows the difference between us and Spurs.

Gibson, Fellaini, Neville and Cahill are too slow to be playing for us. Fellaini and Neville are just so negative, they take the impetus out of every single move and have no creativity whatsoever.

Meanwhile, Howard is having his worst season ever for us and the defence was back to its usual pondeorus self, following the example of our impotent midfield by not putting a tackle in anywhere.

Jelavic must've wondered what he's arrived to ? he'll be anorexic feeding off the scraps our carthorse central midfielders will give him.
Marc Williams
15 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:08:04
Big Vic you are like a NEW signing fella !
That's 3 games & 5 points we wouldn't have salvaged without your goals.

Keep it up & I will genuinely apologise for calling you a waste of your dad's sponk.

Brian Waring
16 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:11:36
Didn't catch any of the game because I had to work. Reading the match report, what was the thinking behind bringing Neville on instead of an attacking player? It didn't sound as if we were under the cosh or anything.
Andy Roberts
17 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:09:25
What goes through his mind?? I cannot fathom the substitution of Cahill for Neville!

Would it be too much to expect positivity from Moyes? Jelavic and Straq up front??? I shouldn't have thought so.

I really am beginning to hate this boring negative shit that he serves up every game. What a wasted opportunity to build some momentum after Fulham and City. Fucking clueless.
Rich Pemberton
18 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:17:26
I'm a big fan of Moyes. I hate the constant and excessive negativity that is ironically levelled at Moyes as his biggest weakness day-in, day-out. However, this last week has been the most positive we have had as a club for many many months, yet the manager has just played one of his most dumbfounding tactics I can remember.

For once we have some positive momentum and attacking options yet we have just luckily drawn a game we should have won comfortably.

We all know what we would have done or at least what we wouldn't have done, but that really was one of the most bizarre fuck-ups Moyes has managed.

Hugely frustrating.
Nick Entwistle
19 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:12:38
Undefeated in five has never been so uninspiring. I really thought there was a shift in momentum after the cup game and City.

Believed that we had played so poor all season that we could kick on and play somewhere near our potential. Looks like a shite state of affairs is all we are this season.

Pienaar and Baines were showing the best of old in patches which bodes well, but these dropped points were down to Moyes. Neville in the middle with Fellaini up front instead of Drenthe or Jelly was a big bowl of dog meat.
Milos Milenkovic
20 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:04:43
I totally agree with you Ernie, it was absolutely shocking substitution from Moyes. Against last team in the league, first thing on his mind is to defend.

On the positive side, I think Jelavic looked very promising and Pienaar had a very good game.
Tom Owen
21 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:17:17
The Moyes lovers will be quick to point out that Moyes changed the game by bringing on Victor who got the equalizer. Moyes will make an attacking change when he's forced too. When we're 1-0 down and there's only 10 minutes to go. 10 minutes too late.

He still doesn't know how to change a game and continues to play safe by bringing on Neville for Cahill and push Fellaini up. For me, I would've partnered Strac with Jelavic, or put Drenthe behind Strac.
Anthony Jones
22 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:17:06
Two wins and the delusional start to think Moyes has turned a new leaf.

No Drenthe, one forward, no Barkley, Neville on for Cahill?!!

Boring, predictable dross.

One swallow doesn't make a summer.
Roman Sidey
23 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:16:27
Doddy, I admire you. You are one in a million.

Moyes out.
Phil Head
24 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:26:35
Another 2 points lost by the ultra-negative tactics of David Moyes.

If I was Roysten Drenthe, I would rip up the loan contract he's on and walk out on the club, I honestly don't know what he has to do to please dithering Davey. The guy was man of the match in the last game against City and gets rewarded by being dropped today, and not only that, didn't even get on the pitch, in a game that was wide open and there to be won.

The game was simply screaming out for someone to be positive and run at a defender instead of the likes of Fellaini and Cahill taking three touches to control the ball before heading back towards their own goal and passing it backwards.
Ian Edwards
25 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:20:33
Neville on for Cahill....

Like for like when Jelavic came on. Two up front only for the last few minutes against relegation fodder.

Welcome to Goodison, Mr Jelavic... marooned up front on your own chasing long balls has started. Your career is over having signed for this Manager. In 2 years your confidence will be shattered and you will be offloaded to a championship team just like Moyes's other forward victims.
John Keating
26 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:20:18
Howard's command in his box is atrocious!! How often do we see him flapping about at crosses, punching ? if you can call it that ? rather than catching???

I don't give a flying fuck about any spin on that ball today ? the fucking one-armed man could have got that!!

You could have the Barcelona team on the pitch, if the goalie is missing those sort of balls, they'd be up shit creek too!
Danny Kewley
27 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:18:17
Why oh why is he so negative? Moyes had the perfect opportunity to set out a good stall today and promote Everton as an attacking side, instead of the dross we've had to put up with pre-transfer window.

As for Howard, the guy is becoming a bigger clown week by week! Through the game he just wasn't paying attention and I thought something dodgy would happen.

Stracq wasn't on his game; Jelly looks good but we've only seen a trifle of him! As regards Neville; why didn't he jump through the transfer window? But at least we picked up an away point!
Richard Dodd
28 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:23:46
Roman, what I can`t get to grips with is that so many of our breed are guilty of the very sin they accuse Moyes of: NEGATIVITY!

Instead of rejoicing in an away point gained, they prefer to rue the two we supposedly lost. Bizarre!
Trevor Lynes
29 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:21:17
I wrote yesterday that EFC is now fast becoming the graveyard of strikers. They get no service and now we are reduced to waiting for crosses to scramble headed goals because we cannot create anything on the FLOOR.

No matter what our position in the league means, we are a team of spoilers and that was also the way we played against City. If we succeed, it's by EFFORT and never from great outfield play.

We are still playing the least entertaining football in the division (and probably other divisions too)..... If we could for once beat a side comprehensively by playing top class football, our fans would be in raptures.

Last week we beat the top team..this week we almost lost to the bottom team. DM is genuinely afraid to play two 'real' strikers together as his emphasis in most games is to not get beat!!
Ian Edwards
30 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:32:03
The team Dreary will pick when everyone is fit:

Howard
Hibbert Distin Jagielka Baines
Neville Rodwell Heitinga Fellaini
Osman
Cahill
Nick Waters
31 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:33:38
Correct Richard ? just as we rejoiced at the home point against Norwich and against Blackburn, and don';t forget how we commiserated with each other after losing against Bolton.
John Daley
32 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:38:04
I have no real understanding of how living with tourettes can impact upon ones daily life. However, thanks to Tim Howard, I now know all too well the agog look of shock, shaking heads and sniggering little shits that seem to surround you when you randomly shout 'twat', in public, at the top of your voice.
Roman Sidey
33 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:35:04
Richard, I was being genuine. I admire your positivity. Some of us just aren't that blessed though, mate.

Most of us were positive for a long time, even after Moyes became more and more negative. Now, it is just getting too much. With comments about how he has to bring the crowds back and such, he goes about sabotaging himself.

How many people do you think will go through the gate next week for the Chelsea game? 29k for City, so it would be a brave man to suggest more than 30k will turn up next game after today's shite.

There's negativity, and there's reality coupled with utter disappointment.

I know you see it differently, Doddy, but a draw to the bottom side in the league is 2 points dropped, regardless of location and weather.
Michael Kenrick
34 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:39:29
You didn't watch the game, did you Doddy?

Just looking at the result, eh?
Brian Waring
35 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:39:21
I think the problem is, Richard, is that we were up against the bottom placed team who have only won once at home all season.
John Keating
36 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:38:01
Richard. Nick is spot on. If we were picking up 3 points at home and 1 away we'd be in the top tier. So when we play the bottom club after picking up 3 against the top club surely we can expect a win!! It was a hiccup ? the Man City game.

We didn't want it until they went ahead. Moyes is saying the City game took it out of us!!!! Well, Wigan played Tuesday as well. Sunderland and Norwich played Wednesday and I see they won. Moyes should not be using excuses like that.

Remember Tuesday night and everyone was getting carried away?? Well they're back down to earth with a bump now eh? Shite!!!
Brian Denton
37 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:39:53
It was the manner of how the draw was 'achieved' Doddy......
Mark Stone
38 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:28:08
"With 14 games to go, we are only 10 points off safety and yet another year in the top league. Just can`t see why my fellow Evertonians can`t see this as a very positive situation, given that we are supposed to be `at death`s door`. Half the clubs in the Prem would swop with our apparent doomsday scenario!"

Its because of our motto, Doddy 'Only The Best Is Good Enough'. Man City might be able to go out and spend £200bn on players, and might have had a brand new stadium paid for by Sport England, but with a motto like Pride in Battle they shouldn't be able to compete with us. Don't you know we won the fucking league in 1891? (PS 1988 - 2002 never happened. When Moyes took over we were boss).
Dean Adams
39 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:36:49
Richard Dodd

Stop being such a wind up merchant. It was poor management, as well you know. Sometimes I think you just love to wind up those poor fellas on here who don't get you!!!!
Roman Sidey
40 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:48:44
Perhaps our new motto should be "Keeping shit clubs in the Premier League since 1993".
Mark Stone
41 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:47:25
PS Doddy we are the only team in the league who don't always beat these 'shit teams'. You wouldn't find the likes of Liverpool or Chelsea coming away from the DW stadium with just a point.
Richard Dodd
42 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:42:44
No, Michael, I didn`t. I don`t cheat the Premier League/Everton by watching pirate sites for nothing.

I listened to the radio broadcast via the official site.
Brian Denton
43 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:53:51
Mark, you have to be careful with saying things like that because they are usually easy to counter. Liverpool, for example, lost at Bolton a couple of weeks ago. It wouldn't take 5 mins to find other examples where these shit teams have beaten top teams. You just give ammo to Doddy!
Bert Fieldhouse
46 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:59:45
David Moyes ? just fuck off to Celtic.

Bring Duncan Ferguson in.
Dean Adams
47 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:59:29
Richard Dodd 419
Unlike the club who cheat the fans out of thier hard earned every week!!!!!!
Brian Hill
48 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:54:00
Mark Stone, unfortunately you would find the Shite coming away from Wigan with just a point, 21/12/2011 Wigan 0 the Shite 0. Although this obviously does not excuse our ridiculous performance today.
John Keating
49 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:02:53
Richard. After the City game you posted "Blue Bill Buys Himself Some Time"... Some people agreed with you.

I think if posted tonight they, would ALL answer NO!!
Amit Vithlani
50 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:01:46
Andy Codling - an outrageous and uncalled for attack on a fellow poster. Grow up Lad and express your opinions without resorting to juvenile insults.
Paul Olsen
51 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:02:49
Thought we looked likely for the first 15. Straq running like a madman, Fella picking up every ball and Pienaar looking the biz.

Went a bit downhill from there...

Gibson really played some awful balls today, poor performance by him in a poor overall display. Donovan wasn´t on his best either, so we were lacking in many departments.
Paul Ferry
52 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:55:14
You didn't watch the game then stop spouting your utter fucking gibberish - love the Tory wont go to pirate stuff attitude - pure Freshfield - negativity? - negativity is the parasitic, myopic, plain dumb passivity that you trot out - hey here's a lesson for you, is it negative to ask for change? I wish it was January still and we didnt have to put up with your utter unbelievable drivel
Brian Waring
54 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:07:44
So just because other teams never came away with all the pts from Wigan, we are supposed to all be happy? What a weak excuse.
Phil McKeown
55 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:03:54
Or unlike fans who actually go to the game doddy

Today was typical moyes , starts with his bollocks 4411 (no sharpey it Fucking isn't 442 regardless what shite you spurt on the radio cos cahill is a midfielder )

His half time sub was an abomination , it should have been drenthe or Jelavic on , then he realises we need to change it too late and finally makes the change , we score and look threatening .

It ain't Fucking rocket science , very disgruntled yet again by a very poor management attitude
Colin Hughes
56 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:01:33
That win against City means nothin if you cant beat bottom of the league the following game, I cant believe what I witnessed at half time when Neville came on. What the hell goes through his head, Wigan weren't even a threat. We take almost 5000 fans to an away game, and he makes a shocking negative sub like that at half time, I wish he'd grow a pair of balls and go for it, what other manager would of made that sub, Jelavic for Cahill, and Drenthe for Gibson pushin peinaar into the middle, should of been the choice
Amit Vithlani
57 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:08:31
Poor pitch, poor teams, horrible match. Half time substitution bewildering, but when Jelavic dummied and Felli was primed to shoot, all may have been forgiven. Not to be.

Positives? From what I saw of Jelavic he looks sharp. Baines confidence is returning.

Straq ran out of puff and Gibson had a shocker. Distin and Pienaar very rusty. Felli looked confused upfront.

Howard needs a spell on the bench. He is a ticking time bomb to his next howler. He clearly has concentration issues - the most notable rickets come in games where the opposition aren't dominant. Twice against Blackburn and now Wigan.

Kieran Kinsella
58 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:10:04
Everyone is being a little bit OTT here. It was a poor game in bad conditions against a team that were desperate not to lose. It would have been wrong to drop Straq after his last game for the Croatian and as far as being negative well he did at least start with Pienaar and Donovan. Drenthe is hit and miss as is Anichebe which means that fans love 'em when they do something good but crucify Moyes when they play poorly. Had Drenthe been in the team today it would have been instead of Pienaar and if he'd played poorly (as he does 50% of the time) everyone would have vilified Moyes for not playing Pienaar. The truth is that the team isn't any good and we knew that all along and I don't know why anyone expected that to change after one good result. Moyes has been given no money to spend and has to sell to buy. We spent less on the Croatian fellow than we spent on Nick Barmby about 15 years ago. He isn't going to be the new Dixie Dean. He might be the new Kevin Campbell if we're lucky but take that up with Kenwright and the bank rather than Moyes. You get what you pay for.
Tony Christian
59 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:18:35
Reality Check: We've just taken four points from six against team going for league and team fighting for survival. The weather was atrocious and some players looked a little leggy on a slippy surface. Wigan scored a fluke. Chill out and enjoy your weekend.
Dean Adams
60 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:16:13
Howard looks shakey! Might be the tourettes. WE looked a bit wobbly at the back when Distin is in the side. We have looked much more confident in the last few games with JH and Duffy, so why not stick with it.
Mick Wrende
61 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:13:28
A point away at wigan - isn't that wonderful. What a positive thing to celebrate on a Saturday night. I am ecstatic with glee. Roll on next week so i can watch more of this breathtaking beautiful football as we sweep majestically towards the opposition goal. Here was I thinking I might never see such splendor at everton again.
John Keating
62 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:18:31
Amit. The problem regarding Howard is that unfortunately we have nobody just now to replace him.
Mucha and Hannemann are worse.
We have to stick with the arsehole until the end of the season.
Where we will get any money from for all the positions we need to replace/fill/back up only God knows !
Shaun Brennan
63 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:25:22
Richard no wonder you behave the way you do. You have been brainwashed by Evertons own radio stream via the official website.

Hey if hitler and Geobbels can do it to a whole nation, surely the OS can do it to formbys very own fool on the hill.
Mike O'Neill
64 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:19:48
Dross is a kind word for what we witnessed today. Totally fed up with Moyes - the Neville substitution is one of his very worst ever ... and there've been a few. It was crying out for a spark from Drenthe but Moyes obviously doesn't trust him, not even against shite opposition, so that's him out the door come June. We only really went for the game in the last 10 minutes - WHY????? (sound of head banging against brick wall)
Peter Cummings
65 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:10:14
A very predictable display after the Lord Mayor's Show last game. We were VERY lucky to salvage a point today as Wigan took the game to us from the start.

When they scored with yet another Howard blunder, it was no more than they deserved. Then he nearly gifted a winner by his habit of punching instead of catching.

A terrible game to watch... aided by lousy refereeing. I hate to say it but you were warned (by me) after the City game; their manager quoted ''we underestmated'' Everton... Ditto, mate, but at least we swiped a point.
Keith Glazzard
66 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:20:06
Cahill has done little to justify his place all season, so starting with him is bad enough. But to substitute him with Neville is three steps backwards.
Jamie Barlow
67 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:35:08
Neville for Cahill. It just upset everything. The players, set up, crowd. Bad, bad substitution. The players we had on the bench and he picks that twat.

Having said that, even with Neville in the side, we should have the players to beat them. They were shite.
Mark Stone
68 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:33:33
Brian Denton and Brian Hill

You both missed my sarcasm (easy mistake with the written word). Wigan held both Liverpool to a 0-0 and 1-1 draw at the DW in the last few weeks. My previous comment was also sarcastic.
Mark Stone
69 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:39:49
Sorry - meant 'and Chelsea' after Liverpool
Phil McKeown
70 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:03:54
Or unlike fans who actually go to the game doddy

Today was typical moyes , starts with his bollocks 4411 (no sharpey it Fucking isn't 442 regardless what shite you spurt on the radio cos cahill is a midfielder )

His half time sub was an abomination , it should have been drenthe or Jelavic on , then he realises we need to change it too late and finally makes the change , we score and look threatening .

It ain't Fucking rocket science , very disgruntled yet again by a very poor management attitude
John Keating
71 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:39:48
Look at the home page.
Look at the Colums, Articles and Mailbag headings.
Only Ste Kenny has a headline that " may " relate to truth.
I wonder what this weeks headings will be ?
We are our own worse enemies !
Ray Robinson
72 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:41:32
The substitution at half time was ridiculous - even more ridiculous was keeping Neville on and taking Hibbert off for Anichebe. I just wish Moyes would occasionally "go for it". Wigan were there for the taking.

And Doddy, what is negative about being dissatisfied with a point at Wigan? In my mind, it's a positive because we know that we can do better. YOU are the negative one in this instance by accepting such dross without complaint.
Brian Hill
73 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:36:47
Utterly shameful "performance". If I did my job like that I would be fired immediately. What are these people actually being paid for? Can anybody explain why Moyes, Neville, Hibbert, Howard et al will retire as multi-millionaires when everybody in the real world has to show some modicum of ability in their profession? Stupefying.
Paul Ferry
74 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:43:39
Can we have less shit on here about Timmy and tourettes; that's fucking out of order. He is a not very good goalie, leave it at that.
Dan Schweizer
75 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:32:32
The tactics were so bad today, I'm speechless! Moyes managed to get everyone negative in one game after such a positive week, he must be delighted.
Richard Dodd
76 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:45:37
OK, I moaned when he made THAT substitution. But are any of you seriously saying that WE are better qualified to manage Everton than Moyes?

Come on........
Ciarán McGlone
77 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:54:21
No Richard, we're not better qualified. That doesn't mean we wouldn't be better at it though.
Peter Laing
78 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:55:44
Makes a change Richard Dodd from cheating Sefton council during work time - what a wanker !
Paul Ferry
79 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:53:03
"But are any of you seriously saying that WE are better qualified to manage Everton than Moyes?"

Where does this Freshfield fool get his logic from? Is that really the burning issue of the day? This is a thread not a job application. We comment here; we do not apply. This is one of the most absurd posts you have tapped out, and we're talking oceans not streams. Not one of us is saying that we ought to be managing EFC, we are, and listen very carefully in Freshfield, I'll say this very slowly, simply expressing our views. We have a right to do so. That said, however, my guess is that there are people here who could have done a better job than Moyes today.

Remember, you negative ones who dare to criticize divine Davey, in this thread Freshfield's court jester has stated loudly and clearly that we ingrates ought to be chuffed that it looks like we might make 40 points and stay in the prem again. Silly us. What meanies we are. 40 points is the new Holy Grail. Join me and Doddy on the Yellow Brick Road.
Chris Fisher
80 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:59:00
This is what it's like being an Everton fan though, every now and then they will do something to give you hope and get you pumped up... then they will bring you crashing back down to earth!!!!!!
Ray Roche
81 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:55:53
Richard, you don't have to be better placed to "manage" Everton than Moyes, but, FFS, his constant negative play, crap substitutions and bizarre decisions mean that most people could do just as good a job at selecting a SIDE that would entertain more.

I have already posted on the matchday thread that Everton have a good record this season for salavaging a point when coming back from a goal down. Why? Because Dithering Dave HAS to play a more attacking game, even if it's only for the usual final 10 mins, in order to snatch a point. So, why doesn't he START with a more positive team selection, instead of chasing the game? Cretin.
Dan Schweizer
82 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:58:37
The decision to play Fellaini upfront for hoofballs absolute dire football again, but I think the worst is when Moyes chucks on a striker at the end and we salvage a point. This is a recurring event which is driving everyone insane. Why can't Moyes see games like these are crying for some attacking?
Kiern Moran
83 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:10:48
Is Anichebe now our leading goalscorer? Not bad for a once pariah.
Paul Ferry
84 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:16:20
The fact that the useless fucking pudding is our EQUAL top scores, says far more about the entire team and the manager than it does about the aforementioned useless fucking lump.
Peter Warren
85 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:20:59
Doddy not more qualified . But we're playin Wigan on a crap wet day, we lack creativity and threat in front of goal , support is down but we'rehigh on confidence and again moyes plays safe. It makes no sense. Loads of us know moyes has qualities but his negatives, the biggest being he is negative and never throws off the shackles means he does our nut in and lots of us sick of him and want change
Peter Warren
86 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:27:18
Ray - spot on
Chris Butler
87 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:26:17
The problem is that his substitutions send the message to the opposition that we're not going out for the win. Neville on for Cahill then he scores an own goal you coudn't make it up. Jelavic deserved more time so he could do something we were very lucky to get a point in the end really.
Dave Wilson
88 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:09:28
Just to talk about the match - a opposed to attacking Doddy or Moyes.

Conditions today were desperate, ANY team would have struggled to play Joined up footy in that.

I`m getting sick of having to come from behind because of indivdual errors, we must be the only team who can find themselves behind without the opponents having a shot on goal - shades of Newcastle.

Made up for Big Vic - cant help chuckling as he continues to come off the bench to confound his critics

Well done to the 5-6 thousand hardy souls who braved the conditions. Terrific support
Eugene Ruane
89 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:27:05
Paul, 464/465

Agree. (TWICE!)
Denis Richardson
90 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:18:40
I don't get annoyed anymore, we all know that Moyes will never change and will always be a ridiculously defense minded manager. Whilst he remains Everton's manager, our 'style' of football will remain the way it is.

With the arrival of Gibson I hoped that I would never have to see Heitinga or Neville in our midfield, I guess Moyes juut cannot help himself - playing 3 holding midfielders against the bottom club. Still we've seen this type of thing many times before (west ham away, newcastle at home a season or two ago etc).

We won't go down this year as teams like Wolves and Wigan are worse and 37-38 points should be enough to avoid the trap. Only slight hope we have this season is the FA cup.

It truly is a sorry state of affairs when we're sitting in February and our top scorer has 4 goals! That's what you get with a defend first and try to nick on strategy.

Will be interesting to see what the gate will be at home to chelsea.
Phil Walling
91 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:28:04
Have to agree,today was utter fucking shite-and Moyes blames the pitch!
Must say,however,Victor has come back a far better finisher than when he went on his holidays.....just like a new signing,some might say!
Message to Doddy,quit whilst you`re losing.
Dave Wilson
92 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:36:43
I`ll have a guess Denis -35,000+

Of course there will be a lot more than that looking for Wembley tickets should - as I expect - we get there
Simon Harris
93 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:26:51
Does anyone know why Barkley wasn't on the bench?



You could have replaced Gibson with a card board cut out and I wouldn't have noticed the difference.

How he remained on the pitch for 90mins is astonishing. He contributed diddly.
Kunal Desai
94 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:21:10
It amazes me how many on here were jizzing themselves on Tuesday night, you'd have thought we'd beaten barcelona or won the league. It doesn't take much to appease evertonians these days. Moyes didn't do anything different on tuesday, it was a lucky result, if we played man city another 10 times at home again this season then how many would we win?? not many.
I didn't see Moyes making astute substitutes to win the game or try and change it, it was the same 11 that he would have picked for the Wigan game, had Pienaar not been signed. This man is tactially inept end of! Albeit the players put a shift in on Tuesday, it doesn't make up for whats been a miserable season.
Denis Richardson
95 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:40:41
Dave, for the sake of Evertons' bank balance I hope you're right but given the number was a little less than 30k for the league leaders, I have my doubts.

Still, maybe the Tuesday night fixture date had something to do with the low turn out for city and many fans will want to get a look at Jelavic dirst hand. Still the performnce and more importantly negative tactics of our manager today shows what we can continue to expect.

Phil Walling
96 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:48:03
If he starts with one striker and has Neville in midfield,I think we should all turn our backs for the first five minutes.
I`ll blow the wgistle!
Phil Rodgers
97 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:56:33
Unbelievable how Everton manage to sap optimism. Its soul destroying.
Dave Wilson
98 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:45:03
The City game was a midweek televised game Denis.
Even the City fans gave it a miss - they sold 22 hundred tickets and sent the rest back.

Moyes is far from being the only negative one here, a week ago people were queing up to predict 3 straight loss`s.

Well we`ve got 4 points - one under desperate conditions - and we have given oursleves a great chance of getting to Wembley.
I suppose he desperate to be miserable will always look for reasons to climb back up onto the window ledge.
Mike Allison
99 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:56:52
No Drenthe at all despite his having created the opening we won from on Tuesday, and Neville on for Cahill. Indefensible.

And this from someone who usually defends Moyes.
Brian Denton
100 Posted 04/02/2012 at 19:59:58
Phil (#478) my dad told me (I think it was after Forest knocked us out of the Cup in 1967 when we were 2-0 up at half time) "Son, you can always rely on Everton to let you down".

Wise words and the years have not made them any less accurate !

Ben Jones
101 Posted 04/02/2012 at 18:57:35
I mean I didnt watch the game, I jus kept following BBC Sport in the horrible train while it was snowing.

I actually thought the team sheet was decent.

But that substitution was disgusting. It does just suggest negativity, and it didnt make any sense, putting a defensive midfield in a more advanced role, when we had two in form strikers on the bench. Only Moyes can describe that one.

Made up for Anichebe though, 5 points he's given us now. Hopefully he can kick on
Denis Richardson
102 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:00:14
Dave, if the performance (for want of a better word) against Wigan today, as well as the tactics employed is ok for you, then you're entitled to that opinion.

With better tactics this club would/should be getting better results as well as achieving its main objective - to entertain the fans. Employing desperately negative tactics is not going to achieve anything for the club long term and the lower the average gate becomes, the higher the pressure gets on the finances.

On the face of it a point away from home is fine but we all know that this team should have achieved more and playing our supposeldy best midfielder in a forward role with 2 strikers on the bench, just to accomodate Nevilel, was just bizaar to say the least.

Had this been a one off and Moyes admitted he got it a bit wrong, then that would be ok. But we know only too well that this is not the first nor likely the last time something like this will happen.


But then thats just my opinion.
Andrew Clare
103 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:14:51
I feel sorry for Jelavic. Welcome to the strikers graveyard.Cahill for Neville! What!
Kevin Hudson
104 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:07:15
Froze my bollocks off today waiting for us to tuck Wigan up; this obviously didn't happen. I thought it was crying out for a Jelavic/Stracqualursi combination, as the Wools looked porous at the back; but I suppose hindsight passes as definitive logic when we haven't won.

As an aside, I posted an article on ToffeeWeb about two years ago. It questioned the virtue of having a goalkeeper who's position remains unchallenged at the club: I still don't think that's healthy - yet another howler.

As a factual antidote to the predictable wailing on the thread, the BBC stats confirm that we were the better team. We had more possession, and had 3 times as many goal attempts than them. On that basis, the points were probably there for the taking.

But on an awkward Sunday League pitch that was cutting up before our eyes, and in horrible conditions, it wasn't so bad: but for a bit more composure in the box, better service, and minus the freakery of their goal, etc....

However, we are putting a decent run together..just two defeats in the last 12 matches, and plenty to come from this team I think..
Joe McMahon
105 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:36:41
Richard Dodd, Richard, Ritchie Baby ? What is it with you? We have lost at Home to Bolton when they were bottom, drawn at home to Blackburn when 2nd from bottom, and scrapped a draw at Wigan when bottom. How can you be happy with such negative crass shite!?!

Your two men ? Moyes & Kenwright ? are nothing but Parasite Charlatans. Even Collymore (who does talk sense) on the radio tonight asked why do Everton only ever score one goal, at the most. After 10 years of keeping it tight, trying to nick one, are you not sick of it yourself?

Welcome Jelavic to Woodison Park aka the Strikers Graveyard.
Frank McGregor
106 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:14:02
Dave Wilson 480,An excellent post agree completely with you,common sense reply to most of the negativity,Yes it was a poor performance totally agree also the substitution of Cahill by Neville.The saving grace was the substitution of Anichebe.I would say the performance of Everton was no better or worse than the performance of Arsenal at Bolton mid week which was a complete waste of time to watch.
Dave Wilson
107 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:29:34
Denis

Nice try at twisting my words, but no cigar.

At no time did I say anything was ok today was ok with me.

Not sure where you and the rest of the people who are saying we were negative today got this from ? did you see the game ?

Donovan, Fellaini, Straq, Anichebe, Cahill, Pienaar, Jellavic, were ALL used in advanced rolls, Baines and Gibson got forward all game, so unless you are judging with preconcieved ideas How is that negative ?

I was there and I have half an idea of how difficult it was to play football. both sides tried to play, both sides failed. Barcelona would have struggled out there today.

But Hey ; I`m sure one of the usual critics will be along shortly by claiming we played with "EIGHT defenders" and that Moyes threw Jellavic on to secure a point.
Bert Fieldhouse
108 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:43:27
Andrew ? spot on!

David Moyes ? the strikers' gravedigger.
Alex Cooke
109 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:38:26
Fuck me, Osman and Rodwell will be fit soon which will see Drenthe slide down the bench even further. Big Vic has done the job since coming back yet only gets 5 mins... Vellios came in, scored three in less than three games worth of minutes, Duffy dropped. Not the way to keep fresh good young players sweet.
Barry Rathbone
110 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:37:46
Moyes will never ever change.

As predictable as the equinox the number of good matches he presides over each season is about the same.... two.

Citeh was one, who knows when the next is but it's enough for present day Everton, 20 to 30 thousand supporters indulge him every other saturday.

A complete mystery to me - but there it is.
Alex Cooke
111 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:53:49
I genuinely think Moyes doesn't know what he's doing anymore. He plays Felli up front with our two top-scoring strikers on the bench and a new signing who's been banging goals galore in for Rangers. Then Neville for Tim at half time... then 20 mins later, Hibbert, who's far better comes off and Neville goes to right back and finally we get two up front. Why not just leave the best right back on and bring a striker or attacking midfielder on at half time and go for the win against a piss poor team?

We have great players, unfortunately they sit on the bench while Moyes favourites who are no more than school-yard players (Neville, Osman etc) dominate the team and therefore dictate the quality of football. Kenwright is wrecking the club but the manager picks the team from a squad that is light on numbers but has a fair bit of quality. He just stubbornly refuses to pick the quality players.

If Redknapp was our manager, he would play Drenthe, Fellaini, Barkley, Pienaar, Anichebe, or Stracqualursi and jelly in the same team, the footy would be better to watch would score more and possibly be in with a shot at catching The Shite. Strange manager there...
Kevin Stewart
112 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:56:43
Please forgive me, Doddy's comments are pure DM excuses... me thinks he is DM. However, Neville & Cahill should nick a football for us again and Moyes should be off back to Preston ? who, by the way, hated his negativity ? 3 failures in the play-offs.
Denis Richardson
113 Posted 04/02/2012 at 20:59:20
Dave Wilson,

Please tell me how the subsitution of Neville for Cahill was postiive?

Playing a holding midfielder as a forward is a pretty odd decision in my book, especially when we have strikers on the bench. The fact that we regularly seem to score and rescue a game only after finally going for it would seem to suggest that if we went for it in the first place we might win more - against sides that are worse than us. This was not Man U ior Arsenal that we were playing, it was the bottom of the league ffs.

Yes I did watch the game and of course recognise the difficult conditions - however the conditions were difficult for both sides and does not excuse brining on a defender to play in midfield and sticking our supposed best holding midfielder forward - against the worst side in the division. If this is ok for you (as I said above) then that is your opinion. If its not ok for you then you don't need to respond to my post, do you.
Paddy McCague
114 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:15:21
Lost for words when I saw Neville for Cahill. What in the world was Moyes thinking??? Pienaar should have been moved into that position and Drenthe for Cahill.
Dave Wilson
115 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:09:05
Denis

Of course I will tell you.

Cahill was injured and came off,

Fellaini moved into Cahills position.

Neville Moved to position vacated by Felaini.. There was no change in formation.
Didnt say it would have been my choice, but at least I understood it.

Heres a question for you ;

How come when Cahill is played up top he`s a midfielder, but when he is replaced by another midfielder he is a forward being replaced by a defender ?

If Moyes was anywhere near as predictable as the criticism that comes up here every time we dont win, we`d already be relegated.

Now if you want to ignore all those players I listed who played in advanced positions and concentrate on a single substitution, then thats your perogative, if you dont, then you dont need to respond to my post either
Phil Bellis
116 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:20:23
"rejoicing in an away point.." at Wigan! (written with a straight font, no doubt)
Brilliant Doddy, brilliant!
Reel `em in, son
Dennis Stevens
117 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:36:29
Back to the harsh reality today, it would seem. The hard fought win over Manchester City was great but now seems to be an exception in as far as we were able to both keep a clean sheet & nick a goal. All too often we fail to do both, which would appear to be pre-requisites for Moyes plan to work effectively.

Unfortunately, that win is the only one in our last six League matches, over which we have averaged just a point per game. This would reflect a trend of diminishing returns, as we have only taken fourteen points from the last twelve matches ? even worse than the sixteen points achieved from the opening twelve matches, & that was hardly considered an auspicious start to the season. It?s a trend Moyes will need to reverse if we are to manage another top half finish, so let?s hope our new signings inspire another late surge!
John Gary Jones
118 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:35:46
Am I the only person who finds it confusing that after a good win against Man City; Moyes chose to change the team?

Surely it would have made sense to retain the same starting 11 who worked so tirelessly for each other and positively against Wigan... even if we made two new signings, start them on the bench and then use them as impact subs to bed them in to the team.
John Ford
119 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:29:06
Sound analysis Dave W. It wasnt a great performance but as usual, as you demonstrate, most of the criticisms re Moyes are pretty weak.

Critical faculties have again been lost in the immediate aftermath of a mediocre performance.
Andy Crooks
120 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:44:05
Whatever the excuses, and, as I didn't see the game there may well be valid ones, the substitution of Neville for Cahill is another in a long line of bewildering swaps made by the coach over the last number of years.

We are better as underdogs, as the City game showed. Backs against the walls is what Moyes does best and if he was Wigan manager I think he would save them. I wish he was.
Tom Bowers
121 Posted 04/02/2012 at 22:12:22
Moyes is pleased with the point yet again!!!! What?against the bottom club when we have just beaten the top club.
Is this man sick or what?
We have some talent at this club but Moyes's negativity is ruining it. Why we cannot start with at least 2 strikers against a team like Wigan and seize the initiative is beyond comprehension.
He brings on an slow defender to replace a slow midfielder at half time and we paid the penalty. This was 2 points sacrificed by Moyes and not for the first time.
Peter Mills
122 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:32:15
I still think there are many to support David Moyes as our manager. But when I came out of that ridiculous crush in the concourse under the stand at half time to see Phil Neville coming on I could only assume it was for an injured defender. I knew Tim Cahill was hurt early on, but I was bewildered that he would be replaced by Neville when we had much better attacking options on the bench.

I accept that Fellaini was pushed forward, but he is never at his best in that role and had been playing well in midfield.

This was a game we should have attacked, whatever the conditions. It was there for the taking.
Peter Mills
123 Posted 04/02/2012 at 22:21:21
Apologies. That should have read "there are many reasons to support David Moyes as our manager". I wonder what Dr Freud would have made of such a mis- type?

Derek Thomas
124 Posted 04/02/2012 at 21:57:11
Despite your clever word play Herr Wordschmit Wilson, Cahill is, when playng in the 451 hole is a midfield / forward ( there were rumours that Tim was carrying an injury yet more indication of Moyes fallability, playing the 3/4 fit favourite over a fit untrusted one )

As to the Subs, If the proper team was picked at the start, while formulating the next line, I look back at that and why bother, it sums it up.

To our / my mind it's game set and match... Pick the right team at the start, but no Moyes reverts to type again and again again, then has to salvage / compound the error with the subs. But we can't see it as you who have this crystal vision can, can we, we have to see it your way don't we, for you are staunch and steadfast in absolute sureness of your point... and you will be saying now that I just don't get it I can't see the crystal vision.

Not can't mate, won't. I refuse outright to subscribe to the Moyes version of so called football reality It's shite. But would it occur to you that We might be right, nah we have the crystal vision. read Dan Schweizer 462, works for me, but then again I am a know nothing none crystal vision see-er.

True you say...save your typing fingers, we agree to differ, well we would, you KNOW you are right, we as we only think we are. and round and round it goes.
Peter Warren
125 Posted 04/02/2012 at 22:59:43
Dave Wilson , I understand you support moyes but your defence is ott and not true.

1 Barcelona would play amazing in those conditions.
2 it was defensive tactics from start and Neville for cahill is not attacking
3 we didn't play attacking football , we sply didn't keep hold of ball or push defenders up til 1 down.
4 attendances not below 30 cos of midweek game or cos on sky.
Wayne Smyth
126 Posted 04/02/2012 at 23:02:39
Sorry Dave(Wilson), we might've had some decent attacking talent on display, but Moyes choice was to play with just 1 up front for 80 minutes of the match. Donovan, Cahill and Pienaar all played deep for a good part of the match leaving Straq isolated for large parts of the game.

If cahill isn't properly fit, he shouldn't be playing, especially with 4 decent strikers to choose from, plus drenthe who'd do a good job in the "cahill" role.

Its no coincidence that in the second half with Neville on the pitch we looked awful. I'm not surprised he gave away an own goal. His "defending" was dire when he moved to right back too. Backing off players who need to be closed down, allowing them to cross without hinderance.

We saw what this team is capable of against Man City last week, there is no excuse for playing within ourselves against the leagues bottom club.
Derek Thomas
128 Posted 04/02/2012 at 23:10:27
Dave Wilson; I was going to let my #521 stand, but once I pressed the submit button a whole lot more popped into my head ( don't bother you might say...too late ).

Apart from disagreeing with you and Mr Ford at al ( where is Ian Tunstead nowadays ) on the whole crystal vision thing, more on my original point of; picking the right 11 from the off.

The team for Wigan???, decisions were made by the man who gets a shitload of cash for making them, his call fair enough.

Tuesday's Hibbo one worked, but, or so it seems more often than not to me/us that the inate conservatism in Moyes errs too far that way and the keep it tight and pinch one is the default setting.

Time after time though, this decision 'ball' fails to clear the first half of the mantra 'wall'. We don't keep it tight. We are then playing catch up, not what history tells us we are well equiped to do.

We played at least 3 different 11's / formations yesterday.

The first one we drew with.

The second one we went a goal down with.

The third one we scored with.

Can you see what it is yet ( as Rolf used to say while painting a few more strokes to fill in the blanks ) ...looks... Ah yes ( lightbulb moment )

Play the third formation FIRST.

The only effective Cahill is the 110% Cahill, he works as a forward and a midfielder then. The carrying of the 60%, might last an hour at reduced effectiveness Cahill does him and us no favour in fullfilling the blessed keep it tight and pinch one crystal vision.

Friday, Tuesday; 2 steps forward. Saturday, one step back and there have been many more backward steps over the last 5 or more years.

The odd person after Fri and Tues got hammered for mentioning papering over the cracks. Sat. would seem to up hold them.

Most of the on field cracks are NOT structural, why then paperover them when an equally simple job with the polyfiller would do; aka getting it right from the off and fuck the crystal vision.

Continuing with the house renovation thing, this is our ' forever home ' the Board, manager and players are just tenants.

All I want is for Moyes to change it slightly or as a last resort go. But he won't, he has the odd for him off day ( Friday Tuesday ).

But people don't change, in fact as they get older the get ' more so '

As I stated earlier we will agree to differ, we both have our own none compatable crystal visions and we both think we are right, again, round and round it goes until the equilibrium is disturbed by an outside event or force.

What might these outside facts be?? I can't see past 5 events.

Resigns, Is sacked, the ' R ' word, the ' A ' word or New owners. the future is not bright.
Roman Sidey
129 Posted 04/02/2012 at 23:54:07
"[T]he BBC stats confirm" fucking nothing Kevin Hudson. We never once looked liked winning that game. Wigan may have not had the stats, but I think they could feel disappointed that they only got a draw, whereas we could only feel frustrated and let down with a draw.

Hindsight has nothing to do with it. For those of us that have to watch from afar, and are able to join the forum while the match is going, most people were predicting the dross, and calling for positive changes BEFORE they weren't made.

Quote from Moyes: "We made some changes to try and win the match."

Someone needs to tell him, Neville for Cahill is not going for the win, Jelavic for Staq was like for like, thus, not really trying to change the course of the game, and Vic for Hibbert is not going for the win when a goal down, it is going for a draw.

Indefensible tonight I'm afraid.

Moyes out.
Ian Smitham
130 Posted 04/02/2012 at 23:50:10
Dave Wilson, not sure I agree with every word you post on here, but from what you have said, you were there and so in my opinion have a better view than those that were not, including me.

Joe McMahon, you also seem to have many views and thanks for your input, just wondered where do you sit at "woodison" and do you manage to get to many aways?
Ian Smitham
131 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:02:56
I am "lucky" enough to have a seat in Top balcony. A few years ago some lads sat near me and they were either drunk or spliffed. They were fanatical, and really critical, one day I had a chat about a previous away game and offered my opinion. The reply was wholly cutting and very sharp in the phrase "if you do not go you do not know" I asked about the games the guy and his mates went to and realised and respected and learned from him.

Just maybe I learned that day and just maybe a few on here need to wind their necks in.

Lastly, I support Everton football club and will to the day I die, maybe subject of a new thread but I wonder in what way some of the posters actually support the club? Do they go? Do they buy stuff? Are they people who call themselves supporters but just come on here for a whinge and moan but contribute nothing positive or offer any solutions to the issues the club would have us believe they have.

Sorry to ramble
Kevin Hudson
132 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:08:11
Roman,

I was there, and the BBC stats bear out what I saw. We were the better team & should have put our chances away.

You apparently think that Wigan would be "dissapointed with a draw."

Is this the same side who managed a solitary shot on goal in 90 minutes, on target, at home..??!

How do you figure that one out..?

Moyes Out. Armchair Experts In.

(Ps: The people who were 'predicting the dross,' were presumably the MOB, who would have also confidently predicted defeat on Tuesday - and mysteriously dissappeared from ToffeeWeb for a few days afterwards).

You're coming out with bollocks, Roman. Again.
Sam Hoare
133 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:17:34
Disappointing and yet a point away and unbeaten in 4 or 5 games.

If last Friday you would have said we could beat Fulham and take 4 points from City and Wigan away, then most of us would have taken that.

A season of mediocrity continues....
Roman Sidey
135 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:36:49
Kevin, I was pointing out that stats are not everything. It says we had more shots on target. Well, I saw every single one of them, and not one of them had much intent about them, and Al-Habsi wasn't troubled by anything except our goal. If you were there you would have seen their wingers skinning our marvellous right back on a fair few occasions. That stat doesn't make it in to the BBC list though does it?
Dennis Stevens
136 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:38:19
Ian, you raised an interesting point about the merits of actually being at the match - 'if you don't go you don't know' is quite valid to a point. Obviously one only sees on the box what they choose to show, & it's certainly not the expansive overview one gets from up in the Top Balcony, which is my preferred spec when I can get there. However, each part of the ground offers a quite different perspective of the same events on the field of play. It often becomes apparent how much this is the case when discussing key points of the match in the pub afterwards!
Jimmy Sørheim
137 Posted 04/02/2012 at 23:55:11
After missing out this game it hit me how Moyes thinks about Everton this season.
He feels that the number 1 aim is to avoid relegation, so he uses his defensive mind to do that.
That is why we see Neville and Heitinga in midfield.
Avoid goals against for all cost, that sums up Moyes this year.

I think he is wrong in his judgement all
together.
This team is better then what Moyes thinks of it, but it is Moyes who manages and therefore he will get his way.

To me reaching 40 points is one thing, but there is a bigger picture also, develop players to play good attacking football for the future is just as important as avoiding relegation, both can happen if you try, but Moyes is to negative instilled towards this club so he refuses to see the positives.

Players like Barkley and perhaps even Vellios are not being used at all, I think Barkley has great potential but Moyes refuses to unleash it.
As for Vellios, he at least desreves to come on earlier in games as a sub, given the goals he has scored he has showed that he has ability, but as with Barkløey Moyes only thinks about AVOIDING relegation, NOTHING more.

It is high time that we as fans demand that a Manager for Everton Football Club does everything in his power to take this club forward.
The way things is going now, even with the new signings is a downward spiral that stops with just avoiding relegation.

To me that is not enough, and if you are a real Everton fan than you will agree that we have to aim for more, build for the future, play attacking football against teams who are beatable, and start using the players for tomorrow, not Phil Neville and ultimately Tim Cahill.

Tim Howard has ticks because of his illness, I think it is time we get a top notch keeper again, like when we had Nigel Martyn, Howard is too weak in the air, and is making mistakes more then what is viewed to be normal.

I think the only way forawrd is for Moyes to go, he has done well and we do have the basics of a good team, but we need a change of vision, and Moyes does not reach that vision, I feel Paul Lambert is the perfect choice, but I fear Kenwright will re-sign Moyes on a new long term contract, or get a terrible replacement like Steve Bruce or Gary Megson.

I am hoping for a change anyway, because I just do not belive in Moyes looking after our long term interests.
Andy Crooks
138 Posted 05/02/2012 at 00:49:13
Kevin, as one of the Mob (opposite to apologist?) I certainly didn't disappear after Tuesday. "Credit to Moyes", "decision vindicated", "magnificent effort", if I recall, were among the phrases I used. Therefore, I feel I am entitled to say that replacing Cahill with Neville was the decision of a coach utterly devoid of imagination and inspiration.

There are those who would say that Moyes cannot be held responsible for individual howlers such as Howard's (yeah, the ball spun but fuck me I'd have saved that). I believe he can; he signed Mucha and Hehnemann and if they aren't better than Howard at present then what are they doing at the club?

I admire anyone who went to Wigan today and I accept that their views are more pertinent than mine. However, I challenge anyone to suggest that pushing Fellaini forward and bringing on Neville was anything other than negative, grim and typical Moyes.
Jon Ferguson
139 Posted 05/02/2012 at 01:02:49
I was dissapointed when Drenthe didn't start; when Neville came on for Cahill, I knew we were screwed. If you don't think dropping points at Wigan is a disappointing result right now, then you're simply not competitive enough.
Peter Barry
140 Posted 05/02/2012 at 02:26:36
This was a game that I, like many others I am sure, was anticipating with enthusiasm, given the events of the previous week, which seemed to indicate a corner had finally been turned this season. However, that was soon dissipated by yet ANOTHER display of the Dire Depressing Dross that Tactics Devoid Dire Davey has served up virtually all season.

Crowned of course by the supreme insult of yet AGAIN replacing a Striker with ANOTHER Defender, and the useless Neville at that, when on level terms with inferior opposition. Any Moyesophile want to defend Dire Davey for that? No, thought not.

MOYES OUT, MOYES OUT, There is no other solution WMWB.
Tony Eastwood
141 Posted 05/02/2012 at 03:41:33
I am in contact with secondary school students who suffer from Tourette's Syndrome every day. At its worst, it's horrible to witness. It's still upsetting to see what it does to those afflicted with it in a less serious way. The fact that Tim has a mild form of this nasty condition shouldn't be part of comments, irrespective of whether he screwed up or not.

I really thought the TW forum contributors were better than this. Leave it alone. Hats off to Tim for what he has achieved in life. Most of us would buckle under completely.
Martin Mason
142 Posted 05/02/2012 at 04:26:12
It's very difficult to say anything positive about that and bringing on Neville and putting Fellaini forward is the work of an idiot. Look how we struggled against Blackburn... and Arsenal stuck 7 past them. That's where we are.
Matt Traynor
143 Posted 05/02/2012 at 06:58:14
Andy (552) I haven't followed this thread, and only clicked on to see how the hell we ended up talking about tourettes...

But, I am in agreement with you. That game yesterday was there for the taking. We should've had our tails up after last week. The Cahill for Neville decision was only "out-baffled" by pushing Fellaini further forward. He polarises views on this board, but in my opinion, his best position is DM - that's where he makes time for himself and seems comfortable. Yes he's 8 ft tall, and has scored a few goals, but that's kids football coach thinking.

Yet again we have a roller-coaster week, but we're used to that now aren't we. For whatever reason, Moyes seems unable to string a run of 5-6-7 games together, something which characterised his first few years. That in part is why these recent seasons just feel like a long drawn out struggle.

My only disagreement with you Andy is about the goal. I guess Howard weighs 13-14 stone. I don't know what you weigh, but just try shifting your body when you're "falling" in one direction! And bear in mind he had no idea the ball was going to do what it did!
Denis Richardson
144 Posted 05/02/2012 at 08:27:33
Dave 501,

Yes I understand what moyes did on the pitch, I just dont understand why he did it. Couple of things;

Fellaini is supposedly our best holding midfielder, why play him out of position in an attacking midfielder role? (Note I have specified my view of the Cahill role here and not used the word 'forward').

Bringing Neville on for Cahill was of course not like for like as you make out, it lead to two changes (Neville taking Felainis position and Fellaini taking Cahills position). So on the whole was more defensive than before (defender now playing CM and a DM midfilder now playiing AM).

Simple fact is, that subsututiion had a very detrimental effect on the teams play and the 2nd half was dire and Fellaini did not look comfortable playing there (not the first time). At half time and at 0-0, Wigan had not really been a threat so why not bring on an attack minded player to swap for Cahill? I.e. a trure like for like change, or god forbid play two recognised strikers for more than 10 minutes, BEFORE we go a goal down.

Neville is an ok RB but an awful centre mid, add to that Fellaini is best in the middle as a holding role and not an attacking midfielder. That substitution was a fuck up by Moyes and a more positive manager would have made a different change.

Paul Gladwell
145 Posted 05/02/2012 at 09:18:02
Same old Moyes, great when he has no options like last Tuesday and clueless when he does have options like yesterday and that substitution.
And what is going on with Barkley? Chamberlain is being let off the leash at Arsenal and will not doubt leave Barkley in his tracks, just like Wiltshire has with Rodwell in terms of quality,but I suppose Sir Alex will be made up as we showed everyone at Carrington the other week what Man Utds future looks like in terms of what they shall be taking off us, I bet that's why we played Rodwell there.
Ray Robinson
146 Posted 05/02/2012 at 09:47:51
Re the substitution yesterday, it was bad enough to bring on a defensive midfielder for Cahill (yes, I know Fellaini moved further upfield but he could have done that anyway), but why Neville for God's sake. He isn't exactly in a rich vein of form is he?

I've seen far worse Everton teams than the current one where I'd have been happy with a point at Wigan, but is it negative to wish for something more with the current squad?

Moyes's managerial talents seem to diminish in proportion to the quality of squad that he assembles.
Tony J Williams
147 Posted 05/02/2012 at 09:57:37
It was a daft substitution to bring on Neville, but the funny thing is that Fellaini had more chances than Cahill did, so it might have worked but for our dope of a goalie again not doing his job.

I try and see the best in everything even though I agree there was no excuse to bring Neville on.
Alan Clarke
148 Posted 05/02/2012 at 10:49:57
Wasn't it just groundhog day earlier in the week? It certainly feels like that watching Everton for the last 10 years. This season apart from the Man City game and possibly the Fulham cup game, every post-match discussion could be just cut and pasted from the week before. Whilst most of us can see how useless Moyes is, we still see the exceptions of deluded Doddy, Tony 'J' Williams and the tactical genius Wilson still offering their usual clueless defence of Dithering Dave. I'm going to just save this comment and write exactly the same again next week.
Thomas Windsor
149 Posted 05/02/2012 at 10:36:24
Against Wigan we played 14 players over the 90 minutes ? 12 of them were internationals at one time... so how come we played so crap?

For me, the answer is the manager: to put Neville on for Cahill when we had Anichibe and Jelavic on the bench just sums him up. Does he not realise us fans have had enough of this boring shit???

Too many managers today have these coaching badges who were shit players, that is the problem. We go to the game to see goals ? that's the first thing I want to see ? how many shots did these two teams achieve in one and a half hours???

Enough said.... MOYES OUT!!!!
Derek Thomas
150 Posted 05/02/2012 at 10:52:09
Tony J # 604; could it be that Fellaini had more chances than Cahill because Fellaini was actually fit to play.
Tony J Williams
151 Posted 05/02/2012 at 11:04:51
Could be, but you could argue that it was the right substitution then. (I know it wasn't be there could be an arguable point)
Robbie Shields
152 Posted 05/02/2012 at 11:04:11
Denis #578, I'm afraid you really are wasting your breath, great observations and reasoning ain't going to get anywhere with some on here.

For what it's worth, I think your post is 100% accurate, how anyone can say it wasn't a defensive substitution is beyond belief.
James Power
153 Posted 04/02/2012 at 17:53:05
This is for ironic purposes isn't it? given both Liverpool and Chelsea did only come away with one point from Wigan. Sorry can't be bothered reading the rest of the thread....
Dave Wilson
154 Posted 05/02/2012 at 10:51:12
Denis #578

I hate that we have a Manc playing for us.

I hate even more that we have a Manc who cant pass a fucken ball playing for us.

I hate when the Gobshites taunt us by singing "Your captains a Manc"

I was gutted When Phil Neville signed for us.

I hate Moyes for chosing him.

I hope every time Neville leaves the field he has played his last game for us.

I Hate Old Trafford, I hate Eastlands, I hate Oasis, I hate the East Lancs Rd.

I loved watching City supporters scuttling off with their tales between their legs on Tuesday.

Try to understand the difference between trying to explain a substitution and trying to justify it.

Alan Clarke.

No lower league game to chose ahead of Evertons yesterday ? Pity, that level of foootball is crying out for a few more footballing Enstiens like you.

I`d have thought even you would have realised that a few dozen people who regularly criticise the manager on this site does not constitute what you laughingly call "most of us" .
Maybe you didnt hear 30.000 people singing "We`re on the march with Moysie`s army" on Tuesday ?

where were you ?.

Oh I forgot, Hindsight merchants like you only ever do misery
Mark Stone
155 Posted 05/02/2012 at 11:56:52
Yes James Power (650). I was being sarcastic. I did confirm that, later on in the thread. I'd actually assumed it would have been obvious.
Ray Robinson
156 Posted 05/02/2012 at 11:58:18
Dave #652, I rarely agree with your "expert" opinions but respect the fact that you normally try to justify your views with reasoned logic. However, you have destroyed your credibility with that anti-Manc rubbish.

I dislike Moyes for picking Neville because he's worse than useless but for ffs what has his place of origin got to do with it?

Do you think Man Utd mind having a certain scouser playing for them?
Dave Wilson
157 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:12:09
Football tribalism Ray ? or call it what you want.

I bitterly resent the fact that Neville is so fucken bad.and still gets a game.

That he sits with his Manc Buddies and cheers on Man United when we aren't playing merely compounds my resentment of him being ALLOWED to wear a royal blue jersey.

If you have managed to rise above this "tribalism" I doff my cap to you.

Never managed it meself...
Rob Walden
158 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:21:18
Dave Wilson ? I just feel sorry for you, to have to live with a state of mind that has so much hate. You must be a deeply unhappy person.

What much of the moaning hate brigade with their obvious agenda on this BB forget is that the team made a massive effort against City earlier in the week. Anyone who trains knows how a major physical effort takes it out of the body for several days afterwards.
Ciarán McGlone
159 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:07:40
Ian Smitham,

Condescending tripe.

I don't need to be sat in the stand to know that putting Neville into right midfield, while Drenthe scratches his head on the bench, is a decision of idiotic proportions.

If I watch the match on TV then I analyse what I see. The argument that you cannot criticise without being there has been battered to death years ago.
Derek Thomas
160 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:13:11
Tony J #631 well of course either it is or it isn't ( we both know it isn't ) so just what sort of none answer was that.

Dave Wilson #652 what are you doing then, explaining it or justifing it, since your post #501 you've taken a bit of flak and you manc rant is just bluster, smoke and mirrors.. ( run out of clever semantics eh ? )

Yes we were all cheering on Friday and Tuesday, that one of the things you do when you win. One of the things you should not do ( without very good reason ) is change what works, especially for the cracked crystal vision of keep it tight and pinch one.

As I said before It's not that I can't see yours ( and Moyeses ) crystal vision... I just plain won't. I cannot subscribe to the false reality of the Moyes vision of how football should be played. We will have to agree to differ.

Yeah I know 'we' think we are right. But you Know you are don't you, hence the protesting too loud manc rant.

Do you and your ilk Like paying good money to watch this shite?

All bluster coz the cat got your tongue... oh yes.
Stephen Kenny
161 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:41:41
Beating Wigan doesn't boost Moyes media profile. Therefore he didn't attach the same significance to it and the players responded in kind.

He didn't set out to lose or draw he just weren't desperate to see us win. That much was clear in his post match comments.

David Moyes looks after number 1 and will continue to do so as long as he's here.
Ray Robinson
162 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:49:42
Dave #657, what has tribalism got to do with it? When Everton are playing Man Utd or Man City, I'm no less partisan than you are but if a Manc happens to play for us or an ex Liverpool player or a three-legged Martian for that matter, the only criteria that I use is are they a) fully committed to the cause b) giving their best in the match. If they're not good enough, that's the manager's fault. As for where they come from, I don't give a monkey's. It's got nothing to do with tribalism.
Mark Stone
163 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:52:20
Martin Mason,' it's very difficult to say anything positive about that and bringing on Neville and putting Fellaini forward is the work of an idiot. Look how we struggled against Blackburn... and Arsenal stuck 7 past them. That's where we are.'

Blackburn beat Man Utd just a month ago. What is your point? We have the 10th highest average attendance in the Premier League, we're 11th in the table and we have the 12th highest wage bill. THAT is where we are.

I disagreed with the Neville substitution yesterday ? I would much rather have seen TC replaced with a forward and Fellaini stay where he was. However, it's comparisons like the one you have made above that really strike me as the work of an idiot.
Mark Riding
164 Posted 05/02/2012 at 13:11:04
Just a week ago.. would you have been happy with the following ??

Saha gone.
Billy gone.

Jelavic in.
Pienaar in.

4 points from the next two games against City and Wigan.

A cup draw against Blackpool or Sheffield Wednesday.

I would have bitten your hand off if you offered me that.

Onwards and upwards.. COYB !!!!
Dave Wilson
165 Posted 05/02/2012 at 12:45:26
Derek #660

Taken flak ? ? ? ? from who ? the people who`s attitude is and always has been directly opposed to mine ? Do you think I`m taken aback or surprised that they dont agree with me ?

My views on Neville have never changed Smoke and Mirrors ? I`m not that clever lad.

Now I`m prepared to accept that the clarity of my "crystal vision" is no match for the clarity of your hindsight, but the day I join the ranks of the determined to be miserable is the day I stop watching footy.

I choose - get that ? its a conscious decision - to believe we are improving and might even be going to Wembley and although I dont agree with yesterdays substitution (the first one) I choose - there I go again - to view it as a minor incident in the scheme of things, something that had little or no effect on the result.


Do you see whats happening here Derek ? its that half full/empty thing again.


Some will choose - they too make a conscious decision - to concentrate on one incident and blame the manager, the performance and the result on it.

I saw Pienaar, Donovan, Anichebe, Jelavic, Straquilursi, Fellaini and Cahiil all play in advanced roles. I saw it ! . .and I`ll tell you something else ; SO DID THE REST OF YOU !

Regardless of what was said here, the pitch was completely shite - that cant be contested.
The manager did get one of his substitutions wrong and our performance was pretty shite . .but I refuse to pretend we played with EIGHT defenders.
I wont ignore the evidence of my own eyes, if that means I cant belong to your`s and Alan Clarkes gang then thats just a dissapointment I`ll have to learn to live with.

Oh btw ; You ask "do I like paying good money to watch this shit"

I`ve done it for nearly 50 years, and with 4 maybe 5 exceptions we have ALWAYS been shite. Unfortunately I`m unable to forget what for many on here, seems too painful to remember.

Besides what else would I do ?

Ben Jones
166 Posted 05/02/2012 at 13:42:40
I've noticed, no matter what everyone has said on here, no one has defended that substitution?

I mean, I didnt watch the game, but to all the people who did, were we being cut through the middle park by Wigan so much to justify putting on a defensive midfielder instead of an attacking midfielder to move another defensive midfielder up front? It's just madness

I mean, we could have put either of the two strikers on.

Or even if Moyes wanted to keep 5 in midfield, he could have been more prudent and put Drenthe/Gueye on so they can go on the wing and put Donovan or Pienaar in the Cahill role.

But no, he does that stupid substitution. It is worse than Wenger's one of Arshavin for Chamberlain, it really is.
Phil Walling
167 Posted 05/02/2012 at 13:50:39
Pure cowardice on Moyes` part although the radio commrntators suggested that our manager clearly wanted `to keep the shape he started with`!
James Martin
168 Posted 05/02/2012 at 14:23:42
Everyone just expects us to be winning every game and turning on the champagne football all the time. Ever think that we don't have a divine right just to go to Wigan and win?

City fans are probably saying the exact same thing after their game against us. They expected to win because they have better players and have spent more money than us but they didn't.

Funny how Mancini who manages the team top of the league also brought De Jong on rather than make an attacking substitution. Even Ferguson got it wrong against Liverpool with his subs. But no, Everton and Moyes are different, how dare they make mistakes after turning over City in mid-week. They should be winning every game, home and away, and entertaining the fans as well, even though they have an injury crisis, and don't have any money.

Get a grip, far too many people on here think they're paying to watch one of Bill's shows; entertainment on demand because I paid for it. Dull, negative away draws have been part of football since it began, every team has them, no one likes them, but to think a mid-table side like Everton will avoid them just because they got one good win in the midweek is ridiculous.
Michael Kenrick
169 Posted 05/02/2012 at 15:58:25
Interesting that no-one on this thread has mentioned what has to be the prime reason for Moyes switching Cahill with Neville.

Cahill was wearing the captain's armband. For Moyes, Neville was the obvious replacement... AS CAPTAIN.

All other considerations suggested mean nothing to Moyes. Entertainment, attacking shape, new striker... It was all about having HIS captain on the field.
Ben Jones
170 Posted 05/02/2012 at 16:27:45
I doubt that was the reason Michael.

Distin, Heitinga or Hibbert could have easily been the captain for the second half.

If he wanted HIS captain, he would started with Neville instead of bencing him.
Ray Roche
171 Posted 05/02/2012 at 16:39:57
Dave Wilson@672 ? "something that had little or no effect on the result." ? So the ball deflecting off Neville for an own goal had "little or no effect on the result" nor did moving our best midfielder up front to waste his time with hoofballs have "little or no effect on the result."

I think you're wrong there, matey. I can't believe that you think the Neville/Cahill substitution was the best change that Moyes could have made, especially as you have been going, as you claim... sorry, say... for almost 50 years, with 4, maybe 5 exceptions being shite. Do you mean 4 or 5 seasons? I hope not...
.
Jamie Barlow
172 Posted 05/02/2012 at 16:57:27
Matt@570, I don't think Andy Crooks holds Tim Howard responsible for the goal at all. It's all Moyes fault for not signing a better goalkeeper than Tim. It's as easy as that.
Dave Wilson
173 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:04:05
Ray

Why on earth do you feel the need to make this shit up? Do you think people can't scroll back?

Nowhere have I said I think the substitution was "the best Moyes could make" I`ve actually gone out of my way to say I didn't agree with it.

And I don't "claim" anything about supporting this team, I just state a fact.

It's difficult to put into words how little you believing me matters to me.
Michael Kenrick
174 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:03:49
I can't see much logic in your reasoning, Ben, since Distin, Heitinga, and Hibbert were selected to start the game, but Cahill was named as captain. This would suggest that he wanted Cahill to start, wanted Neville on the bench as sub, and that he wanted Cahill as captain.

When Cahill was injured and had to be withdrawn, yes, he had the choice of making an attacking substitution (ha!) or he could focus on the need for leadership on the pitch... and doing what he did ? bringing on Captain Neville and moving Fellaini forward.

To a manager of his maddeningly negative proclivities, this would make perfect and complete sense, in the interest of securing "a result" (ie, a draw) rather than going for a win. The fact that his team then secured said draw will be full vindication for him, and fits with him being pleased with a hard point won under tough conditions against a tough opponent ? instead of doing something to actually WIN the match.
Ray Roche
175 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:15:18
Dave. Don't be so touchy.

I know people, even you, can scroll back. So therefore they can see that you have clearly stated that his crap substitution DID have an effect on the game. Is that what you really meant? Maybe I've misread it.

Saying that we have been shite for all but 4 or 5 seasons is, well, shite, actually. Or have I misread that as well?

I would just like Moyes to get a grip and realise that people don't want to watch his miserable excuse for football; I'd like Moyes to be more like his old self, charged up and ecstatic at the result following a good performance like we saw against City.

Now his present demeanour is that of someone who has spent all night at a concert in which the Smiths perform the songs of Leonard Cohen on the day his dog died under the wheels of the hearse carrying his mother's body.
Ray Roche
176 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:22:30
Dave, I also know that you didn't say "the best Moyes could make", which is why it wasn't presented as a quote, it was more of a question asking you if you felt that that was the case.
Dave Wilson
177 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:26:18
Two different things, a bad substitution - a non contributor for a non contributor I callled it at the time - does not neccesarily have an effect on the outcome of a game.

A goalkeeper failing to keep out a ball that my arl grandad would have saved ,will on the other hand DEFINITELY have an effect on a game.

If you saw the Wigan goal as anything other than goalkeeping error then I wont be trying to change your mind.

Its such a pity you choose to see only the negative and hear only Smiths songs.

Some of us loved seeing a rocking Goodison with Moyes. eyes bulging with excitement as the players left the picth to repeated chorus`s of grand old team on Tuesday night.
Andy Crooks
178 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:44:06
Jamie, Tim Howard seems to me to be to be spreading panic more often lately.I like him and thought he was a good signing.
Andy Crooks
179 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:51:28
He isn't under any pressure though,it seems his place is secure no matter what and that is bad for Everton. Moyes must have little faith in the others if he thinks Howard's current is better than they could do. Loyalty is often an admirable trait but not when it goes too far.
Ray Roche
180 Posted 05/02/2012 at 17:44:57
Dave, I, too, love Goodison rocking. I have since 1959. The substitution had a negative effect on the performance and the result. Sadly, it is more the norm with Moyes these days than the exception. I have tried to see the positive for the extent of Moyes tenure, but this season I have run out of excuses for him and can no longer argue his corner on here or in the Gwladys St.

The OG, well, I have only seen it on my PC, I didn't... couldn't bring myself, to watch MotD so you have more idea than I have about Howard's culpability, although The Times doesn't think it was a fault of Howard's, merely an own goal that "squirmed" past him.

Prior to this season, I would like to think that I am more of a "glass half-full" type of bloke, actually, more of a "glass shows some evidence of having been damp at some time in its life" type, but the constant negativity has worn me down. And judging by the attendances, I'm not alone in that respect.

The Smiths? Can't stand them.
Ian Smitham
181 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:01:25
Mr Kenrick, I think you may have hit the nail on head re Captains. DM is always going to pick someone he has absolute trust in as Captain, I would do the same.

However, a sad reflection on the squad is that Pip gets in the team as a Captain when as a player he ought not to be, in my opinion. It is a reflection of the lack of leadership skills in the team, which leads me to what I said the other night having watching him coach Duffy on the job:

I say do not sell Johnny, make him Captain, play him alongside Duffy, keep the ageing Distin as cover and sort the supposed money situation by cashing in on Jags. Nothing against Jags, but if we can still attract he Arse to buy him at age 29 for anything north of £10 mill makes sense.

That done, with incoming TF fees and saved wages from recent deals, then surely the debts must be close to being resolved which in turn will free up a load of Bank interest costs (these must amount to £3m a year) which is a large dose of the £5m we are supposed to lose each year and need to finance by sales of the likes of our young prospects.

Sorry to ramble...
Ian Smitham
182 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:16:28
Before you all have a go at me, remember, the Arteta fee was one thing, but 4 years of saved wages at £75k pw is a lot of overdraft paid off and same with Bily, it is handy to have the TF fee, but saving £50k per week off the wages is also half a mill a year. I won't bore you with analysis of the rest of the deals but would say that everything done since the last accounts must have saved a shed load and no more can people come on here at anywhere else with meltdown comments.

We just paid as I understand it £4m up front to Rangers

Lastly, you will be pleased to hear, I wrote on here a bit ago when the Accounts came out, BK bought 290 shares in the last year, he is the one closest to the business, if it is going to administration, he would know and so why would he blow over £300k buying more shares
Ian Smitham
183 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:16:28
Before you all have a go at me, remember, the Arteta fee was one thing, but 4 years of saved wages at £75k pw is a lot of overdraft paid off and same with Bily, it is handy to have the TF fee, but saving £50k per week off the wages is also half a mill a year. I won't bore you with analysis of the rest of the deals but would say that everything done since the last accounts must have saved a shed load and no more can people come on here at anywhere else with meltdown comments.

We just paid as I understand it £4m up front to Rangers

Lastly, you will be pleased to hear, I wrote on here a bit ago when the Accounts came out, BK bought 290 shares in the last year, he is the one closest to the business, if it is going to administration, he would know and so why would he blow over £300k buying more shares
Ian Smitham
184 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:16:28
Before you all have a go at me, remember, the Arteta fee was one thing, but 4 years of saved wages at £75k pw is a lot of overdraft paid off and same with Bily, it is handy to have the TF fee, but saving £50k per week off the wages is also half a mill a year. I won't bore you with analysis of the rest of the deals but would say that everything done since the last accounts must have saved a shed load and no more can people come on here at anywhere else with meltdown comments.

We just paid as I understand it £4m up front to Rangers

Lastly, you will be pleased to hear, I wrote on here a bit ago when the Accounts came out, BK bought 290 shares in the last year, he is the one closest to the business, if it is going to administration, he would know and so why would he blow over £300k buying more shares
Ray Robinson
186 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:25:44
Ian, any savings on Arteta and Bily means that the club will not increase its existing debt, it doesn't mean that we will necessarily pay off any of the existing debt. Falling attendances and season ticket sales will more than lilkely account for some of the future savings that we make by off-loading Arteta and Bily. I don't think we've yet avoided potential meltdown by any stetch of the imagination but, it it's any consolation, neither have half the teams in the PL.
Ben Jones
187 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:49:11
Yeah Michael, perhaps you're right, but if that's the reason, then it really is a strange one.

I mean, I know Distin was captain at Portsmouth wasnt he? Maybe even for some of the other clubs he played for.

That substitution is gonna play in my mind for a while.
Phil Walling
188 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:17:23
Whinge all we will, it will alter nothing. To all but a few of us on here, Moyes is a hero ? see today`s Mail.

As we write, I suspect Kenwright is preparing the announcement of a new £4Million-a-year contract to coincide with his 10-year anniversary. Only the chairman`s demise will see the manager leaving ? and that`s not likely anytime soon.
Phil Bellis
189 Posted 05/02/2012 at 19:49:52
Dave, a slight digression but an interesting set of anti-Manc statements you put up earlier. Funny thing, tribalism ? I defend, show my pride in, and extol the virtues of Liverpool, my home city, wherever I go. But, when it comes to football, I'm firmly in the ABL camp; I have Liverpool "supporting" acquaintances (including one or two "professional Scousers" living in Sunningdale), but that's about all and would rather be a Manc than a kopite.

Funny old world, funny old game.
Richard Dodd
190 Posted 05/02/2012 at 20:19:57
Few of us would begrudge him that, Wally! I know the amount is obscene but this is football and if it`s the going rate for `Arry, it`s certainly right for Our Davey!
Mick Davies
191 Posted 06/02/2012 at 01:40:52
Dave Wilson @469, so any team would struggle to play football in those conditions? Well strange as it may sound, both sides were playing on the same pitch.

And if we cast our minds back to sunny August, QPR done us at Goodison the week after they were twatted 4-0 at home by the mighty Bolton. Then again, the conditions might have had an effect on our side of course...
James Flynn
192 Posted 06/02/2012 at 01:43:10
Hey the games over. Chelsea up.

COYB

Kenwright OUT!
James Flynn
193 Posted 06/02/2012 at 02:52:45
Toffeeweber Flynn, that New York City boy, his Giants won the Super Bowl!!!!

Times are looking up. Fuck Chelsea. Come get it bitches. You'll find out.

"It's never easy against Everton"

COYB

Kenwright OUT!
Derek Thomas
194 Posted 06/02/2012 at 07:09:54
Michael # 711 exactly, the last para. aka the crystal vision.

Dave Wilson, like I said we agree to differ. I can't stand the Moyes keep it tight and pinch one, especially that we Increasingly fail to do either half of the mantra and a deep down feeling that most of the time he will never change.
Mark Stone
195 Posted 06/02/2012 at 11:35:12
"He isn't under any pressure though,it seems his place is secure no matter what and that is bad for Everton"

Certainly one of the more idiotic comments I have ever read on here. What creates pressure, expectation? Targets? The difference is that the targets you set Moyes are either unachievable (champions league and trophies) based on our finances or immeasurable (style of play), whereas the targets that the board set Moyes have to be realistic and measurable. You can't give a manager the budget of 12th place team and then sack him for consistently finishing in the top 6/7, for a decade. Mind you that motto and history that gives us the superpowers, eh?
Ray Roche
196 Posted 06/02/2012 at 12:45:39
Mark Stone.

The comments you have made regarding our finances against our expectations are correct, however, the style of play is down to Moyes. Sunderland,Norwich and Swansea are all playing better football than us, and Norwich and Swansea haven't spent as much as we have over the last 10 years, and Sunderland are playing expansive, attacking football with the same squad that Bruce assembled. The difference is the managers outlook. I know we have lost Arteta but Moyes reckons that was doen to him.
Mark Stone
197 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:06:24
Means fuck all from the perspective of whether you keep or sack a manager, Ray. Football is a results game, the higher you finish in the league the more money you get, therefore the targets managers are set relate to league position. Consistently, Moyes has exceeded expectations in this regard. Of course there is pressure, he just succeeds.
Dave Wilson
198 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:21:09
Swansea and Norwich both stunk GP out this season And Sunderland stunk out the SOL when we played them there. three shots between them against us (Sunderlands a poxy deflection)

We might be shite, but were a better than that lot
Stephen Kenny
199 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:29:45
Dave,

we have to take them games in isolation as most of us will at best see a few minutes of other sides for most of the season but results say all three are decent sides.

Our results say that we are at a similar level to those.

Looking at each squad I'd say we have the better players by far.

Mark,,

Why is it unreasonable to expect us to win a trophy over the course of a decade?

Cardiff City, who have never been in the PL and have near gone to the wall more than once will have played in more domestic finals over the same period. Many other clubs who have spent less than Everton and invest less per year in wages etc. have also matched or exceeded us in cup comps over the Moyes years.
James Lauwervine
200 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:20:54
I don't blame Howard for the goal, it could happen to any keeper and was bad luck. I do question his command of the box, however, and there were at least two occasions in the game where this could have cost us.

Those using his disorder (NOT AN 'ILLNESS') to poke fun and make crap jokes should be ashamed of themselves.
James Power
201 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:49:20
Thanks Mark Stone - actually when I submitted my comment yesterday, yours was the last comment (re Chelsea and Liverpool) somewhere in between your clarification and a number of other posts have filled the gap, thats why its out of sync. Sarcasm doesn't really come across as well in email as it does in your head...but noted and thank you for the clarification.
Ray Roche
202 Posted 06/02/2012 at 13:46:38
Dave, Stephen has stolen my thunder to an extent, I think we have got a better team/squad than any of the teams I've mentioned, but our performances are dire. We are so negative that it is no longer a pleasure to go the match these days, hence the drop in attendances. Those teams may well have stunk the place out, but Bolton (h), Stoke(h) QPR(h), Blackbourn (h+a) and Norwich (h) couldn't be regarded as sparkling displays by us, could they? Look at Sunderland now and say they are in our shadow, from a results or performance point of view.

Mark Stone.
I realise that Football is a results game and Moyes has exceded expectations on numerous seasons, but he has become far too negative in his outlook. A couple of seasons ago we were playing pretty decent football as well as getting results. Now we're doing neither. And considering the defensive set up we have to watch we are pretty crap at keeping clean sheets,too. Five all season isn't great for such a defensive outlook in my book.
Roman Sidey
203 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:05:36
Dave Wilson, come on, now you're talking complete and utter shite! Oasis were a great band!
Roman Sidey
204 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:06:50
And Ray, five clean sheets, are you serious? Have we kept five clean sheets this season? That's better than I thought. Moyes's game plan is obviously working.
Ray Roche
205 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:13:05
Yes, Roman, astonishing, isn't it? But with the defensive set up I'd probably expect more than that...
Dave Wilson
206 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:01:31
So Ray/Stephen

We have to take the games we actually saw in isolation . . but its ok to comment and praise them for the games we saw little or nothing of ?

I watched Sunderlands win at the Britania on football first yesterday morning and it was typical MON crash bang wallop. If thats your idea of playing attacking expansive football you can forget it.

Neither of you would put a brass razzoo on these teams finishing above us. Yet you cant wait to tell us how much better their managers are doing.

As far as I know, Its not absolutely compulsary to compare our team unfavourably with every other.
Dave Wilson
207 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:18:53
Roman

Oasis are a cheap and nasty imitation of the real thing.
Ray Roche
208 Posted 06/02/2012 at 14:23:51
Dave, I'm sure we all want the same thing on this site.ie: Everton to be successful. Therefore, I would be happy to have seen Everton have a run of results like Sunderland have just enjoyed. It may be, as you call it, "crash bang wallop" football but it has got them results which have seen them leap frog us.

And what have we been watching? Miserable, defensive crap from a manager who I have, personally, lost faith in. And that's at Stoke who came and stole two points of us at Goodison,incidentally.
"But its ok to comment and praise them for the games we saw little or nothing of?" Not quite sure of the point you're making there, Dave.
Roman Sidey
209 Posted 06/02/2012 at 22:23:42
That's the whole point isn't it, Ray. Moyes sets out to be defensive as all hell, and we have only kept five clean sheets all year. Obviously isn't working. I know some people have mentioned that we've only got 10 points to go before we're at the magical 40 point mark of safety, but with our defensive record this year, those 10 points are going to be very hard earned.
Stephen Kenny
210 Posted 07/02/2012 at 13:00:31
Dave do you honestly believe I take any pleasure in us being compared to any of those sides?

Dave Rice
211 Posted 07/02/2012 at 13:16:32
Moyes OUT!

Toffeeweb Expert Committee IN!

Anything else and you're a "Moyes Apologist"

FFS, he's out-spent everyone bar Chelsea in the January window - we should be top three now considering what he spent.

Tactically niave, dithering, negative, no plan B, can't use substitutes, no strategy, negative, etc . ad nauseum.
Mick Davies
212 Posted 08/02/2012 at 04:40:48
Dave Wilson, you take the award for being the least intelligent creature in the known world.
Bob Parrington
213 Posted 08/02/2012 at 06:20:50
Did anybody see any good in the performance against Wigan? Lousy weather conditions and a lousy pitch but we still seemed to run most of the game. Cahill should be rested as he hasn't had a good game for a long while.

Pienaar looked sharp and fitted in well. Jelavic looked like he will be useful, too.

Now, the main thing that is missing is a positive attacking attitude from the manager!
COYB
Gavin Ramejkis
214 Posted 08/02/2012 at 07:23:49
Dave Rice are you being serious about us outspending everyone bar Chelski in January as another Moyes positive.

How about the last two years where Everton were outspent by conference sides?

If you are going to come out with the gushing shite at least have an argument beyond some yawn fest, lets leave the Moyes is all we should expect and be grateful for brigade to their myopia eh?
Dave Rice
215 Posted 08/02/2012 at 08:51:44
Gavin (284) - didn't know I'd said anything like that, I was simply adopting the Toffeeweb mantra - Moyes hasn't got a clue and we all know better.

And your comment -
"If you are going to come out with the gushing shite at least have an argument beyond some yawn fest" - was that supposed to be extreme irony or is that beyond you?
Tony J Williams
216 Posted 08/02/2012 at 09:09:45
Dave, you forgot to add your sarcastic font (cue someone givng me an English lesson about how font isn't the correct term yadda yadda yadda)
Derek Thomas
217 Posted 08/02/2012 at 09:20:24
Dave 092 your last para shows you know the faults, you just can't or won't admit them. Move on from denial. Say No! to the crystal vision

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads